Fred Jelinek

Frederick Jelinek (18 November 1932 – 14 September 2010) was a Czech-American researcher in information theory, automatic speech recognition, and natural language processing. He is well known for his oft-quoted statement, "Every time I fire a linguist, the performance of the speech recognizer goes up".

Jelinek was born in Czechoslovakia before World War II and emigrated with his family to the United States in the early years of the communist regime. He studied engineering at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and taught for 10 years at Cornell University before accepting a job at IBM Research. In 1961, he married Czech screenwriter Milena Jelinek. At IBM, his team advanced approaches to computer speech recognition and machine translation. After IBM, he went to head the Center for Language and Speech Processing at Johns Hopkins University for 17 years, where he was still working on the day he died.

Personal life

Jelinek was born on November 18, 1932, as Bedřich Jelínek in Kladno to Vilém and Trude Jelínek. His father was Jewish; his mother was born in Switzerland to Czech Catholic parents and had converted to Judaism. Jelínek senior, a dentist, had planned early to escape Nazi occupation and flee to England; he arranged for a passport, visa, and the shipping of his dentistry materials. The couple planned to send their son to an English private school. However, Vilém decided to stay at the last minute and was eventually sent to the Theresienstadt concentration camp, where he died in 1945. The family was forced to move to Prague in 1941, but Frederick, his sister and motherthanks to the latter's backgroundescaped the concentration camps.

After the war, Jelinek entered in the gymnasium, despite having missed several years of schooling because education of Jewish children had been forbidden since 1942. His mother, anxious that her son should get a good education, made great efforts for their emigration,As he put it, "she didn't want to emulate my father's big mistake." especially when it became clear he would not be allowed to even attempt the graduation examination. His mother hoped her son would become a physician, but Jelinek dreamed of being a lawyer. He studied engineering in evening classes at the City College of New York and received stipends from the National Committee for a Free Europe that allowed him to study at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. About his choice of specialty, he said: "Fortunately, to electrical engineering there belonged a discipline whose aim was not the construction of physical systems: the theory of information". He obtained his Ph.D. in 1962, with Robert Fano as his adviser.

In 1957, Jelinek paid an unexpected visit to Prague. He had been in Vienna and applied for a visa, hoping to see his former acquaintances again. He met with his old friend Miloš Forman, who introduced him to film student Milena Tobolováwhose screenplay had been the basis for the movie ''Easy Life'' (''Snadný život''). His flight back to the U.S. had a stopover in Munich, during which he called her to propose. Tobolová was considered a dissident and the authorities were not happy with her film. Jelinek asked for help from Jerome Wiesner and Cyrus Eaton, the latter who lobbied Nikita Khrushchev. Following the inauguration of John F. Kennedy, a group of Czech dissidents were allowed to emigrate in January 1961. Thanks to the lobbying, the future Milena Jelinek was one of them.

After completing his graduate studies, Jelinek, who had developed an interest in linguistics, had plans to work with Charles F. Hockett at Cornell University. However these fell through and during the next ten years he continued to study information theory. Having previously worked at IBM during a sabbatical, he began full-time work there in 1972at first on leave for Cornell, but permanently from 1974. He remained there for over twenty years. Although at first he had been offered a regular research job, upon his arrival he learned that Josef Raviv had recently been promoted to head of the newly opened IBM Haifa Research Laboratory, and became head of the Continuous Speech Recognition group at the Thomas J. Watson Research Center. Despite his team's successes in this area, Jelinek's work remained little known in his home country because Czech scientists were not allowed to participate in key conferences.

After the 1989 fall of communism, Jelinek helped establish scientific relationships, regularly visiting to lecture and helping to persuade IBM to establish a computing centre at Charles University. In 1993, he retired from IBM and went to Johns Hopkins University's Center for Language and Speech Processing, where he was director and Julian Sinclair Smith Professor of Electrical and Computer Engineering. He was still working there at the time of his death; Jelinek died of a heart attack at the close of an otherwise normal workday in mid-September 2010. He was survived by his wife, daughter and son, sister, stepsister, and three grandchildren, including Sophie Gold Jelinek.

Research and legacy

Information theory was a fashionable scientific approach in the mid '50s. However, pioneer Claude Shannon wrote in 1956 that this trendiness was dangerous. He said, "Our fellow scientists in many different fields, attracted by the fanfare and by the new avenues opened to scientific analysis, are using these ideas in their own problems  ...  It will be all too easy for our somewhat artificial prosperity to collapse overnight when it is realized that the use of a few exciting words like information, entropy, redundancy, do not solve all our problems."Quoted in Liberman (2010). During the next decade, a combination of factors shut down the application of information theory to natural language processing (NLP) problemsin particular machine translation. One factor was the 1957 publication of Noam Chomsky's '' Syntactic Structures,'' which stated, "probabilistic models give no insight into the basic problems of syntactic structure".Quoted in Young (2010). This accorded well with the philosophy of the artificial intelligence research of the time, which promoted rule-based approaches. The other factor was the 1966 ALPAC report, which recommended that the government should stop funding research into machine translation. ALPAC chairman John Pierce later said that the field was filled with "mad inventors or untrustworthy engineers". He said that the underlying linguistic problems must be solved before attempts at NLP could be reasonably made. These elements essentially halted research in the field.

Jelinek had begun to develop an interest in linguistics after the immigration of his wife, who initially enrolled in the MIT linguistics program with the help of Roman Jakobson. Jelinek often accompanied her to Chomsky's lectures, and even discussed the possibility of changing orientation with his adviser. Fano was "really upset", and after the failure of his project with Hockett at Cornell, he did not return to this field of research until starting work at IBM. The scope of research at IBM was considerably different from that of most other teams. According to Mark Liberman, "While elinekwas leading IBM's effort to solve the general dictation problem during the decade or so following 1972, most other U.S. companies and academic researchers were working on very limited problems  ...  or were staying out of the field entirely".

Jelinek regarded speech recognition as an information theory problema noisy channel, in this case the acoustic signalwhich some observers considered a daring approach. The concept of perplexity was introduced in their first model, New Raleigh Grammar, which was published in 1976 as the paper "Continuous Speech Recognition by Statistical Methods" in the journal ''Proceedings of the IEEE''. According to Young, the basic noisy channel approach "reduced the speech recognition problem to one of producing two statistical models". Whereas New Raleigh Grammar was a hidden Markov model, their next model, called Tangora, was broader and involved n-grams, specifically trigrams. Even though "it was obvious to everyone that this model was hopelessly impoverished", it was not improved upon until Jelinek presented another paper in 1999. The same trigram approach was applied to phones in single words. Although the identification of parts of speech turned out not to be very useful for speech recognition, tagging methods developed during these projects are now used in various NLP applications.

The incremental research techniques developed at IBM eventually became dominant in the field after DARPA, in the mid-80s, returned to NLP research and imposed that methodology to participating teams, shared common goals, data, and precise evaluation metrics. The Continuous Speech Recognition Group's research, which required large amounts of data to train the algorithms, eventually led to the creation of the Linguistic Data Consortium. In the 1980s, although the broader problem of speech recognition remained unsolved, they sought to apply the methods developed to other problems; machine translation and stock value prediction were both seen as options. A group of IBM researchers went on to work for Renaissance Technologies. Jelinek wrote, "The performance of the Renaissance fund is legendary, but I have no idea whether any methods we pioneered at IBM have ever been used. My former colleagues will not tell me: theirs is a very hush-hush operation!" Methods very similar to those developed for achieving speech recognition are at the base of most machine translation systems in use today. Observers have said that Pierce's paradigm, according to which engineering achievements in this area would be built on scientific progress, has been inverted, with the achievements in engineering being at the base of a number of scientific findings.

Jelinek's works won "best paper" awards on several occasions, and he received a number of company awards while he worked at IBM. He received the Society Award for "outstanding technical contributions and leadership" from the IEEE Signal Processing Society for 1997, and the ESCA Medal for Scientific Achievement in 1999. He was a recipient of an IEEE Third Millennium Medal in 2000, the European Language Resources Association's first Antonio Zampolli Prize in 2004, the 2005 James L. Flanagan Speech and Audio Processing Award, and the 2009 Lifetime Achievement Award from the Association for Computational Linguistics. He received an ''honoris causa'' Ph.D. from Charles University in 2001, was elected to the National Academy of Engineering in 2006 and was made one of twelve inaugural fellows of the International Speech Communication Association in 2008.

"Every time I fire a linguist, the performance of the speech recognizer goes up"

Jelinek is often quoted as saying "Every time I fire a linguist, the performance of the speech recognizer goes up."

Although its fame and iconic status are undisputed (it was for example used as the title of a 1998 speech by Julia Hirschberg), its context is unknown and its specific wording and dating are unclear.

According to Daniel Jurafsky and James H. Martin, Jelinek himself recalled the quote as "Anytime a linguist leaves the group the recognition rate goes up" and dated it to December 1988 (Wayne, Pennsylvania), further noting that the quote did not appear in the published proceeding, whereas Roger K. Moore gave the wording as "Every time we fire a phonetician/linguist, the performance of our system goes up" and dated it to an IEEE Automatic Speech Recognition and Understanding workshop held in 1985.

According to Steve Young, "the story goes that one day one of his linguists resigned, and Fred decided to replace him not by another linguist but by an engineer. A little while later, Fred noticed that the performance of his system improved significantly. So he encouraged another linguist to find alternative employment, and sure enough performance improved again."

At a 2004 presentation, Jelinek claimed that he said it in a talk titled "Applying Information Theoretic Methods: Evaluation of Grammar Quality" at the Workshop on Evaluation of NLP Systems (Wayne, Pennsylvania, December 1988). He also gave more details around the context. At the start of their Continuous Speech Recognition at IBM in 1972, two linguists were assigned to the group. The group was trying to make a language model. One of them, Stan Petrick, said "Don't worry, I will just make a little grammar." He never did. One year later, both linguists left, leaving behind a group of mostly engineers and physicists with little experience with linguistics, but much experience with information theory.

Selected publications

*Jelinek, Frederick (1968). ''Probabilistic Information Theory: Discrete and memoryless models''. McGraw-Hill series in systems science. New York: McGraw-Hill. 689p. (review)
*———————- (1969). "Fast sequential decoding algorithm using a stack". ''IBM Journal of Research and Development'' 13(6):675–685. .
*———————- (1969). "Tree encoding of memoryless time-discrete sources with a fidelity criterion". ''IEEE Transactions on Information Theory'' 15(5):584–590. . (received 1971 "Best Paper" award)
*Bahl, Lalit R.; John Cocke, Frederick Jelinek, Josef Raviv (1974). "Optimal decoding of linear codes for minimizing symbol error rate". ''IEEE Transactions on Information Theory'' 20(2):284–287. . (received Information Theory Society Golden Jubilee paper award)
*———————- (1976). "Continuous speech recognition by statistical methods". ''Proceedings of the IEEE'' 64(4):532–556. .
*Brown, P.; J. Cocke, S. Della Pietra, V. Della Pietra, F. Jelinek, R, Mercer and P. Roossin (1988)
"A statistical approach to language translation"
. In Dénes Vargha, ed. ''Coling 88: Proceedings of the 12th conference on Computational linguistics, volume 1''. Budapest: John Von Neumann society for computing sciences. pp. 71–76. . .
*———————- (1990). "Self-Organized Language Modeling for Speech Recognition". In Alex Waibel & Kai-Fu Lee, eds. ''Readings in speech recognition''. San Mateo: Morgan Kaufmann. 629p. .
*———————-; John D. Lafferty and Robert L. Mercer. (1990) "Basic methods of probabilistic context free grammars". Technical Report RC 16374 (72684), IBM.
**Reprinted in Laface, Pietro; Renato De Mori (1992). ''Speech Recognition and Understanding: Recent advances, trends, and applications''. NATO ASI series. Series F, Computer and systems sciences, 75. New York: Springer-Verlag. pp. 345–360. .
*———————- (1997)
''Statistical Methods for Speech Recognition''
Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press. 283p.
(review)(review 2)
* Chelba, Ciprian; Frederick Jelinek (2000). "Structured Language Modeling". ''Computer Speech & Language'' 14(4):283–332. (received 2002 "Best Paper" award).
**Expanded version of a presentation at NLDB'99. Klagenfurt, Austria, June 17–19, 1999 ().
* Xu, Peng; Ahmad Emami and Frederick Jelinek (2003).
Training Connectionist Models for the Structured Language Model
. In Michael Collins and Mark Steedman, eds. ''EMNLP '03 Proceedings of the 2003 conference on Empirical methods in natural language processing''. East Stroudsburg, Penn.: Association for Computational Linguistics. pp. 160–167. . . (won "best paper" award)

References

; Notes

; References

External links

Institutional page
at Johns Hopkins university

{{DEFAULTSORT:Jelinek, Frederick
1932 births
2010 deaths
American people of Bohemian descent
American people of Czech-Jewish descent
Statistical natural language processing
Czechoslovak emigrants to the United States
Cornell University faculty
Harvard University faculty
Johns Hopkins University faculty
MIT School of Engineering alumni
IBM Research computer scientists
IBM employees
Members of the United States National Academy of Engineering
People from Kladno
Speech processing researchers
Natural language processing researchers