Is It Because I'm Black

"Is It Because I'm Black" is a song recorded in 1969 by blues and soul singer Syl Johnson. It was co-written by Johnson, record producer Jimmy Jones (James L. Jones), and Glenn Watts. The recording, issued on the Twinight label in September 1969, reached number 11 on the ''Billboard'' R&B chart, and number 68 on the Hot 100.

Background and recording

By 1969, Johnson had achieved several modest chart successes with songs on traditional themes of romance and relationships, but his marriage had ended, his established backing band had split up, and he was increasingly motivated by the social and economic challenges of American society. Johnson later said: "After Martin Luther King got killed, I wanted to write a song.... I didn’t want to write no song about hating this people or hating that people... I really didn’t have no vendetta against people. It’s a sympathy song." "Syl Johnson - 'Is It Because I'm Black'", ''Numero''
Retrieved February 8, 2020

He linked up with the musicians who until then had been working for Brunswick Records under producer Carl Davis, before leaving under acrimonious circumstances, and recorded "Is It Because I'm Black" with guitarist John Bishop, bassist Bernard Reed, and drummer Hal "Heavy" Nesbitt. Together with horn players Michael Davis and alto saxist Jerry Wilson, the musicians adopted the group name The Pieces of Peace, and toured with Johnson.

Released on the Twinight label (which had changed its name from Twilight because another company already used the name), the single rose up the R&B charts and pop charts at the end of 1969. Journalist Lanre Bakare wrote: "The main lyric from this song has taken on a life of its own and is a phrase that means so much in the American context. Johnson was from Mississippi and in a similar mould to the Chicago blues men like Junior Wells. You can hear that attitude and the grit in the vocal performance on this song. It’s like he’s giving a sermon in a church, and he’s describing – in metaphor and similes – what it’s like to be black in America." Lanre Bakare, "Syl Johnson's Is It Because I'm Black? And a 'world of no pity'", ''The Guardian'', 13 March 2017
Retrieved February 8, 2022 Johnson's obituary referred to the song as "a slow, disconsolate ballad that is among the most affecting of the civil rights era."Ben Beaumont-Thomas, "Syl Johnson, much-sampled blues, funk and soul singer, dies aged 85", ''The Guardian'', 6 February 2022
Retrieved 8 February 2022 Robert Pruter described the song as "superbly arranged and produced...n whichJohnson's plaintive vocals evoked the moodiness of this lamentation over the struggle of being black. The song, however, strangely suggested pride rather than defeatism."

Impact

The single's success led to an extended version becoming the title track on Johnson's 1970 album, described in one source as "the first black concept album", released over a year before Marvin Gaye's ''What's Going On''. However, the album failed to sell in large numbers, Ed Ward, "The 'Complete Mythology' Of Syl Johnson", ''NPR'', August 25, 2011
Retrieved February 8, 2022 which Johnson put down to its lack of marketability to a white audience. The song "Is It Because I'm Black" was later recorded by singers Ken Boothe and Delroy Wilson in Jamaica, and Johnson's recording has been sampled by musicians including the Wu-Tang Clan, and the singer's daughter Syleena Johnson for her song "Color Of My Tears" from her ninth studio album ''Legacy'' (2024).

References

{{Reflist

1969 singles
Syl Johnson songs
Songs about racism and xenophobia