Ivar of Limerick

Ivar of Limerick ( ga, Ímar Luimnich, rí Gall; Ímar ua Ímair; Ímar Ua hÍmair, Ard Rí Gall Muman ocus Gáedel; Íomhar Mór; non, Ívarr ; died 977), was the last Norse king of the city-state of Limerick, and penultimate ''King of the Foreigners of Munster'', reigning during the rise to power of the Dál gCais and the fall of the Eóganachta.

His repeated attempts to assert his authority in Limerick and the surrounding region and possibly over even the greater province of Munster itself earned him the most prominent role as antagonist in the first part of the early 12th century saga and political tract '' Cogad Gáedel re Gallaib'', as an enemy of Mathgamain mac Cennétig, claimant to the title King of Munster, and his more famous younger brother and successor Brian Bóruma.

According to the author of the ''Cogad Gáedel re Gallaib'', Ivar succeeded in establishing himself as King of Munster for a period in the 960s,Todd, ''Cogadh'', pp. 48–9 until routed in the Battle of Sulcoit in 968, but this claim has long been doubted by scholars. He then appears to have returned only a year or two later and established himself in the region again in some capacity.

The sources

The two main sources for the career of Ivar are the early 12th century '' Cogad Gáedel re Gallaib'' itself and what support it receives from the ''Annals of Inisfallen''. Both are believed to have used as their primary source a now lost collection of annals of ultimately ''Chronicle of Ireland'' descent to which were added material of Munster concern.

Unfortunately, however, though the ''Cogad'' author made extensive use of these annals, as well as local sources also now lost, and also some contemporary poetry, his purpose was political and intended to glorify Brian Boru and the Dál gCais for the benefit of his descendant Muirchertach Ua Briain, so although in part annalistic it is also full of exaggerations, flowery language, and dubious passages of various origin. The major problem with the ''Annals of Inisfallen'', on the other hand, is that they are a substantially abbreviated and otherwise edited redaction of the original and so actually preserve less ultimately reliable or contemporary coverage of Ivar in total than does the ''Cogad'', with all its faults. The ''Annals of Inisfallen'' also suffer from a considerable lacuna or simply an empty gap containing no entries at all, for whatever reason, of two and a half critical years in Ivar's career, from mid-969 to the beginning of 972.

The third most important source for this period of Munster history are the ''Annals of the Four Masters'', but they were compiled much later and are occasionally of doubtful reliability, suffering in some cases from interpolations, misplaced entries, and so on. They also cover little of Ivar himself and serve mostly for the major sources above to be checked against in places. A few other sources briefly mentioning Ivar survive but altogether these do not contribute much if anything to our knowledge of him. The ''Annals of Tigernach'' might have been of assistance but they no longer survive for over two centuries between 766 and 974.

Pedigree

Ivar's patronym is not given in the Irish annals,Downham, p. 190 which as mentioned above have survived very incomplete, but he is generally accepted as a member of the prolific Norse dynasty known to historians as the Uí Ímair or House of Ivar. In the ''Cogad'' and related texts he is called Ímar ua (h)Ímair or ''Ímar, grandson of Ímar'', but this can also be read Ímar Ua hÍmair, the capitalization producing the surname meaning "Descendant of Ímar", not unique to him and apparently used by other members of the dynasty as well. His precise relation to the previous rulers of Limerick is uncertain, the last member of the dynasty in the city state and its last known king before him being Aralt mac Sitric, who died in 940 and is generally believed to have been a third son of the great Sihtric Cáech (died 927), king of Dublin and later king of Northumbria. The problem with Ivar being a literal grandson of Ímar I (died 873) is that he would simply have been incredibly old by the time of his death in 977. A previous namesake of Ímar I, namely Ímar ua Ímair, killed in Scotland in 904, might be an alternative grandfather, in which case no correction of the form ''ua Ímair'' in the ''Cogad'' would be needed. At least two generations between the king of Limerick and the founder of the dynasty are required regardless. These assumptions made, Ivar of Limerick can be placed in the pedigree below.

The following list contains only members mentioned in the Irish annals and other reliable and semi-reliable sources, and among those only the ones who can be placed in the pedigree with relative confidence. Thus it is by no means complete.

After various authors. Birthdates are unknown. ''mac'' = son of; ''ingen'' = daughter of; ''ua'' = grandchild of; ''Ua (h)Ímair'' = surname (descendant of Ímar).
* Ímar/Ívar/Ivar/Ívarr (died 873)
** Bárid mac Ímair (died 881)
** Sichfrith mac Ímair (died 888)
** Sitric mac Ímair (died 896)
** ? mac/ingen Ímair, and/or among the above sons
*** Amlaíb ua Ímair (died 896)
*** Ímar ua Ímair (died 904)
*** Ragnall ua Ímair (died 920/1)
**** ? mac Ragnaill (died 942)
**** Ímar (died 950)?
***** probably Ímar of Waterford (died 1000)
****** Gilla Pátraic mac Ímair (died 983)
****** Ragnall mac Ímair (died 995)
****** Donndubán mac Ímair (died 996)
****** Ragnall mac Ímair II (died 1018)
******* ? mac Ragnaill (died 1015)
******* Ragnall mac Ragnaill (died 1035)
****** Sihtric mac Ímair (died 1022)
*** Sihtric Cáech (died 927)
**** Sichfrith mac Sitric (died 937)
**** Ausle mac Sitric (died 937)
**** Aralt mac Sitric (died 940)
***** probably Maccus mac Arailt (died 984/7)
***** probably Gofraid mac Arailt (died 989)
****** Ragnall mac Gofraid (died 1005)
****** Lagmann mac Gofraid (died ?)
******* Amlaíb mac Lagmann (died 1014)
******** ? Donnchadh mac Amlaíb (died 1014)
****** Máel Muire ingen Gofraid (died ?)
**** Gofraid mac Sitriuc (died 951)
**** Amlaíb Cuarán (died 981)
***** Ragnall mac Amlaíb (died 980)
***** Glúniairn (died 989)
****** Gilla Ciaráin mac Glúniairn (died 1014)
****** Sitric? mac Glúniairn (''fl''. 1036)
***** Aralt mac Amlaíb (died 999)
****** Ímar mac Arailt (died 1054)
***** Dubgall mac Amlaíb (died 1014)
***** Ragnailt ingen Amlaíb (died ?)
***** Máel Muire ingen Amlaíb (died 1021)
***** Gytha ingen Amlaíb (died ?)
***** Sigtrygg Silkbeard (died 1042)
****** Artalach mac Sitric (died 999)
****** Amlaíb mac Sitric I/II (died 1013)
****** Glúniairn mac Sitric (died 1031)
****** Amlaíb mac Sitriuc II/I (died 1034)
******* Ragnailt ingen Amlaíb (died ?)
****** Gofraid mac Sitric (died 1036)
****** Cellach ingen Sitric (died 1042)
*** Gofraid ua Ímair (died 934)
**** Alpdann mac Gofraid (died 927)
**** Amlaíb mac Gofraid (died 941)
***** Cammán mac Amlaíb (''fl''. 962)
**** Ragnall mac Gofraid (''fl''. 943)
**** Blácaire mac Gofraid (died 948)
*** ? ua Ímair (or among the above grandsons?)
**** Ímar of Limerick (died 977)
***** Amlaíb mac Ímair (died 977)
***** Dubcenn mac Ímair (died 977)
****** Osli mac Dubceinn (died 1012)
****** Amond mac Dubceinn (died 1014)
***** Aralt mac Ímair (died 978)

Tyrant of Muman

The passage in the ''Cogad Gáedel re Gallaib'' describing Ivar's arrival and kingship in Munster:

The author goes on to describe the system of government which Ivar imposed on Munster, but doing so in a way which reflects the "structure of assessment and control in the territories of the Uí Briain at the time of composition of the text":

There does, however, survive a very similar passage, found not in any surviving version of the ''Cogad'' but in another tract entirely, preserved by Duald Mac Firbis in the 17th century. Its date is uncertain, and it may or may not come from a lost version of the ''Cogad''. Most of the following is also mentioned in the epic, following the above passages, but there is much expanded. The following account at least gives the appearance of being a summary, but this is probably not what it is:

That Ivar or the Norse in general may have been attempting the actual takeover of some part of Munster possibly finds support in the Annals of Inisfallen:

The term used here for the Norse soldiers is ''súaitrech'' "mercenary" and so the passage has been taken by Charles Doherty to refer to the practice of billetting the hired contingents of a standing army, as was common in later times. What is peculiar about this passage is the extent of cooperation between the Gaelic kings. Here the sworn rivals Mathgamain and Máel Muad (the son of Bran) are actually found working together, the only known occasion in their careers. They are joined by one Faelán of uncertain identity, whose mention may either refer to a king of the Déisi Muman who actually died in 966, and who the ''Cogad'' alleges Ivar actually killed, or to an abbot of Emly later mentioned dying in 980. Notably Emly was attacked by Ivar or his relations in 968 not long after the Norse loss in the Battle of Sulcoit in 967, and possibly in retaliation for the Dál gCais plundering of Limerick.

The above account, however, is dated five years after Sulcoit in the Annals of Inisfallen, and is in fact the first entry following the lacuna beginning in mid 969, so we do not know what events have preceded it in the past two and a half years, assuming it is correctly placed. Ivar is first mentioned by name in the surviving annals in early-mid 969, which record that "Beólán Litil and his son were killed by Ímar of Luimnech." The identity of this person is not completely certain but he is assumed to be identical with the Uí Néill king of Lagore (Loch Gabor) or Southern Brega whose death, without cause given, is recorded in several other annals in the same year. Clare Downham notes that this puts Ivar and the Limerick Norse active all the way out in the neighborhood of Dublin and says that Beolán was an ally of the King of Dublin, namely Olaf Cuaran. The ''Cogad'' also records this killing but provides no motive, simply mentioning it immediately after Ivar's return to Limerick, allegedly from Britain, with a second great fleet.Todd, ''Cogadh'', pp. 84–5 After his alleged expulsion sometime following Sulcoit the author of the ''Cogad'' states Ivar and a certain "Amlaíb, son of Amlaíb" attempted the conquest of Britain, but without success, with Amlaib being killed by the king of Britain (unnamed). Having returned to Limerick and killed Beolán (or vice versa), Ivar is said to have then "made many spoils and battles." No other record of these survives, if this properly counts as one, and we must wait til 972 for the Annals of Inisfallen to pick up again.

Economics and the city-state

The sources have recently been reexamined by the scholar Mary Valante, who has taken an economic approach. Accepting Mac Airt's translation of ''súaitrech'' not as ''soldiers'' but ''officials'', she interprets this as Ivar and Norse Limerick's dominance of international trade within its region, sphere of influence, or "periphery" in Ireland. She notes that the poll tax described in the ''Cogad'' "is very similar to that listed in the Book of Rights and the Book of the Uí Maine from Dublin ic, referring to that collected for the Kings of Dublin, and furthermore finds a possible reference to Norse Limerick's royal "officials" in two versions of the Book of Rights itself. However, whether this tribute from Limerick's hinterland (as with Dublin's) was extracted in "a sort of protectionism racket, or as tolls on trade, or as something else entirely is unclear." In any case the Norse economy in Munster, judging from silver finds, appears to have operated somewhat differently from that of the Dublin region. Trade with France, and from there southern Europe and the Mediterranean, can be assumed, but that with elsewhere in the Anglo-Celtic Isles and the wider Norse world may have been more limited by Limerick's location.

Poul Holm has recently argued that Norse Dublin, Limerick, and Waterford, can all three be classed as genuine city-states as such an entity is defined by Mogens Herman Hansen and the Copenhagen Polis Centre. However only Dublin and Limerick can be considered major "central places" and all the remaining Norse settlements and bases were related to one or the other of these two. Limerick had streets in Ivar's time, as reported in the ''Cogad'' when Mathgamain and the Dál gCais storm the great fortress or dún following their victory at Sulcoit.

Scattery Island, or Inis Cathaig, is believed to have been a part of the kingdom of Limerick. Its Norse name has been suggested by Donnchadh Ó Corráin to be composed of the elements ''skattar'' + ''øy'' to mean "tribute island". Ivar is reported here twice in the annals, for which read below.

Maccus

Depending on whether or not Mathgamain and Máel Muad were successful in achieving anything following their resolution in 972, Ivar may or may not have found himself in a very weakened position. Curiously neither of our major primary sources has anything clear to say about the state of affairs at this time. But in 974 Ivar met with misforture, the Annals of Inisfallen reporting that "The son of Aralt made a circuit of Ireland with a great company, and plundered Inis Cathaig, and brought Ímar from it into captivity.", and the Annals of the Four Masters "The plundering of Inis-Cathaigh by Maghnus accus son of Aralt, with the Lag-manns awmenof the islands along with him; and Imhar, lord of the foreigners of Luimneach, was carried off from the island, and the violation of Seanan thereby." His captor is easily identified as Maccus mac Arailt, King of Mann and the Isles, but what are unknown are the circumstances. Ivar may have gone to Scattery because he had been driven out of Limerick proper, or it could have been for some other reason, and whether or not he and Maccus were already associated is unknown. Benjamin Hudson has offered the explanation that this event can be related to Ivar's earlier adventure in Britain as reported in the ''Cogad'', arguing that the "King of Britain" reported slaying his comrade Amlaíb mac Amlaíb should be understood as either Maccus or his brother Gofraid mac Arailt and not some king of the Welsh, otherwise "it probably would have been mentioned in the insular records". (Assuming Hudson is referring only to the Welsh and English records.) Elaborating, he reads this sequence beginning with "a battle over the exploitation of the Welsh" which the sons of Aralt won, and eventually ending with Maccus following Ivar all the way around Ireland to finish it.

However, Maccus and Gofraid are usually assumed to be sons of the Aralt mac Sitric (died 940) mentioned above, the last known king of Limerick before Ivar, thus easily explaining Maccus' interest in the kingdom. Hence dynastic ties and rivalry could have existed. Uniquely Maccus brings the "lawmen" of the Isles with him and instead of being slain Ivar is captured, presumably for some offence in the opinion of Colmán Etchingham,Etchingham, p. 172 and perhaps related to his earlier expedition to Britain as argued by Hudson for another context. A year later in 975 the Annals of Inisfallen report "Ímar escaped over sea, and Inis Ubdan was captured again.", which has also been variously read as him simply being "released" somewhere in the Isles by Maccus. Alternatively, Alex Woolf suggests Ivar may have been ransomed for a sum, noting that the Norse cities "were rapidly becoming the repositories of silver bullion in the western world." In any event who was doing the capturing of Inis Ubdan again, whether Ivar or Mathgamain, is uncertain. This was one of the islands of the Hiberno-Norse city-state but not the one, Inis Sibtonn, on which the capital was located. Mathgamain is earlier reported driving the Norse from it c. 971 in the not entirely reliable Annals of the Four Masters, but this still assumes the Norse has previously captured it themselves.

Notably none of the above, Maccus' capture of Ivar in 974 or his return from anywhere in 975, is reported in the ''Cogad''. The author had the Annals of Inisfallen entries available to him because they come from the same sources he used.

Instigator

In a debated passage, the author of the ''Cogad'' reports Ivar instigating his ally Donnubán mac Cathail (Donovan, the son of Cathal) to meet in his house (commonly said to be hosting a conference or feast) and betray Mathgamain up to Máel Muad mac Brain in 976. Said by the author to be after the confederates, with the addition of Ivar's son Dubcenn, had gone into revolt against Mathgamain, the Dalcassian prince was regardless in a precarious situation, and according to Alice Stopford Green this act of going into an enemy's house was "the formal sign of submission and renouncing supremacy", from where he soon might have proceeded to submit to Máel Muad, although Mathgamain alternatively may have been attempting to detach Donnubán from the alliance. But it has also been argued that this was entirely the product of Ivar's interference with Donnubán and that Máel Muad, a considerably distance away at the time, was in essence the natural and convenient beneficiary, a theory supported by the account in the ''Cogad''. The annals make no mention of Ivar's involvement, simply reporting Mathgamain's seizure in treachery by Donnubán and the killing of the live prisoner by Máel Muad, but at the same time do not exclude it.

Death, sons and descendants

Possibly in retaliation for instigating the betrayal and killing of Mathgamain the year before, Ivar and two of his sons, Amlaíb/Olaf (Cuallaid or "Wild Dog") and Dubcenn ("Dark Head"), were killed, apparently after being surprised, by Brian in 977 on Scattery Island, marking the end of an independent Norse Limerick, which lasted only a surprising fifty five years from the arrival of Tomrair mac Ailchi in 922. At his death in 977, the generally reliable Annals of Inisfallen actually style Ivar '' rí Gall'' or simply ''King of the Foreigners'', a fairly rare style otherwise reserved for the Kings of Dublin, thus perhaps lending at least some weight to the claims of the author of the ''Cogad'' that this was a person of special authority in some domain.

This political saga gives him another son, Aralt, elected ''King of the Foreigners of Munster'' soon after Ivar's slaying. He is said to have perished, slain by Brian's army, along with Donnubán in the Battle of Cathair Cuan, probably somewhere in Uí Fidgenti. A son of Dubcenn, namely Osli ( Auisle < Ásl/Auðgísl), is named later in the saga actually as a "high steward" of Brian, who possibly placed him in control of Mide, when killed by Flaithbertach Ua Néill c. 1012. Another son of Dubcenn may have been Amond, possibly killed fighting on Brian's side in the Battle of Clontarf in 1014.

Ivar is claimed to be survived, through a daughter, by the modern O'Donovan family. This daughter, whose name may or may not survive,The O'Donovan pedigree printed by O'Hart in the 19th century is a synthetic one based in part on much older materials, historical as well as genealogical. Some of O'Hart's sources, including detailed O'Donovan pedigrees in MS, can still be found in the National Library of Ireland, and so it is possible that the name of this daughter is somewhere preserved. is said to have married his ally Donnubán, their eponymous ancestor, although alternatively she may actually have been the daughter of Ivar's son Olaf, a possibility allowed by the pedigrees. But in any case a daughter of this princess and Donnubán is believed to have married Ivar of Waterford and had by him several children.

Notes

References

;Primary sources
;Chronicles
* '' Annals of Clonmacnoise'', translated by Connell MacGeoghagen (1627), ed. Denis Murphy (1896),
The Annals of Clonmacnoise
'. Dublin: Royal Society of Antiquaries of Ireland.
* ''Annals of the Four Masters'', ed. & tr. John O'Donovan (2nd ed., 1856), ''Annála Rioghachta Éireann. Annals of the Kingdom of Ireland by the Four Masters... with a Translation and Copious Notes''. 7 vols. Dublin: Royal Irish Academy
CELT versions
Full scans at Internet Archive
Vol. IVol. IIVol. IIIVol. IVVol. VVol. VIIndices

* ''Annals of Inisfallen'', ed. & tr. Seán Mac Airt (1944), ''The Annals of Inisfallen (MS. Rawlinson B. 503)''. Dublin: DIAS. Electroni
edition
an
translation
at CELT.
* '' Annals of Loch Cé'', ed. & tr. W. M. Hennessy (1871), ''The Annals of Loch Cé''. Rolls Series 54. 2 vols. Dublin
CELT versions
Full scans o
Vol. I
an
Vol. II
at Internet Archive.
* ''Annals of Tigernach'', ed. & tr. Whitley Stokes (1895–97), "The Annals of Tigernach", in '' Revue Celtique 16–18''. Electroni
edition
at CELT an
full scan
at Internet Archive.
* ''Annals of Ulster'', ed. & tr. Seán Mac Airt and Gearóid Mac Niocaill (1983). ''The Annals of Ulster (to AD 1131)''. DIAS
edition
an
translation
available at CELT.
* ''Chronicon Scotorum'', ed. & tr. Gearóid Mac Niocaill (2003). ''Chronicon Scotorum''. Unpublished manuscript made available to UCC.
edition
an

available at CELT.
* '' Cogad Gáedel re Gallaib'', ed. & tr. James Henthorn Todd (1867).
Cogadh Gaedhel re Gallaibh: The War of the Gaedhil with the Gaill
'. London: Longmans, Green, Reader, and Dyer.
* '' Dublin Annals of Inisfallen'', John O'Brien and John Conry (c. 1765). Edition and Latin translation by Charles O'Conor (1825),
Rerum Hibernicarum Scriptores, Volume II
'.
* '' Foras Feasa ar Éirinn'', by Geoffrey Keating (c. 1634), ed. & tr. David Comyn and Patrick S. Dinneen (1902–1914). ''The History of Ireland by Geoffrey Keating''. Irish Texts Society
edition
an

available from CELT.
* ''On the Fomorians and the Norsemen'', by Duald Mac Firbis (c. 1650), ed. & tr. Alexander Bugge (1905).
On the Fomorians and the Norsemen
'. Christiania: J. Chr. Gundersens Bogtrykkeri.
;Other
* Dillon, Myles (ed. & tr.), '' Lebor na Cert''. Dublin: Irish Texts Society. 1962
edition
an

available from CELT.
* Grosjean, P. (ed.), "Poems on St Senán", in J. Fraser, P. Grosjean, & J. G. O'Keeffe (eds.), ''Irish Texts IV''. London. 1934. pp. 68–97
* O'Hart, John,
Irish Pedigrees
'. Dublin: James Duffy and Co. 5th edition, 1892.
;Secondary sources
* Begley, John,
The Diocese of Limerick, Ancient and Medieval
'. Dublin: Browne & Nolan. 1906.
* Bugge, Alexander, "Bidrag til det sidste Afsnit af Nordboernes Historie i Irland", in
Aarbøger for nordisk oldkyndighed og historie, II
'. (Kongelige Nordiske oldskrift-selskab). Copenhagen: H. H. Thirles Bogtrykkeri. 1904. pp. 248–315
alternative scan
* Chadwick, Nora K., "The Vikings and the Western World", in Brian Ó Cuív (ed.),
Proceedings of the International Congress of Celtic Studies held in Dublin, 6–10 July, 1959
'. Dublin Institute for Advanced Studies. 1962. pp. 13–42. (Volume reissued 1975 as
The Impact of the Scandinavian Invasions on the Celtic-speaking Peoples, c. 800–1000 A.D.
')

* Charles, Bertie George, ''Old Norse Relations with Wales''. Cardiff: University of Wales Press. 1934.
* Doherty, Charles, "The Vikings in Ireland: a Review", in Howard B. Clarke, Máire Ní Mhaonaigh, Raghnall Ó Floinn (eds.), ''Ireland and Scandinavia in the Early Viking Age''. Dublin: Four Courts Press. 1998. pp. 288–330.
* Downham, Clare, ''Viking Kings of Britain and Ireland: The Dynasty of Ívarr to A.D. 1014''. Edinburgh: Dunedin. 2007.
* Etchingham, Colmán, "North Wales, Ireland and the Isles: the Insular Viking zone", in '' Peritia 15'' (2001 002: 145–187.
* Green, Alice Stopford,
History of the Irish State to 1014
'. London: Macmillan. 1925.
* Healy, John,
Insula Sanctorum et Doctorum; or, Ireland's Ancient Schools and Scholars
'. Dublin: Sealy, Bryers & Walker. 1890.
* Holm, Poul, "Viking Dublin and the City-State Concept: Parameters and Significance of the Hiberno-Norse Settlement" (Respondent: Donnchadh Ó Corráin), in Mogens Herman Hansen (ed.),
A Comparative Study of Thirty City-State Cultures
'. Denmark: Special-Trykkeriet Viborg. (University of Copenhagen, Polis Center). 2000. pp. 251–62.
* Hudson, Benjamin T.,
Viking Pirates and Christian Princes: Dynasty, Religion, and Empire in the North Atlantic
'. Oxford University Press. 2005.
* Lee, Timothy, "The Northmen of Limerick", in
Journal of the Royal Historical and Archaeological Association of Ireland, Fourth Series, Vol. 9, No. 80
' (July – October , 1889): 227–231
JSTOR
* Ní Mhaonaigh, Máire, "''Cogad Gáedel Re Gallaib'' and the Annals: A Comparison", in '' Ériu 47'' (1996): 101–26
JSTOR
* Ó Corráin, Donnchadh,
General: Vikings in Ireland
'. UCC
Corpus of Electronic Texts
Undated.
* Ó Corráin, Donnchadh, "The Vikings in Ireland", in Anne-Christine Larsen (ed.), ''The Vikings in Ireland.'' Roskilde: The Viking Ship Museum. 2001.
* O'Mahony, John,
A History of the O'Mahony Septs
'. Reprinted from the ''Journal of the Cork Historical and Archaeological Society, Volumes 12–16, Second Series''. 1906–1910.
* Sheehan, John, and Steffen Stummann Hansen, Donnchadh Ó Corráin, "A Viking Age Maritime Haven: A Reassessment of the Island Settlement at Beginish, Co. Kerry", in ''The Journal of Irish Archaeology Vol. 10'' (2001): 93–11
JSTOR
* Steenstrup, Johannes C. H. R.,
Normannerne, Vols. 3–4
'. Copenhagen: Forlagt af Rudolph Klein, I. Cohens Bogtrykkeri. 1882
alternative scan
* Valante, Mary A., "Taxation, tolls and tribute: the language of economics and trade in Viking-Age Ireland", in ''Proceedings of the Harvard Celtic Colloquium 18'' (1998): 242–58
JSTOR
* Valante, Mary A., ''The Vikings in Ireland: Settlement, Trade and Urbanization''. Four Courts Press. 2008.
* Walsh, Annie,
Scandinavian Relations with Ireland during the Viking Period
'. Dublin: The Talbot Press. 1922
alternative scan
* Woolf, Alex, ''From Pictland to Alba 789–1070''. Edinburgh University Press. 2007.
* Young, Jene I., "A Note on the Norse Occupation of Ireland", in ''History 35, Issue 123'' (1950): 11–33
Wiley Online Library

{{DEFAULTSORT:Ivar of Limerick
O'Donovan family
Uí Ímair
977 deaths
Kings of Limerick
10th-century Irish monarchs
Year of birth unknown