Pterygophagy

Lepidophagy is a specialised feeding behaviour in fish that involves eating the scales of other fish. Lepidophagy is widespread, having evolved independently in at least five freshwater families and seven marine families. A related feeding behavior among fish is pterygophagy: feeding on the fins of other fish.

Species

Lepidophagy, or scale-eating, has been reported in a range of fish, including: ''Chanda nama'' (family Ambassidae), ''Plagiotremus'' (family Blenniidae), ''Terapon jarbua'' (family Terapontidae), a few '' Ariopsis'' and ''Neoarius'' species (family Ariidae), '' Pachypterus khavalchor'' (family contentious - variably in Schilbeidae, Bagridae, or Horabagridae), '' Macrorhamphoides uradoi'' (family Triacanthodidae), several pencil catfish (family Trichomycteridae), some piranha, ''Exodon paradoxus'', ''Probolodus'', ''Roeboides'' and ''Roeboexodon'' species (order Characiformes), ''Cyprinodon desquamator'' (family Cyprinodontidae), along with both ''Perissodus'' species, all four ''Plecodus'' species, ''Xenochromis'', ''Haplochromis welcommei'', ''Docimodus'', ''Corematodus'' and '' Genyochromis mento'' (family Cichlidae from the African Great Lakes).

Several of these scale-eaters also feed on fins of other fish, and many omnivorous or predatory fish may on occasion nip the fins of other fish. Only a few species are specialized fin-eaters, or pterygophagous; these include '' Belonophago'', ''Eugnathichthys'' and '' Phago'' (family Distichodontidae), ''Aspidontus'' (family Blenniidae), and '' Smilosicyopus'' (family Gobiidae). A somewhat related behavior is found in ''Magosternarchus'', which feed on the tails (both fin and connective tissue) of other gymnotiform knifefish.

Physiology

Many species of cichlid fish have evolved specialized teeth and mouth structures that make them better able to feed on the scales of other fish. Other species of fish also have a morphology that is better adapted to scale-eating. Many such species’ oral structures closely resemble each other even though they live in different habitats, and many also have specialized jaw structures. One species of fish in particular, called ''Roeboides prognathous'', has a jaw structure that is extremely specialized for lepidophagy. Certain species of lepidophagous catfish, ''Pachypterus khavalchor'', have digestive enzymes which help them to more readily break down the fins, eyes, scales of other fish. There are other morphological structures that are important in scale-eating habitats. There are six lepidophagous cichlid species who employ mimicry strategies to deceive their prey: the colors of the cichlid fish closely resemble the colors of some of their prey. However they not only eat the scales of the fish they resemble, but also prey on a wide range of other species.
File:Dorsal view of right-bending and left-bending mouth morphs of the cichlid Perissodus microlepis - journal.pone.0044670.g001.png, ''Perissodus microlepis'' right and left-bending jaw morphs
File:Lepidophagous fish.jpg, Lepidophagous fish (A and C) with non-lepidophagous relatives (B and D): ''Catoprion mento'' (A), '' Pygopristis denticulata'' (B), '' Roeboides affinis'' (C), '' Charax'' cf''. pauciradiatus'' (D)
File:Catoprion and Pygopristis.jpg, Jaws of serrasalmids: ''Catoprion mento'' (which feed on large scales throughout its life) and ''Pygopristis denticulata'' (which feed only on small scales as juveniles)
File:Catoprion mento skeleton.jpg, Wimple piranha skeleton, showing large consumed scales stacked within its gut

Behaviour

There are many different behaviours associated within lepidophagous fish. Aggression and attack behaviours like chasing and striking prey are common among ''Pachypterus khavalchor'' catfish, who then eat the fallen scales of their prey. The attack behaviour of the wimple piranha ''Catoprion mento'', whose diet consists mainly of scales, is described as a “high-speed” attack. They ram into their prey with their mouth open, biting the prey to obtain their scales. ''Perissodus microlepis'' cichlid fish tear off the scales of their prey as they swim past.
This is very different from other lepidophagous species, who merely knock the scales loose by striking the prey.

There are differences and similarities in lepidophagous behaviours across species. For example, the siluroid catfish's attacking behaviour is similar to that of the '' Probolodus heterostomus'': they both follow their prey and attack their prey from behind. This is different from the behaviour of ''Roeboides prognatus'' and ''Exodon paradoxus'', who remove scales more easily by attacking a specific part of their prey's body called the caudal area. Many studies have examined the hunting behaviours of scale-eating fish and how those behaviours have evolved over time. Certain species of cichlid aggressively mimic the behaviours of their prey, a tactic rarely used by other scale-eating fish species.

Niche

The differences in the niche of certain species may play a role in their behaviours. Lepidophagous behaviours only exist in some species. Adaptive radiation has been mentioned in many articles as having a role in the evolution of lepidophagy. There is some evidence to support this but much is also unclear. Some behaviours in certain species of fish support the theory that extreme environments could be potential causes of scale eating behaviours. Some of those species are named below.

''Cyprinodon'' pupfish

In the case of ''Cyprinodon'' pupfish, almost all have a diet of algae and detritus but the species ''Cyprinodon desquamator'' (only scientifically described in 2013; previously known as ''Cyprinodon'' sp. "lepidophage" or ''Cyprinodon'' sp. "scale-eater") is different. There are only two known cases where several ''Cyprinodon'' species live together: lakes in San Salvador Island, the Bahamas, and Lake Chichancanab, Mexico. In both cases, the co-occurring ''Cyprinodon'' species have diverged into feeding on different things and in lakes on San Salvador Island, this includes the scale-eating ''C. desquamator'' (there are no scale-eaters in Lake Chichancanab, although '' C. maya'' has become a fish-eater).

Cichlids

There is a diverse range of cichilds in Lake Tanganyika in East Africa but the Tanganyikan cichlid tribes, ''Perissodini'' and ''Plecodus'', feed on the scales of cichlids and other fishes. The species of cichilds that exhibit scale eating behaviours live in deep water with very low levels of oxygen and have had to rapidly evolve to keep up with a changing environment and lack of food.

Trade-offs

Fish scales are a nutritional food source, containing layers of keratin and enamel, as well as a dermal portion and a layer of protein-rich mucus. They are a rich source of calcium phosphate. However, the energy expended to make a strike versus the amount of scales consumed per strike puts a limit on the size of the lepidophage; such fish seldom exceed and most are under . Because of this lepidophagous fish usually are much smaller than their prey. Though scales are nutritious, the average amount of scales dislodged and eaten may not be sufficient to make up for the energy lost during the attack. The attack behaviours and strikes that are employed to remove and eat scales have an energy cost and risk of harm to the predator. In light of this, there are also a number of advantages to consuming scales: scales are common, covering the body of most fish species, can be regrown relatively quickly by "prey" fish, are abundant and seasonally reliable, and their removal requires specific behaviours or morphological structures. Scale eating behaviour usually evolves because of lack of food and extreme environmental conditions. The eating of scales and the skin surrounding the scales provides protein-rich nutrients that may not be available elsewhere in the niche.

References

Bibliography

*
*
*
*
*
*

{{diversity of fish

Ambassidae
Characidae
Ariidae
Cichlidae
Ichthyology
Carnivory