crossover (comics)

A crossover is the placement of two or more otherwise discrete fictional characters, settings, or universes into the context of a single story. They can arise from legal agreements between the relevant copyright holders (known as intercompany crossovers), common corporate ownership or unofficial efforts by fans.

This is different from a spoof, where one discrete character, setting, or universe, copies another character, setting, or universe, often in a comedic manner.

Background

Official

Crossovers often occur in an official capacity in order for the intellectual property rights holders to reap the financial reward of combining two or more popular, established properties. In other cases, the crossover can serve to introduce a new concept derivative of an older one. Another intention is to give fictional characters more emotional credibility and thus increase immersion for the fans.

Crossovers generally occur between properties owned by a single holder, but they can, more rarely, involve properties from different holders, provided that the inherent legal obstacles can be overcome. They may also involve using characters that have passed into the public domain with those concurrently under copyright protection.

A crossover story may try to explain its own reason for the crossover, such as characters being neighbors (notable examples being the casts from ''The Golden Girls'' and ''Empty Nest'') or meeting via dimensional rift or similar phenomenon (a common explanation for science fiction properties that have different owners). Some crossovers are not explained at all. Others are absurd or simply impossible within the fictional setting, and have to be ignored by the series' respective continuities. Still others intentionally make the relations between two or more fictional universes confusing, as with ''The Simpsons'' and ''Futurama'', where each show is fiction in the other.

Unofficial

In contrast with legal crossovers, unofficial crossovers are created solely because of the artistic pleasure derived by their creators. Unofficial crossovers often take the form of fan-written fiction and fan art, but the trope is increasingly prevalent in amateur films and audio. Whereas official crossovers are frequently stymied by such concerns as copyright, royalties payments, quality of writing and ownership of the characters, unofficial crossovers are unfettered by such concerns, so long as property holders do not exercise their right to enjoin the distribution of such material. A good example would be the unauthorised live action fan film '' Batman: Dead End'' which brings together the properties of ''Batman'', '' Alien'' and ''Predator'' in one setting.

Unofficial crossovers can also occur in a "what-if" scenario. Roger makes frequent cameo appearances in ''Family Guy'', while Brian makes cameos on ''American Dad!''. Roger, Rallo Tubbs, and Klaus Heissler were seen in the final ''Family Guy'' ''Star Wars'' spoof, " It's A Trap!", as Moff Jerjerrod, Nien Nunb, and Admiral Ackbar, respectively. Stewie also appears as an interactive hallucination of Booth on ''Bones'' when the agent has issues over possibly becoming a sperm donor, with David Boreanaz (who plays Booth) repaying the favor in " Road to the North Pole". An appearance by Elmo, from ''Sesame Street'', was made, in a hallucination of Connie Ray's, on TV sitcom '' The Torkelsons''. Fan fiction fusions between different science fiction movies and series are often created, such as ''Star Wars'' and ''Star Trek'' or ''Babylon 5'' and ''Stargate''. ''M.U.G.E.N.'' is a fighting game engine that features many fan-created and fictional characters and stages from various television series, movies, as well as other video games.

Comics

Crossovers of multiple characters, owned by one company or published by one publisher, have been used to set an established continuity, where characters can frequently meet within one setting. This is especially true of comic book publishers, as different characters in various Marvel, DC, or Valiant comic books frequently interact with one another since they live in a "shared universe". For example, in the Marvel Comics universe, Spider-Man has frequent dealings with another Marvel hero, Daredevil, just as in the DC Comics Universe, the Flash and Green Lantern often collaborate. In comic book terminology, these "guest star" roles are common enough that they are generally not considered crossovers; rather, this short-term collaboration to fight crime is called a team-up. A crossover in comic book terms only occurs when a story spans more than one title. This has led to "crossover events" in which major occurrences are shown as affecting most or all of the stories in the shared universe; see Crossover comics.

The earliest such crossover event was Gardner Fox's ''Zatanna's Search'' which took place in ''Hawkman'' #4 (October/November 1964), ''Detective Comics'' #336 (February 1965), '' The Atom'' #19 (June/July 1965), ''Green Lantern'' #42 (January 1966), ''Detective Comics'' #355 (September 1966), and ''Justice League of America'' #51 (February 1967). This story dealt with Zatanna attempting to reconnect with her father, Zatara, and seeking the aid of Hawkman, Batman, Robin, the Atom, Green Lantern, and the Elongated Man along the way.

The first major crossover event was spearheaded by the Marvel Editor-in-Chief at the time, Jim Shooter. As a way to further toy sales he devised the ''Secret Wars'' crossover which brought all the major Marvel heroes into a 12-issue miniseries to battle a common threat. After the threat was dealt with, they all returned to their regular titles. ''Secret Wars'' was hailed as both a critical and commercial success, largely because the events of the crossover had lasting effects on the characters (such as the introduction of Spider-Man's black suit which would later become the villain Venom). Jim Shooter later perfected his crossover technique at Valiant Comics with the '' Unity'' event. ''Unity'' brought all the Valiant characters together to defeat Mothergod, but was told within the existing Valiant Comics titles (and two bookend special issues). Readers were not obliged to buy all 18 chapters as the story was coherent when reading just one title, but far more layered when all were read. Like ''Secret Wars'', the ''Unity'' crossover had lasting effects on the Valiant universe; most notably the introduction of Turok, the birth of Magnus, Robot Fighter and the death of a major Valiant hero.

Animation

Cartoon crossovers are not uncommon, and most of them – like comics or live-action TV shows – will often feature characters owned by the same company or network. One example is Cartoon Network's ''The Grim Adventures of the KND''. It features five crossovers – ''Ed, Edd n Eddy'', '' Codename: Kids Next Door'', '' The Grim Adventures of Billy & Mandy'', a reference to ''The Powerpuff Girls'', and a quote from ''Scooby-Doo'', which are all licensed Cartoon Network series.
During the 1970s and 1980s, crossovers were particularly common among the Hanna-Barbera properties. Some of the earliest examples happened on '' The New Scooby-Doo Movies'' which featured appearances by characters from ''Harlem Globetrotters'', '' Josie and the Pussycats'', '' Jeannie'', '' Speed Buggy'', '' Batman and Robin'', and ''The Addams Family''. Later, the '' Hanna-Barbera Superstars 10'' set of movies involved several crossovers, including such combinations as '' The Jetsons Meet the Flintstones''. This was taken to an extreme in the 1977–79 series ''Laff-A-Lympics,'' which was essentially a gathering of the Hanna-Barbera characters for a regular series.

Crossovers are not necessarily composed of characters under common ownership. Two of the most notable cartoon crossovers consisted of characters from different companies. Disney's movie ''Who Framed Roger Rabbit'' had characters from various companies, most notably Disney and Warner Bros. The film also includes cameos of characters from MGM.

Another cartoon crossover would occur in 1990, ''Cartoon All-Stars to the Rescue''. This cartoon featured popular characters from children's Saturday morning cartoons, banding together to promote an anti-drug message. ABC, CBS, Fox, and NBC aired this half-hour special one Saturday morning with characters from all their networks, including Huey, Dewey, and Louie (from Disney's ''DuckTales''), Winnie the Pooh, Tigger, Slimer (from ''The Real Ghostbusters'' and ''Extreme Ghostbusters''), Michelangelo (from ''Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles''), Bugs Bunny, Daffy Duck, Alvin and the Chipmunks, the Smurfs, ALF (from his short-lived cartoon spinoff), Garfield, and the trio of Baby Kermit, Baby Piggy, and Baby Gonzo (from Jim Henson's '' Muppet Babies''). Animation companies granted unlimited, royalty-free use of their cartoon characters for this project, a feat that has been unequalled before or since. This cartoon was also introduced by then-President George H. W. Bush and Barbara Bush, and would be distributed to schools and video stores free of charge nationwide.

Webtoons (animated shows from the internet) can also have crossovers with different webtoons, franchises, YouTubers and more. Some examples are when Kate from TomSka's ''Crash Zoom'' series makes an appearance in '' Eddsworld'' as a trick or treater who possesses Matt and Edd in the episode, "Trick or Threat". In addition to this a couple of characters from ''Eddsworld'' make appearances in some ''Crash Zoom'' episodes such as "Orcs and Dorks".

Anime and manga

Anime has also participated in many crossover events featuring characters or shows from the same company or network. One of the biggest projects down would be ''Dream 9 Toriko x One Piece x Dragon Ball Z Super Special Collaboration'' as it includes three ''Shonen Jump'' franchises, being ''Dragon Ball Z'', ''One Piece'', and '' Toriko'', crossed over into an hour long special-like most crossovers, this special is filler, a fan-service episode that follows the common plot line in most crossovers. What makes this crossover unique is when the characters from all three shows split into groups, where the members all share the same clichéd character archetypes, such the main characters Goku, Luffy, and Toriko falling into the dumb, good-natured, strong character archetype.

Manga artist Leiji Matsumoto has been known to cross over the characters of his various stories and characters such as ''Captain Harlock'', ''Galaxy Express 999'', and '' Queen Millennia'', all of which were originally written as separate, self-contained stories. In the '' Maetel Legend'', Queen Promethium is revealed to be having been Yukino Yaoi, the protagonist from ''Queen Millennia''. Matsumoto has also created various crossovers with ''Space Battleship Yamato'', an anime on which he served as director, although the rights to Yamato are actually owned by Yoshinobu Nishizaki.

Film

The first film crossover in a series of Universal Studios monster films was '' Frankenstein Meets the Wolf Man'', in 1943.
After the comics publishing house Marvel Comics ventured into movie production, they set off to produce solitary films with popular superheroes from the Avengers team, with characters from upcoming films making cameo appearances in films starring another superhero, leading up to the crossover film '' The Avengers'' (2012). Inspired by Marvel's success, Warner Bros., who hold movie rights for DC Comics' heroes, announced the production of '' Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice'' (2016) and further plans to develop the cinematic DC Extended Universe, while Paramount Pictures and Entertainment One announced plans to create a cinematic universe on the ''Transformers'' film series.

There have been numerous crossovers in Japanese cinema. The boom of kaiju films saw a lot of crossovers produced at Toho Studios, with some of the monsters forming teams in numerous movies, much like the Marvel movie franchise. Godzilla, Mothra and Rodan (Radon) each first appeared in standalone films before being set against each other or even teaming up against stronger enemies. Their first encounter was in 1964, first in '' Mothra vs. Godzilla'' and a few months later of all three in ''Ghidorah, the Three-Headed Monster''. In 1962, Toho released ''King Kong vs. Godzilla''.

Games

Crossovers in video games occur when otherwise separated fictional characters, stories, settings, universes, or media in a video game meet and interact with each other. These can range from a character simply appearing as a playable character or boss in the game, as a special guest character, or a major crossover where two or more franchises encounter.

''Konami'' made the first crossover video game featuring Simon Belmont from '' Castlevania'', Universal Pictures' King Kong and Mikey from the Warner Bros. movie ''The Goonies'' in '' Konami Wai Wai World'' for the Famicom in 1988.

''Mario & Sonic at the Olympic Games'', released in Japan two months before ''Super Smash Bros. Brawl'', was the first time that Mario and Sonic (as well as their associated characters) appeared in a game together.

Literature

In literature, some authors also engage in crossovers by including characters from different novels they have written in one.

The first popular crossover in literature was the 1885 Mark Twain novel, ''The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn'', which had an important guest appearance by Tom Sawyer. Similarly, Lady Glencora Palliser from the Pallisers series of Anthony Trollope appears towards the end of '' Miss Mackenzie'', a novel published between the first and second Palliser novels in 1865, a character first introduced in the novel, ''Can You Forgive Her?'' (1864). Andrew Lang's 1890 collection, ''Old Friends: Essays in Epistolary Parody'', contains letters combining characters from different sources, including one based on Jane Austen's ''Northanger Abbey'' and Charlotte Brontë's ''Jane Eyre''.

Kim Newman frequently uses this device, as does Stephen King. The works of James Branch Cabell, J.D. Salinger, William Faulkner, Margaret Laurence, Thomas Pynchon, Kurt Vonnegut, Mordecai Richler, Sir H. Rider Haggard, Edgar Rice Burroughs, Robert Heinlein, and Isaac Asimov also cross over with each other, linking different characters and settings together over a number of different works.

Illustrator Howard Pyle conceived his work ''Twilight Land'' as one such crossover. In it, a nameless narrator is transported to "Twilight Land" and meets famous fairy tale characters for a soirée in an inn: Mother Goose, Cinderella, Fortunatus (book), Fortunatus, Sinbad the Sailor, Aladdin, Askeladden, Boots, the The Brave Little Tailor, Valiant Little Tailor, and others gather in the framing device and tell each other adventurous tales featuring other literary personages.

French author Jules Lemaître wrote a sort of sequel to ''Cinderella'', named ''Princess Mimi'', where Cinderella's daughter is courted by Polyphemus and Charles Perrault's ''Hop-o'-My-Thumb''.

Public domain

It is also common for authors to 'crossover' characters who have passed into the public domain, and thus do not require copyright or royalty payments for their use in other works. ''The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen'' by Alan Moore and Kevin O'Neill (comics), Kevin O'Neill is another example of this, as all of the main characters and most of the secondary / background characters are fictional characters whose copyright has expired, and all are characters of different authors and creators brought together within one massive extended universe. Many of the works of Philip José Farmer's Wold Newton family sequences (which has also been explored and developed by other authors) also utilize and interweave numerous otherwise unrelated fictional characters into a rich family history by speculating familial connections between them (such as a blood-relationship between Sherlock Holmes and Tarzan). Roger Zelazny's novel ''A Night in the Lonesome October'' combines Sherlock Holmes, Doctor Frankenstein, Jack the Ripper, and the Cthulhu Mythos, although he never specifically identifies them as such ("The Count", "The Good Doctor", "Jack", etc.).

Occasionally, authors will include into crossovers classic fictional characters whose copyright is still held by the original authors (or at least their estates), but who are nevertheless considered iconic or 'mythic' enough to be recognised from a few character traits or descriptions without being directly named (thus not requiring royalties payments to be made to the copyright holder). A prominent example occurs within ''The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen, Volume One'', wherein a character who is clearly intended in appearance and description by other characters to be Dr. Fu Manchu appears as a significant villain; however, as this character was not in the public domain at the time of writing and the rights still held by the estate of his creator Sax Rohmer, he is not directly named as such in the work and is only referred to as 'the Devil Doctor'.

Television series

Between established shows

Crossovers involving principals can also occur when the characters have no prior relationship, but are related by time period, locale or profession. The ''Law and Order'' series, for example, afford a commonality of setting and profession which lends itself to crossovers, both within the franchise and in a wider universe. Following the cancellation of the ABC soap opera ''One Life to Live'' and its high-rated finale, several characters crossed over into the network's remaining soap opera ''General Hospital'', remaining in the same timeline as their former show.

Between related shows

Though most common on shows of the same production company (see, for example, "Hurricane Saturday"), crossovers have also occurred because shows share the same distributor or television network. A notable example of this kind of link is that between ''Murder, She Wrote'' and ''Magnum, P.I.'' These shows were made by different companies, but owned by Universal Studios and broadcast on CBS. Another case is that of ''Mad About You'' and ''Friends'', which share the character of List of Friends characters#Ursula Buffay, Ursula Buffay. Neither show shares any production or distribution commonality, but rather an actress (Lisa Kudrow), a setting (New York City) and a schedule (''Friends'' initially followed ''Mad About You'' on NBC's Must See TV, Thursday night schedule).

''Mad About You'' and ''Friends'' share another type of "network crossover". On rare occasions, networks have chosen to theme an entire night's programming around a crossover "event". In one case, a New York City Power outage, blackout caused by Paul Reiser's character on ''Mad About You'' was experienced by the characters on ''Friends'' and ''Madman of the People''. Such "event nights" can also be linked by a single character's quest across multiple shows on the same evening. ABC attempted this kind of "event night" crossover with its TGIF (ABC), Friday night programming during the 1997 season. There, they proposed that the title character of ''Sabrina the Teenage Witch (1996 TV series), Sabrina the Teenage Witch'' should chase her cat, Salem Saberhagen, Salem, through ''Boy Meets World'', ''You Wish (TV series), You Wish'' and ''Teen Angel (1997 TV series), Teen Angel'' because it had run away with a "time ball" that was displacing each show through time.

In 2013, the Canadian crime drama series ''Republic of Doyle'' and ''Murdoch Mysteries'' produced a crossover, which was complicated by the shows' incompatible historical settings; ''Murdoch Mysteries'' is a historical series set in the 1890s, while ''Republic of Doyle'' is set in the present day. The problem was solved by having the actors cross over as ''relatives'' of their primary characters; Allan Hawco appeared on the November 25, 2013 episode of ''Murdoch Mysteries'' as Jacob Doyle, a 19th-century ancestor of his regular character Jake Doyle, while Yannick Bisson appeared on a January 2014 episode of ''Republic of Doyle'' as Bill Murdoch, a 21st-century descendant of his regular character William Murdoch.

The earliest example of a crossover in children's television was PBS' 1971 program ''The Electric Company (1971 TV series), The Electric Company''.

Promotional cameos

Crossovers can take the form of a promotional cameo appearance, used to draw attention to another work of fiction, with little rational explanation in the context of the hosting show's narrative. When not clearly presented as parody, this is frequently scorned by fans as blatant commercialism. A notable example of this is ''The Simpsons'' episode "A Star Is Burns", in which the character of Jay Sherman (from ''The Critic'') appeared. It originally aired on March 5, 1995, on FOX right before ''The Critic'' began its second season, its first season having aired on ABC. This episode was largely condemned by fans of ''The Simpsons'' as existing to promote ''The Critic'', an animated series considered inferior by comparison. Even ''Simpsons'' creator Matt Groening objected, preferring to remove his name from the credits of that particular episode in protest.Various reactions, including Matt Groening's, to ''A Star Is Burns''

Spin-offs

In its simplest and most common form, a television crossover involves a starring character on a parent show appearing on a Spin-off (media), spin-off or vice versa because of established character relationships. An obvious example of this type of crossover occurred when Cliff Huxtable of ''The Cosby Show'' visited his daughter, Denise Huxtable, Denise, on ''A Different World (TV series), A Different World''.

More complex multi-production franchises can utilize crossovers of characters to serve as a device in establishing continuity in a shared fictional universe. This crossover is common in the Star Trek crossovers, ''Star Trek'' universe, where minor guest stars from one series have appeared as featured guest stars later ones. A good example of this crossover is that of the Klingons Kor (Star Trek), Kor, Koloth, and Kang (Star Trek), Kang. After the passage of about a century of narrative time, the three onetime adversaries of James T. Kirk, Captain Kirk appeared together in the ''Star Trek: Deep Space Nine'' episode, "Blood Oath (DS9 episode), Blood Oath" – as the Klingons and Federation had become allies in the century between, the former villains are now portrayed as heroes.

The distinction between "spin-off" and "crossover" is sometimes narrow. The two terms can become especially conflated if two shows are linked by a guest star with a single appearance. There is debate, for instance over whether ''Out of the Blue (1979 TV series), Out of the Blue'' is a spin-off of ''Happy Days'', or whether the star of ''Out of the Blue'' merely crossed over into ''Happy Days''.

Parodic crossovers

Often, the problems of bringing together two shows with different narrative ambitions make the writing of a crossover burdensome. Such difficulties are encountered by situation comedies that wish to crossover with television drama, dramatic television programs. The satirical crossover—ranging in length from a cameo to a full sketch comedy, comedy sketch or episode—is an extremely popular way of circumventing this problem. By various means, such crossovers typically avoid outcry from fans by being obvious parody or Homage (arts), homage. However, on rare occasion, the humor of such crossovers can be used by one show make a narrative point by capitalizing on the audience's experience of the other program.

Parodic crossovers can be directly established as being outside the continuity of one or all of the properties being crossed over. A good example is the crossover between ''The Simpsons'' and ''The X-Files'', which was largely accepted as being outside standard ''X-Files'' continuity.

They can occur by virtue of a dream sequence, in which the characters of one show will appear as part of a dream had by a character on another show. This method was perhaps used most famously to explain to audiences that the entirety of ''Newhart'' had been the dream of Bob Newhart's character on ''The Bob Newhart Show''. It has more recently been used to demonstrate that cast members of ''The Young and the Restless'' appeared in a dream of a character on ''The King of Queens''.

Parodic crossovers can take the form of "joke, gag" cameos by characters of one property appearing on another. Crossovers of this type can also be completely wordless. This type of crossover is more common on animated programs, such as when Bender (Futurama), Bender found and ate Bart Simpson's shorts on ''Futurama'', or Milhouse Van Houten, Milhouse had a talking Bender doll on ''The Simpsons''. This would seem to be another case when a popular franchise is acknowledged as fiction and not a crossover of the stories.

Perhaps the most obvious parodic crossover is found when characters from two series interact outside ''either'' series. This occurs most commonly on a sketch comedy show or as a humorous interlude on an award telecast. Such crossovers may sometimes involve the real actors—for example, a sketch on ''Royal Canadian Air Farce'' saw Yasir and Sarah from ''Little Mosque on the Prairie'' buying the gas station from ''Corner Gas'', with many of the characters in the sketch being portrayed by the shows' real actors—although they may also feature one genuine star from the show amid a cast comprised otherwise of the sketch show's own stable of actors.
Parodic crossovers can be used to lend verisimilitude to the fictional world of a program. Characters from a fictional television series may appear on a stylized version of an established non-fictional television series, such as game shows or reality shows. These crossovers between celebrity hosts and fictional characters are quite common on situation comedy, situation comedies. ''Mama's Family'' once appeared on ''Family Feud'' and the townsfolk of ''The Vicar of Dibley'' have had their heirlooms valuated on ''Antiques Roadshow'', for instance.

German crossover

One of the earlier instances of crossovers in TV productions outside the US is the episode ' (1990), which was produced by Westdeutscher Rundfunk, WDR and Deutscher Fernsehfunk, DFF as a crossover between the West Germany, West German crime series and the East Germany, East German crime series ''Polizeiruf 110''. Their respective popular heroes Horst Schimanski and Peter Fuchs join forces to solve a case in the turmoil of the time after the Berlin Wall#The fall, fall of the Berlin Wall. The episode was produced during the short transition period between the fall of the Berlin Wall and the German reunification, reunification of Germany.

See also

* Amalgam Comics
* Canon (fiction)
* Callback (comedy)
* Continuity (fiction)
* Cross-licensing
* Fanfiction
* Fictional character
* Fictional universe
* Shared universe
* Tommy Westphall
* Wold Newton family

References

External links

Thoughts On Crossovers In General (Kathryn Andersen)
An essay musing on the numerous elements necessary to a successful crossover (primarily aimed at fan-written fiction).


Crossovers which build upon and take place in Philip José Farmer's World Newton continuity.


Jess Nevins' history of the fictional crossover

{{Superhero fiction

Crossover fiction,
Comics terminology
Film and video terminology
Television terminology