
"The Idiot Boy" is a poem written by
William Wordsworth
William Wordsworth (7 April 177023 April 1850) was an English Romantic poetry, Romantic poet who, with Samuel Taylor Coleridge, helped to launch the Romanticism, Romantic Age in English literature with their joint publication ''Lyrical Balla ...
, a representative of the
Romantic movement
Romanticism (also known as the Romantic movement or Romantic era) was an artistic and intellectual movement that originated in Europe towards the end of the 18th century. The purpose of the movement was to advocate for the importance of subjec ...
in English literature. The poem was composed in spring 1798 and first published in the same year in ''
Lyrical Ballads
''Lyrical Ballads, with a Few Other Poems'' is a collection of poems by William Wordsworth and Samuel Taylor Coleridge, first published in 1798 and generally considered to have marked the beginning of the English Romantic movement in literature. ...
'', a collection of poems written by Wordsworth and
Samuel Taylor Coleridge
Samuel Taylor Coleridge ( ; 21 October 177225 July 1834) was an English poet, literary critic, philosopher, and theologian who was a founder of the Romantic Movement in England and a member of the Lake Poets with his friend William Wordsworth ...
, which is considered to be a turning point in the history of English literature and the Romantic movement. The poem investigates such themes as language,
intellectual disability
Intellectual disability (ID), also known as general learning disability (in the United Kingdom), and formerly mental retardation (in the United States), Rosa's Law, Pub. L. 111-256124 Stat. 2643(2010).Archive is a generalized neurodevelopmental ...
, maternity, emotionality (excessive or otherwise), organisation of experience and "transgression of the natural."
"The Idiot Boy" is Wordsworth's longest poem in ''Lyrical Ballads'' (with 463 lines), although it is surpassed in length by Coleridge's "
The Rime of the Ancient Mariner
''The Rime of the Ancient Mariner'' (originally ''The Rime of the Ancyent Marinere''), written by English poet Samuel Taylor Coleridge in 1797–98 and published in 1798 in the first edition of '' Lyrical Ballads'', is a poem that recounts th ...
." It was the 16th poem of the collection in the original 1798 edition, and the 21st poem in the 1800 edition, which added Wordsworth's famous
Preface to Lyrical Ballads.
Summary of the plot
The poem tells the story of the titular "Idiot Boy," as well as his mother Betty Foy and their gravely ill neighbour Susan Gale. As Johnny's father, a woodsman, is away from home, Betty decides to send her son to the nearest town on horseback, so that he may bring with him a doctor who could help Susan. However, Johnny gets lost trying to reach the town at night, and his mother is forced to follow him. When she reaches the doctor's house, she realizes Johnny is not there and returns home in a state of agitation, forgetting to bring the doctor with her. Eventually, Johnny is reunited with his mother, and their neighbour rises from her bed, miraculously cured.
Form
The poem uses a five-line stanza of
tetrameter
In poetry, a tetrameter is a line of four metrical feet. However, the particular foot can vary, as follows:
* '' Anapestic tetrameter:''
** "And the ''sheen'' of their ''spears'' was like ''stars'' on the ''sea''" (Lord Byron, " The Destruction ...
lines, with a rhyming scheme of ABCCB, said to be a "variation on the long meter
quatrain
A quatrain is a type of stanza, or a complete poem, consisting of four Line (poetry), lines.
Existing in a variety of forms, the quatrain appears in poems from the poetic traditions of various ancient civilizations including Persia, Ancient India ...
." It has been described as a realisation of the traditional form of the
ballad
A ballad is a form of verse, often a narrative set to music. Ballads were particularly characteristic of the popular poetry and song of Great Britain and Ireland from the Late Middle Ages until the 19th century. They were widely used across Eur ...
, chiefly because of its "unobtrusive" narrator, as well as "an extreme example of the naive or rustic style in poetry."
Balladic Elements
The poem contains allusions to many romantic ballad commonplaces, connected mainly with
Gottfried August Bürger
Gottfried August Bürger (31 December 1747 – 8 June 1794) was a German poet. His ballads were very popular in Germany. His most noted ballad, ''Lenore (ballad), Lenore'', found an audience beyond readers of the German language in an English l ...
's ballads "
Lenore" and "
The Wild Huntsman." This is exemplified mainly by the mock-heroic section of the poem (lines 322-356), as well as its opening stanza (lines 1-6), where moonlight and the presence of owls take centre stage as the attributes of the ballad:
'T'is eight o'clock – a clear March night,
'The moon is up – the sky is blue,
'The owlet in the moonlight air,
He shouts from nobody knows where
He lengthens out his lonely shout,
Halloo! halloo! a long halloo!
Johnny has been dubbed "a
Quixotic hero," as well as a
knight errant
A knight-errant (or knight errant) is a figure of medieval Chivalric romance, chivalric romance literature. The adjective '':wikt:errant, errant'' (meaning "wandering, roving") indicates how the knight-errant would wander the land in search of adv ...
, and an allusion to
Don Quixote
, the full title being ''The Ingenious Gentleman Don Quixote of La Mancha'', is a Spanish novel by Miguel de Cervantes. Originally published in two parts in 1605 and 1615, the novel is considered a founding work of Western literature and is of ...
has been found in the narrator's vision of Johnny hunting sheep in line 337 of the poem. He has been connected to "a long tradition of fools," as the poem explores his extraordinary, unorthodox perception of the world. The poem, however, seems to emphasise a defamiliarization of such clichés, rather than emulate them. The poem's connection to the ballad genre has also been described as tenuous, as it is said to exhibit a shift in focus from the exploration of a plot to the exploration of abstract feeling.
The Narrator
The narrator of "The Idiot Boy" is considered to be "comic," as well as "dramatized," "highly limited" and even "incompetent." He is described as a poetic figure "variously affected" by the story he narrates, and thus both "detached" from and "engaged" in the events of the poem. Though he is not directly involved in the story of the poem himself, certain qualities of his "may be inferred from
isstylistic habits," as well as the parts of the poem in which he addresses his audience.
The narrator's attitude towards Johnny seems benevolent, however he criticises Betty with "a trace of patronizing condescension" in lines 22-26:
The world will say 'tis very idle,
Bethink you of the time of night;
There's not a mother, no not one.
But when she hears what you have done.
Oh! Betty she'll be in a fright.
Condescension may also be found in the narrator's description of Johnny as a "fierce and dreadful hunter," (338) as well as in his negative response to Betty's imaginings about her son's fate (lines 212-216).
So, through the moonlight lane she goes,
And far into the moonlight dale;
And how she ran, and how she walked,
And all that to herself she talked,
would surely be a tedious tale.
However, he is said to be just as much a source of speculation as she is, as he strives to "fill in the gaps of his story" with "fanciful adventure."
Out of ninety stanzas of the poem, approximately one third of them begin with the conjunctions "and," "but" or "so," which suggests that its narrator is focused chiefly on a simple, sequential retelling of the story. He also seems prone to simplifying the character's experience into simple binary opposites, such as when referring to the life or death of Susan Gale (52-56), in Betty's instructions to Johnny (62-66; "
w to turn left and how to right") or in the description of her search for him (217-221).
In high and low, above, below,
ln great and small, in round and square,
In tree and tower was Johnny seen,
In bush and brake, in black and green,
'Twas Johnny, Johnny everywhere.
Despite this, some evidence of the narrator's skilfulness has been identified in his usage of humour and deliberate poetic structures, such as the recurring theme of the owls.
The Muses
The mock-heroic fragment of the poem (lines 322-356) may be read as a "self-conscious comment on the narrator's efforts," as he expresses affection towards his
muses
In ancient Greek religion and Greek mythology, mythology, the Muses (, ) were the Artistic inspiration, inspirational goddesses of literature, science, and the arts. They were considered the source of the knowledge embodied in the poetry, lyric p ...
in a way similar to how Betty's affection towards Johnny is portrayed (compare "Ye muses! Whom I love so well" (356) with "Him whom she loves, her idiot boy" (lines 16 and 376). The narrator's appeal to the muses has also been described as a way to comment on the anxiousness which readers may experience expecting a full account of the titular character's "strange adventures" (351), as they would in more traditional sentimental stories.
In lines 347-348 the narrator claims that he has practised poetry (been "bound" to the muses) for fourteen years, which is a fact true about Wordsworth in the moment of writing the poem. These lines have been read to suggest the narrator's incompetence, as trades would typically be learnt in a period of seven years. However, the narrator has also been dubbed a "deliberately naïve version of
ordsworth" not to be confused with the author himself, but rather to be identified with a "narrow-minded" and "excessively genteel" style of poetry criticised by Wordsworth.
Humour
"The Idiot Boy's" tone is considered to be comedic. Its humour has been dubbed a "defence against the ominous threats facing Johnny," as well as a "burlesque" of the philosophical discourse of
intellectual disability
Intellectual disability (ID), also known as general learning disability (in the United Kingdom), and formerly mental retardation (in the United States), Rosa's Law, Pub. L. 111-256124 Stat. 2643(2010).Archive is a generalized neurodevelopmental ...
in the
Enlightenment
Enlightenment or enlighten may refer to:
Age of Enlightenment
* Age of Enlightenment, period in Western intellectual history from the late 17th to late 18th century, centered in France but also encompassing (alphabetically by country or culture): ...
, as by "mocking the reader's sense of decorum" the poem seems to challenge literary and social preconceptions.
The sources of humour in the poem have been found in the contrast between the fragments devoted to Johnny and Betty and the elements of the narrator's mock-heroic voice, as well as the comedic force of Betty's failure to ask for the doctor's help joint with Susan's miraculous recovery. Thus, the poem's humour has been classified as "one of happy resolution."
Characters and Themes
Moonlight and the Supernatural
Supernatural elements of the poem are found chiefly in Betty's visions of Johnny's undoing (lines 232-241) and in the narrator's mock-heroic section (322-356):
'Oh saints! what is become of him?
Perhaps he's climbed into an oak,
Where he will stay until he is dead;
Or, sadly he has been misled,
And joined the wandering gipsy-folk.
'Or him that wicked pony's carried
To the dark cave, the goblin's hall;
Or in the castle he's pursuing,
Among the ghosts his own undoing;
Or playing with the waterfall.'
Betty imagines her son's downfall to be caused by
goblins
A goblin is a small, grotesque, monstrous humanoid creature that appears in the folklore of multiple European cultures. First attested in stories from the Middle Ages, they are ascribed conflicting abilities, temperaments, and appearances dep ...
(238) or ghosts (240), but the narrator disregards her concerns, describing them as "unworthy" and "wild":
Betty's superstitious speculation has been described as her way of dealing with her anxiety for Johnny – namely the fear of him dying (suggested by his "playing with the waterfall" in line 241). Her anxious behaviour is also found to contrast with the aura of peaceful "transcendence" evoked by the moonlight. The moon, in turn, is identified with Johnny's "other-worldliness," as he experiences the uncanniness of the night.
Despite its abundance of supernatural elements, the poem has been found to be focused rather on "social commentary" in line with Wordsworth's aim "to give the charm of novelty to things of every day" (as described by Coleridge).
Johnny Foy and Intellectual Disability
Johnny Foy exhibits non-normative behaviour and atypical verbal expression, which has led critics to interpret his condition as
intellectual disability
Intellectual disability (ID), also known as general learning disability (in the United Kingdom), and formerly mental retardation (in the United States), Rosa's Law, Pub. L. 111-256124 Stat. 2643(2010).Archive is a generalized neurodevelopmental ...
. "The Idiot Boy" is said to explore how such disabilities are mythologized in order to establish them as a proper subject for linguistic and psychologic deliberations, and it has been connected with "an emergent 'humane' understanding of cognitive difference."
The poem's usage of the term "
idiot
An idiot, in modern use, is a stupid or foolish person.
"Idiot" was formerly a technical term in legal and psychiatric contexts for some kinds of profound intellectual disability where the mental age is two years or less, and the person cannot ...
" has been said to carry "connotations of deficiency," and the word itself has been counted amongst those used "to provoke revulsion or to ostracize groups of people."
Johnny's condition is said to transgress "the limits of being," as well as the "binary oppositions of order and disorder, reason and idiocy,
..purity and disgust." He has also been connected with the poem's subversion of romantic conventions, as he himself is free of any literary and socio-cultural preconceptions.
Although Johnny's and his mother's roles in the poem are discussed at length, his father is notably absent from the poem and only mentioned by his profession in lines 37-39.
Johnny's Joy and Poeticism
Michael Mason claims that Johnny experiences "Wordsworthian joy," a state in which a passive observer perceives natural phenomena "in themselves," with no outside point of reference, as illustrated by Johnny's misclassification of owl cries and the moon in lines 447-463:
For, while they all were travelling home,
Cried Betty 'Tell us, Johnny, do,
Where all this long night you have been,
What you have heard, what you have seen,
And, Johnny, mind you tell us true.'
Now Johnny all night long had heard
The owls in tuneful concert strive;
No doubt too he the moon had seen;
For in the moonlight he had been
From eight o'clock till five.
And thus, to Betty's question, he
Made answer, like a traveller bold
(His very words I give to you),
'The cocks did crow to-whoo, to-whoo,
And the sun did shine so cold,' –
Thus answered Johnny in his glory,
And that was all his travel's story.
This sense of joy has also been connected with an escape from the restrained world of rationality into one where language is "subordinate to feeling." Johnny's account of his journey has been said to present him as an "imaginative" and "poetic" figure, as he seems to creatively organise his new experience. However, although this is identified with "poetic insight," Johnny all the same fails to reach the doctor and let him help his neighbour.
This portrayal seems to criticise the popular perception of intellectually disabled people in
the Enlightenment
The Age of Enlightenment (also the Age of Reason and the Enlightenment) was a European intellectual and philosophical movement active from the late 17th to early 19th century. Chiefly valuing knowledge gained through rationalism and empirici ...
, as it would likely lead to Johnny being read as "revolting" or "inhuman" due to his disability, in line with Coleridge's remark that Wordsworth has not "taken sufficient care to preclude from the reader's fancy the disgusting images of ordinary, morbid idiocy."
Furthermore, Johnny's apparent lack of reason, contrasted with the suggestion that his horse is both capable of thought and that he "thinks of
ohnnyas 'what' rather than 'whom'" in lines 121-126, has been connected with
John Locke
John Locke (; 29 August 1632 (Old Style and New Style dates, O.S.) – 28 October 1704 (Old Style and New Style dates, O.S.)) was an English philosopher and physician, widely regarded as one of the most influential of the Enlightenment thi ...
's classification of "
changelings
A changeling, also historically referred to as an auf or oaf, is a human-like creature found throughout much of European folklore. According to folklore, a changeling was a substitute left by a supernatural being when kidnapping a human being. ...
" – a species between humans and animals.
But then he is a horse that thinks!
And when he thinks his pace is slack,
Now, though he knows poor Johnny well,
Yet for his life he cannot tell
What he has got upon his back.
Despite his failure, Johnny's experience is said to be "cathartic for
isentire community," transforming it "into a more integral and caring" one, as he, his mother and their neighbour are once more brought together.
Abuse of Language
Abuse of language similar to Johnny's is prevalent throughout the poem, as exemplified by Susan's miraculous recovery, made possible when she recovers as she regains "control over her utterance," and by the doctor's ironic lines (262-271), which subvert the expectations one might hold towards a member of his profession and the principles of the
Hippocratic Oath.
'Oh doctor! doctor! Where's my Johnny?'
'I'm here, what is't you want with me?'
'Oh sir! you know I'm Betty Foy,
And I have lost my poor dear boy,
You know him – him you often see;
'He's not so wise as some folks be.'
'The devil take his wisdom!' said
The doctor, looking somewhat grim,
'What, woman! should I know of him?'
And, grumbling, he went back to bed.
Even the narrator may be characterised by a similar linguistic inefficiency, as he is unable to continue his narrative in lines 352-356 due to what Gordon Thomas calls his "aphasia."
O gentle Muses! is this kind?
Why will ye thus my suit repel?
Why of your further aid bereave me?
And can ye thus unfriendly, leave me;
Ye Muses! whom I love so well.
Johnny's seemingly rational mother also fails to keep her composure throughout the poem, as signified by line 249 ("Unworthy things she talked and wild").
"Burring"
The word "burr" is often used in the poem (lines 19, 107, 115, 387) to refer to a sound made by Johnny, which has been classified as his "physiological response to the cold," as well as a mimicry of the owls, or his steed. Betty, however, interprets it as "the noise he loves" (line 110). This may be read as faulty, as the "burr" may not have any meaning to him after all, or, conversely, as accurate, as it may signify that Johnny's noises are "perfectly comprehensible" to him and his loved ones.
Burr, burr – now Johnny's lips they burr,
As loud as any mill, or near it;
Meek as a lamb the pony moves,
And Johnny makes the noise he loves,
And Betty listens, glad to hear it.
Johnny's "burring" has been likened to Wordsworth's own – that is, to his Northumberland accent, "characterized by a strong, guttural pronunciation of 'r,'" and to his narrator's stylistic mistakes, which suggest that his "competency as a storyteller is limited." These include overuse of repetition (lines 82-86, 92-96, 177-181), as well as distortion of "syntax for the sake of rhyme" (lines 365-366) and "an exaggerated inversion of normal word order" (in lines 34-36, in which the usage of the verb "ail" is simultaneously transitive and intransitive, and thus logically indecipherable).
But when the pony moved his legs,
Oh! then for the poor Idiot Boy!
For joy he cannot hold the bridle,
For joy his head and heels are idle,
He's idle all for very joy. (82-86)
..
Old Susan lies a-bed in pain,
And sorely puzzled are the twain,
For what she ails they cannot guess. (34-36)
This abuse of "poetic diction," however, has been characterised as an element of Wordsworth's critique of the use of popular language in poetry, and as "evidence not of Wordsworth's failure as a poet but of his skill" in "defining his dramatized narrator."
Betty Foy and "Maternal Passion"
In the
Preface to Lyrical Ballads, Wordsworth expressed his aim to portray human nature by "tracing the maternal passion through many of its more subtle windings." Betty's approach to her son has, however, been dubbed by
John Wilson John Wilson may refer to:
Academics
* John Wilson (historian) (1799–1870), author of ''Our Israelitish Origin'' (1840), a founding text of British Israelism
* John Wilson (agriculturalist) (1812–1888), British agriculturalist
* John Matthias ...
as "almost unnatural" and by Coleridge as "an impersonation of an instinct abandoned by judgement," signifying that Wordsworth's contemporaries found the poem "lacking" in this regard.
Wilson's criticism of Betty's affection towards her son has been said to follow a sense of reciprocal sympathy described by
Adam Smith
Adam Smith (baptised 1723 – 17 July 1790) was a Scottish economist and philosopher who was a pioneer in the field of political economy and key figure during the Scottish Enlightenment. Seen by some as the "father of economics"——— or ...
in his
Theory of Moral Sentiments
''The Theory of Moral Sentiments'' is a 1759 book by Adam Smith. It provided the ethical, philosophical, economic, and methodological underpinnings to Smith's later works, including ''The Wealth of Nations'' (1776), '' Essays on Philosophical S ...
, as, in that view, "no self-respecting mother ought to adore a son so indifferent to and incapable of returning love." Betty's inability to understand Johnny's burring has also been said to signify her being "incapable of representing him" in a perception of intellectual disability contemporary to Wordsworth.
Wordsworth's portrayal of Betty has been connected with the exploration of "his ability to love like a mother (totally, vulnerably or irrationally
..," as even her and Johnny's surname (Foy) has been connected with the French word ''foi'' meaning faith.
Betty has also been ascribed the role of the poet due to her accounts of Johnny's adventure. This role, in turn, allows for the narrator to be read as her double, guilty of the same susceptibility to emotions in his reports, which "exposes
ispoetic pretension and lack of self-awareness." The narrator and Betty are therefore jointly described as "
epresentingdebased popular poets," whereas Johnny stands as "the heroic poet of the
reativeImagination," as opposed to their superfluous fancy.
Reception
"The Idiot Boy" was counted amongst ''
Lyrical Ballads
''Lyrical Ballads, with a Few Other Poems'' is a collection of poems by William Wordsworth and Samuel Taylor Coleridge, first published in 1798 and generally considered to have marked the beginning of the English Romantic movement in literature. ...
most experimental and controversial poems in the perception of its early reviewers. In the period of 1798-1800 it was reprinted only once, in 80 lines, in the issue of
Critical Review for October 1798, in which it was famously criticised by
Robert Southey
Robert Southey (; 12 August 1774 – 21 March 1843) was an English poet of the Romantic poetry, Romantic school, and Poet Laureate of the United Kingdom, Poet Laureate from 1813 until his death. Like the other Lake Poets, William Wordsworth an ...
as "
esemblinga Flemish picture in the worthlessness of its design and the excellence of its execution."
The poem was generally negatively described by
John Wilson John Wilson may refer to:
Academics
* John Wilson (historian) (1799–1870), author of ''Our Israelitish Origin'' (1840), a founding text of British Israelism
* John Wilson (agriculturalist) (1812–1888), British agriculturalist
* John Matthias ...
and Coleridge.
William Hazlitt
William Hazlitt (10 April 177818 September 1830) was an English essayist, drama and literary criticism, literary critic, painter, social commentator, and philosopher. He is now considered one of the greatest critics and essayists in the history ...
wrote that he felt "a ''chaunt'' in the recitation" of the poems declaimed to him by Wordsworth and Coleridge, including "The Idiot Boy, which would "
ctas a spell upon the hearer, and
isarmthe judgment". Hazlitt's remarks may suggest that despite any criticism he might have had towards the poems delaimed, they were signified by an effective use of meter (though possibly misleadingly so).
Marilyn Butler
Marilyn Speers Butler, Lady Butler, FRSA, FRSL, Fellow of the British Academy, FBA (''née'' Evans; 11 February 1937 – 11 March 2014) was a British literary criticism, literary critic. She was King Edward VII Professor of English Literature at ...
writes that "most of the
eviewers of the ''Lyrical Ballads''praised poems which use an elevated language and subject, like '
Tintern Abbey
Tintern Abbey ( ) is a ruined medieval abbey situated adjacent to the village of Tintern in Monmouthshire, on the Welsh bank of the River Wye, which at this location forms the border between Monmouthshire in Wales and Gloucestershire in England. ...
,' and attacked those using a 'mean' language and subject, like 'The Idiot Boy.'" In line with this, Janina Nordius comments that "great talent wasted on a dubious topic seems to be the dominant critical view" of the poem, and Roger Murray claims that "no one has warmly defended" it. Murray also finds the poem to have "too little grace
..ever to be ranked alongside Wordsworth's greatest poems," though he sees its portrayal of Betty as its saving grace.
Conversely, Michael Mason remarked that "The Idiot Boy," as one of "the more ballad-like of Wordsworth's contributions
n Lyrical Ballads,was generally well received," and Albert E. Wilhelm claimed it was "one of Wordsworth's best known but least appreciated" poems.
Quality
The "Idiot Boy" been described as "incongruous" and as "a failure" by
Geoffrey H. Hartman, as its repetitions "draw too much attention to Wordsworth's own 'burring,'" Joshua King argues, however, that such features are "what make
he poeminteresting," as they suggest "a human community made possible by blind patterns of sensation, pleasure and habit, rather than primarily by rationality and linguistic ability."
Jonathan Wordsworth dubbed the poem a "comic masterpiece" and "an almost faultless work of art," as well as "a creation of exquisite tact, at once humorous and deeply moving." In line with this, John F. Danby comments that the tone of the poem is "beautifully mock-solemn and yet indulgently ready with its sympathy," and Daniel Robinson claims that "the warm comedic tones, which never mock the boy, complement perfectly the affection his mother feels, and the affection
hereader ought to feel for him," though the poem "subverts the sentimentality readers would have expected from a poem on mental disability in a newspaper or magazine of the time." Although the poem "appears frivolous" with its "feminine rhymes, overblown diction and laughable characters," Karen Guendel argues that it warrants a second, more in-depth look due to its subversion of expectations and metaliterary critique of its own narrator.
Wordsworth's transgressions have, however, been noted by Anne McWhir to "
reventus from noticing" his perpetuation of the binary oppositions of what is vulgar and proper, as he strives to select the latter kind of language for his poetry. Zoe Beenstock has also criticised the poem's aims at recontextualising intellectual disability, claiming that Wordsworth "remains focused on the able-bodied interlocutors who learn to value their own freedom by watching the spectacle of disability and dependence."
Responses to Johnny
Responses to Johnny's condition seem to range from condescending dismissal to explorations of his state of being which classify it as serious, "in touch with the divine" or "extra human," as he is found to have access to "other dimensions" of perception, both "natural and divine." Johnny has even been said to represent an ideal Wordsworthian poet, a liminal figure "between childhood and manhood," as well as "the earthly and the divine," due to his disability.
Daniel Robinson argues that "although calling Johnny an 'idiot' seems callous," he is portrayed "without sentimentality or pathos and with great respect." On the negative side, Wordsworth's portrayal of Johnny has also been described as "ludicrous."
Responses to Betty
Joshua King claims that the author's contemporaries were unable to sympathise with Betty Foy, as her love for Johnny transgressed their "standards of propriety," defined by "rationality and the clear use of language." Conversely, modern criticism has largely found the poem "faithful to
ordsworth'sobjective."
Roger Murray claims that "The Idiot Boy" displays "the evolution" of a mother's mind. He also finds Betty to be the true main character of the poem, instead of Johnny, as it is mainly her search for Johnny that the narrative follows. Similarly, G. H. Durrant claims that "the essential meaning of the poem" is conveyed in how Betty's love "leads
ohnnysafely and serenely through
isperils," while she "suffers fear and anguish on his behalf." Zachary Leader, however, argues for the opposite, claiming that it is Johnny's "oddity" that "takes centre stage" in the poem.
Karen Guendel has noted that the poem "invites us to question Betty's judgement," and that, in light of her reckless decision to send out her son into the night and her failure to acquire help for her neighbour, it is her fancy that motivates her decision-making, rather than her love for Johnny or her rationality, as she "daydreams idly, casting Johnny and herself as the hero and heroine of various shopworn plots." This, according to Guendel, may be read as Wordsworth's critique of sensationalist popular literature.
Author's Comments
Wordsworth commented on the "purpose" of the poem in the 1802
Preface to Lyrical Ballads, saying that it adheres to his goal to "follow the fluxes and refluxes of the mind when agitated by the great and simple affectations of our nature" by "tracing the maternal passion through many of its more subtle windings." In the
Fenwick Notes he explained:
Wordsworth's fondness of the poem has been identified "a frustrated desire for his dead mother,"
Ann Wordsworth, though this claim has also been disputed as too simplistic an assumption. His and his narrator's pleasure in narration have also been connected with the exploration of transgressive maternal love, melancholy and "the originary deviance of poetry."
Wordsworth's sister,
Dorothy Wordsworth
Dorothy Wordsworth (25 December 1771 – 25 January 1855) was an English author, poet, and diarist. She was the sister of the Romanticism, Romantic poet William Wordsworth, and the two were close all their adult lives. Dorothy Wordsworth had ...
, was similarly "enchanted" with the poem.
Responses to Criticism
Wordsworth defended the poem against
John Wilson John Wilson may refer to:
Academics
* John Wilson (historian) (1799–1870), author of ''Our Israelitish Origin'' (1840), a founding text of British Israelism
* John Wilson (agriculturalist) (1812–1888), British agriculturalist
* John Matthias ...
's critique in his letter from 7 June 1802, claiming that his negative response to "an Idiot" as the subject of the poem was caused by "petty social prejudice" of the higher social strata, enabled by their ability to isolate themselves from intellectually disabled people. He also commented that he wrote the poem with "exceeding delight and pleasure," and claimed that his usage of the word "idiot" was unavoidable, as he knew no better word "to which we had attached passion" to replace it with, mentioning "lack-wit," "half-wit," and "witless" as alternatives. This has been read as a signal of him "
imingat the semantic reorientation" of the word.
Wordsworth has been said to exoticize and glorify intellectually disabled people in his letter to Wilson, granting them "visionary privilege."
He also partially conceded to Wilson's concept of repulsion towards intellectual disability as an element of human nature, as what he claimed was the factor distinguishing Johnny from other intellectually disabled people, "usually disgusting in their persons," was his ability to produce speech.
Connections with other works
* "The Idiot Boy" as well as Wordsworth's "
The Somersetshire Tragedy" have been connected with
Thomas Poole's "John Walford" – an account of a murder of an intellectually disabled woman called Jenny by her husband.
* Shortly before the publication of ''
Lyrical Ballads
''Lyrical Ballads, with a Few Other Poems'' is a collection of poems by William Wordsworth and Samuel Taylor Coleridge, first published in 1798 and generally considered to have marked the beginning of the English Romantic movement in literature. ...
'', on 30 June 1798 issue of ''
The Morning Post
''The Morning Post'' was a conservative daily newspaper published in London from 1772 to 1937, when it was acquired by ''The Daily Telegraph''.
History
The paper was founded by John Bell. According to historian Robert Darnton, ''The Morning ...
'' there appeared a poem titled "
The Idiot
''The Idiot'' (Reforms of Russian orthography, pre-reform Russian: ; post-reform ) is a novel by the 19th-century Russian author Fyodor Dostoevsky. It was first published serially in the journal ''The Russian Messenger'' in 1868–1869.
The titl ...
" written by
Robert Southey
Robert Southey (; 12 August 1774 – 21 March 1843) was an English poet of the Romantic poetry, Romantic school, and Poet Laureate of the United Kingdom, Poet Laureate from 1813 until his death. Like the other Lake Poets, William Wordsworth an ...
. In line with the contemporary "standards of correctness," the poem avoids using a word similar to Johnny's "burr" when describing the sounds made by an intellectually disabled person, instead using the phrase "half artic'late call" (line 10).
* Johnny's voyage has been compared with the journey to the underworld taken by
Virgil
Publius Vergilius Maro (; 15 October 70 BC21 September 19 BC), usually called Virgil or Vergil ( ) in English, was an ancient Rome, ancient Roman poet of the Augustan literature (ancient Rome), Augustan period. He composed three of the most fa ...
's
Aeneas
In Greco-Roman mythology, Aeneas ( , ; from ) was a Troy, Trojan hero, the son of the Trojan prince Anchises and the Greek goddess Aphrodite (equivalent to the Roman Venus (mythology), Venus). His father was a first cousin of King Priam of Troy ...
in the ''
Aeneid
The ''Aeneid'' ( ; or ) is a Latin Epic poetry, epic poem that tells the legendary story of Aeneas, a Troy, Trojan who fled the Trojan War#Sack of Troy, fall of Troy and travelled to Italy, where he became the ancestor of the Ancient Rome ...
'', as the "holly-bough" that Johnny holds in his hand (mentioned in lines 57-61 and 87-91) seems to allude to the golden bough which Aeneas sought for safety in his travel, and as Virgil's depiction of the underworld seems to reflect Betty's vision of Johnny's ill fate. The maternal love of Betty has also been connected with
Cyrene's strength-endowing "effluence" from Virgil's ''
Georgics
The ''Georgics'' ( ; ) is a poem by Latin poet Virgil, likely published in 29 BCE. As the name suggests (from the Greek language, Greek word , ''geōrgiká'', i.e. "agricultural hings) the subject of the poem is agriculture; but far from bei ...
''.
*
Charles Dickens
Charles John Huffam Dickens (; 7 February 1812 – 9 June 1870) was an English novelist, journalist, short story writer and Social criticism, social critic. He created some of literature's best-known fictional characters, and is regarded by ...
' ''
Barnaby Rudge
''Barnaby Rudge: A Tale of the Riots of Eighty'' (commonly known as ''Barnaby Rudge'') is a historical novel by English novelist Charles Dickens. ''Barnaby Rudge'' was one of two novels (the other was ''The Old Curiosity Shop'') that Dickens pub ...
'' has been said to "
wesomething of his origin to Johnny Foy", as they share "an undefined, good-natured dementia" and are "most fully connected with humanity through the unfailing devotion of their respective mothers."
* The poem's narrator has been compared to
Laurence Sterne
Laurence Sterne (24 November 1713 – 18 March 1768) was an Anglo-Irish novelist and Anglican cleric. He is best known for his comic novels ''The Life and Opinions of Tristram Shandy, Gentleman'' (1759–1767) and ''A Sentimental Journey Thro ...
's
Tristram Shandy Tristram may refer to:
Literature
* the title character of ''The Life and Opinions of Tristram Shandy, Gentleman'', a novel by Laurence Sterne
* the title character of '' Tristram of Lyonesse'', an epic poem by Algernon Charles Swinburne
*"Tristr ...
, as they both have difficulty finishing their stories, and their respective invocations appear only towards the end of both works.
* Johnny's account of his voyage has been connected with
Henry Vaughan
Henry Vaughan (17 April 1621 – 23 April 1695) was a Welsh metaphysical poet, author and translator writing in English, and a medical physician. His religious poetry appeared in ''Silex Scintillans'' in 1650, with a second part in 1655.''Oxfo ...
's "The Night," as "the paradoxical interplay between sun and moon, heat and cold, darkness and light" is likewise key to Vaughan's poem.
Other Works by Wordsworth
* Wordsworth described "The Idiot Boy" along with his "
The Mad Mother" as poems pertaining to "maternal passion" in the
Preface to Lyrical Ballads.
* Wordsworth mentions the plot of "The Idiot Boy" in book XIV of his autobiographical poem ''
The Prelude
''The Prelude or, Growth of a Poet's Mind; An Autobiographical Poem '' is an autobiographical poem in blank verse by the English poet William Wordsworth. Intended as the introduction to the more philosophical poem ''The Recluse,'' which Wordswort ...
'' (lines 397-406). "The Idiot Boy" has also been likened to the Winander boy episode of Book V of ''
The Prelude
''The Prelude or, Growth of a Poet's Mind; An Autobiographical Poem '' is an autobiographical poem in blank verse by the English poet William Wordsworth. Intended as the introduction to the more philosophical poem ''The Recluse,'' which Wordswort ...
,'' as both Johnny and the Winander boy echo the sound of the owls. The Snowdon episode of Book XIII of the 1805 edition of ''The Prelude'', as well as Wordsworth's "
A Night Piece," have been connected with "The Idiot Boy" as pieces "featuring a lunar epiphany."
* The moonlight is also mentioned in Wordsworth's "
Peter Bell Peter Bell may refer to:
People
* Peter Hansborough Bell (1810–1898), governor of Texas, U.S. representative
* Peter Bell (footballer, born 1898) (1898–1965), English footballer
* Peter Bell (footballer, born 1976), Australian rules footballe ...
," which seems to allude to Johnny's journey, and has even been dubbed the poem's sequel.
* The narrator's appeal to the muses has been connected with Wordsworth's "Simon Lee," the speaker of which similarly seems to "
ebukehis reader for wanting sentimental stories and arousing incidents."
* Johnny has been grouped with the leach-gatherer from "
Resolution and Independence
"Resolution and Independence" is a lyric poem by the English Romantic poet William Wordsworth, composed in 1802 and published in 1807 in '' Poems in Two Volumes''. The poem contains twenty stanzas written in modified rhyme royal, and describes Wor ...
", Luke from "
Michael
Michael may refer to:
People
* Michael (given name), a given name
* he He ..., a given name
* Michael (surname), including a list of people with the surname Michael
Given name
* Michael (bishop elect)">Michael (surname)">he He ..., a given nam ...
" and
Lucy Gray
"Lucy Gray" is a poem written by William Wordsworth in 1799 and published in his ''Lyrical Ballads''. It describes the death of a young girl named Lucy Gray, who went out one evening into a storm.
Background
The poem was inspired by Wordsworth ...
as Wordsworth's "
ntermediariesbetween
atureand man".
* The poem has been grouped with other "Pre-
Goslar
Goslar (; Eastphalian dialect, Eastphalian: ''Goslär'') is a historic town in Lower Saxony, Germany. It is the administrative centre of the Goslar (district), district of Goslar and is located on the northwestern wikt:slope, slopes of the Harz ...
poems with vagrants or itinerants as subjects," such as "The Thorn," "
The Mad Mother," "
Old Man Travelling
Old or OLD may refer to:
Places
*Old, Baranya, Hungary
*Old, Northamptonshire, England
*Old Street station, a railway and tube station in London (station code OLD)
*OLD, IATA code for Old Town Municipal Airport and Seaplane Base, Old Town, Mai ...
" and "
The Complaint of a forsaken Indian Woman" as allusions to their "substantial literary precedents (wandering bard or minstrel; pilgrim; knight-errant)."
Connections with Coleridge
* The poem has been compared with Coleridge's "
Christabel" as "particularly valuable in tandem" due to their "complementary" explorations "of language,
tsdivinity
..and how
tsuse and misuse
..may at once both reveal and hide thoughts".
* The poem has been connected with Coleridge's "
The Rhyme of the Ancient Mariner" as well as Wordsworth's "
The Female Vagrant" as "a more light-hearted instance of
heir
Inheritance is the practice of receiving private property, titles, debts, entitlements, privileges, rights, and obligations upon the death of an individual. The rules of inheritance differ among societies and have changed over time. Offi ...
pattern of departure and return." Moreover, "both Johnny and the
arinerhave imaginative experiences illuminated by moonlight," and both poems "conclude with a provocative undercutting of narrative expectations."
* Coleridge's
Osorio
Osorio (also Osório) is a surname of Spanish, Portuguese and Basque origins. One meaning of the name is “hunter of wolves”. Notable people with this surname include:
Surname
* Aitor Osorio (born 1975), Andorran swimmer
* Aldo Osorio (bor ...
has also been noted to anticipate the motives of the owls, moonlight, caverns and the waterfall found in "The Idiot Boy."
Parody
* Wordsworth complains about an apparent parody of his poem written by
Peter Bayley in his letter to
Walter Scott
Sir Walter Scott, 1st Baronet (15 August 1771 – 21 September 1832), was a Scottish novelist, poet and historian. Many of his works remain classics of European literature, European and Scottish literature, notably the novels ''Ivanhoe'' (18 ...
from 16 October 1803. The poem was titled "
The Fisherman's Wife."
* The poem has been alluded to in an anonymously published poem called "Benjamin the Wagonner, A Ryghte merrie and conceited Tale in Verse" printed in the 1819 Literary Gazette. Just as "The Idiot Boy" describes the "happy, happy, happy John" (96), the parody speaks of "Happy, happy, happy people / Happy, ignorant of law," imagined by Wordsworth on a visit to "a fanciful country."
*
George Byron
George Gordon Byron, 6th Baron Byron (22 January 1788 – 19 April 1824) was an English poet. He is one of the major figures of the Romantic movement, and is regarded as being among the greatest poets of the United Kingdom. Among his best-kno ...
alluded to "The Idiot Boy" in lines (259-266) of his 1840 poem called "
English Bards and Scotch Reviewers: A Satire."
Footnotes
References
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
External links
*
{{DEFAULTSORT:Idiot Boy
1798 poems
Poetry by William Wordsworth