Composition
Individual books
Scholars usually assume that there exists an original core of prophetic tradition behind each book which can be attributed to the figure after whom it is named. In general, each book includes three types of material: * Autobiographical material in the first person, some of which may go back to the prophet in question; * Biographical materials about the prophet in the third person – which incidentally demonstrate that the collection and editing of the books was completed by persons other than the prophets themselves; * Oracles or speeches by the prophets, usually in poetic form, and drawing on a wide variety of genres, including covenant lawsuit, oracles against the nations, judgment oracles, messenger speeches, songs, hymns, narrative, lament, law, proverb, symbolic gesture, prayer, wisdom saying, and vision. The noteworthy exception is theAs a collection
It is not known when these short works were collected and transferred to a single scroll, but the first extra-biblical evidence for the Twelve as a collection is c. 190 BCE in the writings of Yeshua ben Sirach, and evidence from theSequence of books
Academic debates
In the 21st century, “claims for Persian period influence or origins have ballooned.” The recent Oxford Handbook of the Minor Prophets Jason Radine summarizes the ongoing “Persian Turn” in Minor Prophets scholarship. It refers to a scholarly trend towards dating much of the biblical composition and editing of the Minor Prophets to the Persian period (539–323 BCE). This trend is rooted in earlier scholarly theories, such as the Graf-Wellhausen Hypothesis, which suggested that elements of the Pentateuch, particularly the “Priestly” writings, originated during the Persian era. Additionally, Spinoza’s 17th-century argument that Ezra authored large portions of the Hebrew Bible influenced this perspective. This trend has gained momentum as a growing number of scholars now posit that many prophetic books, once assumed to date from earlier periods, were likely finalized or significantly edited during the Persian period. Researchers like Reinhard Kratz distinguish between the original oracles of ancient Near Eastern prophets and the later literary works attributed to them, which reflect the scribal efforts of later editors. This theory has been opposed by other scholars, however. For instance, Heath Dewrell argues that many literary features of the Book of Hosea are also attested in Neo-Assyrian prophecies. Since these prophetic texts were written close to the time of Hosea and were not substantially edited centuries after their authors' time, Dewrell finds no reason to think that the biblical book underwent any major editing either. While dating texts from the Persian period is appropriate for books like Haggai and Zechariah, which explicitly mention that era, scholars caution against oversimplifying the dating process. Radine argues that categorizing too much biblical material as Persian-era production risks obscuring the complex, long-term development of biblical literature. In particular, the diversity of themes, literary styles, and theological perspectives in the Minor Prophets suggests that their formation spanned a much longer period than the Persian era alone. The scholar Ehud Ben Zvi suggests that much of the biblical material from the Persian period was produced within the relatively small and interconnected community of Jerusalem, where scribes were likely aware of each other’s works. Ben Zvi, Ehud. 2009. “The Concept of Prophetic Books and Its Historical Setting.” In The Production of Prophecy: Constructing Prophecy and Prophets in Yehud, edited by Diana V. Edelman and Ehud Ben Zvi, 73–95. London: Equinox. This view emphasizes the importance of understanding how these texts were shaped within their historical and cultural contexts. However, Radine argues that this approach risks overlooking earlier material that predated the Persian period but was later edited or integrated into these texts.Christian commemoration
In theSee also
* Biblical prophecy *References
Further reading
* Achtemeier, Elizabeth R. & Murphy, Frederick J. ''The New Interpreter’s Bible, Vol. VII: Introduction to Apocalyptic Literature, Daniel, The Twelve Prophets'' (Abingdon, 1996) * Cathcart, Kevin J. & Gordon, Robert P. ''The Targum of the Minor Prophets''. The Aramaic Bible 14 (Liturgical Press, 1989) * Chisholm, Robert B. ''Interpreting the Minor Prophets'' (Zondervan, 1990) * * * Feinberg, Charles L. ''The Minor Prophets'' (Moody, 1990) * Ferreiro, Alberto (ed). ''The Twelve Prophets''. Ancient Christian Commentary on Scripture (Inter-Varsity Press, 2003) * * Hill, Robert C. (tr). ''Theodoret of Cyrus: Commentary on the Prophets Vol 3: Commentary on the Twelve Prophets'' (Holy Cross Orthodox Press, 2007) * * House, Paul R. ''The Unity of the Twelve''. JSOT Supplement Series, 97 (Almond Press, 1990) * Jones, Barry Alan. ''The Formation of the Book of the Twelve: a Study in Text and Canon''. SBL Dissertation Series 149 (Society of Biblical Literature, 1995) * Keil, Carl Friedrich. ''Keil on the Twelve Minor Prophets (1878)'' (Kessinger, 2008) * Longman, Tremper & Garland, David E. (eds). ''Daniel–Malachi''. The Expositor's Bible Commentary (Revised ed) 8 (Zondervan, 2009) * McComiskey, Thomas Edward (ed). ''The Minor Prophets: An Exegetical and Expository Commentary'' (Baker, 2009) * ''Navarre Bible, The: Minor Prophets'' (Scepter & Four Courts, 2005) * Nogalski, James D. ''Literary Precursors to the Book of the Twelve''. Beihefte zur Zeitschrift für die Alttestamentliche Wissenschaft (Walter de Gruyter, 1993) * * Petterson, Anthony R., ‘The Shape of the Davidic Hope across the Book of the Twelve’, '' Journal for the Study of the Old Testament'' 35 (2010), 225–46. * Phillips, John. ''Exploring the Minor Prophets''. The John Phillips Commentary Series. (Kregel, 2002) * * Roberts, Matis (ed). ''Trei asar: The Twelve Prophets: a New Translation with a Commentary Anthologized from Talmudic, Midrashic, and Rabbinic Sources'' (Mesorah, 1995–) * Rosenberg, A.J. (ed). ''The Twelve Prophets: Hebrew Text and English Translation''. Soncino Books of the Bible (Soncino, 2004) * * Shepherd, Michael B. ''The Twelve Prophets in the New Testament'' (Peter Lang, 2011). ISBN 9781433113468. * Slavitt, David R. (tr). ''The Book of the Twelve Prophets'' (Oxford University Press, 1999) * Smith, James E. ''The Minor Prophets''. Old Testament Survey (College Press, 1994) * Stevenson, John. ''Preaching From The Minor Prophets To A Postmodern Congregation'' (Redeemer, 2008) * Walton, John H. (ed). ''The Minor Prophets, Job, Psalms, Proverbs, Ecclesiastes, Song of Songs'' Zondervan Illustrated Bible Backgrounds Commentary (Zondervan, 2009) * {{Authority control * 08 Prophetic books