I Hate U (Prince Song)

"I Hate U" (also spelled "👁 Hate U" or "Eye Hate U" to reflect the pictograph in the published title) is a song by American musician Prince, released on September 12, 1995, as the lead single from his seventeenth studio album, ''The Gold Experience'' (1995).

Development and songwriting

"I Hate U" was nearly a solo effort from Prince, although he credited Minneapolis musician Ricky Peterson with co-production and arranging, as well as providing additional keyboards. American actress, model and singer Carmen Electra says Prince told her it was about her:

Song description

Beginning with crashing drums, the "NPG Operator" welcomes the listener to "The Hate Experience" (which Prince would later entitle the song's maxi-single), before leading into the first verse where Prince sings in delicate falsetto about a cheating woman, whom he hates "like a day without sunshine". A church-like organ moves the song along, while a musical segment borrowed from "Baby" (a track from his 1978 album ''For You'') provides breaks throughout the track. After the second verse and chorus, the song enters a lengthy middle section which is sung/spoken in Prince's normal voice. This section is a "courtroom drama" where Prince submits his evidence of his cheating lover to a judge. When he asks the woman to state her name for the court, he interrupts her with a vocal reference from the album's previous track—"Billy Jack Bitch". Toward the end of the drama, he states that being without her is killing him emotionally and that he actually still loves her. After a final chorus, again using an impassioned falsetto, Prince launches into a brief but effective guitar solo which climaxes and ends the song.

Chart performance

"I Hate U" was Prince's last original single to reach the US Top 40. (His earlier hit "1999" did sneak back into the Top 40 in the song's namesake year, peaking at number 40, but this was a reissued single, not a new release and, in 1996, "Betcha by Golly Wow!" from ''Emancipation'' made the Top 40, but all of the singles from ''Emancipation'' were promotional in the US so they were not allowed to chart on the Hot 100—only on the Hot 100 Airplay. Several Prince songs also returned to the Top 40 in 2016, the year of his death, as re-entries; none were songs appearing in the top 40 for the first time).

"I Hate U" was very successful on the charts. It peaked within the top 10 of the R&B/Hip-Hop and Rhythmic charts and it reached number 12 on the ''Billboard'' Hot 100. Unlike the last two Prince singles, "I Hate U" was less successful on Mainstream/Top 40 radio, as it did not chart on the ''Billboard'' Top 40 Mainstream chart. It did however receive minor Mainstream/Top 40 airplay as it did chart it the lower regions of the top 40 of the Mediabase / Radio+Records CHR/Pop Airplay chart. In the UK, "I Hate U" peaked at number 20.

Critical reception

In an retrospective review, Andy Healy from Albumism stated that the "heartbreak" in the song is "palpable as a bittersweet love song in the grandest tradition of "done me wrong" songs." In his weekly UK chart commentary in ''Dotmusic'', James Masterton wrote, "Only the Artist Formerly Known As Prince could write a love song called "I Hate You"", adding that "this one is unlikely to progress too much further even if it is one of his more laidback soulful efforts." Alexis Petridis from ''The Guardian'' said "I Hate You" is " The Most Beautiful Girl in the World"'s "evil twin", noting it as "more pillow-soft soul, this time attacking rather than hymning a woman, complete with a faintly problematic faux-courtroom scene." Chuck Campbell from ''Knoxville News Sentinel'' declared it as "a bitter-on-sex song on which the singer battles his contradictory feelings for an infidel as only he can." Cheo H. Coker from ''Los Angeles Times'' described it as a "ballad reminiscent of "International Lover", hatfinds Prince pulling out his famous falsetto to castigate a lover foolish enough to leave him for another man." Pan-European magazine ''Music & Media'' named it Single of the Week, commenting, "Hatred is a subject you either treat with fury or with restrained anger. But Prince simply fits in both methods in a ballad with the perfect build-up from low-key to intensity." Carol Cooper from ''Rolling Stone'' viewed it as "soulful", adding that it "sums up the Princely persona in a nutshell. He loves his women and his colleagues, but he can't allow them a dominant role in his life or his work."

Music video

There was an unreleased music video circulating among Prince collectors of this single. The music video, which was filmed at Paisley Park Studios on October 22, 1995 and directed by Prince himself, featured Prince's then-fiancée Mayte Garcia, dancing in some shots and Prince telling Mayte off in the courtroom, and Michael Bland (part of The New Power Generation) as the judge. On January 26, 2018, the video was finally revealed to the public on the official Prince YouTube Channel. It has amassed more than 1.4 million views as of May 2023

B-sides/remixes

The single's B-side was an instrumental "Quiet Night Mix" of "I Hate U" featuring long-time collaborator Eric Leeds on saxophone. A maxi single on CD and vinyl included several remixes of the track. The most notable was an extended remix which omitted the "courtroom drama" and featured Prince delivering much more personal lyrics. A rumor at the time was that the lyrics of this version referred to Carmen Electra (whom Prince had worked with and dated for a time) after it was discovered that she "gave her body to" N.P.G. member Tony M. "in the name of fun". Electra has confirmed that the song was written about her. Other versions of the song were various edits. The Japanese CD single was unique in that it included the album version of "Endorphinmachine" as an extra track.

Charts

Weekly charts

Year-end charts

References

{{Prince singles

Prince (musician) songs
1995 singles
Songs written by Prince (musician)
NPG Records singles
Warner Records singles
Song recordings produced by Prince (musician)
Songs about infidelity
Songs about heartache
Contemporary R&B ballads