Panthera Spelaea

''Panthera spelaea'', commonly known as the cave lion (or less commonly as the steppe lion), is an extinct ''Panthera'' species that was native to Eurasia and northwest North America during the Pleistocene epoch. Genetic analysis of ancient DNA has revealed that while closely related, it was a distinct species genetically isolated from the modern lion (''Panthera leo''), with the genetic divergence between the two species estimated at around 500,000 years ago.

The earliest fossils of the ''P. spelaea'' lineage (either regarded as the separate species ''Panthera fossilis'' or the subspecies ''P. spelaea fossilis'') in Eurasia date to around 700,000 years ago (with possible late Early Pleistocene records). It is closely related and probably ancestral to the American lion (''Panthera atrox''). The species ranged from Western Europe to eastern Beringia in North America, and was a prominent member of the mammoth steppe fauna, and an important apex predator across its range along with other large carnivores like cave hyenas, which cave lions came into conflict with.

It closely resembled living lions with a coat of yellowish-grey fur though unlike extant lions, males appear to have lacked manes. Whether or not cave lions lived in social groups like living lions is uncertain, but they are frequently suggested to have been largely solitary, similar to living tigers.

''Panthera spelaea'' interacted with both Neanderthals and modern humans, who used their pelts and in the case of the latter, depicted them in artistic works.

Cave lions became extinct about 13,000 years ago, the precise cause of which is unknown, though climatic change, changes in prey abundance, and competition with other carnivores and humans have been suggested as possible causal factors.

Research history and taxonomy

In 1774, the Zoolithenhöhle cave near the village of Burggaillenreuth in Bavaria, southern Germany was brought to scientific attention by Johan Friedrich Esper, who realised that the bones of extinct animals were present in the cave. In 1810, a fossil skull from the cave was given the scientific name ''Felis spelaea'' by Georg August Goldfuss. It possibly dates to the Last Glacial Period.

Several anatomical studies of remains of ''Panthera spelaea'' were conducted during the early-mid 19th century, who found the morphology of the species most similar to lions, tigers and jaguars. A monograph by W. Dawkins and W. Sandford studying ''P. spelaea'' published in 1868 found that it had closest affinities with the modern lion. At the end of the 19th century, the earliest remains of ''P. spelaea'' from Siberia were reported by M. Tschersky, who mistook them for those of a tiger. During the 20th century and the first decade of the 21st century, ''Panthera spelaea'' was often regarded as a subspecies of the modern lion, and therefore as ''Panthera leo spelaea''. However, other authors considered the cave lion to be more closely related to the tiger, based in part on a comparison of skull shapes, with some proposing that it should be considered a subspecies of the tiger as ''Panthera tigris spelaea''. Analysis of cave lion mitochondrial genomes published in 2004 supported the modern lion as the closest relative of ''P. spelaea,'' with this result being later confirmed by analysis of the nuclear genome. Results from morphological studies showed that it is distinct in cranial and dental anatomy to justify the specific status of ''Panthera spelaea''. Results of genetic studies also support this assessment.

In 2001, the subspecies ''Panthera spelaea vereshchagini'' was proposed for seven specimens found in Siberia and Yukon, which have smaller skulls and teeth than the average ''P. spelaea''. Before 2020, genetic analysis using ancient DNA provided no evidence for their distinct subspecific status; DNA signatures from ''P. spelaea'' from Europe and Alaska were indistinguishable, suggesting one large panmictic population. However, analysis of mitochondrial genome sequences from 31 cave lions showed that they fall into two monophyletic clades. One lived across western Europe and the other was restricted to Beringia during the Pleistocene. For this reason, the Beringian population is considered a distinct subspecies, ''P. s. vereshchagini''.

Evolution

Lion-like pantherine felids first appeared in the Tanzanian Olduvai Gorge about . These cats dispersed into Eurasia from East Africa around the end of the Early Pleistocene and the beginning of the Middle Pleistocene, giving rise to ''Panthera fossilis.'' The oldest widely accepted fossils of ''P. fossilis'' in Europe date to around 700,000-600,000 years ago, such as that from Pakefield in England, with possible older fossils from Western Siberia dating to the late Early Pleistocene, with a 2024 study suggesting a presence in Spain by 1 million years ago during the latest Early Pleistocene around the same age as the Siberian specimen. Different authors considered ''Panthera fossils'' as either a distinct species ancestral to ''P. spelaea'', or as a subspecies of ''P. spelaea''. Recent nuclear genomic evidence suggest that interbreeding between modern lions and all Eurasian fossil lions took place up until 500,000 years ago, but by 470,000 years ago, no subsequent interbreeding between the two lineages occurred.

The following cladogram shows the genetic relationship between ''P. spelaea'' and other pantherine cats.The arrival of ''Panthera (spelaea) fossilis'' in Europe was part of a faunal turnover event around the Early-Middle Pleistocene transition in which many of the species that characterised the preceding late Villafranchian became extinct. In the carnivore guild, this notably included the giant hyena '' Pachycrocuta'' and the sabertooth cat '' Megantereon''. Following the arrival of ''Panthera (spelaea) fossilis'' the lion-sized sabertooth cat ''Homotherium'' and the "European jaguar" '' Panthera gombaszoegensis'' became much rarer, ultimately becoming extinct in Europe during the late Middle Pleistocene, with competition with lions suggested to be a likely important factor.

Specimens intermediate between ''P. fossilis'' and Late Pleistocene ''P. spelaea'' are referred to as the subspecies ''P. s. intermedia''. The transition from ''P. fossilis'' to Late Pleistocene ''P. spelaea'' shows significant reduction in body size, as well as changes in skull and tooth morphology. Mitochondrial DNA sequence data from fossil lion remains show that the American lion represents a sister group of Late Pleistocene ''P. spelaea'', and likely arose when an early ''P. spelaea'' population became isolated south of the Cordilleran Ice Sheet. Initially this was suggested to be around 340,000 years ago, but later studies suggested that the split between the two species was probably younger, around 165,000 years ago, consistent with the late first appearance of ''P. spelaea'' in Eastern Beringia (now Alaska and adjacent regions) during the Illinoian (around 190-130,000 years ago).

Characteristics

Carvings and cave paintings of cave lions, which were discovered in the Lascaux and Chauvet Caves in France, were dated to 15,000 to 17,000 years old. A drawing in the Chauvet cave depicts two cave lions walking together. The one in the foreground is slightly smaller than the one in the background, which has been drawn with a scrotum and without a mane. Such cave paintings suggest that male cave lions completely lacked manes, or at most had very small manes.

Early members of the cave lion lineage assigned to ''Panthera'' (''spelaea'') ''fossilis'' during the Middle Pleistocene were considerably larger than individuals of ''P. spelaea'' from the Last Glacial Period and modern lions, with some of these individuals having an estimated length of , shoulder height of and body mass of , respectively, making them among the largest cats to have ever lived. The Late Pleistocene ''Panthera spelaea spelaea'' was noticeably smaller though still large relative to living cats, with an estimated length of and shoulder height of , respectively, The species showed a progressive size reduction over the course of the Last Glacial Period up until its extinction, with the last ''P. spelaea'' populations comparable in size to small-sized modern lions, with a body mass of only , a body length of and shoulder height of respectively.

''P. spelaea'' had a relatively longer and narrower muzzle compared to that of the extant lion, with the zygomatic region being strongly arched, with the carnassial teeth having differences in cusp morphology (displaying preparastyles). Like modern lions, females were smaller than males. Compared to the earlier ''P.'' (''spelaea'') ''fossilis'', Late Pleistocene ''P. spelaea spelaea'' differs (in addition to previously mentioned size differences) in having larger incisor teeth, more narrow and flattened canines, as well narrower upper and lower third and fourth premolars, which display some differences in cusp morphology, with the lower first molar being narrower and more elongate. The orbits (eye sockets) of ''P. spelaea spelaea'' are also relatively larger and muzzle marginally narrower compared to ''P.'' (''spelaea'') ''fossilis,'' with the nasal region also being proportionally narrower, while the postorbital and mastoid regions of the skull are wider, with the tympanic bullae being more inflated.

In 2016, hair found near the Maly Anyuy River was identified as cave lion hair through DNA analysis. Comparison with hair of a modern lion revealed that cave lion hair was probably similar in colour as that of the modern lion, though slightly lighter. In addition, the cave lion is thought to have had a very thick and dense undercoat comprising closed and compressed yellowish-to-white wavy downy hair with a smaller mass of darker-coloured guard hairs, possibly an adaptation to the Ice Age climate. While juveniles fur coat colour was yellowish, adult cave lions are suggested to have had grey fur.

Distribution and habitat

During the Last Glacial Period, ''P. spelaea'' formed a contiguous population across the mammoth steppe, from Western Europe to northwest North America. It was widely distributed in the Iberian Peninsula, Italian Peninsula, Southeast Europe, Great Britain, Central Europe, the East European Plain, the Ural Mountains, most of Northeast Asia (ranging as far south as Northeast China and possibly the Korean peninsula), and across the Bering land bridge into Alaska and Yukon. The cave lion had a wide elevation range, with finds extending up over above sea level in the European Alps and in Buryatia in Northern Asia, though they probably did not occupy mountainous habitats all-year round.

The cave lion probably inhabited predominantly open habitats such as steppe and grasslands although it would have also have occurred in open woodlands as well. While during the Last Glacial Period it was often associated with cold environments, the species also inhabited temperate environments, such as in Europe during the Last Interglacial/Eemian.

Paleobiology

Ecology

''P. spelaea'' was one of the keystone species of the mammoth steppe, being one of the main apex predators alongside the gray wolf, cave hyena and brown bear. Large amounts of bones belonging to ''P. spelaea'' were excavated in caves, where bones of cave hyena, cave bear and Paleolithic artefacts were also found. Despite their common name, "cave lions" probably only infrequently if ever used caves, and were present in regions where caves were absent.Diedrich, C.G. & ŽÁK, K. 2006
Prey deposits and den sites of the Upper Pleistocene hyena Crocuta crocuta spelaea (Goldfuss, 1823) in horizontal and vertical caves of the Bohemian Karst (Czech Republic)
''Bulletin of Geosciences'' 81(4), 237–276 (25 figures). Czech Geological Survey, Prague. ISSN 1214-1119. Some of these accumulations of cave lion bones in cave hyena dens have been attributed to confrontations between cave hyenas and cave lions over carcasses, with the remains of cave lions killed in these confrontations subsequently transported to the dens.

Isotopic analyses of bone collagen samples extracted from remains in Europe and East Beringia indicate that reindeer were particularly prominent in the diet of cave lions in these regions during the Last Glacial Period. Cave lions also seem to have opportunistically preyed on the cubs of cave bears, with adult cave bears also likely being targeted at least on occasion. Isotopic analysis of other European specimens suggests a diet including wild horse, woolly mammoth and cave bears for these individuals. It may have sought out hibernating bears in montane caves as a food source during the winter. Bite marks found on the bones of straight-tusked elephants in Neumark Nord, Germany, dating to the Last Interglacial, have been suggested to be the result of scavenging by cave lions.

Other possible prey species were giant deer, red deer, muskox, aurochs, wisent, steppe bison, and young woolly rhinoceros. It likely competed for prey with the European leopards, cave hyenas, brown bears and grey wolves in Eurasia, along with short-faced bears, the sabertooth cat ''Homotherium'', and Beringian wolves in Beringia.

Social behavior

Whether or not cave lions were gregarious like modern lions is unclear. Sabol and Puzachenko in their 2024 paper stated that the cave lions are "generally thought" to have been solitary, but that "opinions on this vary" and that the question remained open. Some experts, such as Guthrie argue that the cave lion lived solitarily or only in small family groups, based primarily on the lack of manes (which are highly important to the social hierarchy of modern lions) depicted on Paleolithic cave art. This argument was criticized by Yamaguichi and colleagues, they argued that the emergence of group living in lions probably predates the split between cave lions and modern lions and the evolution of manes in modern lions. On the other hand, authors argued gregariousness via sexual dimorphism. Sexual dimorphism within canine dimensions suggests cave lions had similar sexual dimorphism to lions, and in evolutionary context may suggests they lived in groups according to Yamaguichi and colleagues. Boeskorov and their colleagues suggested that the more extreme sexual dimorphism seen in cave lions could suggest that they lived in larger prides. However they admitted that there isn’t enough evidence to conclude on their social structure. On the contrary, Valkenburgh and Sacco warned that sexual dimorphism isn’t a reliable way to determine group behavior, as leopards are also very sexually dimorphic in canine dimensions but live a solitary lifestyle.

Isotopic analysis on cave lions by Hervé Bocherens and colleagues lead them to suggest that cave lions may have been solitary, due to cave lions shifting their diets after the disappearance of cave hyenas, carcasses being consumed the cave hyenas as well, suggests they were at a competitive disadvantage, and the scattering of isotopic data between individuals. Within mountain ranges and higher altitude environments, cave lions may have also been solitary or hunt in mating pairs, much like today’s lions. Lions tend to hunt in prides in altitudes below 1,500 meters, but within higher altitudes, they tend to be solitary or hunt in mating pairs. This proposed behavior for cave lions is further supported by the ratios of males and females from Moravian Karst being 1:1.

Cave lion cubs appear to have lived in dens during their earliest stages of life, like modern lion cubs and were likely solely raised by females, like living ''Panthera'' species.

Relationship with humans

Cave lions were hunted and their pelts exploited in Europe by Neanderthals during the Middle Paleolithic, and during the Upper Paleolithic by modern humans in Spain as evidenced in the La Garma site dating to the Magdalenian. Modern humans also drew cave paintings of cave lions, engraved their likeness on bones and created sculptures of them, including the famous anthropomorphic lion-man (''Löwenmensch)'' figure from Hohlenstein-Stadel cave in Germany dating to around 41-35,000 years ago with the body of a human and the head of a lion. Cave lion canines with perforated holes may have been worn as personal ornaments. Decorated stones with engravings representing cave lions have been found in southern Italy.

Extinction

Radiocarbon dating suggests that the species went extinct approximately simultaneously across its range during the last few thousand years of the Late Pleistocene, around 14-15,000 years ago, possibly surviving around 1000 years later in the far east North American portion of its range. This timing roughly corresponds to the onset of the Bølling–Allerød Interstadial warm period and the consequent collapse of the mammoth steppe ecosystem. The precise cause of its extinction is unclear, but possibly involved environmental change from open habitats to closed forests, changes in prey abundance, as well as human impact, though it is difficult to distentangle the precise causes of its extinction. Competition with wolves may have been an important factor in its extinction. Cave lions appear to have undergone a population bottleneck that considerably reduced their genetic diversity between 47,000 and 18,000 years ago, probably driven at least in part by climatic instability.

Mummified specimens

In 2008, a well-preserved mature cave lion specimen was unearthed near the Maly Anyuy River in Chukotka Autonomous Okrug, which still retained some clumps of hair.
In 2015, two frozen cave lion cubs, estimated to be between 25,000 and 55,000 years old, were discovered close to the Uyandina River in Yakutia, Siberia in permafrost.
Research results indicate that the cubs were likely barely a week old at the time of their deaths, as their milk teeth had not fully erupted. Further evidence suggests the cubs were hidden at a den site until they were strong enough to follow their mother back to the pride, as with modern lions. Researchers believe that the cubs were trapped and killed by a landslide, and that the absence of oxygen underground hindered their decomposition and allowed the cubs to be preserved in such good condition. A second expedition to the site where the cubs were found was planned for 2016, in hopes of finding either the remains of a third cub or possibly the cubs' mother.

In 2017, another frozen specimen, thought to be a lion cub, was found in Yakutia on the banks of the Tirekhtyakh River (), a tributary of the Indigirka River. This male cub was thought to be slightly older than the 2015 cubs at the time of its death; it is estimated to have been around one and a half to two months. In 2018, another preserved carcass of a cub was found in a location away. It was considered to be around a month old when it died approximately 50,000 years ago, and presumed to be a sibling of the male cub. However, carbon dating showed them to have lived about 15,000 years apart, with the female estimated to have lived 28,000 years ago, and the male 43,448 years ago. Both cubs were well preserved, albeit with a few damages, with the female possibly being the "best preserved" animal discovered from the Ice age.

Notes

See also

* History of lions in Europe
*Megafauna
*'' Panthera atrox''
*'' Panthera blytheae''
*'' Panthera gombaszoegensis''
*'' Panthera palaeosinensis''
*'' Panthera shawi''
*'' Panthera youngi''
*'' Panthera zdanskyi''
*'' Panthera leo sinhaleyus''
*'' Panthera leo fossilis''

References

External links

Prehistoric cats and prehistoric cat-like creatures
from the Messybeast Cat Resource Archive


volume 5, chapter 1, by Hans Krause.


, from the Dinosaur Mailing List. (Groiss)

Photo-reconstruction of Panthera spelaea
by paleoartis
Roman Uchytel

{{Authority control

spelaea
spelaea
Pleistocene carnivorans
Pleistocene extinctions
Pleistocene mammals of Asia
Pleistocene mammals of Europe
Pleistocene mammals of North America
Fossil taxa described in 1810
Taxa named by Georg August Goldfuss
Apex predators
Species that are or were threatened by climate change
History of lions in Europe