Enigmosauridae

''Enigmosaurus'' (meaning "Enigma lizard" or "Enigmatic lizard") is a genus of therizinosauroid that lived in Asia during the Late Cretaceous period. It was a medium-sized, ground-dwelling, bipedal herbivore that represents the third therizinosaur taxon from the Bayan Shireh Formation, although it is known from the lower part. The genus is monotypic, including only the type species ''E. mongoliensis'', known from a well preserved pelvis and other tentative body remains.

Discovery and naming

The holotype, IGM 100/84, was discovered at the Khara Khutul locality in the Bayan Shireh Formation (sometimes called Baynshire Formation or the Baynshirenskaya Svita), southeastern Mongolia, dating from the Late Cretaceous period, and first reported in 1979 on a pelvic comparison with other theropod dinosaurs. At the time, little was known about therizinosaurs. In 1980, it was mentioned again, this time in the new infraorder created by the Mongolian paleontologists Rinchen Barsbold and Altangerel Perle: Segnosauria. Nicknamed as the "Dinosaur from Khara Khutul", it was shortly described and included into the Segnosauria.

Three years later, the type species, ''Enigmosaurus mongoliensis'', was named and described in 1983 by Barsbold. The preserved elements consist of a partial skeleton, lacking the skull, that includes a well preserved pelvic girdle with other postcrania. The generic name, ''Enigmosaurus'', was stated to be derived from Greek ' (, meaning enigma) and (, meaning lizard), in reference to the aberratic and unusual shape of its pelvis. The specific name, ''mongoliensis'', refers to the country of its discovery, Mongolia.Translated paper
/ref> Some therizinosaur fossil findings at the Iren Dabasu Formation were first thought to be referable to ''Enigmosaurus''. Although it is commonly known from the pelvis, several remains not mentioned in the original description of the holotype were labelled under the same specimen number (IGM 100/84). These elements are in poor condition compared to the pelvis, and they were not measured and illustrated: proximal end of a femur; large femoral shaft, might be a tibial shaft; some ribs; distal end of a humerus; a tentative radius and the proximal end of an ulna. The femur however, was not found in association with the holotype individual, therefore it should be assigned to Therizinosauria ''incertae sedis''; the other remains might pertain to the holotype. A very large left femur, measuring long, was labelled with the same specimen number too, however, it was not associated with the holotype due to its large size (larger than the pelvis itself). Nevertheless, it seems to approach the size of the closer ''Segnosaurus''.

Possible synonymy with ''Erlikosaurus''

Some paleontologists proposed that ''Enigmosaurus'' was likely the same animal as '' Erlikosaurus'', since both were found in the same geologic formation, ''Enigmosaurus'' is known from pelvic remains, whereas the pelvis of ''Erlikosaurus'' is unknown and distinguishing traits between them were absent; if proven, this would make ''Enigmosaurus'' a junior synonym of ''Erlikosaurus''. However, the ''Enigmosaurus'' pelvis doesn't resemble that of ''Segnosaurus'' as would be expected for the connection with ''Erlikosaurus'', and there is a huge size difference. In addition, both genera are known from different strata (lower and upper), and they are considered to be distinct animals by most authors.

Description

''Enigmosaurus'' was a relatively large-bodied therizinosaur, with an estimated length of and a weight between .Genus List for Holtz 2012
/ref> As noted by Barsbold in the original description of ''Enigmosaurus'', it can recognised by the following characteristics: the pubis and ischium are short; elongated margin in the anterior presymphyseal region of the distal pubis. However, in the revised diagnosis by Zanno et al. 2010, there are even more specific traits for ''Enigmosaurus'' that were not pointed out/analyzed before: prominent cranial and caudal processes on the dorsoventrally somewhat flattened pubic boot; the pubic feet are fused, being medially elongated, a medial expansion forms a V-shaped structure; the medial fusion of the obturator process and pubic body, forms a tetraradiate process.

The holotype pelvis is in relatively good preservation, compromising the sacral vertebrae, partial ilium, right and left pubis and the left ischium. The pelvis is somewhat large as a whole and opisthopubic. The ilium is widely positioned and turned externally; it preserves a large cubic process in the posterodorsal area. Elongated pubic peduncles are present in the ilium; the ischial peduncles are more reduced though. The distal end of the pubis is elongated, recurved and stocky. The ischium, is slightly shorter than the pubis and parallel to it, with a narrow shaft. The obturator process on the front edge of the ischium is horizontally elongated and low. Open edges are appreciable on the large trochanteric fossa. Apparently, the sacrum preserves six vertebrae, with elongated transverse processes. For instance, its pelvis is very particular compared to other therizinosaur relatives, featuring areas of bone resorption and bone remodeling on the ilium. These specific traits may indicate the advanced age of the individual, if true, the fusion of the obturator process and pubic body could be discarded as an authentic autapomorphy for the species. Zanno noted that more analyses are required to settle this enigma.

Classification

''Enigmosaurus'' was by the describers assigned to a separate Enigmosauridae (now obsolete) due to its aberrant pelvis, but later considered a member of the Segnosauridae which are today called the Therizinosauridae. Lindsay Zanno in 2010 recovered a position more basal in the Therizinosauroidea.

Below are the results of the recently performed phylogenetic analysis of the Therizinosauria by Hartman et al. 2019, in which ''Enigmosaurus'' is recovered as a derived therizinosauroid.

Paleoecology

The remains of ''Enigmosaurus'' were found in sediments that were deposited during the Late Cretaceous period on the Bayan Shireh Formation, Khara Khutul locality, about 95.9 ± 6.0 million to 89.6 ± 4.0 million years ago, Cenomanian-Santonian ages. Being a therizinosaur, it was likely a slow herbivore and/or omnivore, as suggested by most authors all over the time. The biodiversity across the formation was characterized by therizinosaurs, as seen on the remains of ''Enigmosaurus'', ''Erlikosaurus'' and ''Segnosaurus''. The holotype location, Khara Khutul, has also yielded the contemporary ''Segnosaurus'' and an unnamed velociraptorine. Most of the remaining paleofauna from this formation is known from Upper strata, whereas ''Enigmosaurus'' is known from Lower strata.

At the locality, diverse paleoflora has been discovered, such as Cornaceae reported with '' Bothrocaryum gobience'' and '' Nyssoidea mongolica'' as fine representatives. Numerous fossil fruit findings at the locality reflect the large presence of angiosperm plants on the formation. The unearthed fruits bear some resemblance with ''Abelmoschus esculentus'', however, definitive taxonomic affinities are quite unclear.

See also

* Timeline of therizinosaur research
* Rinchen Barsbold
* Glossary of dinosaur anatomy
* Anatomical terms of location

References

{{Taxonbar, from=Q134611

Therizinosauria
Dinosaur genera
Late Cretaceous dinosaurs
Taxa named by Rinchen Barsbold
Taxa named by Altangerel Perle
Fossil taxa described in 1983
Dinosaurs of Mongolia