Gryposaurus Notabilis

''Gryposaurus'' (meaning "hooked-nosed (Greek ''grypos'') lizard"; sometimes incorrectly translated as "griffin (Latin ''gryphus'') lizard") was a genus of duckbilled dinosaur that lived about 80 to 75 million years ago, in the Late Cretaceous (late Santonian to late Campanian stages) of North America. Named species of ''Gryposaurus'' are known from the Dinosaur Park Formation in Alberta, Canada, and two formations in the United States: the Lower Two Medicine Formation in Montana and the Kaiparowits Formation of Utah. A possible additional species from the Javelina Formation in Texas may extend the temporal range of the genus to 66 million years ago.

''Gryposaurus'' is similar to ''Kritosaurus'', and for many years the two were thought to be synonyms. It is known from numerous skulls, some skeletons, and even some skin impressions that show it to have had pyramidal scales projecting along the midline of the back. It is most easily distinguished from other duckbills by its narrow arching nasal hump, sometimes described as similar to a "Roman nose," and which may have been used for species or sexual identification, and/or combat with individuals of the same species. A large bipedal/quadrupedal herbivore around long, it may have preferred river settings.

History of discovery

''Gryposaurus'' is based on specimen NMC 2278, a skull and partial skeleton collected in 1913 by George F. Sternberg from what is now known as the Dinosaur Park Formation of Alberta, along the Red Deer River. This specimen was described and named by Lawrence Lambe shortly thereafter, Lambe drawing attention to its unusual nasal crest. A few years earlier, Barnum Brown had collected and described a partial skull from New Mexico, which he named ''Kritosaurus''. This skull was missing the snout, which had eroded into fragments; Brown restored it after the duckbill now known as ''Edmontosaurus annectens'', which was flat-headed, and believed that some unusual pieces were evidence of compression. Lambe's description of ''Gryposaurus'' provided evidence of a different type of skull configuration, and by 1916 the ''Kritosaurus'' skull had been redone with a nasal arch and both Brown and Charles Whitney Gilmore, Charles Gilmore had proposed that ''Gryposaurus'' and ''Kritosaurus'' were one and the same. This idea was reflected in William Parks (paleontologist), William Parks's naming of a nearly complete skeleton from the Dinosaur Park Formation as ''Kritosaurus incurvimanus'', not ''Gryposaurus incurvimanus'' (although he left ''Gryposaurus notabilis'' in its own genus). Direct comparison between ''Kritosaurus incurvimanus'' and ''Gryposaurus notabilis'' is hindered by the fact that the ''incurvimanus'' type specimen is missing the front part of the skull, so the full shape of the nasal arch cannot be seen. The 1942 publication of the influential R. S. Lull, Lull and Wright monograph on hadrosaurs sealed the ''Kritosaurus''/''Gryposaurus'' question for nearly fifty years in favor of ''Kritosaurus''. Reviews beginning in the 1990s, however, called into question the identity of ''Kritosaurus navajovius'', which has limited material for comparison with other duckbills. Thus, ''Gryposaurus'' has once again been separated, at least temporarily, from ''Kritosaurus''.

This situation is made more confusing by old suggestions by some authors, including Jack Horner, that ''Hadrosaurus'' is also the same as either ''Gryposaurus'', ''Kritosaurus'', or both. This hypothesis was most common in the late 1970s–early 1980s, and appears in some popular books; one well-known work, ''The Illustrated Encyclopedia of Dinosaurs'', uses ''Kritosaurus'' for the Canadian material (''Gryposaurus''), but identifies the mounted skeleton of ''K. incurvimanus'' as ''Hadrosaurus'' in a photo caption. Although Horner in 1979 used the new combination ''Hadrosaurus [Kritosaurus] notabilis'' for a partial skull and skeleton and a second less-complete skeleton from the Bearpaw Shale of Montana (which have since fallen out of the literature), by 1990 he had changed his position, and was among the first to again use ''Gryposaurus'' in print. Current thought is that ''Hadrosaurus'', although known from fragmentary material, can be distinguished from ''Gryposaurus'' by differences in the humerus, upper arm and ilium (bone), ilium.

Further research has revealed the presence of a second species, ''G. latidens'', from slightly older rocks in Montana than the classic gryposaur localities of Alberta. Based on two parts of a skeleton collected in 1916 for the American Museum of Natural History, ''G. latidens'' is also known from bone bed, bonebed material. Horner, who described the specimens, considered it to be a less Synapomorphy, derived species.

New material from the Kaiparowits Formation of Utah, in Grand Staircase–Escalante National Monument, includes a skull and partial skeleton that represent the species ''G. monumentensis''. Its skull was more robust than that of the other species, and its predentary had enlarged prongs along its upper margin, where the lower jaw's beak was based. This new species greatly expands the geographic range of this genus, and there may be a second, more lightly built species present as well. Multiple gryposaur species are known from the Kaiparowits Formation, represented by cranial and postcranial remains, and were larger than their northern counterparts.

In Texas, specifically at the Javelina Formation and the El Picacho Formation, indeterminate hadrosaur remains resembling ''Kritosaurus'' and ''Gryposaurus'' have been unearthed for decades, but none were considered to be identifiable as a determined genus of hadrosaur, but do resemble some species of Kritosaurini or at least some species of ''Kritosaurus''. However, in 2016, a possibly forth valid species of ''Gryposaurus'' named ''G. alsatei'', which was named after Alsate, who was the last leader of the Mescalero Apaches, was unearthed in the Javelina Formation in Texas. Further research is needed to confirm its validity.

Species

As of 2016, there are currently three named species that are recognized as valid today: ''G. notabilis'', ''G. latidens'', and ''G. monumentensis''. The type species ''G. notabilis'' is from the Campanian, late Campanian-age Upper Cretaceous Dinosaur Park Formation of Alberta, Canada. It is now thought that another species from the same formation, ''Kritosaurus incurvimanus'' (also known as ''Gryposaurus incurvimanus''), is a synonym of ''G. notabilis''. The two had been differentiated by the size of the nasal arch (larger and closer to the eyes in ''G. notabilis'') and the form of the upper arm (longer and more robust in ''K. incurvimanus''). Ten complete skulls and twelve fragmentary skulls are known for ''G. notabilis'' along with postcrania, as well as with two skeletons with skulls that had been assigned to ''K. incurvimanus''. ''G. latidens'', from the Santonian, late Santonian-early Campanian Two Medicine Formation, Lower Two Medicine Formation of Pondera County, Montana, Pondera County, Montana, USA, is known from partial skulls and skeletons from several individuals. Its nasal arch is prominent like that of ''G. notabilis'', but farther forward on the snout, and its teeth are less Synapomorphy, derived, reflecting iguanodont-like characteristics. The nomen nudum, informal name "Hadrosauravus" is an early, unused name for this species. ''G. monumentensis'' is known from a skull and partial skeleton from Utah. ''G. monumentensis'' was listed second on the top 10 list of new species in 2008 by the International Institute for Species Exploration. Recently, a possible fourth species of ''Gryposaurus'', ''Gryposaurus alsatei'', was unearthed in the Javelina Formation, which dates to the late Maastrichtian, along with an unnamed species of ''Kritosaurus'' and an undescribed saurolophine which closely resembles ''Saurolophus'', but with a more solid crest. Fossil remains of ''Gryposaurus'' have also been unearthed in the El Picacho Formation in Texas.

The dubious hadrosaurid Stephanosaurus, ''Stephanosaurus marginatus'' was considered a possible species of ''Kritosaurus'', following the synonymy of ''Gryposaurus'' with ''Kritosaurus''. However, this synonymy was rejected in the 2004 edition of the ''Dinosauria'', with ''Stephanosaurus'' being tabulated as dubious.

Description

''Gryposaurus'' was a hadrosaurid of typical size and shape; one of the best specimens of this genus, the nearly complete type specimen of ''Kritosaurus incurvimanus'' (now regarded as a synonym of ''Gryposaurus notabilis'') came from an animal about long. This specimen also has the best example of integument, skin impressions for ''Gryposaurus'', showing this dinosaur to have had several different types of scalation: pyramidal, ridged, limpet-shaped feature scales forming scutes upwards of 3.8 centimeters long (1.5 inches) on the flank and tail; uniform polygonal basement scales on the neck and sides of the body; and pyramidal structures, flattened side-to-side, with fluted sides, longer than tall and found along the top of the back in a single midline row. In 2016, Gregory S. Paul estimated the size of ''G. latidens'' at in length and in body mass and the other two species (''G. notabilis'' and ''G. monumentensis'') at in length and in body mass.

The three named species of ''Gryposaurus'' differ in details of the skull and lower jaw. The prominent nasal arch found in this genus is formed from the paired nasal bones. In profile view, they rise into a rounded hump in front of the eyes, reaching a height as tall as the highest point of the back of the skull. The skeleton is known in great detail, making it a useful point of reference for other duckbill skeletons.

Classification

''Gryposaurus'' was a saurolophine (hadrosaurine of older references) hadrosaurid, a member of the duckbill subfamily without hollow head crests. The general term "gryposaur" is sometimes used for duckbills with arched nasals. ''Tethyshadros'' was once thought to fall into this group as well, before it was described (then known under the nickname "Antonio"). A subfamily, Gryposaurinae, was coined by Jack Horner (paleontologist), Jack Horner as part of a larger revision that promoted Hadrosaurinae to family status, but is not now in use. A rough equivalent is Kritosaurini, as used by Alberto Prieto-Márquez. ''Kritosaurus'' has been proposed to be a synonym of ''Gryposaurus'', but it is slightly younger. Additionally, while the skull of ''Kritosaurus'' is incompletely known, lacking most of the bones in front of the eyes, it was very similar to that of ''Gryposaurus''.

The following is a cladogram based on the phylogenetic analysis conducted by Prieto-Márquez and Wagner in 2012, showing the relationships of ''Gryposaurus'' among the other kritosaurins:

Paleobiology

As a hadrosaurid, ''Gryposaurus'' would have been a bipedal/quadrupedal herbivore, eating a variety of plants. Its skull had special joints that permitted a grinding motion analogous to mastication, chewing, and its tooth, teeth were continually replacing and packed into dental batteries that contained hundreds of teeth, only a relative handful of which were in use at any time. Plant material would have been cropped by its broad beak, and held in the jaws by a cheek-like organ. Its feeding range would have extended from the ground to about above. The paleontologists who unearthed ''G.'' ''monumentensis'' back in the 2000s brought the fact that this creature dined on tough, fibrous plant material which would imply that ''Gryposaurs'' was both a Grazing (behaviour), grazer and a Browsing (herbivory), browser.

Like other ornithischia, bird-hipped dinosaurs of the Dinosaur Park Formation, ''Gryposaurus'' appears to have only existed for part of the duration of time that the rocks were being formed. As the formation was being laid down, it recorded a change to more ocean, marine-influenced conditions. ''Gryposaurus'' is absent from the upper part of the formation, with ''Prosaurolophus'' present instead. Other dinosaurs known from only the lower part of the formation include the horned ''Centrosaurus'' and the hollow-crested duckbill ''Corythosaurus''. ''Gryposaurus'' may have preferred river-related settings.

Nasal arch

The distinctive nasal arch of ''Gryposaurus'', like other cranial modifications in duckbills, may have been used for a variety of social functions, such as identification of sexes or species and social ranking. It could also have functioned as a tool for broadside pushing or butting in social contests, and there may have been inflatable air sacs flanking it for both visual and auditory signaling. The top of the arch is roughened in some specimens, suggesting that it was covered by thick, keratinized skin, or that there was a cartilage, cartilaginous extension.

Paleoecology

Utah

Argon-argon dating, Argon-argon radiometric dating indicates that the Kaiparowits Formation was deposited between 76.1 and 74.0 million years ago, during the Campanian stage of the Late Cretaceous period. During the Late Cretaceous period, the site of the Kaiparowits Formation was located near the western shore of the Western Interior Seaway, a large inland sea that split North America into two landmasses, Laramidia to the west and Appalachia to the east. The plateau where dinosaurs lived was an ancient floodplain dominated by large channels and abundant wetland peat swamps, ponds and lakes, and was bordered by highlands. The climate was wet and humid, and supported an abundant and diverse range of organisms. This formation contains one of the best and most continuous records of Late Cretaceous terrestrial life in the world.

''Gryposaurus monumentensis'' shared its natural environment, paleoenvironment with other dinosaurs, such as dromaeosauridae, dromaeosaurid theropods, the troodontidae, troodontid ''Talos sampsoni'', ornithomimids like ''Ornithomimus, Ornithomimus velox'', tyrannosaurids like ''Albertosaurus'' and ''Teratophoneus'', ankylosauria, armored ankylosaurids, the hadrosaurid, duckbilled hadrosaur ''Parasaurolophus, Parasaurolophus cyrtocristatus'', the ceratopsians ''Utahceratops, Utahceratops gettyi'', ''Nasutoceratops titusi'' and ''Kosmoceratops, Kosmoceratops richardsoni'' and the oviraptorosaurian ''Hagryphus, Hagryphus giganteus''. Other paleofauna present in the Kaiparowits Formation included chondrichthyes, chondrichthyans (sharks and rays), frogs, salamanders, turtles, lizards and crocodilians. A variety of early mammals were present including multituberculates, marsupials, and insectivorans.

See also

* Timeline of hadrosaur research
*2016 in paleontology

References

{{Taxonbar, from=Q385949

Saurolophinae
Dinosaur genera
Campanian dinosaurs
Dinosaur Park Formation
Two Medicine Formation
Kaiparowits Formation
Taxa named by Lawrence Lambe
Fossil taxa described in 2014
Dinosaurs of Canada
Dinosaurs of the United States