Paradise Lost (DS9)

"Paradise Lost" is the 84th episode of the television series '' Star Trek: Deep Space Nine'', the 12th episode of the fourth season. It is the second part of a two-part episode, following on from the preceding episode, " Homefront."

Set in the 24th century, the series follows the adventures of the crew of the fictional space station Deep Space Nine, managed by the United Federation of Planets, which lies adjacent to a wormhole connecting the Alpha and Gamma Quadrants of the galaxy. The Gamma Quadrant is home to the Dominion, a hostile empire ruled by the shape-shifting Changelings. In "Homefront", Deep Space Nine's captain Benjamin Sisko is brought to Earth to assist Admiral Leyton with planetary security after a terrorist attack on the planet is apparently perpetrated by Changelings; while there, he visits his father, who runs a restaurant in New Orleans. In this episode, Sisko uncovers Leyton's attempt at a coup d'état to seize power for Starfleet, the Federation's military.

Plot

Earth has been placed under martial law due to a seemingly imminent Dominion invasion, but Sisko believes that there is more going on than meets the eye. With the aid of Deep Space Nine's security officer Odo, and Cadet Nog's connections with an elite and selective group of cadets at Starfleet Academy, Sisko gathers evidence that Admiral Leyton is planning a coup d'état. He takes the information to the Federation's president, Jaresh-Inyo; however, Jaresh-Inyo is hesitant to act in the absence of concrete evidence.

Sisko is confronted by a Changeling in the guise of Miles O'Brien, a DS9 crew member. He tells Sisko there are actually only a total of four Changelings on Earth, and mockingly points out to Sisko how much panic they have caused, drastically out of proportion to their actual numbers.

Sisko contacts Major Kira, second in command on DS9, to uncover the evidence Jaresh-Inyo needs: a Starfleet officer on DS9, Lieutenant Arriaga, has been manipulating the wormhole at Leyton's behest to create the impression that a cloaked Dominion fleet is en route to Earth. Before he can present the evidence to Jaresh-Inyo, Leyton has Sisko framed as being a Changeling and imprisoned. Odo breaks Sisko out of prison.

The crew of DS9 is en route to Earth on the USS '' Defiant'', bringing Arriaga to confess to the conspiracy. In order to prevent Arriaga's evidence from reaching Earth, Leyton orders the USS ''Lakota'' to intercept, telling the crew that the ''Defiant'' is crewed by Changelings. When the ''Lakota'' fires on the ''Defiant'', Lt. Cmdr. Worf, in command of the ''Defiant'', has no choice but to return fire. Outmatched by the ''Defiant's'' superior armor and firepower, the ''Lakota'' is on the brink of destruction when Leyton orders them to destroy the ''Defiant''. As Sisko confronts Leyton with a phaser, the captain of the ''Lakota'', Captain Benteen, refuses orders to destroy the ''Defiant'' and stands down, allowing the ''Defiant'' on its way. With his conspiracy falling apart, Leyton resigns, and the state of emergency is lifted.

Reception

In 2016, ''The Hollywood Reporter'' rated the two-part episode consisting of "Homefront" and "Paradise Lost" as the 22nd best episode of ''Star Trek'' overall, praising how the episode "quietly drives home the scale of the danger facing humanity" and the casting of Brock Peters as Joseph Sisko.

In 2014, Keith R.A. DeCandido reviewed the episode for ''Tor.com'', giving it a rating of six out of ten. He noted the episode's exploration of situational ethics, and the two-parter's similarity to the film ''Seven Days in May''.

In 2018, CBR rated "Homefront" and "Paradise Lost" as the 16th best multi-episode story in the ''Star Trek'' franchise.

In 2020, io9 listed this and "Homefront" as "must-watch" episodes of the series, describing the plot as a "dark, moral dilemma".

Cultural references

As Captain Sisko reads out the names of officers transferred by Leyton, he lists the names Daneeka, McWatt, Snowden, Orr and Moodus. Each of these is the name of a character in the Joseph Heller novel ''Catch-22'': Doc Daneeka, McWatt (a pilot), Snowden (a radio-gunner), Orr and Colonel Moodus.

Capt. Benteen, the commander of the USS Lakota, shares a name with Frederick Benteen. Frederick Benteen was commander of a battalion of US Cavalry soldiers at the Battle of Little Bighorn, against the Lakota Sioux. He and his battalion survived because he did not rush to battle with George Armstrong Custer.

References

External links

*
*
*

{{Star Trek: Deep Space Nine episodes, 4

1996 American television episodes
Star Trek: Deep Space Nine season 4 episodes
Television episodes written by Ira Steven Behr
Television episodes written by Ronald D. Moore
Star Trek: Deep Space Nine episodes in multiple parts
Television episodes about impersonation
Television episodes set in New Orleans
Television episodes set in San Francisco
Television episodes directed by Reza Badiyi