HOME

TheInfoList



OR:

Pauline Kael (; June 19, 1919 – September 3, 2001) was an American film critic who wrote for ''
The New Yorker ''The New Yorker'' is an American magazine featuring journalism, commentary, criticism, essays, fiction, satire, cartoons, and poetry. It was founded on February 21, 1925, by Harold Ross and his wife Jane Grant, a reporter for ''The New York T ...
'' from 1968 to 1991. Known for her "witty, biting, highly opinionated and sharply focused" reviews, Kael often defied the consensus of her contemporaries. One of the most influential American film critics of her era, she left a lasting impression on the art form.
Roger Ebert Roger Joseph Ebert ( ; June 18, 1942 – April 4, 2013) was an American Film criticism, film critic, film historian, journalist, essayist, screenwriter and author. He wrote for the ''Chicago Sun-Times'' from 1967 until his death in 2013. Eber ...
argued in an obituary that Kael "had a more positive influence on the climate for film in America than any other single person over the last three decades". Kael, he said, "had no theory, no rules, no guidelines, no objective standards. You couldn't apply her 'approach' to a film. With her it was all personal." In a blurb for ''The Age of Movies'', a collection of her writings for the Library of America, Ebert wrote that "Like
George Bernard Shaw George Bernard Shaw (26 July 1856 – 2 November 1950), known at his insistence as Bernard Shaw, was an Irish playwright, critic, polemicist and political activist. His influence on Western theatre, culture and politics extended from the 188 ...
, she wrote reviews that will be read for their style, humor and energy long after some of their subjects have been forgotten." For American readers, she brought attention to international cinema, and championed
New Hollywood The New Hollywood, Hollywood Renaissance, American New Wave, or New American Cinema (not to be confused with the New American Cinema of the 1960s that was part of Experimental film, avant-garde underground film, underground cinema), was a movemen ...
directors. Sanford Schwartz writes that, in the 1960s, she "gave a breathing, textured life to the aims and sensibilities of
Ingmar Bergman Ernst Ingmar Bergman (14 July 1918 – 30 July 2007) was a Swedish film and theatre director and screenwriter. Widely considered one of the greatest and most influential film directors of all time, his films have been described as "profoun ...
,
Jean-Luc Godard Jean-Luc Godard ( , ; ; 3 December 193013 September 2022) was a French and Swiss film director, screenwriter, and film critic. He rose to prominence as a pioneer of the French New Wave film movement of the 1960s, alongside such filmmakers as ...
,
Federico Fellini Federico Fellini (; 20 January 1920 – 31 October 1993) was an Italian film director and screenwriter. He is known for his distinctive style, which blends fantasy and baroque images with earthiness. He is recognized as one of the greatest and ...
,
Satyajit Ray Satyajit Ray (; 2 May 1921 – 23 April 1992) was an Indian film director, screenwriter, author, lyricist, magazine editor, illustrator, calligraphy, calligrapher, and composer. He is widely considered to be one of the greatest and most influ ...
,
Akira Kurosawa was a Japanese filmmaker who List of works by Akira Kurosawa, directed 30 feature films in a career spanning six decades. He is widely regarded as one of the greatest and most influential filmmakers in the History of film, history of cinema ...
,
François Truffaut François Roland Truffaut ( , ; ; 6 February 1932 – 21 October 1984) was a French filmmaker, actor, and critic. He is widely regarded as one of the founders of the French New Wave. He came under the tutelage of film critic Andre Bazin as a ...
, and
Michelangelo Antonioni Michelangelo Antonioni ( ; ; 29 September 1912 – 30 July 2007) was an Italian film director, screenwriter, and editor. He is best known for his "trilogy on modernity and its discontents", ''L'Avventura'' (1960), ''La Notte'' (1961), and '' ...
, among other European and Asian directors; and she endowed
Robert Altman Robert Bernard Altman ( ; February 20, 1925 – November 20, 2006) was an American film director, screenwriter, and film producer, producer. He is considered an enduring figure from the New Hollywood era, known for directing subversive and sat ...
,
Martin Scorsese Martin Charles Scorsese ( , ; born November17, 1942) is an American filmmaker. One of the major figures of the New Hollywood era, he has received List of awards and nominations received by Martin Scorsese, many accolades, including an Academ ...
, Paul Mazursky, Brian De Palma, and
Francis Ford Coppola Francis Ford Coppola ( ; born April 7, 1939) is an American filmmaker. He is considered one of the leading figures of the New Hollywood and one of the greatest filmmakers of all time. List of awards and nominations received by Francis Ford Coppo ...
, among American directors of the following decade, with the same full-bodied presence. ..Her deepest subject, in the end, isn't movies at all—it's how to live more intensely."


Early life and education

Kael was born to Isaac Paul Kael and Judith Kael (née Friedman), Jewish immigrants from
Poland Poland, officially the Republic of Poland, is a country in Central Europe. It extends from the Baltic Sea in the north to the Sudetes and Carpathian Mountains in the south, bordered by Lithuania and Russia to the northeast, Belarus and Ukrai ...
, on a chicken farm among other Jewish chicken farmers, in Petaluma, California. Her siblings were Louis (1906), Philip (1909), Annie (1912), and Rose (1913). Her parents lost their farm when Kael was eight, and the family moved to
San Francisco San Francisco, officially the City and County of San Francisco, is a commercial, Financial District, San Francisco, financial, and Culture of San Francisco, cultural center of Northern California. With a population of 827,526 residents as of ...
, where Kael attended Girls High School. Kael wrote of film critics of her generation: "We were in almost at the beginning, when something new was added to the human experience." Her parents took her to see silent films, which she later referred to, writing that D. W. Griffith's ''Intolerance'' (1916) was "the greatest movie ever made" and that Renée Falconetti's performance in
Carl Theodor Dreyer Carl Theodor Dreyer (; 3 February 1889 – 20 March 1968), commonly known as Carl Th. Dreyer, was a Danish film director and screenwriter. Widely considered one of the greatest filmmakers in history, his movies are noted for emotional austerity ...
's '' The Passion of Joan of Arc'' (1928) was "the finest ever recorded on film". In 1936, Kael matriculated at the
University of California, Berkeley The University of California, Berkeley (UC Berkeley, Berkeley, Cal, or California), is a Public university, public Land-grant university, land-grant research university in Berkeley, California, United States. Founded in 1868 and named after t ...
, where she studied philosophy, literature, and art. She dropped out in 1940. Kael had intended to go to law school, but fell in with a group of artists and moved to
New York City New York, often called New York City (NYC), is the most populous city in the United States, located at the southern tip of New York State on one of the world's largest natural harbors. The city comprises five boroughs, each coextensive w ...
with the poet Robert Horan. Three years later, Kael returned to Berkeley and "led a bohemian life", writing plays and working in experimental film. In 1948, she and the filmmaker James Broughton had a daughter, Gina James, whom Kael raised alone. Gina had a congenital heart defect for much of her childhood that Kael could not afford the surgery to correct. To support her daughter and herself, Kael worked a series of menial jobs such as cook and seamstress, along with stints as an advertising copywriter.


Early career

In 1952, Peter D. Martin, the editor of ''City Lights'', overheard Kael arguing about films in a coffeeshop with a friend and asked her to review
Charlie Chaplin Sir Charles Spencer Chaplin (16 April 188925 December 1977) was an English comic actor, filmmaker, and composer who rose to fame in the era of silent film. He became a worldwide icon through his screen persona, the Tramp, and is considered o ...
's '' Limelight'' (1952). Kael dubbed the film "Slimelight" and began publishing film criticism regularly in magazines. Kael later said of her writing: "I worked to loosen my style—to get away from the term-paper pomposity that we learn at college. I wanted the sentences to breathe, to have the sound of a human voice." She disparaged the supposed critic's ideal of objectivity, calling it "saphead objectivity", and incorporated aspects of autobiography into her criticism. In a review of Vittorio De Sica's '' Shoeshine'' (1946) that has been ranked among her most memorable,Seligman (2004). p. 37. Kael described seeing the film Kael broadcast many of her early reviews on Berkeley's alternative public radio station KPFA, and in 1955 she married Edward Landberg, the owner of the Berkeley Cinema-Guild and Studio. Their marriage soon ended in divorce, but he agreed to pay for Gina's heart surgery, and made Kael the manager of the cinema in 1955, a position she held until 1960. In that role, she programmed the films at the two-screen facility, "unapologetically repeat ngher favorites until they also became audience favorites". She also wrote "pungent" capsule reviews of the films, which her patrons began collecting.Thomson, David (2002). "Pauline Kael." '' The New Biographical Dictionary of Film''. New York: Alfred A. Knopf. . p. 449-50.


Going mass-market

Kael continued to juggle writing with other work until she received an offer to publish a book of her criticism. Published in 1965 as '' I Lost It at the Movies,'' the collection was a surprise bestseller, selling 150,000 paperback copies. Coinciding with a job at the high-circulation women's magazine ''
McCall's ''McCall's'' was a monthly United States, American women's magazine, published by the McCall Corporation, that enjoyed great popularity through much of the 20th century, peaking at a readership of 8.4 million in the early 1960s. The publication ...
,'' Kael (as ''
Newsweek ''Newsweek'' is an American weekly news magazine based in New York City. Founded as a weekly print magazine in 1933, it was widely distributed during the 20th century and has had many notable editors-in-chief. It is currently co-owned by Dev P ...
'' put it in a 1966 profile) "went mass". That same year, Kael wrote a blistering review of ''
The Sound of Music ''The Sound of Music'' is a musical with music by Richard Rodgers, lyrics by Oscar Hammerstein II, and a book by Howard Lindsay and Russel Crouse. It is based on the 1949 memoir of Maria von Trapp, '' The Story of the Trapp Family Singers''. ...
'' in ''McCall's''. After mentioning that some of the press had dubbed it "The Sound of Money", she called the film's message a "sugarcoated lie that people seem to want to eat". According to legend, this review got her fired from ''McCall's'' (''The New York Times'' said as much in Kael's obituary), but Kael and the magazine's editor, Robert Stein, denied this. According to Stein, he fired her "months later, after she kept panning every commercial movie from '' Lawrence of Arabia'' and '' Dr. Zhivago'' to '' The Pawnbroker'' and '' A Hard Day's Night''." Kael's dismissal from ''McCall's'' led to a stint from 1966 to 1967 at ''
The New Republic ''The New Republic'' (often abbreviated as ''TNR'') is an American magazine focused on domestic politics, news, culture, and the arts from a left-wing perspective. It publishes ten print magazines a year and a daily online platform. ''The New Y ...
'', whose editors continually altered her writing without her permission. In October 1967, Kael wrote a long essay on '' Bonnie and Clyde'' that the magazine declined to publish. William Shawn of ''
The New Yorker ''The New Yorker'' is an American magazine featuring journalism, commentary, criticism, essays, fiction, satire, cartoons, and poetry. It was founded on February 21, 1925, by Harold Ross and his wife Jane Grant, a reporter for ''The New York T ...
'' obtained the piece and ran it in ''The New Yorker'' issue of October 21. Kael's rave review was at odds with prevailing opinion, which was that the film was inconsistent in its blending of comedy and violence. According to critic David Thomson, "she was right about a film that had bewildered many other critics." A few months after the essay ran, Kael quit ''The New Republic'' "in despair". In 1968, Shawn asked her to join ''The New Yorker'' staff; she alternated as film critic every six months with Penelope Gilliatt until 1979, and became the sole critic in 1980 after a year's leave of absence working in the film industry.


''The New Yorker'' tenure

Initially, many considered Kael's colloquial, brash writing style an odd fit with the sophisticated and genteel ''New Yorker''. Kael remembered "getting a letter from an eminent ''The New Yorker'' writer suggesting that I was trampling through the pages of the magazine with cowboy boots covered with dung". During her tenure at ''The New Yorker'', she took advantage of a forum that permitted her to write at length—and with minimal editorial interference—thereby achieving her greatest prominence. By 1968, ''
Time Time is the continuous progression of existence that occurs in an apparently irreversible process, irreversible succession from the past, through the present, and into the future. It is a component quantity of various measurements used to sequ ...
'' magazine called her "one of the country's top movie critics". In 1970, Kael received a George Polk Award for her work as a critic at ''The New Yorker''. She continued to publish collections of her writing with suggestive titles such as '' Kiss Kiss Bang Bang'', '' When the Lights Go Down'', and '' Taking It All In''. Her fourth collection, '' Deeper into Movies'' (1973), won the U.S.
National Book Award The National Book Awards (NBA) are a set of annual U.S. literary awards. At the final National Book Awards Ceremony every November, the National Book Foundation presents the National Book Awards and two lifetime achievement awards to authors. ...
in the Arts and Letters category."National Book Awards – 1974"
National Book Foundation. Retrieved 2012-03-10. (With acceptance speech by Kael.)
"Arts and Letters" was an award category from 1964 to 1976.
It was the first nonfiction book about film to win a National Book Award. Kael also wrote philosophical essays on movie-going, the modern Hollywood film industry, and what she saw as the lack of courage on the part of audiences to explore lesser-known, more challenging movies (she rarely used the word "film" because she felt it was too elitist). Among her more popular essays were a damning 1973 review of
Norman Mailer Nachem Malech Mailer (January 31, 1923 – November 10, 2007), known by his pen name Norman Kingsley Mailer, was an American writer, journalist and filmmaker. In a career spanning more than six decades, Mailer had 11 best-selling books, at least ...
's semi-fictional ''Marilyn: a Biography'' (an account of
Marilyn Monroe Marilyn Monroe ( ; born Norma Jeane Mortenson; June 1, 1926 August 4, 1962) was an American actress and model. Known for playing comic "Blonde stereotype#Blonde bombshell, blonde bombshell" characters, she became one of the most popular sex ...
's life); an incisive 1975 look at Cary Grant's career; and " Raising Kane" (1971), a book-length essay on the authorship of the film ''
Citizen Kane ''Citizen Kane'' is a 1941 American Drama (film and television), drama film directed by, produced by and starring Orson Welles and co-written by Welles and Herman J. Mankiewicz. It was Welles's List of directorial debuts, first feature film. ...
'' that was the longest piece of sustained writing she had yet done. Commissioned as an introduction to the shooting script in ''The Citizen Kane Book'', "Raising Kane" was first printed in two consecutive issues of ''The New Yorker''. The essay extended Kael's dispute of the auteur theory, arguing that Herman J. Mankiewicz, the screenplay's coauthor, was virtually its sole author and the film's actual guiding force. Kael further alleged that
Orson Welles George Orson Welles (May 6, 1915 – October 10, 1985) was an American director, actor, writer, producer, and magician who is remembered for his innovative work in film, radio, and theatre. He is among the greatest and most influential film ...
had schemed to deprive Mankiewicz of screen credit. Welles considered suing Kael for
libel Defamation is a communication that injures a third party's reputation and causes a legally redressable injury. The precise legal definition of defamation varies from country to country. It is not necessarily restricted to making assertions ...
. He was defended by critics, scholars and friends, including Peter Bogdanovich, who rebutted Kael's claims in a 1972 article that included the revelation that Kael had appropriated the extensive research of a UCLA faculty member without crediting him.
Woody Allen Heywood Allen (born Allan Stewart Konigsberg; November 30, 1935) is an American filmmaker, actor, and comedian whose career spans more than six decades. Allen has received many List of awards and nominations received by Woody Allen, accolade ...
said of Kael: "She has everything that a great critic needs except judgment. And I don't mean that facetiously. She has great passion, terrific wit, wonderful writing style, huge knowledge of film history, but too often what she chooses to extol or fails to see is very surprising."''This is Orson Welles'', Introduction : My Orson, page xxiii–xv, Da Capo Press, 1998 Edition Kael battled the editors of the ''New Yorker'' as much as her own critics. She fought with Shawn to review the 1972 pornographic film '' Deep Throat'', eventually relenting. According to Kael, after reading her unfavorable review of Terrence Malick's 1973 film '' Badlands'', Shawn said, "I guess you didn't know that Terry is like a son to me." Kael responded, "Tough shit, Bill", and her review was printed unchanged. Other than sporadic confrontations with Shawn, Kael said she did most of her work at home, writing.Davis (2002). p. 40. Upon the release of Kael's 1980 collection '' When the Lights Go Down'', her ''New Yorker'' colleague Renata Adler published an 8,000-word review in ''
The New York Review of Books ''The New York Review of Books'' (or ''NYREV'' or ''NYRB'') is a semi-monthly magazine with articles on literature, culture, economics, science and current affairs. Published in New York City, it is inspired by the idea that the discussion of ...
'' that dismissed the book as "jarringly, piece by piece, line by line, and without interruption, worthless." Adler argued that Kael's post-1960s work contained "nothing certainly of intelligence or sensibility" and faulted her "quirks ndmannerisms", including repeated use of "bullying" imperatives and rhetorical questions. The piece quickly became infamous in literary circles, described by ''Time'' magazine as "the New York literary Mafia sbloodiest case of assault and battery in years." Kael did not respond to it, but Adler's review became known as "the most sensational attempt on Kael's reputation". In 1979, Kael accepted an offer from
Warren Beatty Henry Warren Beatty (né Beaty; born March 30, 1937) is an American actor and filmmaker. His career has spanned over six decades, and he has received an Academy Award and three Golden Globe Awards. He also received the Irving G. Thalberg Memor ...
to be a consultant to
Paramount Pictures Paramount Pictures Corporation, commonly known as Paramount Pictures or simply Paramount, is an American film production company, production and Distribution (marketing), distribution company and the flagship namesake subsidiary of Paramount ...
, but left the position after only a few months to return to writing criticism.


Later years

In the early 1980s, Kael was diagnosed with
Parkinson's disease Parkinson's disease (PD), or simply Parkinson's, is a neurodegenerative disease primarily of the central nervous system, affecting both motor system, motor and non-motor systems. Symptoms typically develop gradually and non-motor issues become ...
, which sometimes has a
cognitive Cognition is the "mental action or process of acquiring knowledge and understanding through thought, experience, and the senses". It encompasses all aspects of intellectual functions and processes such as: perception, attention, thought, ...
component. As her condition worsened, she became increasingly depressed about the state of American films, along with feeling that "I had nothing new to say". In a March 11, 1991, announcement that ''The New York Times'' called "earth-shattering", Kael announced her retirement from reviewing films regularly. She said she would still write essays for ''The New Yorker'' and "reflections and other pieces of writing about movies", but over the next 10 years, she published no new work except an introduction to her 1994 compendium ''For Keeps''. In the introduction (which was reprinted in ''The New Yorker''), Kael wrote: "I'm frequently asked why I don't write my memoirs. I think I have". Though she published nothing new, Kael was not averse to giving interviews, occasionally giving her opinion on new films and television shows. In a 1998 interview with '' Modern Maturity'', she said she sometimes regretted not being able to review: "A few years ago, when I saw '' Vanya on 42nd Street'', I wanted to blow trumpets. Your trumpets are gone once you've quit." She died at her home in
Great Barrington, Massachusetts Great Barrington is a New England town, town in Berkshire County, Massachusetts, United States. It is part of the Pittsfield, Massachusetts, Metropolitan Statistical Area. The population was 7,172 at the 2020 United States census, 2020 census. Bot ...
, on September 3, 2001, at the age of 82.


Style

Kael was known for mingling high and low culture; per ''
The New York Times ''The New York Times'' (''NYT'') is an American daily newspaper based in New York City. ''The New York Times'' covers domestic, national, and international news, and publishes opinion pieces, investigative reports, and reviews. As one of ...
'', "Kael could mingle references to literary lions like
Saul Bellow Saul Bellow (born Solomon Bellows; June 10, 1915April 5, 2005) was a Canadian-American writer. For his literary work, Bellow was awarded the Pulitzer Prize, the 1976 Nobel Prize in Literature, and the National Medal of Arts. He is the only write ...
, Jean Genet and
Norman Mailer Nachem Malech Mailer (January 31, 1923 – November 10, 2007), known by his pen name Norman Kingsley Mailer, was an American writer, journalist and filmmaker. In a career spanning more than six decades, Mailer had 11 best-selling books, at least ...
with demotic condemnations like loony, sleazo, junk and bummer." She often made allusions to other arts; reviewing '' Jules and Jim'', she wrote, "The film was adapted from Henri-Pierre Roché's autobiographical novel, written when he was seventy-four .. If some of us have heard of Roché, it is probably just the scrap of information that he was the man who introduced Gertrude Stein to Picasso—but this scrap shouldn't be discarded, because both Stein and Picasso are relevant to the characters and period of ''Jules and Jim''. Roché is now dead, but the model for Catherine, the Jeanne Moreau role, is a German literary woman who is still alive; it was she who translated ''
Lolita ''Lolita'' is a 1955 novel written by Russian-American novelist Vladimir Nabokov. The protagonist and narrator is a French literature professor who moves to New England and writes under the pseudonym Humbert Humbert. He details his obsession ...
'' into German." She writes that the two title characters are "
Mutt and Jeff ''Mutt and Jeff'' is a long-running and widely popular American newspaper comic strip created by cartoonist Bud Fisher in 1907 about "two mismatched wikt:tinhorn, tinhorns". It is commonly regarded as the first daily comic strip. The concept o ...
,
Sancho Panza Sancho Panza (; ) is a fictional character in the novel ''Don Quixote'' written by Spain, Spanish author Miguel de Cervantes, Miguel de Cervantes Saavedra in 1605. Sancho acts as squire to Don Quixote and provides comments throughout the novel, ...
and Don Quixote, devoted friends, contentedly arguing about life and letters." Richard Corliss contrasts Kael with
Andrew Sarris Andrew Sarris (October 31, 1928 – June 20, 2012) was an American film critic. He was a leading proponent of the auteur theory of film criticism. Early life Sarris was born in Brooklyn, New York, to Greek immigrant parents, Themis (née Kat ...
: "Sarris' prose was dense, balanced, aphoristic, alliterative; he had taken more from the French than just the ''politique des auteurs''. Kael's was loping, derisive, intimate, gag-packed, as American as Lenny Bruce. I can recall reading one of Kael's early pieces in Film Quarterly (1961, maybe) and being shocked—shocked!—to see she'd used a contraction. In those prim days, when most serious film criticism read like term papers in sociology and most popular reviews read like wire copy, Kael's writing was the battle cry of a vital and dangerous new era, the equivalent of
Little Richard Richard Wayne Penniman (December 5, 1932 – May 9, 2020), known professionally as Little Richard, was an American singer, pianist, and songwriter. He was an influential figure in popular music and culture for seven decades. Described as the "Ar ...
's primal 'A wop bop a loo bop, a wop bam boom!' that announced the birth of rock 'n' roll."


Opinions

Kael's opinions often ran contrary to her fellow critics'. Occasionally, she championed films considered critical failures, such as '' The Warriors'' and '' Last Tango in Paris''. She was not especially cruel to some films that many critics deplored—such as the 1972 '' Man of La Mancha'' (she praised Sophia Loren's performance). She panned some films that had widespread critical admiration, such as '' Network'', '' A Woman Under the Influence'' ("murky, ragmop"), '' The Loneliness of the Long Distance Runner'', most experimental cinema (calling it "a creature of publicity and mutual congratulations on artistry"), most student films ("freshmen compositions"), '' It's a Wonderful Life'', '' Shoah'' ("logy and exhausting"), '' Dances with Wolves'' ("a nature boy movie"), and '' 2001: A Space Odyssey'' ("monumentally unimaginative"). Her opinions' originality and the forceful way she expressed them won her ardent supporters and angry detractors. Kael's reviews included a pan of ''
West Side Story ''West Side Story'' is a Musical theatre, musical conceived by Jerome Robbins with music by Leonard Bernstein, lyrics by Stephen Sondheim, and a Book (musical theatre), book by Arthur Laurents. Inspired by William Shakespeare's play ''Romeo an ...
'' (1961) that drew harsh replies from its fans; ecstatic reviews of '' Z'' and '' MASH'' that enormously boosted their popularity; and enthusiastic appraisals of Brian De Palma's early films. Her "preview" of
Robert Altman Robert Bernard Altman ( ; February 20, 1925 – November 20, 2006) was an American film director, screenwriter, and film producer, producer. He is considered an enduring figure from the New Hollywood era, known for directing subversive and sat ...
's film ''
Nashville Nashville, often known as Music City, is the capital and List of municipalities in Tennessee, most populous city in the U.S. state of Tennessee. It is the county seat, seat of Davidson County, Tennessee, Davidson County in Middle Tennessee, locat ...
'' appeared in print several months before the film was completed, in an attempt to prevent the studio from recutting the film and to catapult it to box-office success. Kael was an opponent of the auteur theory, criticizing it both in her reviews and in interviews. She preferred to analyze films without thinking about the director's other works.
Andrew Sarris Andrew Sarris (October 31, 1928 – June 20, 2012) was an American film critic. He was a leading proponent of the auteur theory of film criticism. Early life Sarris was born in Brooklyn, New York, to Greek immigrant parents, Themis (née Kat ...
, a key proponent of the theory, debated it with Kael in the pages of ''
The New Yorker ''The New Yorker'' is an American magazine featuring journalism, commentary, criticism, essays, fiction, satire, cartoons, and poetry. It was founded on February 21, 1925, by Harold Ross and his wife Jane Grant, a reporter for ''The New York T ...
'' and various film magazines. Kael argued that a film should be considered a collaborative effort. In " Raising Kane", she argues that ''Citizen Kane'' relies extensively on the distinctive talents of Mankiewicz and cinematographer Gregg Toland.


Views on violence

Kael had a taste for antihero films that violate taboos involving sex and violence; this reportedly alienated some of her readers. But she panned '' Midnight Cowboy'' (1969), the X-rated antihero film that won an Oscar for Best Picture. She also strongly disliked films she felt were manipulative or appealed in superficial ways to conventional attitudes and feelings. She was particularly critical of
Clint Eastwood Clinton Eastwood Jr. (born May 31, 1930) is an American actor and film director. After achieving success in the Western (genre), Western TV series ''Rawhide (TV series), Rawhide'', Eastwood rose to international fame with his role as the "Ma ...
: her reviews of his films and acting were resoundingly unfavorable, and she became known as his nemesis. Kael was an enthusiastic, if occasionally ambivalent, supporter of Sam Peckinpah and
Walter Hill Walter Hill (born January 10, 1942) is an American film director, screenwriter and producer known for his action films and revival of the Western (genre), Western genre. He has directed such films as ''The Driver'', ''The Warriors (film), The ...
's early work, both of whom specialized in violent action dramas. Her collection ''5001 Nights at the Movies'' includes favorable reviews of nearly all of Peckinpah's films except '' The Getaway'' (1972), as well as Hill's '' Hard Times'' (1975), '' The Warriors'' (1979), and '' Southern Comfort'' (1981). Despite her initial dismissal of John Boorman's '' Point Blank'' (1967) for what she felt was its pointless brutality, she later called it "intermittently dazzling" with "more energy and invention than Boorman seems to know what to do with ... one comes out exhilarated but bewildered".Kael, Pauline. ''5001 Nights at the Movies'', Henry Holt and Company, 1991. But Kael reacted badly to some action films she felt pushed what she called "right-wing" or "fascist" agendas. She called Don Siegel's '' Dirty Harry'' (1971), starring Eastwood, a "right-wing fantasy", "a remarkably single-minded attack on liberal values", and "fascist medievalism".Kael, Pauline. ''Deeper into Movies,'' Warner Books, 1973. In an otherwise extremely favorable review of Peckinpah's '' Straw Dogs'', Kael concluded that Peckinpah had made "the first American film that is a fascist work of art". In her review of
Stanley Kubrick Stanley Kubrick (; July 26, 1928 – March 7, 1999) was an American filmmaker and photographer. Widely considered one of the greatest filmmakers of all time, Stanley Kubrick filmography, his films were nearly all adaptations of novels or sho ...
's '' A Clockwork Orange'' (1971), Kael wrote that she felt some directors who used brutal imagery were desensitizing audiences to violence:


Accusations of homophobia

In his preface to a 1983 interview with Kael for the gay magazine '' Mandate'', Sam Staggs wrote: "she has always carried on a love/hate affair with her gay legions. ... like the bitchiest queen in gay mythology, she has a sharp remark about everything". But in the early 1980s, largely in response to her review of the 1981 drama '' Rich and Famous,'' Kael faced notable accusations of
homophobia Homophobia encompasses a range of negative attitudes and feelings toward homosexuality or people who identify or are perceived as being lesbian, Gay men, gay or bisexual. It has been defined as contempt, prejudice, aversion, hatred, or ant ...
. First remarked upon by Stuart Byron in ''
The Village Voice ''The Village Voice'' is an American news and culture publication based in Greenwich Village, New York City, known for being the country's first Alternative newspaper, alternative newsweekly. Founded in 1955 by Dan Wolf (publisher), Dan Wolf, ...
'', according to gay writer Craig Seligman, the accusations eventually "took on a life of their own and did real damage to her reputation". In her review, Kael called the straight-themed ''Rich and Famous'' "more like a homosexual fantasy", saying that one female character's "affairs, with their masochistic overtones, are creepy, because they don't seem like what a woman would get into".Seligman (2004). p. 152. Byron, who "hit the ceiling" after reading the review, was joined by '' The Celluloid Closet'' author Vito Russo, who argued that Kael equated promiscuity with homosexuality, "as though straight women have never been promiscuous or been given the permission to be promiscuous". In response to her review of ''Rich and Famous'', several critics reappraised Kael's earlier reviews of gay-themed films, including a wisecrack Kael made about the gay-themed '' The Children's Hour'': "I always thought this was why lesbians needed sympathy—that there isn't much they ''can'' do." Seligman has defended Kael, saying that these remarks showed "enough ease with the topic to be able to crack jokes—in a dark period when other reviewers ... 'felt that if homosexuality were not a crime it would spread. Kael rejected the accusations as "craziness", adding, "I don't see how anybody who took the trouble to check out what I've actually written about movies with homosexual elements in them could believe that stuff."


Nixon quote

In December 1972, a month after U.S. President
Richard Nixon Richard Milhous Nixon (January 9, 1913April 22, 1994) was the 37th president of the United States, serving from 1969 until Resignation of Richard Nixon, his resignation in 1974. A member of the Republican Party (United States), Republican ...
was reelected in a landslide, Kael gave a lecture at the
Modern Language Association The Modern Language Association of America, often referred to as the Modern Language Association (MLA), is widely considered the principal professional association in the United States for scholars of language and literature. The MLA aims to "str ...
during which she said: "I live in a rather special world. I only know one person who voted for Nixon. Where they ixon's other supportersare I don't know. They're outside my ken. But sometimes when I'm in a theater I can feel them." A ''New York Times'' article about the lecture quoted this. Kael was subsequently misquoted as having said, "I can't believe Nixon won. I don't know anyone who voted for him" or something that similarly expressed surprise at the election result. This misquotation became an
urban legend Urban legend (sometimes modern legend, urban myth, or simply legend) is a genre of folklore concerning stories about an unusual (usually scary) or humorous event that many people believe to be true but largely are not. These legends can be e ...
, and has been cited by conservatives (such as Bernard Goldberg, in his 2001 book ''
Bias Bias is a disproportionate weight ''in favor of'' or ''against'' an idea or thing, usually in a way that is inaccurate, closed-minded, prejudicial, or unfair. Biases can be innate or learned. People may develop biases for or against an individ ...
'') as an example of insularity among the liberal elite. The misquotation has also been attributed to other writers, such as Joan Didion.


Influence

Owen Gleiberman said Kael "was more than a great critic. She reinvented the form, and pioneered an entire aesthetic of writing." As soon as she began writing for ''The New Yorker'', Kael greatly influenced her fellow critics. In the early 1970s, Cinerama distributors "initiate a policy of individual screenings for each critic because her remarks uring the filmwere affecting her fellow critics". In the 1970s and 1980s, Kael cultivated friendships with a group of young, mostly male critics, some of whom emulated her distinctive writing style. Referred to derisively as the "Paulettes", they dominated national film criticism in the 1990s. Critics who have acknowledged Kael's influence include, among many others, A. O. Scott of ''
The New York Times ''The New York Times'' (''NYT'') is an American daily newspaper based in New York City. ''The New York Times'' covers domestic, national, and international news, and publishes opinion pieces, investigative reports, and reviews. As one of ...
'', David Denby and Anthony Lane of ''The New Yorker'', David Edelstein of ''
New York Magazine ''New York'' is an American biweekly magazine concerned with life, culture, politics, and style generally, with a particular emphasis on New York City. Founded by Clay Felker and Milton Glaser in 1968 as a competitor to ''The New Yorker'' a ...
'', Greil Marcus, Elvis Mitchell, Michael Sragow, Armond White, and Stephanie Zacharek of ''
Salon Salon may refer to: Common meanings * Beauty salon A beauty salon or beauty parlor is an establishment that provides Cosmetics, cosmetic treatments for people. Other variations of this type of business include hair salons, spas, day spas, ...
''. It was repeatedly alleged that, after her retirement, Kael's "most ardent devotees deliberate with each other oforge a common School of Pauline position" before their reviews were written. When confronted by the rumor that she ran "a conspiratorial network of young critics", Kael said she believed that critics imitated her style rather than her opinions, saying, "A number of critics take phrases and attitudes from me, and those takings stick out—they're not integral to the writer's temperament or approach". Asked in 1998 whether she thought her criticism had affected the way films were made, Kael deflected the question, saying, "If I say yes, I'm an egotist, and if I say no, I've wasted my life". Several directors' careers were profoundly affected by her, most notably that of ''
Taxi Driver ''Taxi Driver'' is a 1976 American neo-noir psychological drama film directed by Martin Scorsese and written by Paul Schrader. Set in a morally decaying New York City following the Vietnam War, it stars Robert De Niro as veteran Marine and ...
'' screenwriter Paul Schrader, who was accepted at UCLA Film School's graduate program on Kael's recommendation. Under her mentorship, Schrader worked as a film critic before taking up screenwriting and directing full time.
Derek Malcolm Derek Elliston Michael Malcolm (12 May 1932 – 15 July 2023) was an English film critic and historian. Early life Derek Elliston Michael Malcolm was born on 12 May 1932. He was the son of Douglas Malcolm (died 1967) and Dorothy Vera (died 196 ...
, who worked for several decades as a film critic for ''
The Guardian ''The Guardian'' is a British daily newspaper. It was founded in Manchester in 1821 as ''The Manchester Guardian'' and changed its name in 1959, followed by a move to London. Along with its sister paper, ''The Guardian Weekly'', ''The Guardi ...
'', said: "If a director was praised by Kael, he or she was generally allowed to work, since the money-men knew there would be similar approbation across a wide field of publications". Alternately, Kael was said to have had the power to prevent filmmakers from working;
David Lean Sir David Lean (25 March 190816 April 1991) was an English film director, producer, screenwriter, and editor, widely considered one of the most important figures of Cinema of the United Kingdom, British cinema. He directed the large-scale epi ...
said that her criticism of his work "kept him from making a movie for 14 years" (referring to the 14-year break between '' Ryan's Daughter'' in 1970 and '' A Passage to India'' in 1984). In 1978, Kael received the Women in Film Crystal Award for outstanding women who, through their endurance and the excellence of their work, have helped to expand the role of women in the entertainment industry. In his 1988 film ''
Willow Willows, also called sallows and osiers, of the genus ''Salix'', comprise around 350 species (plus numerous hybrids) of typically deciduous trees and shrubs, found primarily on moist soils in cold and temperate regions. Most species are known ...
'', George Lucas named one of the villains "General Kael" after her. Kael had often reviewed Lucas's work unenthusiastically; in her review of ''Willow'', she called the character an "'' hommage à moi''". Though he began directing films after she retired,
Quentin Tarantino Quentin Jerome Tarantino (; born March 27, 1963) is an American filmmaker, actor, and author. Quentin Tarantino filmography, His films are characterized by graphic violence, extended dialogue often featuring much profanity, and references to ...
was also influenced by Kael. He read her criticism voraciously while growing up and said that Kael was "as influential as any director was in helping me develop my aesthetic".
Wes Anderson Wesley Wales Anderson (born May 1, 1969) is an American filmmaker. Wes Anderson filmography, His films are known for themes of grief, loss of innocence, and dysfunctional families. Due to his films' eccentricity, distinctive visual and narrative ...
recounted his efforts to screen his film '' Rushmore'' for Kael in a 1999 ''The New York Times'' article titled "My Private Screening With Pauline Kael". He later wrote to Kael, saying: " ur thoughts and writing about the movies avebeen a very important source of inspiration for me and my movies, and I hope you don't regret that". In 1997, cultural critic
Camille Paglia Camille Anna Paglia ( ; born April 2, 1947) is an American academic, social critic and Feminism, feminist. Paglia was a professor at the University of the Arts (Philadelphia), University of the Arts in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania from 1984 until ...
said Kael was her second-favorite critic (behind Parker Tyler), criticizing Kael's commentary on such films as '' La Dolce Vita'' and '' Last Year at Marienbad'' but also calling her "unfailingly perceptive .. ertart, lively, colloquial style I thought exactly right for a mass form like the movies." In January 2000, filmmaker
Michael Moore Michael Francis Moore is an American film director, producer, screenwriter, and author. Moore's work frequently addresses various Social issue, social, political, and economic topics. He first became publicly known for his award-winning debut ...
posted a recollection of Kael's response to his 1989 documentary film '' Roger & Me''. Moore wrote that Kael was incensed that she had to watch ''Roger & Me'' in a cinema after Moore refused to send her a tape for her to watch at home, and she resented ''Roger & Me'' winning Best Documentary at the 55th New York Film Critics Circle Awards. Moore said:
two weeks later, she wrote a nasty, mean review of my film in ''The New Yorker''. It was OK with me that she didn't like the film, and it didn't bother me that she didn't like the point I was making, or even how I was making it. What was so incredibly appalling and shocking is how she printed outright lies about my movie. I had never experienced such a brazen, bald-faced barrage of disinformation. She tried to rewrite history.... Her complete fabrication of the facts was so weird, so out there, so obviously made-up, that my first response was this must be a humor piece she had written.... But, of course, she wasn't writing comedy. She was a deadly serious historical revisionist.
Kael's career is discussed at length in the 2009 documentary '' For the Love of Movies'' by critics whose careers she helped shape, such as Owen Gleiberman and Elvis Mitchell, as well as by those who fought with her, such as
Andrew Sarris Andrew Sarris (October 31, 1928 – June 20, 2012) was an American film critic. He was a leading proponent of the auteur theory of film criticism. Early life Sarris was born in Brooklyn, New York, to Greek immigrant parents, Themis (née Kat ...
. The film also shows several of Kael's appearances on PBS, including one alongside
Woody Allen Heywood Allen (born Allan Stewart Konigsberg; November 30, 1935) is an American filmmaker, actor, and comedian whose career spans more than six decades. Allen has received many List of awards and nominations received by Woody Allen, accolade ...
. In 2011, Brian Kellow published a biography of Kael, ''A Life in the Dark''. In a 2024 interview, director
Ridley Scott Sir Ridley Scott (born 30 November 1937) is an English film director and producer. He directs films in the Science fiction film, science fiction, Crime film, crime, and historical drama, historical epic genres, with an atmospheric and highly co ...
said that Kael's harsh critique of his 1982 film '' Blade Runner'' made him question the value of such reviews, and that he never read reviews of his films after that. The Pauline Kael Breakout Award for outstanding contribution to cinema is awarded annually by the Florida Film Critics Circle. Rob Garver's documentary '' What She Said: The Art of Pauline Kael'' was released in 2018. With Sarah Jessica Parker narrating for Kael, the film is a portrait of Kael's work and her influence on the male-dominated worlds of cinema and film criticism. David Thomson wrote of Kael: "How good was she? Very, very good, because she was a terrific journalist who took immense pains to seem spontaneous, who believed that it ought to be possible to write about entertainments in ways that made them more stimulating for thousands of people ... she established for a while something that had not been true since the impact of television—that the movies were ours, that they spoke to and for a society and were the most telling, deeply felt impression of who we were and might be ... as time passes, I suspect she will seem more remarkable, more useful as a measure of her time, and more sexy. I suspect she would have given it all up if she could have had one scene in one film—like Dorothy Malone with Bogart in ''The Big Sleep''.


Awards

* 1964: John Simon Guggenheim Memorial Foundation Fellowship * 1970: George Polk Award, Criticism * 1974:
National Book Award The National Book Awards (NBA) are a set of annual U.S. literary awards. At the final National Book Awards Ceremony every November, the National Book Foundation presents the National Book Awards and two lifetime achievement awards to authors. ...
, Arts and Letters, for '' Deeper into Movies'' * 1978: Crystal Award, Women in Film Crystal Awards * 1980: Muse Award, New York Women in Film & Television * 1991: Mel Novikoff Award,
San Francisco International Film Festival The San Francisco International Film Festival (abbreviated as SFIFF), organized by SFFILM, is held each spring for two weeks, presenting around 200 films from over 50 countries. The festival highlights current trends in international film and vid ...
* 1994: Special Award,
Los Angeles Film Critics Association The Los Angeles Film Critics Association (LAFCA) is an American film critic organization founded in 1975. Background Its membership comprises film critics from Los Angeles–based print and electronic media. In December of each year, the organi ...
Awards * 1995: Writer Award, Gotham Independent Film Awards * 2012: Posthumous induction into the ''Online Film & Television Association'' Film Hall of Fame, Behind the Scenes, Film Criticism


Bibliography


Books

* '' I Lost It at the Movies'' (1965) * '' Kiss Kiss Bang Bang'' (1968) * '' Going Steady'' (1969) * ''The Citizen Kane Book'' (1971) * '' Deeper into Movies'' (1973) * '' Reeling'' (1976) * '' When the Lights Go Down'' (1980) * '' 5001 Nights at the Movies'' (1982, revised in 1984 and 1991) * '' Taking It All In'' (1984) * '' State of the Art'' (1985) * '' Hooked'' (1989) * '' Movie Love'' (1991) * ''For Keeps'' (1994) * ''Raising Kane, and other essays'' (1996)


Reviews and essays


"Trash, Art, and the Movies"
essay published in the Feb. 1969 issue of '' Harper's'' * " Raising Kane", book-length essay on the making of ''
Citizen Kane ''Citizen Kane'' is a 1941 American Drama (film and television), drama film directed by, produced by and starring Orson Welles and co-written by Welles and Herman J. Mankiewicz. It was Welles's List of directorial debuts, first feature film. ...
'' published in the February 20, 1971 and February 27, 1971 issues of ''The New Yorker''
"Stanley Strangelove"
review of '' A Clockwork Orange'' from a January 1972 issue of ''The New Yorker''
"The Man From Dream City"
profile of Cary Grant from the July 14, 1975 issue of ''The New Yorker'' * * Reviews '' Mrs. Soffel'', directed by
Gillian Armstrong Gillian May Armstrong (born 18 December 1950) is an Australian feature film and documentary film director, director, best known for ''My Brilliant Career (film), My Brilliant Career'' (1979), ''Mrs. Soffel'' (1984), ''High Tide (1987 film), Hi ...
, and '' The Cotton Club'', directed by
Francis Ford Coppola Francis Ford Coppola ( ; born April 7, 1939) is an American filmmaker. He is considered one of the leading figures of the New Hollywood and one of the greatest filmmakers of all time. List of awards and nominations received by Francis Ford Coppo ...
* Reviews '' A Passage to India'', directed by
David Lean Sir David Lean (25 March 190816 April 1991) was an English film director, producer, screenwriter, and editor, widely considered one of the most important figures of Cinema of the United Kingdom, British cinema. He directed the large-scale epi ...
* Reviews '' Micki and Maude'', directed by
Blake Edwards Blake Edwards (born William Blake Crump; July 26, 1922 – December 15, 2010) was an American film director, producer and screenwriter. Edwards began his career in the 1940s as an actor, but he soon began writing screenplays and radio scripts ...
; '' Starman'', directed by
John Carpenter John Howard Carpenter (born January 16, 1948) is an American filmmaker, composer, and actor. Most commonly associated with horror film, horror, action film, action, and science fiction film, science fiction films of the 1970s and 1980s, he is ...
; '' The Flamingo Kid'', directed by Garry Marshall


See also

* Women in film *
Andrew Sarris Andrew Sarris (October 31, 1928 – June 20, 2012) was an American film critic. He was a leading proponent of the auteur theory of film criticism. Early life Sarris was born in Brooklyn, New York, to Greek immigrant parents, Themis (née Kat ...
* Auteur theory *
Film criticism Film criticism is the analysis and evaluation of films and the film medium. In general, film criticism can be divided into two categories: Academic criticism by film studies, film scholars, who study the composition of film theory and publish ...
* ''
The New Yorker ''The New Yorker'' is an American magazine featuring journalism, commentary, criticism, essays, fiction, satire, cartoons, and poetry. It was founded on February 21, 1925, by Harold Ross and his wife Jane Grant, a reporter for ''The New York T ...
'' *
Susan Sontag Susan Lee Sontag (; January 16, 1933 – December 28, 2004) was an American writer, critic, and public intellectual. She mostly wrote essays, but also published novels; she published her first major work, the essay "Notes on "Camp", Notes on 'Ca ...


References


Works cited

* Brantley, Will, ed. (1996). ''Conversations with Pauline Kael''. University Press of Mississippi. . * * *


Further reading

* *


External links

* * * * * * *
What She Said: The Art of Pauline Kael
' on
IMDb IMDb, historically known as the Internet Movie Database, is an online database of information related to films, television series, podcasts, home videos, video games, and streaming content online – including cast, production crew and biograp ...

''What She Said: The Art of Pauline Kael'' official site
* {{DEFAULTSORT:Kael, Pauline 1919 births 2001 deaths 20th-century American Jews 20th-century American journalists 20th-century American musicians 20th-century American non-fiction writers 20th-century American women writers American film critics American people of Polish-Jewish descent American women critics American women film critics American women non-fiction writers Deaths from Parkinson's disease in Massachusetts Jewish American journalists Jewish American musicians Jewish American non-fiction writers Jewish women writers Journalists from the San Francisco Bay Area National Book Award winners National Society of Film Critics Members The New Yorker critics People from Great Barrington, Massachusetts People from Petaluma, California UC Berkeley College of Letters and Science alumni Writers from the San Francisco Bay Area