genus
Genus (; : genera ) is a taxonomic rank above species and below family (taxonomy), family as used in the biological classification of extant taxon, living and fossil organisms as well as Virus classification#ICTV classification, viruses. In bino ...
of
dromaeosaurid
Dromaeosauridae () is a family (biology), family of feathered coelurosaurian Theropoda, theropod dinosaurs. They were generally small to medium-sized feathered carnivores that flourished in the Cretaceous period (geology), Period. The name Drom ...
dinosaur
Dinosaurs are a diverse group of reptiles of the clade Dinosauria. They first appeared during the Triassic Geological period, period, between 243 and 233.23 million years ago (mya), although the exact origin and timing of the #Evolutio ...
that lived during the
Late Cretaceous
The Late Cretaceous (100.5–66 Ma) is the more recent of two epochs into which the Cretaceous Period is divided in the geologic time scale. Rock strata from this epoch form the Upper Cretaceous Series. The Cretaceous is named after ''cre ...
in what is now
Alberta
Alberta is a Provinces and territories of Canada, province in Canada. It is a part of Western Canada and is one of the three Canadian Prairies, prairie provinces. Alberta is bordered by British Columbia to its west, Saskatchewan to its east, t ...
, Canada. The first specimen, a partial skull, was discovered in 1995 by the
fossil collector
Fossil collecting (sometimes, in a non-scientific sense, fossil hunting) is the collection of the fossils for scientific study, hobby, or profit. Fossil collecting, as practiced by amateurs, is the predecessor of modern paleontology and many ...
Wayne Marshall in the
Horseshoe Canyon Formation
The Horseshoe Canyon Formation is a stratigraphic unit of the Western Canada Sedimentary Basin in southwestern Alberta. It takes its name from Horseshoe Canyon, an area of badlands near Drumheller.
The Horseshoe Canyon Formation is part of th ...
, about from the
Royal Tyrrell Museum of Palaeontology
The Royal Tyrrell Museum of Palaeontology (RTMP; often referred to as the Royal Tyrrell Museum) is a palaeontology museum and research facility in Drumheller, Alberta, Canada. The museum was named in honour of Joseph Burr Tyrrell, and is situate ...
where it was brought for preparation. In 2004, the specimen became the
holotype
A holotype (Latin: ''holotypus'') is a single physical example (or illustration) of an organism used when the species (or lower-ranked taxon) was formally described. It is either the single such physical example (or illustration) or one of s ...
of the new genus and species ''Atrociraptor marshalli''; the generic name is
Latin
Latin ( or ) is a classical language belonging to the Italic languages, Italic branch of the Indo-European languages. Latin was originally spoken by the Latins (Italic tribe), Latins in Latium (now known as Lazio), the lower Tiber area aroun ...
for "savage robber", and the specific name refers to Marshall. The holotype consists of the (frontmost bones of the upper jaw), a (main bone of the upper jaw), the (tooth-bearing bones of the lower jaw), associated teeth, and other skull fragments. Isolated teeth from the same formation have since been assigned to ''Atrociraptor''.
Estimated to have measured about in length and weighed , ''Atrociraptor'' was a relatively small dromaeosaurid. As a dromaeosaurid, it would have had a large sickle-claw on the second toe and pennaceous feathers. ''Atrociraptor'' differs from its contemporary relatives in that its face is much deeper, and its teeth are more strongly inclined backwards than in most other dromaeosaurids and are almost all the same size. It also differed from most relatives in details of the skull, such as the part of the premaxilla below the nostril being taller than long, and in that its maxillary fenestra was larger. The fragmentary nature of the holotype has made the exact relations of ''Atrociraptor'' uncertain; it was initially thought to be a velociraptorine, but is now considered a
saurornitholestine
Eudromaeosauria ( ; "true dromaeosaurs") is a subgroup of terrestrial dromaeosaurid theropod dinosaurs. They were small to large-sized predators that flourished during the Cretaceous Period. Eudromaeosaur fossils are known almost exclusively fr ...
.
''Atrociraptor'' is thought to have been specialised for attacking larger prey than other dromaeosaurids, due to its deep snout. Various ideas for how dromaeosaurids used their sickle-claws have been proposed, and 21st-century studies suggest they used them to grasp and restrain struggling prey while dismembering them with the mouth. The holotype specimen is known from the Horsethief
Member
Member may refer to:
* Military jury, referred to as "Members" in military jargon
* Element (mathematics), an object that belongs to a mathematical set
* In object-oriented programming, a member of a class
** Field (computer science), entries in ...
of the Horseshoe Canyon Formation, which dates to the
Maastrichtian
The Maastrichtian ( ) is, in the International Commission on Stratigraphy (ICS) geologic timescale, the latest age (geology), age (uppermost stage (stratigraphy), stage) of the Late Cretaceous epoch (geology), Epoch or Upper Cretaceous series (s ...
age, and ranges from around 72.2–71.5 million years ago. Assigned teeth from other parts of the formation indicate it survived for over 2 million years and across a wide geographic area.
Discovery
In 1995, the part-time
fossil collector
Fossil collecting (sometimes, in a non-scientific sense, fossil hunting) is the collection of the fossils for scientific study, hobby, or profit. Fossil collecting, as practiced by amateurs, is the predecessor of modern paleontology and many ...
Wayne Marshall discovered a partial skull of a
dromaeosaurid
Dromaeosauridae () is a family (biology), family of feathered coelurosaurian Theropoda, theropod dinosaurs. They were generally small to medium-sized feathered carnivores that flourished in the Cretaceous period (geology), Period. The name Drom ...
(commonly called "raptor")
dinosaur
Dinosaurs are a diverse group of reptiles of the clade Dinosauria. They first appeared during the Triassic Geological period, period, between 243 and 233.23 million years ago (mya), although the exact origin and timing of the #Evolutio ...
in the
Horseshoe Canyon Formation
The Horseshoe Canyon Formation is a stratigraphic unit of the Western Canada Sedimentary Basin in southwestern Alberta. It takes its name from Horseshoe Canyon, an area of badlands near Drumheller.
The Horseshoe Canyon Formation is part of th ...
of
Drumheller
Drumheller is a town on the Red Deer River in the badlands of east-central Alberta, Canada. It is located northeast of Calgary and south of Stettler. The Drumheller portion of the Red Deer River valley, often referred to as Dinosaur Vall ...
in
Alberta
Alberta is a Provinces and territories of Canada, province in Canada. It is a part of Western Canada and is one of the three Canadian Prairies, prairie provinces. Alberta is bordered by British Columbia to its west, Saskatchewan to its east, t ...
, Canada, about west of the
Royal Tyrrell Museum of Palaeontology
The Royal Tyrrell Museum of Palaeontology (RTMP; often referred to as the Royal Tyrrell Museum) is a palaeontology museum and research facility in Drumheller, Alberta, Canada. The museum was named in honour of Joseph Burr Tyrrell, and is situate ...
. Marshall had previously worked in the museum's mounting shop, helping to construct exhibits until the museum opened in 1985, and reported fossils to museum staff as he found them over the years. Jaw fragments and teeth eroding from the hillside led to the discovery of the dromaeosaur specimen; Marshall collected the loose fossil fragments and delivered them to the palaeontologist Philip J. Currie at the museum, and the remaining parts were later collected. Much of the specimen was in a relatively hard block of
sandstone
Sandstone is a Clastic rock#Sedimentary clastic rocks, clastic sedimentary rock composed mainly of grain size, sand-sized (0.0625 to 2 mm) silicate mineral, silicate grains, Cementation (geology), cemented together by another mineral. Sand ...
, and preparation revealed the right (main bone of the upper jaw) exposed in outer side-view and the right (tooth-bearing bone of the lower jaw) exposed in inner side view, and both of these bones were left in the block.
In 2004, Currie and the palaeontologist David Varricchio made the specimen (catalogued as RTMP 95.166.1) the
holotype
A holotype (Latin: ''holotypus'') is a single physical example (or illustration) of an organism used when the species (or lower-ranked taxon) was formally described. It is either the single such physical example (or illustration) or one of s ...
of the new
genus
Genus (; : genera ) is a taxonomic rank above species and below family (taxonomy), family as used in the biological classification of extant taxon, living and fossil organisms as well as Virus classification#ICTV classification, viruses. In bino ...
and species ''Atrociraptor marshalli''. The generic name is derived from the
Latin
Latin ( or ) is a classical language belonging to the Italic languages, Italic branch of the Indo-European languages. Latin was originally spoken by the Latins (Italic tribe), Latins in Latium (now known as Lazio), the lower Tiber area aroun ...
words , which means , and , . The
specific name Specific name may refer to:
* in Database management systems, a system-assigned name that is unique within a particular database
In taxonomy, either of these two meanings, each with its own set of rules:
* Specific name (botany), the two-part (bino ...
references Marshall, the discoverer, and the full name can be translated as "Marshall's savage robber". Since then, Marshall has led the museum staff to many important finds. In all, the holotype preserves both (frontmost bone of the upper jaw, freed from the rock matrix), a right maxilla, both dentaries (the left one is incomplete), associated teeth (some having fallen out of their sockets prior to fossilisation), and numerous bone fragments from the skull. The specimen was not fully prepared by the time of its original description, so in 2022, the palaeontologist Mark J. Powers and colleagues used
computed tomography
A computed tomography scan (CT scan), formerly called computed axial tomography scan (CAT scan), is a medical imaging technique used to obtain detailed internal images of the body. The personnel that perform CT scans are called radiographers or ...
to visualise further details of the skull. Numerous isolated teeth from the Horseshoe Canyon Formation (some of which had originally been assigned to ''
Saurornitholestes
''Saurornitholestes'' ("lizard-bird thief") is a genus of carnivorous dromaeosaurid theropod dinosaur from the late Cretaceous of Canada (Alberta and Saskatchewan) and the United States (Montana, New Mexico, Alabama, and South Carolina).
Two spe ...
'') have since been assigned to ''Atrociraptor''. Some of these were found in a
bonebed
A bone bed is any geological stratum or deposit that contains bones of whatever kind. Inevitably, such deposits are sedimentary in nature. Not a formal term, it tends to be used more to describe especially dense collections such as Lagerstätte. ...
in
Dry Island Buffalo Jump Provincial Park
Dry Island Buffalo Jump Provincial Park is a provincial park in Central Alberta, Canada, located about southeast of Red Deer and northeast of Trochu, 1 mile north and 10 miles east of Huxley. The park is situated along the Red Deer River and fe ...
, which also preserves multiple ''
Albertosaurus
''Albertosaurus'' (; meaning "Alberta lizard") is a genus of large tyrannosaurid theropod dinosaur that lived in northwestern North America during the early to middle Maastrichtian age of the Late Cretaceous period, about 71 million yea ...
'' individuals.
''Atrociraptor'' was featured in the 2022 film ''
Jurassic World Dominion
''Jurassic World Dominion'' is a 2022 American Science fiction film, science fiction action film directed by Colin Trevorrow, who co-wrote the screenplay with Emily Carmichael (filmmaker), Emily Carmichael from a story by Derek Connolly and Tre ...
'', with the director describing it as more "brutish" than ''
Velociraptor
''Velociraptor'' (; ) is a genus of small dromaeosaurid dinosaurs that lived in Asia during the Late Cretaceous epoch, about 75 million to 71 million years ago. Two species are currently recognized, although others have been assigned in th ...
'' as it appears in the film. A ''
/Film
''/Film'', also spelled ''SlashFilm'', is a blog that covers movie news, reviews, interviews, and trailers. It was founded by Peter Sciretta in August 2005. The site's reviews appear on Rotten Tomatoes, and as of 2024, two of its leading film cr ...
'' writer commented that while ''Atrociraptor'' "might sound like another made-up
hybrid
Hybrid may refer to:
Science
* Hybrid (biology), an offspring resulting from cross-breeding
** Hybrid grape, grape varieties produced by cross-breeding two ''Vitis'' species
** Hybridity, the property of a hybrid plant which is a union of two diff ...
dinosaur invented for the ''Jurassic World'' films ... it's a very real dino with its own Wiki page and everything".
Description
''Atrociraptor'' was a relatively small dromaeosaurid, comparable to ''Velociraptor'' in size, and is estimated to have measured about in length and weighed . As a dromaeosaur, it would have had large arms, a long tail with vertebrae encased in rod-like extensions, and a large sickle-claw on the robust, hyper-extendible second toe. Fossils of other dromaeosaurids, such as ''
Zhenyuanlong
''Zhenyuanlong'' (meaning ''"Zhenyuan's dragon"'', from Chinese language, Chinese Pinyin :wikt:龙, 龙/:wikt:龍, 龍 lóng ''"dragon"'') is a genus of Dromaeosauridae, dromaeosaurid dinosaur from the Yixian Formation of Liaoning, China. It liv ...
'', show that even relatively large members of the group had pennaceous feathers, with large wings on the arms and long feathers on the tail. ''Atrociraptor'' does not have
autapomorphies
In phylogenetics, an autapomorphy is a distinctive feature, known as a derived trait, that is unique to a given taxon. That is, it is found only in one taxon, but not found in any others or outgroup taxa, not even those most closely related to ...
(unique diagnostic features) that can be used to distinguish it, but it has a unique combination of features that is so far unknown in relatives. ''Atrociraptor'' mainly differs from its contemporary relatives ''
Bambiraptor
''Bambiraptor'' is a Late Cretaceous, 72-million-year-old, bird-like dromaeosaurid theropod dinosaur described by scientists at the University of Kansas, Yale University, and the University of New Orleans.
The holotype fossil is less than one ...
'', ''Saurornitholestes'', and ''Velociraptor'' in that its face is much deeper, and in that its maxillary teeth are more strongly inclined backwards than in most other dromaeosaurids, and in the teeth being almost all the same size.
The relatively deep premaxillae have four teeth each, the same number as in other dromaeosaurids. The part of the premaxilla below the nostril is taller than long from front to back, as in ''
Deinonychus
''Deinonychus'' ( ; ) is a genus of Dromaeosauridae, dromaeosaurid Theropoda, theropod dinosaur with one described species, ''Deinonychus antirrhopus''. This species, which could grow up to long, lived during the early Cretaceous Period (ge ...
'', ''
Utahraptor
''Utahraptor'' (meaning "Utah's predator") is a genus of large dromaeosaurid (a group of feathered carnivorous theropods) dinosaur that lived during the Early Cretaceous period from around 139 to 135 million years ago in what is now the United ...
'', and perhaps ''
Dromaeosaurus
''Dromaeosaurus'' (; ) is a genus of Dromaeosauridae, dromaeosaurid theropod dinosaur that lived during the Late Cretaceous period (middle late Campanian and Maastrichtian), sometime between 80 and 69 million years ago, in Alberta, Canada and th ...
'', while the opposite is the case for ''Bambiraptor'', ''Saurornitholestes'', and ''Velociraptor''. There is an elongated extension below the nostril, the subnarial process, that is wedged between the and the maxilla, as in other dromaeosaurids. The almost parallel subnarial and internarial (above the nostrils) processes are oriented more upwards than hindwards due to the depth of the snout, unlike in other dromaeosaurids where the opposite is true. The shallow depression on the side of the premaxilla that marks the lower front limit of the nostril opening is nested between the subnarial and internarial processes, while it extends further to the front in ''Velociraptor''.
The second tooth of the premaxilla is the largest of the four therein, based on the size of the , as in some relatives. As in ''Saurornitholestes'', the front is on the inner hind edge of the tooth, but more forwards positioned than the hind cutting edge. The teeth look more J-shaped than D-shaped in cross section. The on the front and hind cutting edges of the premaxillary teeth have almost the same basal diameter, though those on the front are taller. There are 2.3–3.0 serrations per .
The , an opening in the front of the antorbital fossa (a depression around the
antorbital fenestra
An antorbital fenestra (plural: fenestrae) is an opening in the skull that is in front of the eye sockets. This skull character is largely associated with Archosauriformes, archosauriforms, first appearing during the Triassic Period. Among Extant ...
, the large opening in front of the eye), is positioned right under the maxillary fenestra, another opening. In relatives where both these fenestrae are known, the promaxillary fenestra is well in front of and below the maxillary fenestra. The maxilla is roughly triangular and relatively deeper than in other dromaeosaurids. The height between the maxillary fenestra and the tooth-bearing margin of the maxilla is more than twice the height of the largest tooth in ''Atrociraptor'', whereas it is less than twice that in other dromaeosaurids. If the teeth can be assumed to have had the same relative height among dromaeosaurids, the short and deep appearance of the maxilla of ''Atrociraptor'' could be due to the snout having an increased depth rather than because the snout was shortened.
The antorbital fenestra of ''Atrociraptor'' was relatively small compared to in other dromaeosaurids, with the portion in the maxilla taking up less than 43% its length, and the antorbital fossa also appears to have been relatively smaller. The rounded maxillary fenestra is larger than in relatives, and had a diameter of about when complete. In front of a depression on the side at the back of the maxilla, the margin of the antorbital fossa slopes forwards and up at a higher angle than in other dromaeosaurids. Right above the margin of the tooth sockets, the maxilla has a row of neurovascular foramina (which supplied blood). The lower margin of the maxilla is strongly convex when seen from the side.
The maxilla contains eleven teeth (comparable to most other dromaeosaurids), which are closely packed in their sockets with no gaps between them. The maxillary teeth are narrow from side to side, blade-like, and have a distinct inclination towards the back and down; only the teeth of ''Bambiraptor'' and ''Deinonychus'' are similarly inclined. The maxillary dentition is almost
isodont
Hinge teeth are part of the anatomical structure of the inner surface of a bivalve shell, i.e. the shell of a bivalve mollusk. Bivalves by definition have two valves, which are joined together by a strong and flexible ligament situated on the hin ...
(the teeth being of similar size), and, unusually for dromaeosurids, there are no gaps left by shed teeth in the holotype. The teeth vary little in overall height, while in ''Velociraptor'' every other tooth is noticeably longer than those next to it. The maxillary teeth have larger serrations on their hind cutting edge, 3–4.5 per mm, than their front, 5–8 per mm. The serrations on the hind edge have relatively straight shafts with hooked tips, and are taller than the serrations at the front. The front and hind cutting edges lie on the midline of the maxillary teeth like in relatives but unlike ''Dromaeosaurus'', and the teeth are generally comparable to those of ''Bambiraptor'', ''Deinonychus'', ''Saurornitholestes'', and ''Velociraptor''.
The dentary of ''Atrociraptor'' is similar to those of other dromaeosaurids. The upper and lower margins are almost parallel, though the height decreases somewhat towards the back of the tooth-bearing part. The (an opening at the side of the lower jaw) appears to have been small and set low as in relatives, and the dentary has two rows of nutritive foramina. The dentary is thin from side to side, the
Meckelian canal
The Meckelian groove (or Meckel's groove, Meckelian fossa, or Meckelian foramen, or Meckelian canal) is an opening in the medial (inner) surface of the mandible (lower jaw) which exposes the Meckelian cartilage.
Classification
Within Dromaeosauridae, ''Atrociraptor'' is a member of
Eudromaeosauria
Eudromaeosauria (International Phonetic Alphabet, ; "true dromaeosaurs") is a subgroup of terrestrial Dromaeosauridae, dromaeosaurid theropod dinosaurs. They were small to large-sized predators that flourished during the Cretaceous Period (geolo ...
(or "true dromaeosaurids"), a group that includes the subfamilies
Saurornitholestinae
Eudromaeosauria (International Phonetic Alphabet, ; "true dromaeosaurs") is a subgroup of terrestrial Dromaeosauridae, dromaeosaurid theropod dinosaurs. They were small to large-sized predators that flourished during the Cretaceous Period (geolo ...
,
Velociraptorinae
Eudromaeosauria ( ; "true dromaeosaurs") is a subgroup of terrestrial dromaeosaurid theropod dinosaurs. They were small to large-sized predators that flourished during the Cretaceous Period. Eudromaeosaur fossils are known almost exclusively f ...
, and Dromaeosaurinae. Below is a cladogram showing the position of Eudromaeosauria within Dromaeosauridae.
The pattern of eudromaeosaur dispersal is controversial among scientists. Some researchers have suggested that saurornitholestines are the earliest-diverging members of this group. If that is the case, it suggests a North American origin for Eudromaeosauria. However, if saurornitholestines are more closely related to velociraptorines, then they may have immigrated to North America from Asia closer to the end of the Cretaceous. The general uncertainty of the internal classification of Eudromaeosauria complicates discussion of the placement of ''Atrociraptor''. This is compounded by the incompleteness of the known remains (four skull bones and several teeth). The skull and teeth of ''Atrociraptor'' bear similarities to many dromaeosaur taxa including ''Dromaeosaurus'', ''
Shri
Shri (; , ) is a Sanskrit term denoting resplendence, wealth and prosperity, primarily used as an honorific.
The word is widely used in South and Southeast Asian languages such as Assamese, Meitei ( Manipuri), Marathi, Malay (including In ...
'', ''Saurornitholestes'', and '' Kuru''. For this reason, some studies fully omit ''Atrociraptor'' from the presentation of their findings in order to improve the clarity of the interrelationships they found in their phylogenetic analyses.
When ''Atrociraptor'' was first described in 2004, it was found to be closely related to ''Deinonychus'' and assigned to the dromaeosaurid
subfamily
In biological classification, a subfamily (Latin: ', plural ') is an auxiliary (intermediate) taxonomic rank, next below family but more inclusive than genus. Standard nomenclature rules end botanical subfamily names with "-oideae", and zo ...
Velociraptorinae, a group known predominantly from the
Late Cretaceous
The Late Cretaceous (100.5–66 Ma) is the more recent of two epochs into which the Cretaceous Period is divided in the geologic time scale. Rock strata from this epoch form the Upper Cretaceous Series. The Cretaceous is named after ''cre ...
of Asia. This was based on the difference in size between the front and back serrations on the maxillary teeth and the size of the second premaxillary tooth. The describers cautioned that this position might change if more fossil material was found. A 2009 analysis by the palaeontologist Nicholas Longrich and Currie instead grouped ''Atrociraptor'' with ''Saurornitholestes'' as part of a new subfamily: Saurornitholestinae. By 2012, the palaeontologist Alan H. Turner and colleagues stated that the three phylogenetic analyses featuring ''Atrociraptor'' so far had such disparate results that there was no consensus regarding its affinity to other dromaeosaurids.
In their 2013 description of '' Acheroraptor'', the palaeontologist David Evans and colleagues suggested that ''Atrociraptor'' was the
sister taxon
In phylogenetics, a sister group or sister taxon, also called an adelphotaxon, comprises the closest relative(s) of another given unit in an evolutionary tree.
Definition
The expression is most easily illustrated by a cladogram:
Taxon A and ...
of the much older genus ''Deinonychus'' in a
clade
In biology, a clade (), also known as a Monophyly, monophyletic group or natural group, is a group of organisms that is composed of a common ancestor and all of its descendants. Clades are the fundamental unit of cladistics, a modern approach t ...
more advanced than Saurornitholestinae but outside of both Velociraptorinae and Dromaeosaurinae. This analysis used the same phylogenetic data set as the earlier analysis by Longrich and Currie, but included additional taxa which had been described in the interim. The analysis that accompanied the 2015 description of ''
Dakotaraptor
''Dakotaraptor'' (meaning “thief from Dakota”) is a possible chimaeric genus of maniraptoriform theropod dinosaur that lived in western North America during the Late Cretaceous period. The remains have been found in the Maastrichtian-aged ...
'' by the palaeontologist Robert DePalma and colleagues suggested that ''Atrociraptor'' was a member of Dromaeosaurinae, alongside ''Deinonychus'', although they did not directly comment on the placement of ''Atrociraptor'' in their analysis. A similar result to DePalma and colleagues was found by the palaeontologists William and Kristen Parsons later in 2015.
By the 2020s, dromaeosaurid systematics included several unique phylogenetic datasets which have produced slightly different results. One of these datasets is the so-called "TWiG matrix" (an abbreviation for the Theropod Working Group), developed by the palaeontologists
Steven Brusatte
Stephen Louis "Steve" Brusatte FRSE (born April 24, 1984) is an American author and evolutionary biologist who specializes in the anatomy and evolution of dinosaurs. He was educated at the University of Chicago for his Bachelor's degree, at the ...
,
Andrea Cau
Andrea Cau is an Italian vertebrate paleontologist. He specialises in the study of dinosaur cladistics. Cau named the unique dromaeosaurid theropod '' Halszkaraptor'' in 2017. He also reanalysed the theropod ''Balaur'', placing it as a basal avial ...
,
Mark Norell
Mark Allen Norell (born July 26, 1957) is an American vertebrate paleontologist. He is currently the chairman of paleontology and a research associate at the American Museum of Natural History. He is best known as the discoverer of the first ...
, and several other researchers, which contains data for most named
coelurosaurian
Coelurosauria (; from Greek, meaning "hollow-tailed lizards") is the clade containing all theropod dinosaurs more closely related to birds than to carnosaurs.
Coelurosauria is a subgroup of theropod dinosaurs that includes compsognathids, tyra ...
taxa and is updated regularly by new authors. Other matrices include the matrix published by Mark Powers, the one published by Scott Hartman and colleagues, and one produced by Philip Currie and David Evans. In many of the most updated analyses for each of these matrices, including data from recently described taxa, ''Atrociraptor'' has been consistently found to be a member of Saurornitholestinae.
The results of two analyses, displaying two of the possible hypotheses of the affinities of ''Atrociraptor'', are shown below.
;Evans, Larson, & Currie 2013
;Czepiński 2023
Palaeobiology
The palaeontologist
Gregory S. Paul
Gregory Scott Paul (born December 24, 1954) is an American freelance researcher, author and illustrator who works in paleontology. He is best known for his work and research on theropoda, theropod dinosaurs and his detailed illustrations, both l ...
suggested in 2016 that ''Atrociraptor'' was able to attack relatively large prey and to wound it more than its relatives with its strong head and teeth. Powers and colleagues noted in 2022 that all dromaeosaurids with their deep maxillae are considered to have been predators, based on their relatively large size, few yet large serrated teeth, recurved claws including their sickle-claws, and a very developed
olfactory system
The olfactory system, is the sensory nervous system, sensory system used for the sense of smell (olfaction). Olfaction is one of the special senses directly associated with specific organs. Most mammals and reptiles have a main olfactory system ...
(sense of smell). The development of deep snouts in addition was probably an adaptation for handling
vertebrate
Vertebrates () are animals with a vertebral column (backbone or spine), and a cranium, or skull. The vertebral column surrounds and protects the spinal cord, while the cranium protects the brain.
The vertebrates make up the subphylum Vertebra ...
prey; velociraptorines with their elongated snouts that allowed for rapid biting at the cost of power perhaps specialised in smaller prey in their desert environments, and the small-bodied ''Acheroraptor'' and ''Saurornitholestes'' with their intermediate snout dimensions may have had more generalised diets in their more diverse ecosystems. The diverse and abundant prey in the environments of ''Atrociraptor'' and ''Deinonychus'' may have allowed for more specialised diets of large-bodied prey for these deep-snouted dromaeosaurids.
Dromaeosaurids are thought to have used the large sickle-claws on their second toes to deal with prey, and theories about how this was done have ranged from using the claws for slashing to climbing up prey larger than themselves. A 2011 study by the palaeontologist Denver W. Fowler and colleagues found these ideas unlikely, and instead suggested the claws were used like those of modern
birds of prey
Birds of prey or predatory birds, also known as (although not the same as) raptors, are hypercarnivorous bird species that actively predation, hunt and feed on other vertebrates (mainly mammals, reptiles and smaller birds). In addition to speed ...
, to grip and pin down prey, and immobilise it while dismembering it with the mouth. Fowler and colleagues called this the "Raptor Prey Restraint" model, and added that the grasping feet showed a shift to using the feet instead of the hands for restraining prey, as the forelimbs became increasingly feathered. The forelimbs could instead have been used for "stability flapping" as seen in birds of prey, which, along with movement of the tail, would have helped the predator stay in position when struggling with the prey. In 2019, the palaeontologist Peter J. Bishop examined the
biomechanics
Biomechanics is the study of the structure, function and motion of the mechanical aspects of biological systems, at any level from whole organisms to Organ (anatomy), organs, Cell (biology), cells and cell organelles, using the methods of mechani ...
of dromaeosaurid sickle-claws through a musculoskeletal 3D model of the hindlimb of ''Deinonychus''. The results supported that the claws were used for grasping and restraining prey smaller than the dromaeosaurid itself, but did not rule out other behaviours also involving crouching, such as stabbing and cutting prey at close quarters.
Palaeoecology
Palaeoenvironment
The holotype remains of ''Atrociraptor'' were found at a locality west of the Royal Tyrrell Museum of Palaeontology. This locality is part of the Horsethief
Member
Member may refer to:
* Military jury, referred to as "Members" in military jargon
* Element (mathematics), an object that belongs to a mathematical set
* In object-oriented programming, a member of a class
** Field (computer science), entries in ...
of the Horseshoe Canyon Formation, which is the second-oldest member of the formation. The Horsethief Member ranges from around 72.2–71.5 million years ago, a timespan of about 700,000 years. Teeth from elsewhere in the Horseshoe Canyon Formation have been assigned to ''Atrociraptor''. If these assignments are valid, it would mean ''Atrociraptor'' had a wide geographic and temporal distribution. These remains push the latest occurrence of ''Atrociraptor'' to the Tolman Member of the formation (about 70.9–69.6 million years ago), suggesting the genus may have existed for over 2 million years.
In the early Maastrichtian, the continent of
Laramidia
Laramidia was an island continent that existed during the Late Cretaceous period (99.6–66 Year#SI prefix multipliers, Ma), when the Western Interior Seaway split the continent of North America in two. In the Mesozoic era, Laramidia was an island ...
(today North America) was about 8 degrees of
latitude
In geography, latitude is a geographic coordinate system, geographic coordinate that specifies the north-south position of a point on the surface of the Earth or another celestial body. Latitude is given as an angle that ranges from −90° at t ...
further North than North America is today. Despite this, the average temperature of the area was almost certainly much warmer than the region is today. The mean annual temperature in the early Maastrichtian is estimated to have been around , compared to today. The lower part of the Horseshoe Canyon Formation, where the holotype was discovered, corresponds to poorly-drained sediments which reflect a depositional setting with a lot of standing water. The sediments of the Horsethief Member are composed primarily of
coal
Coal is a combustible black or brownish-black sedimentary rock, formed as rock strata called coal seams. Coal is mostly carbon with variable amounts of other Chemical element, elements, chiefly hydrogen, sulfur, oxygen, and nitrogen.
Coal i ...
,
shale
Shale is a fine-grained, clastic sedimentary rock formed from mud that is a mix of flakes of Clay mineral, clay minerals (hydrous aluminium phyllosilicates, e.g., Kaolinite, kaolin, aluminium, Al2Silicon, Si2Oxygen, O5(hydroxide, OH)4) and tiny f ...
s, sandstones, and
mudstone
Mudstone, a type of mudrock, is a fine-grained sedimentary rock whose original constituents were clays or muds. Mudstone is distinguished from ''shale'' by its lack of fissility.Blatt, H., and R.J. Tracy, 1996, ''Petrology.'' New York, New York, ...
s. These sediments are rich with organic materials, which reflect a highly saturated and humid environment, likely a
coastal plain
A coastal plain (also coastal plains, coastal lowland, coastal lowlands) is an area of flat, low-lying land adjacent to a sea coast. A fall line commonly marks the border between a coastal plain and an upland area.
Formation
Coastal plains can f ...
Western Interior Seaway
The Western Interior Seaway (also called the Cretaceous Seaway, the Niobraran Sea, the North American Inland Sea, or the Western Interior Sea) was a large inland sea (geology), inland sea that existed roughly over the present-day Great Plains of ...
. This suggests that the region was very humid and composed primarily of
wetlands
A wetland is a distinct semi-aquatic ecosystem whose groundcovers are flooded or saturated in water, either permanently, for years or decades, or only seasonally. Flooding results in oxygen-poor ( anoxic) processes taking place, especially ...
with a high
water table
The water table is the upper surface of the phreatic zone or zone of saturation. The zone of saturation is where the pores and fractures of the ground are saturated with groundwater, which may be fresh, saline, or brackish, depending on the loc ...
. This is further corroborated by the presence of a wider variety of
turtle
Turtles are reptiles of the order (biology), order Testudines, characterized by a special turtle shell, shell developed mainly from their ribs. Modern turtles are divided into two major groups, the Pleurodira (side necked turtles) and Crypt ...
s in the lower members of the formation than in the higher members.
As the Maastrichtian stage progressed, the Western Interior Seaway began to shrink, which is reflected in the
palaeoclimatic
Paleoclimatology (British spelling, palaeoclimatology) is the scientific study of climates predating the invention of meteorological instruments, when no direct measurement data were available. As instrumental records only span a tiny part of Ea ...
reconstructions of the region. Later sediments are believed to have been further inland and less humid than those of the late
Campanian
The Campanian is the fifth of six ages of the Late Cretaceous epoch on the geologic timescale of the International Commission on Stratigraphy (ICS). In chronostratigraphy, it is the fifth of six stages in the Upper Cretaceous Series. Campa ...
. This may be responsible for the apparent change in fauna during this period. How these climatic changes affected ''Atrociraptor'' is not clear, due to the rarity of its remains, but the discovery of teeth from the geologically younger Tolman Member suggests that the taxon may have survived through this period. Despite the apparent decline in temperature and humidity, it is known that major flooding events continued throughout this period. The ''Albertosaurus'' bonebed which contains teeth referred to ''Atrociraptor'', dated to one of the upper members of the Horseshoe Canyon Formation, was believed to have been deposited during a major storm. Despite the regression of the Western Interior Seaway, Cretaceous Alberta became wetter and more humid in the uppermost part of the formation (around 68 million years ago), returning to conditions similar to those of the Horsethief Member. No remains from these youngest sediments have been assigned to ''Atrociraptor'', which suggests that either the change in climate forced the small theropod to move elsewhere or it became extinct.
Contemporary fauna and flora
The holotype of ''Atrociraptor'' is the only fossil discovered from its locality, so it is not known for certain if any of the animals from the Horsethief Member directly coexisted with it, but many of them are known to have been contemporaneous. The Horsethief Member of the Horseshoe Canyon Formation constitutes the upper part of the so-called ''Edmontosaurus regalis-Pachyrhinosaurus canadensis'' zone. As the name suggests, two common terrestrial herbivores in these lower strata were ''
Pachyrhinosaurus
''Pachyrhinosaurus'' (from Ancient Greek ' (), thick; ' (), nose; and (), lizard) is a genus of centrosaurine ceratopsid dinosaur from the Late Cretaceous period of North America. The first examples were discovered by Charles M. Sternberg in ...
'' and ''
Edmontosaurus
''Edmontosaurus'' ( ) (meaning "lizard from Edmonton"), with the second species often colloquially and historically known as ''Anatosaurus'' or ''Anatotitan'' (meaning "duck lizard" and "giant duck"), is a genus of hadrosaurid (duck-billed) din ...
''. The lower part of Horseshoe Canyon also preserves fossils of other
ceratopsid
Ceratopsidae (sometimes spelled Ceratopidae) is a family of ceratopsian dinosaurs including ''Triceratops'', '' Centrosaurus'', and '' Styracosaurus''. All known species were quadrupedal herbivores from the Upper Cretaceous. All but one species are ...
s including ''
Anchiceratops
''Anchiceratops'' ( ) is an extinct genus of chasmosaurinae, chasmosaurine ceratopsid dinosaur that lived approximately 72 to 71 million years ago during the latter part of the Cretaceous Period (geology), Period in what is now Alberta, Canada.
' ...
'', ''
Arrhinoceratops
''Arrhinoceratops'' (meaning "no nose-horn face", derived from the Ancient Greek "a-/α-" "no", rhis/ῥίς "nose" "keras/κέρας" "horn", "-ops/ὤψ" "face") is a genus of herbivorous ceratopsian dinosaur. The name was coined as its origina ...
'', and several indeterminate specimens.
Ankylosaur
Ankylosauria is a group of herbivorous dinosaurs of the clade Ornithischia. It includes the great majority of dinosaurs with armor in the form of bony osteoderms, similar to turtles. Ankylosaurs were bulky quadrupeds, with short, powerful l ...
s are also well-represented in this member. The genera ''
Edmontonia
''Edmontonia'' is a genus of panoplosaurin nodosaurid dinosaur from the Late Cretaceous Period. It is part of the Nodosauridae, a family within Ankylosauria. It is named after the Edmonton Formation (now the Horseshoe Canyon Formation in Canada ...
'' and ''
Anodontosaurus
''Anodontosaurus'' is an extinct genus of ankylosaurid dinosaurs within the subfamily Ankylosaurinae. It is known from the entire span of the Late Cretaceous Horseshoe Canyon Formation (mid Late Campanian to "middle" Maastrichtian stage, about ...
'' have been found alongside indeterminate ankylosaur remains.
Hadrosaurid
Hadrosaurids (), also hadrosaurs or duck-billed dinosaurs, are members of the ornithischian family Hadrosauridae. This group is known as the duck-billed dinosaurs for the flat duck-bill appearance of the bones in their snouts. The ornithopod fami ...
remains are very common, but many of these are not confidently assigned to any genera other than ''Edmontosaurus''. Fragmentary remains of
pachycephalosaurid
Pachycephalosauria (; from Greek παχυκεφαλόσαυρος for 'thick headed lizards') is a clade of ornithischian dinosaurs. Along with Ceratopsia, it makes up the clade Marginocephalia. With the exception of two species, most pachycepha ...
s have also been found.
Theropod
Theropoda (; from ancient Greek , (''therion'') "wild beast"; , (''pous, podos'') "foot"">wiktionary:ποδός"> (''pous, podos'') "foot" is one of the three major groups (clades) of dinosaurs, alongside Ornithischia and Sauropodom ...
remains are also common in the Horsethief Member. ''
Ornithomimus
''Ornithomimus'' (; "bird mimic") is a genus of ornithomimid theropod dinosaurs from the Campanian and Maastrichtian ages of Late Cretaceous Western North America. ''Ornithomimus'' was a swift, bipedal dinosaur which fossil evidence indicates wa ...
'' and ''
Struthiomimus
''Struthiomimus'', meaning "ostrich-mimic" (from the Greek στρούθειος/''stroutheios'', or "of the ostrich", and μῖμος/''mimos'', meaning "mimic" or "imitator"), is a genus of ornithomimid dinosaurs from the late Cretaceous of Nor ...
'' are known from several specimens, and other coelurosaurs are known from a few remains. These include the
troodontid
Troodontidae is a clade of bird-like theropod dinosaurs from the Late Jurassic to Late Cretaceous. During most of the 20th century, troodontid fossils were few and incomplete and they have therefore been allied, at various times, with many dinos ...
caenagnathid
Caenagnathidae is a family of derived caenagnathoid dinosaurs from the Cretaceous of North America and Asia. They are a member of the Oviraptorosauria, and relatives of the Oviraptoridae. Like other oviraptorosaurs, caenagnathids had specialized ...
s ''
Apatoraptor
''Apatoraptor'' (meaning "deceptive thief") is a genus of caenagnathid dinosaur which contains a single species, ''A. pennatus''. The only known specimen was discovered in the Campanian-age Horseshoe Canyon Formation of Alberta.
Discovery
In 1 ...
'' and ''
Epichirostenotes
''Epichirostenotes'' (meaning "above ''Chirostenotes''", because it lived after the latter genus) is a genus of oviraptorosaurian dinosaur from the late Cretaceous. ''Epichirostenotes'' is known from an incomplete skeleton found in 1923 at the H ...
''. Although their remains are not known directly from the Horsethief Member, ''Dromaeosaurus'', ''
Paronychodon
''Paronychodon'' (meaning "beside claw tooth") was a theropod dinosaur genus. It is a tooth taxon, often considered dubious because of the fragmentary nature of the fossils, which include "buckets" of teeth from many disparate times and places b ...
'', and the poorly-understood taxon ''
Richardoestesia
''Richardoestesia'' is a morphogenus of theropod dinosaur teeth, originally described from the Late Cretaceous of what is now Canada, the United States and Kazakhstan. It currently contains two species, ''R. gilmorei'' and ''R. isosceles'', a ...
'' (known only from teeth) are known from both older and younger deposits, so they are inferred to have existed at this time as well. The largest theropod in the Horsethief Member (and the Horseshoe Canyon Formation generally) was the
tyrannosaurid
Tyrannosauridae (or tyrannosaurids, meaning "tyrant lizards") is a family of coelurosaurian theropod dinosaurs that comprises two subfamilies containing up to fifteen genera, including the eponymous ''Tyrannosaurus''. The exact number of genera ...
''Albertosaurus''.
Teeth found in the higher layers of the Horseshoe Canyon Formation (the Morrin and Tolman members) suggest that ''Atrociraptor'' may have also been a constituent of the younger ''Hypacrosaurus altispinus-Saurolophus osborni'' zone. This period is typified by the presence of the hadrosaurids ''
Saurolophus
''Saurolophus'' (; meaning "lizard crest") is a genus of large hadrosaurid dinosaur from the Late Cretaceous period of Asia and North America, that lived in what is now the Horseshoe Canyon and Nemegt formations about 70 million to 66 million ...
'' and ''
Hypacrosaurus
''Hypacrosaurus'' (meaning "near the highest lizard"
reek υπο-, ''hypo-'' = less + ακρος, ''akros'', high
Reek may refer to:
Places
* Reek, Netherlands, a village in the Dutch province of North Brabant
* Croagh Patrick, a mountain in the west of Ireland nicknamed "The Reek"
People
* Nikolai Reek (1890–1942), Estonian military commander
* Salme Ree ...
because it was almost but not quite as large as ''Tyrannosaurus'') is an extinct genus of hadrosaurid, duckbill dinosaur simila ...
'', in addition to numerous hadrosaur remains that have not yet been assigned to a particular genus. This time interval extended from 71.5–69.6 million years ago and immediately followed the ''Edmontosaurus regalis''-''Pachyrhinosaurus canadensis'' dinosaur zone. ''Edmontosaurus'', ''Pachyrhinosaurus'', and ''Edmontonia'' that characterise the Horsethief Member appear to be completely absent from this zone, although these genera did persist elsewhere in Laramidia. The ceratopsids ''Anchiceratops'' and ''Arrhinoceratops'' persist into the Morrin Member and the early layers of the even younger Tolman Member, as does the ankylosaurid ''Anodontosaurus'' and the large predator ''Albertosaurus''.
The aforementioned teeth, which have been assigned to ''Atrociraptor'', suggest that it directly shared its environment in the Tolman Member with ''Albertosaurus'', ''Hypacrosaurus'', one or more troodontids,
ornithomimid
Ornithomimidae (meaning "bird-mimics") is an extinct family of theropod dinosaurs which bore a superficial resemblance to modern ostriches. Ornithomimids were fast, omnivorous or herbivorous dinosaurs known mainly from the Late Cretaceous Period ...
s, and possibly other dromaeosaurids. Small dinosaurs are also more common in the Tolman Member. These include the leptoceratopsid ''
Montanoceratops
''Montanoceratops'' is an extinct genus of small ceratopsian dinosaur that lived approximately 70 million years ago during the latter part of the Cretaceous Period (geology), Period in what is now Montana and Alberta. ''Montanoceratops'' was a s ...
'', the pachycephalosaurid ''
Sphaerotholus
''Sphaerotholus'' is a genus of pachycephalosaurid dinosaur from the Upper Cretaceous of the western United States and Canada. To date, five species have been described: the type species, ''S. goodwini'', from the Den-na-zin Member of the Kirtla ...
'', the
thescelosaurid
Thescelosauridae is a clade of neornithischians from the Cretaceous of East Asia and North America. The group was originally used as a name by Charles M. Sternberg in 1937, but was not formally defined until 2013, where it was used by Brown and ...
''
Parksosaurus
''Parksosaurus'' (meaning "William Parks (paleontologist), William Parks's lizard") is a genus of neornithischian dinosaur from the Maastrichtian, early Maastrichtian-age Upper Cretaceous Horseshoe Canyon Formation of Alberta, Canada. It is based ...
'', and the
alvarezsaurid
Alvarezsauridae is a family of small, long-legged dinosaurs. Although originally thought to represent the earliest known flightless birds, they are now thought to be an early diverging branch of maniraptoran theropods. Alvarezsaurids were highly ...
''
Albertonykus
''Albertonykus'' (meaning "Alberta claw") is an alvarezsaurid dinosaur from the Maastrichtian-age (Upper Cretaceous) rocks of the Horseshoe Canyon Formation of Alberta, Canada. It is known from forelimb and hindlimb remains from multiple individ ...
'', in addition to the diverse assemblage of small theropods known from the Horsethief Member. The absence of these fossils from the older members does not necessarily mean that these taxa did not exist at that time, and may simply be reflective of the
fossil bias
Taphonomy is the study of how organisms decay and become fossilized or preserved in the paleontological record. The term ''taphonomy'' (from Greek , 'burial' and , 'law') was introduced to paleontology in 1940 by Soviet scientist Ivan Efremov ...
which makes the preservation of small-bodied animals less likely.
Remains of animals other than dinosaurs are known from throughout the Horseshoe Canyon Formation. Fish are common fossils and are represented by sclerorhynchoids,
guitarfish
The guitarfish, also referred to as shovelnose rays, are a family, Rhinobatidae, of rays. The guitarfish are known for an elongated body with a flattened head and trunk and small, ray-like wings. The combined range of the various species is tro ...
,
sturgeon
Sturgeon (from Old English ultimately from Proto-Indo-European language, Proto-Indo-European *''str̥(Hx)yón''-) is the common name for the 27 species of fish belonging to the family Acipenseridae. The earliest sturgeon fossils date to the ...
s,
paddlefish
Paddlefish (family Polyodontidae) are a family of ray-finned fish belonging to order Acipenseriformes, and one of two living groups of the order alongside sturgeons (Acipenseridae). They are distinguished from other fish by their elongated rost ...
osteoglossomorph
Osteoglossomorpha is a group of bony fish in the Teleostei.
Notable members
A notable member is the arapaima (''Arapaima gigas''), the largest freshwater fish in South America and one of the largest bony fishes alive. Other notable members inclu ...
s,
elopiformes
The Elopiformes are the order of ray-finned fish including the tarpons, tenpounders, and ladyfish, as well as a number of extinct types. They have a long fossil record, easily distinguished from other fishes by the presence of an additional s ...
,
ellimmichthyiformes
The Ellimmichthyiformes, also known as double-armored herrings, are an Extinction, extinct Order (biology), order of Actinopterygii, ray-finned fish known from the Early Cretaceous to the Oligocene. They were the sister group to the extant true h ...
Frog
A frog is any member of a diverse and largely semiaquatic group of short-bodied, tailless amphibian vertebrates composing the order (biology), order Anura (coming from the Ancient Greek , literally 'without tail'). Frog species with rough ski ...
s and
salamander
Salamanders are a group of amphibians typically characterized by their lizard-like appearance, with slender bodies, blunt snouts, short limbs projecting at right angles to the body, and the presence of a tail in both larvae and adults. All t ...
s are also known from teeth found in these deposits alongside
polyglyphanodontia
Polyglyphanodontia, also known as the Borioteiioidea, is an extinct clade of Cretaceous lizards. Polyglyphanodontians were the dominant group of lizards in North America and Asia during the Late Cretaceous.
Chronology and distribution
Most pol ...
n lizards. Turtles were also very diverse in the warm and humid climate of the early Maastrichtian. Fossils of macrobaenids,
chelydrid
The Chelydridae is a family of turtles that has seven extinct and two extant genera. The extant genera are the snapping turtles, ''Chelydra'' and ''Macrochelys''. Both are endemic to the Western Hemisphere. The extinct genera are '' Acherontemys' ...
s,
trionychid
Trionychidae is a family of turtles, commonly known as softshell turtles or simply softshells. The family was described by Leopold Fitzinger in 1826. Softshells include some of the world's largest freshwater turtles, though many can adapt to liv ...
s,
adocid
The Adocidae are an extinct family of aquatic and omnivorous turtles. They are freshwater cryptodiran turtles and are mainly known from Cretaceous and Paleogene Asia and North America.
Taxonomy
Phylogeny modified from Danilov ''et al.'' (2013) ...
s, and the giant genus ''
Basilemys
''Basilemys'' ("king turtle" in Greek) is a large, terrestrial Nanhsiungchelyidae, nanhsiungchelyid turtle from the Upper Cretaceous of North and Central America. ''Basilemys'' has been found in rocks dating to the Campanian and Maastrichtian subd ...
'' have been found from the parts of Horseshoe Canyon Formation that correspond to wetlands. The
choristodere
Choristodera (from the Greek χωριστός ''chōristos'' + δέρη ''dérē'', 'separated neck') is an extinct order of semiaquatic diapsid reptiles that ranged from the Middle Jurassic, or possibly Triassic, to the Miocene (168 to 20 or p ...
genus ''
Champsosaurus
''Champsosaurus'' is an extinct genus of crocodile-like choristodere reptile, known from the Late Cretaceous and early Paleogene periods of North America and Europe (Campanian–Paleocene). The name ''Champsosaurus'' is thought to come from , () ...
'' was also a resident of Alberta during this time.
A wide variety of fossil plants have been found in the Horseshoe Canyon Formation. The most numerous and diverse of these are the
conifer
Conifers () are a group of conifer cone, cone-bearing Spermatophyte, seed plants, a subset of gymnosperms. Scientifically, they make up the phylum, division Pinophyta (), also known as Coniferophyta () or Coniferae. The division contains a sin ...
s, which are known from plant body fossils and a diverse array of seeds. Among the conifers present were
pines
A pine is any conifer tree or shrub in the genus ''Pinus'' () of the family Pinaceae. ''Pinus'' is the sole genus in the subfamily Pinoideae.
''World Flora Online'' accepts 134 species-rank taxa (119 species and 15 nothospecies) of pines as ...
,
redwood
Sequoioideae, commonly referred to as redwoods, is a subfamily of Pinophyta, coniferous trees within the family (biology), family Cupressaceae, that range in the Northern Hemisphere, northern hemisphere. It includes the List of superlative tree ...
s, cypresses, yellow woods, and yews, as well as some conifers that have not been confidently identified by
paleobotanists
Paleobotany or palaeobotany, also known as paleophytology, is the branch of botany dealing with the recovery and identification of plant fossils from geological contexts, and their use for the biological reconstruction of past environments (pale ...
.
Ginkgoes
''Ginkgo'' is a genus of non-flowering seed plants, assigned to the gymnosperms. The scientific name is also used as the English common name. The order to which the genus belongs, Ginkgoales, first appeared in the Permian, , and ''Ginkgo'' is n ...
are also known from the region during the Cretaceous. Uniquely, fossils of true
cycads
Cycads are seed plants that typically have a stout and woody (ligneous) trunk with a crown of large, hard, stiff, evergreen and (usually) pinnate leaves. The species are dioecious, that is, individual plants of a species are either male or ...
– which are otherwise very abundant among
Mesozoic
The Mesozoic Era is the Era (geology), era of Earth's Geologic time scale, geological history, lasting from about , comprising the Triassic, Jurassic and Cretaceous Period (geology), Periods. It is characterized by the dominance of archosaurian r ...
flora – appear to be completely absent from the Horseshoe Canyon Formation.
Seed fern
In botany, a seed is a plant structure containing an embryo and stored nutrients in a protective coat called a ''testa''. More generally, the term "seed" means anything that can be sown, which may include seed and husk or tuber. Seeds are the ...
spermatophyte
A seed plant or spermatophyte (; New Latin ''spermat-'' and Greek ' (phytón), plant), also known as a phanerogam (taxon Phanerogamae) or a phaenogam (taxon Phaenogamae), is any plant that produces seeds. It is a category of embryophyte (i.e. la ...
s, have been found, and some plant remains that resemble the genus '' Nilssonia'' have been suggested to belong to true cycads.
Angiosperm
Flowering plants are plants that bear flowers and fruits, and form the clade Angiospermae (). The term angiosperm is derived from the Greek words (; 'container, vessel') and (; 'seed'), meaning that the seeds are enclosed within a fruit ...
s had undergone a significant diversification event during the
Cretaceous Terrestrial Revolution The Cretaceous Terrestrial Revolution (abbreviated KTR), also known as the Angiosperm Terrestrial Revolution (ATR) by authors who consider it to have lasted into the Palaeogene, describes the intense floral diversification of flowering plants (ang ...
, and by the early Maastrichtian, they were common components of North American terrestrial ecosystems. However, in the Horseshoe Canyon Formation, leaf imprints, fossilized wood, stems, and fruits from angiosperms are rare fossils. Fossilized leaves and fruits of
plane tree
''Platanus'' ( ) is a genus consisting of a small number of tree species native to the Northern Hemisphere. They are the sole living members of the family Platanaceae.
All mature members of ''Platanus'' are tall, reaching in height. The type ...
saxifrages
''Saxifraga'' is the largest genus in the family Saxifragaceae, containing about 473 species of holarctic perennial plants, known as saxifrages or rockfoils. The Latin word ''saxifraga'' means literally "stone-breaker", from Latin ' ("rock" or " ...
, and katsura have been identified. Most angiosperm remains so far discovered have been in the form of seeds and pollen. Such trace fossils from lotuses,
laurels
''Laurus nobilis'' is an aromatic evergreen tree or large shrub with green, glabrous (smooth) leaves. It is in the flowering plant family Lauraceae. According to Flora Cretica (Kleinsteuber Books, 2024, ISBN 978-3-9818110-5-6) the stem can be 1 ...
,
hornworts
Hornworts are a group of Non-vascular plant, non-vascular Embryophytes (land plants) constituting the division Anthocerotophyta (). The common name refers to the elongated horn-like structure, which is the sporophyte. As in mosses and liverworts ...
,
witch hazel
Witch-hazels or witch hazels (''Hamamelis'') are a genus of flowering plants in the family Hamamelidaceae, with three species in North America ('' H. ovalis'', '' H. virginiana'', and '' H. vernalis''), and one each in Japan ('' H.&nb ...
s,
elm tree
Elms are deciduous and semi-deciduous trees comprising the genus ''Ulmus'' in the family Ulmaceae. They are distributed over most of the Northern Hemisphere, inhabiting the temperate and tropical-montane regions of North America and Eurasia, p ...
s,
buckthorn
''Rhamnus'' is a genus of about 140 accepted species of shrubs or small trees, commonly known as buckthorns, in the family Rhamnaceae. Its species range from tall (rarely to ) and are native mainly in east Asia and North America, but found thr ...
s,
beech
Beech (genus ''Fagus'') is a genus of deciduous trees in the family Fagaceae, native to subtropical (accessory forest element) and temperate (as dominant element of Mesophyte, mesophytic forests) Eurasia and North America. There are 14 accepted ...
es,
birch
A birch is a thin-leaved deciduous hardwood tree of the genus ''Betula'' (), in the family Betulaceae, which also includes alders, hazels, and hornbeams. It is closely related to the beech- oak family Fagaceae. The genus ''Betula'' contains 3 ...
es,
willow
Willows, also called sallows and osiers, of the genus ''Salix'', comprise around 350 species (plus numerous hybrids) of typically deciduous trees and shrubs, found primarily on moist soils in cold and temperate regions.
Most species are known ...
s, and
cashew
Cashew is the common name of a tropical evergreen tree ''Anacardium occidentale'', in the family Anacardiaceae. It is native to South America and is the source of the cashew nut and the cashew apple, an accessory fruit. The tree can grow as t ...
s, among others, have also been found, but body fossils from these plants are not yet known from the area.
Fossil remains from non-spermatophytes are rare, and typically only their
spore
In biology, a spore is a unit of sexual reproduction, sexual (in fungi) or asexual reproduction that may be adapted for biological dispersal, dispersal and for survival, often for extended periods of time, in unfavourable conditions. Spores fo ...
s are preserved. The morphology of these spores is used to determine the affinities of these plants. From this, it has been determined that the Horseshoe Canyon Formation was also home to a diverse assemblage of
fern
The ferns (Polypodiopsida or Polypodiophyta) are a group of vascular plants (plants with xylem and phloem) that reproduce via spores and have neither seeds nor flowers. They differ from mosses by being vascular, i.e., having specialized tissue ...
s,
tree fern
Tree ferns are arborescent (tree-like) ferns that grow with a trunk (botany), trunk elevating the fronds above ground level, making them trees. Many extant tree ferns are members of the order Cyatheales, to which belong the families Cyatheaceae ( ...
s,
water clover
''Marsilea'' is a genus of approximately 65 species of Aquatic plant, aquatic ferns of the family Marsileaceae. The name honours Italian naturalist Luigi Ferdinando Marsili (1656–1730).
These small plants are of unusual appearance and do not r ...
s,
horsetail
''Equisetum'' (; horsetail) is the only living genus in Equisetaceae, a family of vascular plants that reproduce by spores rather than seeds.
''Equisetum'' is a "living fossil", the only living genus of the entire subclass Equisetidae, which ...
s,
quillwort
''Isoetes'', commonly known as the quillworts, is a genus of lycopod. It is the only living genus in the family Isoetaceae and order Isoetales. , there were about 200 recognized species, with a cosmopolitan distribution mostly in aquatic habitats ...
s,
club mosses
Lycopodiopsida is a class of vascular plants also known as lycopsids, lycopods, or lycophytes. Members of the class are also called clubmosses, firmosses, spikemosses and quillworts. They have dichotomously branching stems bearing simple leaves ...
,
moss
Mosses are small, non-vascular plant, non-vascular flowerless plants in the taxonomic phylum, division Bryophyta (, ) ''sensu stricto''. Bryophyta (''sensu lato'', Wilhelm Philippe Schimper, Schimp. 1879) may also refer to the parent group bryo ...
es, and
liverwort
Liverworts are a group of non-vascular land plants forming the division Marchantiophyta (). They may also be referred to as hepatics. Like mosses and hornworts, they have a gametophyte-dominant life cycle, in which cells of the plant carry ...