Kate Elder
   HOME

TheInfoList



OR:

Mary Katherine Horony Cummings (November 7, 1849 – November 2, 1940), popularly known as Big Nose Kate, was a Hungarian-born American outlaw, gambler, prostitute and longtime companion and
common-law Common law (also known as judicial precedent, judge-made law, or case law) is the body of law primarily developed through judicial decisions rather than statutes. Although common law may incorporate certain statutes, it is largely based on prec ...
wife of
Old West The American frontier, also known as the Old West, and popularly known as the Wild West, encompasses the geography, history, folklore, and culture associated with the forward wave of American expansion in mainland North America that bega ...
gambler and gunfighter
Doc Holliday John Henry Holliday (August 14, 1851 – November 8, 1887), better known as Doc Holliday, was an American dentistry, dentist, gambling, gambler, and gunfighter who was a close friend and associate of Sheriff, lawman Wyatt Earp. Holliday is b ...
. "Tough, stubborn and fearless", she was educated, but chose to work as a prostitute due to the independence it provided her. She is the only woman with whom Holliday is known to have had a relationship.


Early life

Mary Katherine Horony (also Harony (original family name from Hungary), Haroney, and Horoney) was born on November 7, 1849, in Érsekújvár,
Kingdom of Hungary The Kingdom of Hungary was a monarchy in Central Europe that existed for nearly a millennium, from 1000 to 1946 and was a key part of the Habsburg monarchy from 1526-1918. The Principality of Hungary emerged as a Christian kingdom upon the Coro ...
(present-day
Nové Zámky Nové Zámky (; ) is a town in Nové Zámky District in the Nitra Region of southwestern Slovakia. Geography The town is located on the Danubian Lowland, on the Nitra River, at an altitude of 119 metres. It is located around 100 km fr ...
,
Slovakia Slovakia, officially the Slovak Republic, is a landlocked country in Central Europe. It is bordered by Poland to the north, Ukraine to the east, Hungary to the south, Austria to the west, and the Czech Republic to the northwest. Slovakia's m ...
). She was the second daughter of Hungarian physician and teacher Mihály Horony (1817–1865) and Katalin Boldizsár (1830–1865).


Immigration to the United States

In 1860, Dr. Horony, his second wife Katharina, and his children left Hungary for the United States, arriving in New York City on the German ship ''Bremen'' in September. The Horony family settled in a predominantly German area of
Davenport, Iowa Davenport ( ) is a city in Scott County, Iowa, United States, and its county seat. It is situated along the Mississippi River on the eastern border of the state. Davenport had a population of 101,724 as of the 2020 United States census, 2020 cen ...
, in 1862. Horony and his wife died within a month of one another in 1865. Mary Katherine and her younger siblings were placed in the home of her brother-in-law, Gustav Susemihl, and in 1870 they were left in the care of attorney Otto Smith.1935 Bork interview, Arizona Historical Society, Boyer Collection, Tucson, AZ The 1870
United States Census The United States census (plural censuses or census) is a census that is legally mandated by the Constitution of the United States. It takes place every ten years. The first census after the American Revolution was taken in 1790 United States ce ...
records for Davenport show Horony's younger sister, 15-year-old Wilhelmina (Wilma), living with and working as a domestic for Austrian-born David Palter and his Hungarian wife Bettina.


St. Louis and Dodge City

In 1866, at age 16, Horony ran away from her foster home and stowed away on a riverboat bound for St. Louis, Missouri. Horony later claimed that while she lived in St. Louis she married a dentist named Silas Melvin with whom she had a son, and that both died of yellow fever. The United States Census records report that a Silas Melvin lived in St. Louis in the mid 1860s but that he was married to a steamship captain's daughter named Mary Bust. The census also shows that another Melvin was employed by a St. Louis asylum. Since Horony met
Doc Holliday John Henry Holliday (August 14, 1851 – November 8, 1887), better known as Doc Holliday, was an American dentistry, dentist, gambling, gambler, and gunfighter who was a close friend and associate of Sheriff, lawman Wyatt Earp. Holliday is b ...
in the early 1870s, she may have confused the two and their occupations when recalling the facts later in her life.Glenn Boyer, ''Who Is Big Nose Kate?'' Researcher Jan Collins states that Horony entered the Ursuline
Convent A convent is an enclosed community of monks, nuns, friars or religious sisters. Alternatively, ''convent'' means the building used by the community. The term is particularly used in the Catholic Church, Lutheran churches, and the Anglican ...
but did not remain long. In 1869, she is recorded as working as a prostitute for madam Blanche Tribole in St. Louis. In 1874, Horony was fined for working as a "sporting woman", i.e. a prostitute, in a " sporting house" in
Dodge City, Kansas Dodge City is a city in and the county seat of Ford County, Kansas, United States. As of the 2020 census, the population of the city was 27,788. It was named after nearby Fort Dodge, which was named in honor of Grenville Dodge. The city ...
, run by Nellie "Bessie" (Ketchum) Earp,
James Earp James Cooksey Earp (June 28, 1841 – January 25, 1926) was a lesser known older brother of Old West lawman Virgil Earp and lawman/gambler Wyatt Earp. Unlike his brothers, he was a saloon-keeper and was not present at the Gunfight at the O.K. ...
's wife.


Joins Doc Holliday

In 1876, Horony moved to
Fort Griffin, Texas Fort Griffin, now a Texas state historic site as Fort Griffin State Historic Site, was a US Cavalry fort established 31 July 1867 by four companies of the Sixth Cavalry, U.S. ArmyCarter, R.G., ''On the Border with Mackenzie'', 1935, Washingto ...
, where in 1877 she met
Doc Holliday John Henry Holliday (August 14, 1851 – November 8, 1887), better known as Doc Holliday, was an American dentistry, dentist, gambling, gambler, and gunfighter who was a close friend and associate of Sheriff, lawman Wyatt Earp. Holliday is b ...
at John Shanssey's Saloon, where Holliday was dealing cards. According to his cousin and biographer Karen Holliday Tanner, Holliday considered Horony to be his intellectual equal, while she appreciated his refined manners. By this time, Horony had earned the nickname "Big Nose Kate". Horony was tough, stubborn, and with a temper that matched Holliday's.


Move to Dodge City

The couple's departure from Fort Griffin was dramatic. A card game between Holliday and a local bully by the name of Ed Bailey, lead to a confrontation where Bailey kept sneaking a look at the
discards Discards are the portion of a catch of fish which is not retained on board during commercial fishing operations and is returned, often dead or dying, to the sea. The practice of discarding is driven by economic and political factors; fish which are ...
, something that was prohibited by the rules of Western Poker. This violation could force the offending player to forfeit the pot. Holliday warned Bailey twice but was ignored. Bailey did it a third time, but this time Holliday raked in the pot without showing his hand nor saying a word. Bailey immediately brought his revolver out from under the table. Before Bailey could fire Holliday pulled a knife and slashed the man across the stomach, killing him. Holliday maintained he acted in self-defence and was arrested and incarcerated in a local hotel room, there being no jail in the town. The killing incited some townsfolk to form a vigilante group to seek revenge on Holliday. Horony came to Holliday's aid by setting fire to an old shed to distract the mob. With the townsfolk redirected to fight the fire, Horony confronted the Deputy guarding Holliday with a gun and she and Holliday escaped into the night. After hiding out that night they headed to Dodge City, Kansas on stolen horses, arriving the next morning at Deacon Cox's Boarding House. The two registered as Dr. and Mrs. J.H. Holliday. Holliday opened a dental practice by day but spent most of his time gambling and drinking. The two fought regularly and sometimes violently, but made up after fights despite the volatile relationship. According to Horony, the couple later married in Valdosta, Georgia. They traveled to Trinidad, Colorado, and then to Las Vegas, New Mexico, where they lived for about two years. Holliday worked as a dentist by day and ran a saloon on Center Street by night. Horony also occasionally worked at a dance hall in Santa Fe, New Mexico. By her own account, Horony and Holliday met up again with
Wyatt Earp Wyatt Berry Stapp Earp (March 19, 1848 – January 13, 1929) was an American lawman in the American West, including Dodge City, Kansas, Dodge City, Wichita, Kansas, Wichita, and Tombstone, Arizona, Tombstone. Earp was involved in the gunfight ...
and his brothers on their way to the
Arizona Territory The Territory of Arizona, commonly known as the Arizona Territory, was a territory of the United States that existed from February 24, 1863, until February 14, 1912, when the remaining extent of the territory was admitted to the Union as the ...
.
Virgil Earp Virgil Walter Earp (July 18, 1843 – October 19, 1905) was an American lawman. He was both deputy U.S. Marshal and City Marshal of Tombstone, Arizona, Tombstone, Arizona Territory, Arizona, when he led his younger brothers Wyatt Earp, Wyatt a ...
had already been in Prescott, Arizona, and persuaded his brothers to move to
Tombstone A gravestone or tombstone is a marker, usually stone, that is placed over a grave. A marker set at the head of the grave may be called a headstone. An especially old or elaborate stone slab may be called a funeral stele, stela, or slab. The us ...
. Holliday was making money at the gambling tables in Prescott. In 1880, he and Horony parted ways when Horony left for
Globe, Arizona Globe ( "Place of Metal") is a city in and the county seat of Gila County, Arizona, Gila County, Arizona, United States. As of the 2020 United States census, 2020 census, the population of the city was 7,249. Globe was founded c. 1875 as a mini ...
, but she rejoined Holliday soon after he arrived in Tombstone.


Move to Tombstone

Holliday, like his friend Wyatt Earp, was always looking for an opportunity to make money, and joined the Earps in Tombstone during the fall of 1880. On March 15, 1881, at 10:00 pm, three cowboys attempted to rob a Kinnear & Company stagecoach carrying $26,000 in
silver bullion Bullion is non-ferrous metal that has been refined to a high standard of elemental purity. The term is ordinarily applied to bulk metal used in the production of coins and especially to precious metals such as gold and silver. It comes from t ...
(by the inflation adjustment algorithm: $ in today's dollars) near
Benson, Arizona Benson is a city in Cochise County, Arizona, Cochise County, Arizona, United States. As of the 2020 United States census, 2020 census, the population of the city was 5,355. It was founded as a rail terminal for the area, and is located approxim ...
, during which the popular driver Eli "Budd" Philpot and passenger Peter Roerig were killed. Cochise County Cowboy Bill Leonard, a former
watchmaker A watchmaker is an artisan who makes and repairs watches. Since a majority of watches are now factory-made, most modern watchmakers only repair watches. However, originally they were master craftsmen who built watches, including all their par ...
from New York City, was one of three men implicated in the robbery, and he and Holliday had become good friends. When Horony and Holliday had a fight, County Sheriff
Johnny Behan John Harris Behan (October 24, 1844 – June 7, 1912) was an American law enforcement officer and politician who served as Sheriff of Cochise County in the Arizona Territory, during the gunfight at the O.K. Corral and was known for his oppositi ...
and Milt Joyce, a county supervisor and owner of the Oriental Saloon, decided to exploit the situation. Both were members of the Tombstone Ten Percent Ring. Behan and Joyce plied Horony with alcohol and suggested to her a way to get even with Holliday. She signed an affidavit implicating Holliday in the murders and attempted robbery. Judge
Wells Spicer Wells W. Spicer (1831–1885 or 1887) was an American journalist, prospector, politician, lawyer and judge whose legal career immersed him in two significant events in frontier history: the Mountain Meadows massacre in the Utah Territory in 1857; ...
issued an
arrest warrant An arrest warrant is a warrant issued by a judge or magistrate on behalf of the state which authorizes the arrest and detention of an individual or the search and seizure of an individual's property. Canada Arrest warrants are issued by a jud ...
for Holliday. The Earps found witnesses who could attest to Holliday's whereabouts elsewhere at the time of the murders. Horony said that Behan and Joyce had influenced her to sign a document she didn't understand. With the Cowboy plot revealed, Judge Spicer freed Holliday. The district attorney threw out the charges, labeling them "ridiculous". After Holliday was released, he gave Horony money and put her on the stage. Horony returned to Globe for a time, but she returned to Tombstone in October of that year.


Gunfight at the O.K. Corral

In a 1939 letter to her niece Lillian Rafferty, Horony claimed that she was in the Tombstone area with Holliday during the days before the shootout. According to Horony, she was with Holliday in Tucson, Arizona when they attended the San Augustin Feast and Fair in Levin Park during October 1881. On October 20, 1881,
Morgan Earp Morgan Seth Earp (April 24, 1851 – March 18, 1882) was an American sheriff and Marshal, lawman. He served as Tombstone, Arizona, Tombstone, Arizona Territory, Arizona's Special Policeman when he helped his brothers Virgil Earp, Virgil and W ...
rode to Tucson to request Holliday's assistance with dealing with
Cochise County Cowboys The Cochise County Cowboys is the modern name for a loosely associated group of outlaws living in Pima and Cochise Counties in Arizona in the late 19th century. The term "cowboy", as opposed to " cowhand," had only begun to come into wider use ...
who had threatened to kill the Earps. She wrote that Holliday asked her to remain in Tucson for her safety, but she refused, and traveled with Holliday and Earp. Horony reminisced in the letter about her stay with Holliday at C.S. Fly's Boarding House which bordered the alley where the
Gunfight at the O.K. Corral The gunfight at the O.K. Corral pitted lawmen against members of a loosely organized group of cattle rustlers and horse thieves called the Cowboys on October 26, 1881. While lasting less than a minute, the gunfight has been the subject of ...
took place. Horony accurately described minor details of the shootout, writing that on the day of the gunfight a man entered Fly's Boarding House with a "bandaged head" and a rifle. He was looking for Holliday, who was still in bed after a night of gambling. Horony recalled that the man who was turned away by Mrs. Fly was later identified as
Ike Clanton Joseph Isaac Clanton (c. 1847 – June 1, 1887) was a member of a loose association of outlaws known as Cochise County Cowboys, The Cowboys who clashed with lawmen Wyatt Earp, Wyatt, Virgil Earp, Virgil and Morgan Earp as well as Doc Holliday. ...
, whom city marshal
Virgil Earp Virgil Walter Earp (July 18, 1843 – October 19, 1905) was an American lawman. He was both deputy U.S. Marshal and City Marshal of Tombstone, Arizona, Tombstone, Arizona Territory, Arizona, when he led his younger brothers Wyatt Earp, Wyatt a ...
had pistol-whipped earlier that day when he found Clanton carrying a rifle and pistol in violation of city ordinances. Clanton's head was bandaged afterward. Virgil Earp had disarmed him earlier that day and told Ike he would leave Ike's confiscated rifle and revolver at the Grand Hotel, which was favored by cowboys when they were in town. Ike testified afterward that he had tried to buy a new revolver at Spangenberger's gun and hardware store on 4th Street but the owner saw Ike's bandaged head and refused to sell him one. Clanton was unarmed at the time of the shootout later that afternoon. Ike testified that he picked up the weapons from William Soule, the jailer, a couple of days later. Author
Glenn Boyer Glenn G. Boyer (January 5, 1924 – February 14, 2013)
2013-02-19
was a controversial author who pub ...
disputes that Horony saw the gunfight through the window of the boarding house. Also according to him, Horony stated that after Doc Holliday returned to his room, he sat at the edge of his bed and wept from the shock of what had happened during the close-range gunfight. "That was awful," Horony claims he said. "Just awful." Boyer's work, however, has been rejected by serious scholars.


After the O.K. Corral and later life

Horony is reported to have made trips to Tombstone to see Holliday until he left for Colorado in April 1882. In 1887, Horony traveled to Redstone, Colorado, close to Glenwood Springs, Colorado, to visit with her brother Alexander. Some historians have tried to connect Horony and Doc to possible reconciliation attempts between the two.


Marriage to George Cummings

After Doc Holliday died in 1887, Horony married Irish blacksmith George Cummings in Aspen, Colorado, on March 2, 1890. After working several mining camps throughout Colorado, they moved to Bisbee, Arizona, where she briefly ran a bakery. After returning to Willcox, Arizona, in
Cochise County Cochise County ( ) is a county in the southeastern corner of the U.S. state of Arizona. It is named after Cochise, a Chiricahua Apache who was a key war leader during the Apache Wars. The population was 125,447 at the 2020 census. The county ...
, Cummings became an abusive alcoholic and they separated. In 1900, Horony moved to Dos Cabezas or
Cochise Cochise ( ; Apache: or , ; later or , ; June 8, 1874) was the leader of the Chiricahui local group of the Chokonen and principal nantan of the Chokonen band of a Chiricahua Apache. A key war leader during the Apache Wars, he led an upri ...
and worked for John and Lulu Rath, owners of the Cochise Hotel. George Cummings committed suicide in Courtland, Arizona, in July 1915. Horony is enumerated in the 1910 U.S. Census in Dos Cabezas, Arizona, as a member of the home of miner John J. Howard. When Howard died in 1930, Horony was the executrix of his estate. She contacted his only daughter, who lived in Tempe, Arizona, and settled the inheritance. In 1931 the 80-year-old Horony contacted her longtime friend, Arizona Governor
George W. P. Hunt George Wylie Paul Hunt (November 1, 1859 – December 24, 1934) was an American politician and businessman. He was the first governor of Arizona, serving a total of seven terms, along with President of the convention that wrote Arizona's con ...
, and applied for admittance to the Arizona Pioneers' Home in Prescott, Arizona. The home had been established in 1910 by the State of Arizona for destitute and ailing miners and male pioneers of the
Arizona Territory The Territory of Arizona, commonly known as the Arizona Territory, was a territory of the United States that existed from February 24, 1863, until February 14, 1912, when the remaining extent of the territory was admitted to the Union as the ...
. It took Horony six months to be admitted because the home had a requirement that residents must be US citizens. According to the 1935 Bork interview, Horony was owed money by the Howard estate, but the amount owed was not enough to buy firewood through the winter, as Horony had complained in her letters to the governor. She was admitted as one of the first female residents of the home. She lived there and became an outspoken resident, assisting other residents with living comforts. Horony wrote many letters to the Arizona state legislature, often contacting the governor when she was not satisfied with their response. Near the end of her life, several reporters tried to record Horony's life story, her relationship with Doc Holliday and her time in Tombstone. She only talked to Anton Mazzonovich and Prescott historian A.W. Bork.


Death and discrepancies in records

Horony died on November 2, 1940, five days before her 91st birthday, of acute myocardial insufficiency, a condition she started showing symptoms of the day before her death. Her death certificate states that she also suffered from
coronary artery disease Coronary artery disease (CAD), also called coronary heart disease (CHD), or ischemic heart disease (IHD), is a type of cardiovascular disease, heart disease involving Ischemia, the reduction of blood flow to the cardiac muscle due to a build-up ...
and advanced
arteriosclerosis Arteriosclerosis, literally meaning "hardening of the arteries", is an umbrella term for a vascular disorder characterized by abnormal thickening, hardening, and loss of elasticity of the walls of arteries; this process gradually restricts th ...
. Horony's death certificate contained significant discrepancies regarding her parents' names and her birthplace. Although she was born in Hungary, her death certificate states she was born in Davenport, Iowa, to father Marchal H. Michael and mother Catherine Baldwin. The birthplace of both her parents is shown on the certificate as "unknown".ADHS Arizona Genealogy Birth and Death Certificates online
. Retrieved March 11, 2010.
The superintendent of the Pioneer Home is named as the informant on the death certificate. Horony was buried on November 6, 1940, in the Arizona Pioneers' Home Cemetery in Prescott, Arizona.


Cultural depictions

*
Jo Van Fleet Jo Van Fleet (December 29, 1915"The Birth of C ...
played Horony (as Kate Fisher) in ''Gunfight at the O.K. Corral (film)">Gunfight at the O.K. Corral The gunfight at the O.K. Corral pitted lawmen against members of a loosely organized group of cattle rustlers and horse thieves called the Cowboys on October 26, 1881. While lasting less than a minute, the gunfight has been the subject of ...
'' (1957). * Grace Lee Whitney played Horony (as Kate Fisher) in the 1964 ''Death Valley Days'' Television episode "The Quiet and the Fury." The episode covers the incident with Ed Bailey and Horony's rescue of Holliday. * Horony was played by
Faye Dunaway Dorothy Faye Dunaway (born January 14, 1941) is an American actress. She is the recipient of List of awards and nominations received by Faye Dunaway, many accolades, including an Academy Award, a Primetime Emmy Award, three Golden Globe Awards, ...
in the 1971 film ''
Doc DOC, Doc, doc or DoC may refer to: People and characters * Doc, an abbreviation of doctor * Doc (nickname) * Doc (mascot), the Towson University mascot Persons * The D.O.C., American rapper (born 1968) * Doc Gallows (born 1983), ring nam ...
''. * In the 1993 film ''
Tombstone A gravestone or tombstone is a marker, usually stone, that is placed over a grave. A marker set at the head of the grave may be called a headstone. An especially old or elaborate stone slab may be called a funeral stele, stela, or slab. The us ...
'', she was portrayed by Polish actress
Joanna Pacuła Joanna Pacuła (; born 30 December 1957) is a Polish actress and model. Born in Tomaszów Lubelski and immigrating to the United States in the early 1980s, she first gained prominence through her modeling work for '' Vogue''. Her breakthrough pe ...
. * Horony was portrayed by
Isabella Rossellini Isabella Fiorella Elettra Giovanna Rossellini (; born 18 June 1952) is an Italian actress and model. The daughter of Swedish actress Ingrid Bergman and Italian film director Roberto Rossellini, she is noted for her successful tenure as a Lancôme ...
in the 1994 movie ''
Wyatt Earp Wyatt Berry Stapp Earp (March 19, 1848 – January 13, 1929) was an American lawman in the American West, including Dodge City, Kansas, Dodge City, Wichita, Kansas, Wichita, and Tombstone, Arizona, Tombstone. Earp was involved in the gunfight ...
''.


References


Further reading

* ''On the Paper Trail of Big Nose Kate'', Angel M. Brant, Self-published September 2008. This book contains pictorial info never published by past Cummings' authors. * ''Old West Researcher'', A.M. Brant. * ''Wyatt Earp, Family Friends and Foes, Volume I, Who Was Big Nose Kate'', Glenn G. Boyer, Arizona University Press, 1997 (). This source includes many assertions about Horony which have been rejected by serious scholars. * * * Bowmaster, Patrick A.
A Fresh Look at 'Big Nose Kate
'' ''NOLA Quarterly'' 22 (July – September 1998): 12-24 * * "The Lily of the West", Kathleen Morris, Five Star Publishing / Cengage, January 2019.


External links


Arizona Pioneers' Home
{{Authority control People from American folklore American prostitutes American female prostitutes Hungarian prostitutes Emigrants from the Austrian Empire to the United States People from Arizona Territory People from Prescott, Arizona American people of Hungarian descent People from Pest, Hungary 1850 births 1940 deaths People of the Cochise County conflict People from Tombstone, Arizona