In mathematics, an operad is a structure that consists of abstract
operations
Operation or Operations may refer to:
Arts, entertainment and media
* ''Operation'' (game), a battery-operated board game that challenges dexterity
* Operation (music), a term used in musical set theory
* ''Operations'' (magazine), Multi-Man ...
, each one having a fixed finite number of inputs (arguments) and one output, as well as a specification of how to compose these operations. Given an operad , one defines an ''algebra over '' to be a set together with concrete operations on this set which behave just like the abstract operations of . For instance, there is a Lie operad such that the algebras over are precisely the
Lie algebra
In mathematics, a Lie algebra (pronounced ) is a vector space \mathfrak g together with an operation called the Lie bracket, an alternating bilinear map \mathfrak g \times \mathfrak g \rightarrow \mathfrak g, that satisfies the Jacobi iden ...
s; in a sense abstractly encodes the operations that are common to all Lie algebras. An operad is to its algebras as a
group
A group is a number of persons or things that are located, gathered, or classed together.
Groups of people
* Cultural group, a group whose members share the same cultural identity
* Ethnic group, a group whose members share the same ethnic ide ...
is to its
group representation
In the mathematical field of representation theory, group representations describe abstract groups in terms of bijective linear transformations of a vector space to itself (i.e. vector space automorphisms); in particular, they can be used t ...
s.
History
Operads originate in
algebraic topology
Algebraic topology is a branch of mathematics that uses tools from abstract algebra to study topological spaces. The basic goal is to find algebraic invariants that classify topological spaces up to homeomorphism, though usually most classif ...
; they were introduced to characterize iterated
loop space
In topology, a branch of mathematics, the loop space Ω''X'' of a pointed topological space ''X'' is the space of (based) loops in ''X'', i.e. continuous pointed maps from the pointed circle ''S''1 to ''X'', equipped with the compact-open topo ...
J. Peter May
Jon Peter May (born September 16, 1939 in New York) is an American mathematician working in the fields of algebraic topology, category theory, homotopy theory, and the foundational aspects of spectra. He is known, in particular, for the May s ...
in 1970. The word "operad" was created by May as a
portmanteau
A portmanteau word, or portmanteau (, ) is a blend of wordsmonad" (and also because his mother was an opera singer).
Interest in operads was considerably renewed in the early 90s when, based on early insights of
Maxim Kontsevich
Maxim Lvovich Kontsevich (russian: Макси́м Льво́вич Конце́вич, ; born 25 August 1964) is a Russian and French mathematician and mathematical physicist. He is a professor at the Institut des Hautes Études Scientifiques a ...
,
Victor Ginzburg
Victor Ginzburg (born 1957) is a Russian American mathematician who works in representation theory and in noncommutative geometry. He is known for his contributions to geometric representation theory, especially, for his works on representations ...
rational homotopy theory
In mathematics and specifically in topology, rational homotopy theory is a simplified version of homotopy theory for topological spaces, in which all torsion in the homotopy groups is ignored. It was founded by and . This simplification of homo ...
could be explained using
Koszul duality In mathematics, Koszul duality, named after the French mathematician Jean-Louis Koszul, is any of various kinds of dualities found in representation theory of Lie algebras, abstract algebras (semisimple algebra) and topology (e.g., equivariant co ...
Poisson manifold
In differential geometry, a Poisson structure on a smooth manifold M is a Lie bracket \ (called a Poisson bracket in this special case) on the algebra (M) of smooth functions on M , subject to the Leibniz rule
: \ = \h + g \ .
Equivalen ...
graph
Graph may refer to:
Mathematics
*Graph (discrete mathematics), a structure made of vertices and edges
**Graph theory, the study of such graphs and their properties
*Graph (topology), a topological space resembling a graph in the sense of discre ...
Maxim Kontsevich
Maxim Lvovich Kontsevich (russian: Макси́м Льво́вич Конце́вич, ; born 25 August 1964) is a Russian and French mathematician and mathematical physicist. He is a professor at the Institut des Hautes Études Scientifiques a ...
Suppose is a set and for we define
:,
the set of all functions from the cartesian product of copies of to .
We can compose these functions: given , , the function
:
is defined as follows: given arguments from , we divide them into blocks, the first one having arguments, the second one arguments, etc., and then apply to the first block, to the second block, etc. We then apply to the list of values obtained from in such a way.
We can also permute arguments, i.e. we have a right action of the
symmetric group
In abstract algebra, the symmetric group defined over any set is the group whose elements are all the bijections from the set to itself, and whose group operation is the composition of functions. In particular, the finite symmetric group ...
on , defined by
:
for , and .
The definition of a symmetric operad given below captures the essential properties of these two operations and .
Definition
Non-symmetric operad
A ''non-symmetric operad'' (sometimes called an ''operad without permutations'', or a ''non-'' or ''plain'' operad) consists of the following:
* a sequence of sets, whose elements are called ''-ary operations'',
* an element in called the ''identity'',
* for all positive integers , , a ''composition'' function
:
satisfying the following coherence axioms:
* ''identity'':
* ''associativity'':
::
Symmetric operad
A symmetric operad (often just called ''operad'') is a non-symmetric operad as above, together with a right action of the
symmetric group
In abstract algebra, the symmetric group defined over any set is the group whose elements are all the bijections from the set to itself, and whose group operation is the composition of functions. In particular, the finite symmetric group ...
on for , denoted by and satisfying
*''equivariance'': given a permutation ,
::
::(where on the right hand side refers to the element of that acts on the set by breaking it into blocks, the first of size , the second of size , through the th block of size , and then permutes these blocks by , keeping each block intact)
:and given permutations ,
::
::(where denotes the element of that permutes the first of these blocks by , the second by , etc., and keeps their overall order intact).
The permutation actions in this definition are vital to most applications, including the original application to loop spaces.
Morphisms
A morphism of operads consists of a sequence
:
that:
* preserves the identity:
* preserves composition: for every ''n''-ary operation and operations ,
::
* preserves the permutation actions: .
Operads therefore form a
category
Category, plural categories, may refer to:
Philosophy and general uses
*Categorization, categories in cognitive science, information science and generally
* Category of being
* ''Categories'' (Aristotle)
* Category (Kant)
* Categories (Peirce) ...
denoted by .
In other categories
So far operads have only been considered in the
category
Category, plural categories, may refer to:
Philosophy and general uses
*Categorization, categories in cognitive science, information science and generally
* Category of being
* ''Categories'' (Aristotle)
* Category (Kant)
* Categories (Peirce) ...
of sets. More generally, it is possible to define operads in any
symmetric monoidal category In category theory, a branch of mathematics, a symmetric monoidal category is a monoidal category (i.e. a category in which a "tensor product" \otimes is defined) such that the tensor product is symmetric (i.e. A\otimes B is, in a certain strict s ...
C . In that case, each is an object of C, the composition is a morphism in C (where denotes the tensor product of the monoidal category), and the actions of the symmetric group elements are given by isomorphisms in C.
A common example is the category of
topological spaces
In mathematics, a topological space is, roughly speaking, a geometrical space in which closeness is defined but cannot necessarily be measured by a numeric distance. More specifically, a topological space is a set whose elements are called poi ...
and continuous maps, with the monoidal product given by the
cartesian product
In mathematics, specifically set theory, the Cartesian product of two sets ''A'' and ''B'', denoted ''A''×''B'', is the set of all ordered pairs where ''a'' is in ''A'' and ''b'' is in ''B''. In terms of set-builder notation, that is
: A\ ...
. In this case, a topological operad is given by a sequence of ''spaces'' (instead of sets) . The structure maps of the operad (the composition and the actions of the symmetric groups) are then assumed to be continuous. The result is called a ''topological operad''. Similarly, in the definition of a morphism of operads, it would be necessary to assume that the maps involved are continuous.
Other common settings to define operads include, for example, modules over a commutative ring,
chain complex
In mathematics, a chain complex is an algebraic structure that consists of a sequence of abelian groups (or modules) and a sequence of homomorphisms between consecutive groups such that the image of each homomorphism is included in the kernel of ...
es,
groupoid
In mathematics, especially in category theory and homotopy theory, a groupoid (less often Brandt groupoid or virtual group) generalises the notion of group in several equivalent ways. A groupoid can be seen as a:
*'' Group'' with a partial fun ...
s (or even the category of categories itself),
coalgebra In mathematics, coalgebras or cogebras are structures that are dual (in the category-theoretic sense of reversing arrows) to unital associative algebras. The axioms of unital associative algebras can be formulated in terms of commutative diagra ...
s, etc.
Algebraist definition
Given a commutative ring ''R'' we consider the category of modules over ''R''. An ''operad'' over ''R'' can be defined as a
monoid object
In category theory, a branch of mathematics, a monoid (or monoid object, or internal monoid, or algebra) in a monoidal category is an object ''M'' together with two morphisms
* ''μ'': ''M'' ⊗ ''M'' → ''M'' called ''multiplication'',
* '' ...
in the monoidal category of endofunctors on (it is a monad) satisfying some finiteness condition.”finiteness" refers to the fact that only a finite number of inputs are allowed in the definition of an operad. For example, the condition is satisfied if one can write
:,
:.
For example, a monoid object in the category of "polynomial endofunctors" on is an operad. Similarly, a symmetric operad can be defined as a monoid object in the category of -objects, where means a symmetric group. A monoid object in the category of
combinatorial species
In combinatorial mathematics, the theory of combinatorial species is an abstract, systematic method for deriving the generating functions of discrete structures, which allows one to not merely count these structures but give bijective proofs in ...
is an operad in finite sets.
An operad in the above sense is sometimes thought of as a generalized ring. For example, Nikolai Durov defines his generalized rings as monoid objects in the monoidal category of endofunctors on that commute with filtered colimits. This is a generalization of a ring since each ordinary ring ''R'' defines a monad that sends a set ''X'' to the underlying set of the free ''R''-module generated by ''X''.
Understanding the axioms
Associativity axiom
"Associativity" means that ''composition'' of operations is associative
(the function is associative), analogous to the axiom in category theory that ; it does ''not'' mean that the operations ''themselves'' are associative as operations.
Compare with the associative operad, below.
Associativity in operad theory means that expressions can be written involving operations without ambiguity from the omitted compositions, just as associativity for operations allows products to be written without ambiguity from the omitted parentheses.
For instance, if is a binary operation, which is written as or . So that may or may not be associative.
Then what is commonly written is unambiguously written operadically as . This sends to (apply on the first two, and the identity on the third), and then the on the left "multiplies" by .
This is clearer when depicted as a tree:
which yields a 3-ary operation:
However, the expression is ''a priori'' ambiguous:
it could mean , if the inner compositions are performed first, or it could mean ,
if the outer compositions are performed first (operations are read from right to left).
Writing , this is versus . That is, the tree is missing "vertical parentheses":
If the top two rows of operations are composed first (puts an upward parenthesis at the line; does the inner composition first), the following results:
which then evaluates unambiguously to yield a 4-ary operation.
As an annotated expression:
:
If the bottom two rows of operations are composed first (puts a downward parenthesis at the line; does the outer composition first), following results:
which then evaluates unambiguously to yield a 4-ary operation:
The operad axiom of associativity is that ''these yield the same result'', and thus that the expression is unambiguous.
Identity axiom
The identity axiom (for a binary operation) can be visualized in a tree as:
meaning that the three operations obtained are equal: pre- or post- composing with the identity makes no difference. As for categories, is a corollary of the identity axiom.
Examples
Endomorphism operad in sets and operad algebras
The most basic operads are the ones given in the section on "Intuition", above. For any set , we obtain the ''endomorphism operad '' consisting of all functions . These operads are important because they serve to define operad algebras. If is an operad, an operad algebra over is given by a set and an operad morphism . Intuitively, such a morphism turns each "abstract" operation of into a "concrete" -ary operation on the set . An operad algebra over thus consists of a set together with concrete operations on that follow the rules abstractely specified by the operad .
Endomorphism operad in vector spaces and operad algebras
If ''k'' is a
field
Field may refer to:
Expanses of open ground
* Field (agriculture), an area of land used for agricultural purposes
* Airfield, an aerodrome that lacks the infrastructure of an airport
* Battlefield
* Lawn, an area of mowed grass
* Meadow, a grass ...
, we can consider the category of finite-dimensional
vector space
In mathematics and physics, a vector space (also called a linear space) is a set whose elements, often called '' vectors'', may be added together and multiplied ("scaled") by numbers called '' scalars''. Scalars are often real numbers, but ...
s over ''k''; this becomes a monoidal category using the ordinary
tensor product
In mathematics, the tensor product V \otimes W of two vector spaces and (over the same Field (mathematics), field) is a vector space to which is associated a bilinear map V\times W \to V\otimes W that maps a pair (v,w),\ v\in V, w\in W to an e ...
over ''k.'' We can then define endomorphism operads in this category, as follows. Let ''V'' be a finite-dimensional vector space The ''endomorphism operad'' of ''V'' consists of
# = the space of linear maps ,
# (composition) given , , ..., , their composition is given by the map ,
# (identity) The identity element in is the identity map ,
# (symmetric group action) operates on by permuting the components of the tensors in .
If is an operad, a ''k''-linear operad algebra over is given by a finite-dimensional vector space ''V'' over ''k'' and an operad morphism ; this amounts to specifying concrete multilinear operations on ''V'' that behave like the operations of . (Notice the analogy between operads&operad algebras and rings&modules: a module over a ring ''R'' is given by an abelian group ''M'' together with a ring homomorphism .)
Depending on applications, variations of the above are possible: for example, in algebraic topology, instead of vector spaces and tensor products between them, one uses (reasonable) topological spaces and cartesian products between them.
"Little something" operads
The ''little 2-disks operad'' is a topological operad where consists of ordered lists of ''n'' disjoint disks inside the
unit disk
In mathematics, the open unit disk (or disc) around ''P'' (where ''P'' is a given point in the plane), is the set of points whose distance from ''P'' is less than 1:
:D_1(P) = \.\,
The closed unit disk around ''P'' is the set of points whose ...
of centered at the origin. The symmetric group acts on such configurations by permuting the list of little disks. The operadic composition for little disks is illustrated in the accompanying figure to the right, where an element is composed with an element to yield the element obtained by shrinking the configuration of and inserting it into the ''i-''th disk of , for .
Analogously, one can define the ''little n-disks operad'' by considering configurations of disjoint ''n''-balls inside the unit ball of .
Originally the ''little n-cubes operad'' or the ''little intervals operad'' (initially called little ''n''-cubes
PROP
A prop, formally known as (theatrical) property, is an object used on stage or screen by actors during a performance or screen production. In practical terms, a prop is considered to be anything movable or portable on a stage or a set, distinct ...
s) was defined by
Michael Boardman
John Michael Boardman (13 February 193818 March 2021) was a mathematician whose speciality was algebraic and differential topology. He was affiliated with the University of Cambridge, England and the Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore, Mar ...
and
Rainer Vogt
Rainer may refer to:
People
* Rainer (surname)
* Rainer (given name)
Other
* Rainer Island, an island in Franz Josef Land, Russia
* 16802 Rainer
Year 168 ( CLXVIII) was a leap year starting on Thursday (link will display the full calendar ...
in a similar way, in terms of configurations of disjoint
axis-aligned
In geometry, an axis-aligned object (axis-parallel, axis-oriented) is an object in ''n''-dimensional space whose shape is aligned with the coordinate axes of the space.
Examples are axis-aligned rectangles (or hyperrectangles), the ones with edg ...
''n''-dimensional
hypercube
In geometry, a hypercube is an ''n''-dimensional analogue of a square () and a cube (). It is a closed, compact, convex figure whose 1-skeleton consists of groups of opposite parallel line segments aligned in each of the space's dimensions ...
unit hypercube
A unit cube, more formally a cube of side 1, is a cube whose sides are 1 unit long.. See in particulap. 671. The volume of a 3-dimensional unit cube is 1 cubic unit, and its total surface area is 6 square units..
Unit hypercube
The term '' ...
. Later it was generalized by May to the little convex bodies operad, and "little disks" is a case of "folklore" derived from the "little convex bodies".
Rooted trees
In graph theory,
rooted tree
In graph theory, a tree is an undirected graph in which any two vertices are connected by ''exactly one'' path, or equivalently a connected acyclic undirected graph. A forest is an undirected graph in which any two vertices are connected by ' ...
s form a natural operad. Here, is the set of all rooted trees with ''n'' leaves, where the leaves are numbered from 1 to ''n.'' The group operates on this set by permuting the leaf labels. Operadic composition is given by replacing the ''i''-th leaf of by the root of the ''i''-th tree , for , thus attaching the ''n'' trees to and forming a larger tree, whose root is taken to be the same as the root of and whose leaves are numbered in order.
Swiss-cheese operad
The ''Swiss-cheese operad'' is a two-colored topological operad defined in terms of configurations of disjoint ''n''-dimensional disks inside a unit ''n''-semidisk and ''n''-dimensional semidisks, centered at the base of the unit semidisk and sitting inside of it. The operadic composition comes from gluing configurations of "little" disks inside the unit disk into the "little" disks in another unit semidisk and configurations of "little" disks and semidisks inside the unit semidisk into the other unit semidisk.
The Swiss-cheese operad was defined by
Alexander A. Voronov
Alexander A. Voronov (russian: Александр Александрович Воронов) (born November 25, 1962) is a Russian-American mathematician specializing in mathematical physics, algebraic topology, and algebraic geometry. He is ...
. It was used by
Maxim Kontsevich
Maxim Lvovich Kontsevich (russian: Макси́м Льво́вич Конце́вич, ; born 25 August 1964) is a Russian and French mathematician and mathematical physicist. He is a professor at the Institut des Hautes Études Scientifiques a ...
to formulate a Swiss-cheese version of Deligne's conjecture on Hochschild cohomology. Kontsevich's conjecture was proven partly by Po Hu, Igor Kriz, and
Alexander A. Voronov
Alexander A. Voronov (russian: Александр Александрович Воронов) (born November 25, 1962) is a Russian-American mathematician specializing in mathematical physics, algebraic topology, and algebraic geometry. He is ...
and then fully by
Justin Thomas
Justin Louis Thomas (born April 29, 1993) is an American professional golfer who plays on the PGA Tour and is former World Number One. In 2017, Thomas experienced a breakout year, winning five PGA Tour events and the FedEx Cup championship. H ...
.
Associative operad
Another class of examples of operads are those capturing the structures of algebraic structures, such as associative algebras, commutative algebras and Lie algebras. Each of these can be exhibited as a finitely presented operad, in each of these three generated by binary operations.
For example, the associative operad is a symmetric operad generated by a binary operation , subject only to the condition that
:
This condition corresponds to
associativity
In mathematics, the associative property is a property of some binary operations, which means that rearranging the parentheses in an expression will not change the result. In propositional logic, associativity is a valid rule of replacement ...
of the binary operation ; writing multiplicatively, the above condition is . This associativity of the ''operation'' should not be confused with associativity of ''composition'' which holds in any operad; see the axiom of associativity, above.
In the associative operad, each is given by the
symmetric group
In abstract algebra, the symmetric group defined over any set is the group whose elements are all the bijections from the set to itself, and whose group operation is the composition of functions. In particular, the finite symmetric group ...
, on which acts by right multiplication. The composite permutes its inputs in blocks according to , and within blocks according to the appropriate .
The algebras over the associative operad are precisely the
semigroup
In mathematics, a semigroup is an algebraic structure consisting of a Set (mathematics), set together with an associative internal binary operation on it.
The binary operation of a semigroup is most often denoted multiplication, multiplicatively ...
s: sets together with a single binary associative operation. The ''k''-linear algebras over the associative operad are precisely the associative ''k-''algebras.
Terminal symmetric operad
The terminal symmetric operad is the operad which has a single ''n''-ary operation for each ''n'', with each acting trivially. The algebras over this operad are the commutative semigroups; the ''k''-linear algebras are the commutative associative ''k''-algebras.
Operads from the braid groups
Similarly, there is a non- operad for which each is given by the Artin
braid group
A braid (also referred to as a plait) is a complex structure or pattern formed by interlacing two or more strands of flexible material such as textile yarns, wire, or hair.
The simplest and most common version is a flat, solid, three-strande ...
. Moreover, this non- operad has the structure of a braided operad, which generalizes the notion of an operad from symmetric to braid groups.
Linear algebra
In
linear algebra
Linear algebra is the branch of mathematics concerning linear equations such as:
:a_1x_1+\cdots +a_nx_n=b,
linear maps such as:
:(x_1, \ldots, x_n) \mapsto a_1x_1+\cdots +a_nx_n,
and their representations in vector spaces and through matric ...
, real vector spaces can be considered to be algebras over the operad of all linear combinations . This operad is defined by for , with the obvious action of permuting components, and composition given by the concatentation of the vectors , where . The vector for instance represents the operation of forming a linear combination with coefficients 2,3,-5,0,...
This point of view formalizes the notion that linear combinations are the most general sort of operation on a vector space – saying that a vector space is an algebra over the operad of linear combinations is precisely the statement that ''all possible'' algebraic operations in a vector space are linear combinations. The basic operations of vector addition and scalar multiplication are a
generating set
In mathematics and physics, the term generator or generating set may refer to any of a number of related concepts. The underlying concept in each case is that of a smaller set of objects, together with a set of operations that can be applied t ...
for the operad of all linear combinations, while the linear combinations operad canonically encodes all possible operations on a vector space.
Similarly,
affine combination In mathematics, an affine combination of is a linear combination
: \sum_^ = \alpha_ x_ + \alpha_ x_ + \cdots +\alpha_ x_,
such that
:\sum_^ =1.
Here, can be elements ( vectors) of a vector space over a field , and the coefficients \alpha_ ...
s,
conical combination Given a finite number of vectors x_1, x_2, \dots, x_n in a real vector space, a conical combination, conical sum, or weighted sum''Convex Analysis and Minimization Algorithms'' by Jean-Baptiste Hiriart-Urruty, Claude Lemaréchal, 1993, pp. 101, 102/ ...
s, and
convex combination
In convex geometry and vector algebra, a convex combination is a linear combination of points (which can be vectors, scalars, or more generally points in an affine space) where all coefficients are non-negative and sum to 1. In other ...
s can be considered to correspond to the sub-operads where the terms of the vector sum to 1, the terms are all non-negative, or both, respectively. Graphically, these are the infinite affine hyperplane, the infinite hyper-octant, and the infinite simplex. This formalizes what is meant by being or the standard simplex being model spaces, and such observations as that every bounded convex polytope is the image of a simplex. Here suboperads correspond to more restricted operations and thus more general theories.
Commutative-ring operad and Lie operad
The ''commutative-ring operad'' is an operad whose algebras are the commutative rings. It is defined by