Cyrtoctenus
   HOME

TheInfoList



OR:

''Hibbertopterus'' is a genus of
eurypterid Eurypterids, often informally called sea scorpions, are a group of extinct marine arthropods that form the Order (biology), order Eurypterida. The earliest known eurypterids date to the Darriwilian stage of the Ordovician period, 467.3 Myr, mil ...
, a group of extinct marine
arthropod Arthropods ( ) are invertebrates in the phylum Arthropoda. They possess an arthropod exoskeleton, exoskeleton with a cuticle made of chitin, often Mineralization (biology), mineralised with calcium carbonate, a body with differentiated (Metam ...
s. Fossils of ''Hibbertopterus'' have been discovered in deposits ranging from the
Devonian The Devonian ( ) is a period (geology), geologic period and system (stratigraphy), system of the Paleozoic era (geology), era during the Phanerozoic eon (geology), eon, spanning 60.3 million years from the end of the preceding Silurian per ...
period in
Belgium Belgium, officially the Kingdom of Belgium, is a country in Northwestern Europe. Situated in a coastal lowland region known as the Low Countries, it is bordered by the Netherlands to the north, Germany to the east, Luxembourg to the southeas ...
,
Scotland Scotland is a Countries of the United Kingdom, country that is part of the United Kingdom. It contains nearly one-third of the United Kingdom's land area, consisting of the northern part of the island of Great Britain and more than 790 adjac ...
and the
United States The United States of America (USA), also known as the United States (U.S.) or America, is a country primarily located in North America. It is a federal republic of 50 U.S. state, states and a federal capital district, Washington, D.C. The 48 ...
to the
Carboniferous The Carboniferous ( ) is a Geologic time scale, geologic period and System (stratigraphy), system of the Paleozoic era (geology), era that spans 60 million years, from the end of the Devonian Period Ma (million years ago) to the beginning of the ...
period in Scotland,
Ireland Ireland (, ; ; Ulster Scots dialect, Ulster-Scots: ) is an island in the North Atlantic Ocean, in Northwestern Europe. Geopolitically, the island is divided between the Republic of Ireland (officially Names of the Irish state, named Irelan ...
, the
Czech Republic The Czech Republic, also known as Czechia, and historically known as Bohemia, is a landlocked country in Central Europe. The country is bordered by Austria to the south, Germany to the west, Poland to the northeast, and Slovakia to the south ...
and
South Africa South Africa, officially the Republic of South Africa (RSA), is the Southern Africa, southernmost country in Africa. Its Provinces of South Africa, nine provinces are bounded to the south by of coastline that stretches along the Atlantic O ...
. The type species, ''H. scouleri'', was first named as a species of the significantly different ''
Eurypterus ''Eurypterus'' ( ) is an extinct genus of eurypterid, a group of organisms commonly called "sea scorpions". The genus lived during the Silurian period, from around 432 to 418 million years ago. ''Eurypterus'' is by far the most well-studied and ...
'' by Samuel Hibbert in 1836. The generic name ''Hibbertopterus'', coined more than a century later, combines his name and the
Greek Greek may refer to: Anything of, from, or related to Greece, a country in Southern Europe: *Greeks, an ethnic group *Greek language, a branch of the Indo-European language family **Proto-Greek language, the assumed last common ancestor of all kno ...
word πτερόν (''pteron'') meaning "wing". ''Hibbertopterus'' was the largest eurypterid within the stylonurine suborder, with the largest fossil specimens suggesting that ''H. scouleri'' could reach lengths around 180–200 centimetres (5.9–6.6 ft). Though this is significantly smaller than the largest eurypterid overall, ''
Jaekelopterus ''Jaekelopterus'' is a genus of predatory eurypterid Eurypterids, often informally called sea scorpions, are a group of extinct marine arthropods that form the Order (biology), order Eurypterida. The earliest known eurypterids date to the ...
'', which could reach lengths of around , ''Hibbertopterus'' is likely to have been the heaviest due to its broad and compact body. Furthermore, trackway evidence indicates that the South African species ''H. wittebergensis'' might have reached lengths similar to ''Jaekelopterus''. Like many other stylonurine eurypterids, ''Hibbertopterus'' fed through a method called sweep-feeding. It used its specialised forward-facing
appendages An appendage (or outgrowth) is an external body part or natural prolongation that protrudes from an organism's body such as an arm or a leg. Protrusions from single-celled bacteria and archaea are known as cell-surface appendages or surface app ...
(limbs), equipped with several spines, to rake through the
substrate Substrate may refer to: Physical layers *Substrate (biology), the natural environment in which an organism lives, or the surface or medium on which an organism grows or is attached ** Substrate (aquatic environment), the earthy material that exi ...
of the environments in which it lived in search for small invertebrates to eat, which it could then push towards its mouth. Though long hypothesised, the fact that eurypterids were capable of terrestrial locomotion was definitely proven through the discovery of a fossil trackway made by ''Hibbertopterus'' in Scotland. The trackway showed that an animal measuring around had slowly lumbered across a stretch of land, dragging its
telson The telson () is the hindmost division of the body of an arthropod. Depending on the definition, the telson is either considered to be the final segment (biology), segment of the arthropod body, or an additional division that is not a true segm ...
(the posteriormost division of its body) across the ground after it. How ''Hibbertopterus'' could survive on land, however briefly, is unknown but it might have been possible through either its gills being able to function in air as long as they were wet or by the animal possessing a dual
respiratory system The respiratory system (also respiratory apparatus, ventilatory system) is a biological system consisting of specific organs and structures used for gas exchange in animals and plants. The anatomy and physiology that make this happen varies grea ...
, theorised to have been present in at least some eurypterids. Though sometimes, and often historically, treated as distinct genera, the hibbertopterid eurypterids ''Cyrtoctenus'' and ''Dunsopterus'' have been suggested to represent adult
ontogenetic stage Ontogeny (also ontogenesis) is the origination and development of an organism (both physical and psychological, e.g., moral development), usually from the time of fertilization of the egg to adult. The term can also be used to refer to the stu ...
s of ''Hibbertopterus''. The features of fossils associated with these genera suggest that the sweep-feeding strategy of ''Hibbertopterus'' changed significantly over the course of its life, from simpler raking organs present in younger specimens to specialised comb-like organs capable of trapping prey (rather than simply pushing it towards the mouth) in adults.


Description

Like other known
hibbertopterid Hibbertopteridae (the name deriving from the type genus ''Hibbertopterus'', meaning "Samuel Hibbert-Ware, Hibbert's wing") is a family of Eurypterid, eurypterids, an extinct group of aquatic Arthropod, arthropods. They were members of the superfam ...
eurypterid Eurypterids, often informally called sea scorpions, are a group of extinct marine arthropods that form the Order (biology), order Eurypterida. The earliest known eurypterids date to the Darriwilian stage of the Ordovician period, 467.3 Myr, mil ...
s, ''Hibbertopterus'' was a large, broad-bodied and heavy animal. It was the largest known eurypterid of the suborder
Stylonurina Stylonurina is one of two suborders of eurypterids, a group of extinct arthropods commonly known as "sea scorpions". Members of the suborder are collectively and informally known as "stylonurine eurypterids" or "stylonurines". They are known from ...
, composed of those eurypterids that lacked swimming paddles. A
carapace A carapace is a dorsal (upper) section of the exoskeleton or shell in a number of animal groups, including arthropods, such as crustaceans and arachnids, as well as vertebrates, such as turtles and tortoises. In turtles and tortoises, the unde ...
(the part of the
exoskeleton An exoskeleton () . is a skeleton that is on the exterior of an animal in the form of hardened integument, which both supports the body's shape and protects the internal organs, in contrast to an internal endoskeleton (e.g. human skeleton, that ...
which covered the head) referred to the species ''H. scouleri'', from
Carboniferous The Carboniferous ( ) is a Geologic time scale, geologic period and System (stratigraphy), system of the Paleozoic era (geology), era that spans 60 million years, from the end of the Devonian Period Ma (million years ago) to the beginning of the ...
Scotland Scotland is a Countries of the United Kingdom, country that is part of the United Kingdom. It contains nearly one-third of the United Kingdom's land area, consisting of the northern part of the island of Great Britain and more than 790 adjac ...
, measures wide. Since ''Hibbertopterus'' was unusually wide relative to its length for a eurypterid, the animal in question would probably have measured around 180–200 centimetres (5.9–6.6 ft) in length. Even though there were eurypterids of greater length (such as ''
Jaekelopterus ''Jaekelopterus'' is a genus of predatory eurypterid Eurypterids, often informally called sea scorpions, are a group of extinct marine arthropods that form the Order (biology), order Eurypterida. The earliest known eurypterids date to the ...
'' and '' Carcinosoma''), ''Hibbertopterus'' was very deep-bodied and compact in comparison to other eurypterids and the mass of the specimen in question would likely have rivalled that of other giant eurypterids (and other giant arthropods), if not surpassed them. In addition to fossil finds of large specimens, fossil trackways attributed to the species ''H. wittebergensis'' from South Africa indicates an animal around in length (the same size attributed to the largest known eurypterid, ''Jaekelopterus''), though the largest known fossil specimens of the species only appear to have reached lengths of . The forward-facing
appendages An appendage (or outgrowth) is an external body part or natural prolongation that protrudes from an organism's body such as an arm or a leg. Protrusions from single-celled bacteria and archaea are known as cell-surface appendages or surface app ...
(limbs) of ''Hibbertopterus'' (pairs 2, 3 and 4) were specialised for gathering food. The
distal Standard anatomical terms of location are used to describe unambiguously the anatomy of humans and other animals. The terms, typically derived from Latin or Greek roots, describe something in its standard anatomical position. This position provi ...
podomere The arthropod leg is a form of jointed appendage of arthropods, usually used for walking. Many of the terms used for arthropod leg segments (called podomeres) are of Latin origin, and may be confused with terms for bones: ''coxa'' (meaning hip, : ...
s (leg segments) of these three pairs of limbs were covered with long spines, and the end of each limb was covered with sensory organs. These adaptations suggest that ''Hibbertopterus'', like other hibbertopterids, would have fed by a method referred to as sweep-feeding, using its limbs to sweep through the
substrate Substrate may refer to: Physical layers *Substrate (biology), the natural environment in which an organism lives, or the surface or medium on which an organism grows or is attached ** Substrate (aquatic environment), the earthy material that exi ...
of its environment in search for food. The fourth pair of appendages, though used in feeding like the second and third pairs, was also used for locomotion and the two final pairs of legs (pairs five and six overall) were solely locomotory. As such, ''Hibbertopterus'' would have used a
hexapoda The subphylum Hexapoda (from Greek for 'six legs') or hexapods comprises the largest clade of arthropods and includes most of the extant arthropod species. It includes the crown group class Insecta (true insects), as well as the much smaller c ...
l (six-legged) gait. Although not enough fossil material is known of the other hibbertopterid eurypterids to discuss the differences between them with full confidence, ''Hibbertopterus'' is defined based on a collection of definite characteristics. The
telson The telson () is the hindmost division of the body of an arthropod. Depending on the definition, the telson is either considered to be the final segment (biology), segment of the arthropod body, or an additional division that is not a true segm ...
(the posteriormost division of the body) was hastate (e.g. shaped like a ''
gladius ''Gladius'' () is a Latin word properly referring to the type of sword that was used by Ancient Rome, ancient Roman foot soldiers starting from the 3rd century BC and until the 3rd century AD. Linguistically, within Latin, the word also came t ...
'', a
Roman Roman or Romans most often refers to: *Rome, the capital city of Italy *Ancient Rome, Roman civilization from 8th century BC to 5th century AD *Roman people, the people of Roman civilization *Epistle to the Romans, shortened to Romans, a letter w ...
sword) and had a keel running down the middle, with in turn had a small indentation in its own centre. The walking legs of ''Hibbertopterus'' had extensions at their base and lacked longitudinal posterior grooves in all of its podomeres (leg segments).Jeram, Andrew J.; Selden, Paul A. (1993)
"Eurypterids from the Viséan of East Kirkton, West Lothian, Scotland"
''Earth and Environmental Science Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh''. 84 (3-4): 301–308. doi: 10.1017/S0263593300006118.
ISSN An International Standard Serial Number (ISSN) is an eight-digit to uniquely identify a periodical publication (periodical), such as a magazine. The ISSN is especially helpful in distinguishing between serials with the same title. ISSNs a ...
  1755-6929.
Some of these characteristics, in particular the shape of the telson, are thought to have been shared by other hibbertopterids, which are much less well preserved than ''Hibbertopterus'' itself.


Table of species

The status of the 10 species listed below follow a 2018 surveyDunlop, J. A., Penney, D. & Jekel, D. 2018
A summary list of fossil spiders and their relatives
In World Spider Catalog. Natural History Museum Bern
by German paleontologists Jason A. Dunlop and Denise Jekel and British paleontologist David Penney and size- and temporal ranges follow a 2009 study by American paleontologists James Lamsdell and Simon J. Braddy unless otherwise noted. The distinguishing features of ''H. caledonicus'', ''H. dewalquei'', ''H. ostraviensis'' and ''H. peachi'' follow the 1968 description of these species. The descriptors, Norwegian paleontologist Leif Størmer and British paleontologist Charles D. Waterston, did not consider these species to represent eurypterids, though any emended diagnosis of them is yet to be published.


History of research

In 1831, Scottish naturalist John Scouler described the remains, consisting of a massive and unusual
prosoma The cephalothorax, also called prosoma in some groups, is a tagma of various arthropods, comprising the head and the thorax fused together, as distinct from the abdomen behind. (The terms ''prosoma'' and ''opisthosoma'' are equivalent to ''cepha ...
(head) and several tergites (segments from the back of the animal), of a large and strange arthropod discovered in deposits in Scotland of Lower Carboniferous age, but did not assign a name to the fossils. Through Scouler's examination, the fossils represent the second eurypterid to be scientifically studied, just six years after the 1825 description of ''
Eurypterus ''Eurypterus'' ( ) is an extinct genus of eurypterid, a group of organisms commonly called "sea scorpions". The genus lived during the Silurian period, from around 432 to 418 million years ago. ''Eurypterus'' is by far the most well-studied and ...
'' itself. Five years later, in 1836, British geologist Samuel Hibbert redescribed the same fossil specimens, giving them the name ''Eurypterus scouleri''. The eurypterid genus ''Glyptoscorpius'' was named by British geologist
Ben Peach Benjamin Neeve Peach (6 September 1842 – 29 January 1926) was a British geologist. Life Peach was born at Gorran Haven in Cornwall on 6 September 1842 to Jemima Mabson and Charles William Peach, an amateur British naturalist and geologis ...
, who also named the species ''G. perornatus'' (treated as the type species of ''Glyptoscorpius'' by later researchers although it had not originally been designated as such) in 1882. The genus was based on ''G. perornatus'' and the fragmentary species ''G. caledonicus'', previously described as the plant ''Cycadites caledonicus'' by English paleontologist
John William Salter John William Salter (15 December 1820 – 2 December 1869) was an English naturalist, geologist, and palaeontologist. Salter was apprenticed in 1835 to James De Carle Sowerby, and was engaged in drawing and engraving the plates for Sowerby' ...
in 1863. This designation was reinforced with more fossil fragments discovered in the Coomsdon Burn, which Peach referred to ''Glyptoscorpius caledonicus''. In 1887 Peach described ''G. minutisculptus'' from
Mount Vernon Mount Vernon is the former residence and plantation of George Washington, a Founding Father, commander of the Continental Army in the Revolutionary War, and the first president of the United States, and his wife, Martha. An American landmar ...
,
Glasgow Glasgow is the Cities of Scotland, most populous city in Scotland, located on the banks of the River Clyde in Strathclyde, west central Scotland. It is the List of cities in the United Kingdom, third-most-populous city in the United Kingdom ...
, and ''G. kidstoni'' from
Radstock Radstock is a town and civil parish on the northern slope of the Mendip Hills in Somerset, England, about south-west of Bath and north-west of Frome. It is within the area of the unitary authority of Bath and North East Somerset. The Radsto ...
in
Somerset Somerset ( , ), Archaism, archaically Somersetshire ( , , ) is a Ceremonial counties of England, ceremonial county in South West England. It is bordered by the Bristol Channel, Gloucestershire, and Bristol to the north, Wiltshire to the east ...
. Peach's ''Glyptoscorpius'' is highly problematic; some of the diagnostic characteristics used when describing it are either questionable or outright meaningless. For instance, the original description had been based on ''G. caledonicus'' and ''G. perornatus'' but since the parts of the body preserved in the fossils described don't completely overlap it is impossible to say if Peach's diagnostic characteristics actually apply to the two original species. Though only represented by two small, jointed and vaguely cylindrical fossil fragments (both discovered in the Portage sandstones of Italy, New York), the species today recognised as ''H. wrightianus'' has had a complicated taxonomic history. Originally described in 1881 as a species of plant, the fragmentary fossil referred to as "'' Equisetides wrightiana''" was noted to represent the fossil remains of a eurypterid by American paleontologist James Hall in 1884, three years later. Though Hall assigned the species to ''Stylonurus'', that same year British paleontologists Henry Woodward and Thomas Rupert Jones assigned the fossil to the genus '' Echinocaris'', believing the fossils represented a
phyllocarid Phyllocarida is a subclass of crustaceans, comprising the extant order Leptostraca and the extinct orders Hymenostraca and Archaeostraca. This clade of marine crustaceans diversified extensively during the Ordovician The Ordovician ( ) is a ...
crustacean Crustaceans (from Latin meaning: "those with shells" or "crusted ones") are invertebrate animals that constitute one group of arthropods that are traditionally a part of the subphylum Crustacea (), a large, diverse group of mainly aquatic arthrop ...
. The assignment to ''Echinocaris'' was probably based on the slightly spinose surface of the fossils, but in 1888 Hall and American paleontologist
John Mason Clarke John Mason Clarke (April 15, 1857 – May 29, 1925) was an American teacher, geologist and paleontologist. __TOC__ Early career Born in Canandaigua, New York, the fifth of six children of Noah Turner Clarke and Laura Mason Merrill, he attended ...
pointed out that no described ''Echinocaris'' actually had spines similar to what Woodward and Jones suggested and as such, reassigned the species back to ''Stylonurus'', interpreting the fossils as fragments of the long walking legs. An assignment to ''Stylonurus'' was affirmed by Clarke and American paleontologist
Rudolf Ruedemann Rudolf Ruedemann (October 16, 1864–June 18, 1956) was a German American paleontologist, widely known as an expert in graptolites, enigmatic fossil animals. He worked at the New York State Museum for over 40 years, including a decade as State ...
in their influential ''The Eurypterida of New York'' in 1912, though no distinguishing features of the fossils were given due to their fragmentary nature. Inexplicably, ''Pterygotus hibernicus'' (a species described by British paleontologist William Hellier Baily in 1872) was reassigned to ''Hibbertopterus'' by American paleontologist Erik N. Kjellesvig-Waering in 1964 as part of a greater, but apparently flawed re-examination of the various species assigned to the family Pterygotidae. Kjellesvig-Waering retained ''P. dicki'' as part of ''Pterygotus''. Scottish paleontologists Lyall I. Anderson and Nigel H. Trewin and German paleontologist Jason A. Dunlop noted in 2000 that Kjellesvig-Waering's acceptance of the original designation for ''Pterygotus dicki'' was "burdensome" as it is based on highly fragmentary material. They noted that like many other pterygotid species, ''P. dicki'' represented yet another name applied to some scattered segments, a practice they deemed "taxonomically unsound". Though they suggested that further research was required to determine whether or not the taxon was valid at all, they did note that the presence of a fringe to the segments formed by their ornamentation was absent in all other species of ''Pterygotus'', but "strikingly similar" to what was present in ''Cyrtoctenus''. Subsequent research treated ''P. dicki'' as a species of ''Cyrtoctenus''. When Kjellesvig-Waering designated the genus ''Hibbertopterus'' in 1959, ''Eurypterus scouleri'' had already been referred to (considered a species of) the related ''
Campylocephalus ''Campylocephalus'' is a genus of eurypterid, a group of extinct aquatic arthropods. Fossils of ''Campylocephalus'' have been discovered in deposits ranging from the Carboniferous period in the Czech Republic (the species ''C. salmi'') to the Pe ...
'' for some time. Kjellesvig-Waering recognised ''Campylocephalus scouleri'' as distinct from the type species of that genus, ''C. oculatus'', in that the prosoma of ''Campylocephalus'' was more narrow, had a subelliptical (almost elliptical) shape and had its widest point in the middle rather than at the base. Further differences were noted in the position and shape of the animal's compound eyes, which in ''Hibbertopterus'' are surrounded by a ring-like shape of hardened integument (absent in ''Campylocephalus''). The eyes of ''Hibbertopterus'' are also located near the center of the head whereas those of ''Campylocephalus'' are located further back. The generic name ''Hibbertopterus'' was selected to honor the original descriptor of ''H. scouleri'', Samuel Hibbert. The fact that ''Glyptoscorpius'' was questionable at best and that its type species, ''G. perornatus'', (and other species, such as ''G. kidstoni'') had recently been referred to the genus '' Adelophthalmus'' prompted Norwegian paleontologist Leif Størmer and British paleontologist Charles D. Waterston to in 1968 re-examine the various species that had been referred to it. Because ''G. perornatus'' was the type species of ''Glyptoscorpius'', the genus itself became synonymous with ''Adelophthalmus''. That same year, the species ''G. minutisculptus'' had been designated the type species of a distinct eurypterid genus, '' Vernonopterus''. Størmer and Waterston concluded that the ''Glyptoscorpius'' species ''G. caledonicus'' was to be part of a new genus, which they named ''Cyrtoctenus'' (the name deriving from the Greek ''Cyrtoctenos'', a curved comb) and they named a new species, ''C. peachi'' (named in honour of Ben Peach), as its type. Both of these species were based on fragmentary fossil remains. Furthermore, the species ''G. stevensoni'', named in 1936, was referred to the new genus ''Dunsopterus''. The key diagnostic feature of ''Cyrtoctenus'' was its comb-like first appendages. Waterston remarked in another 1968 paper that the "controversial" ''Stylonurus wrightianus'' was similar to the unusual and massive prosomal appendage of ''Dunsopterus'' and as such reassigned ''S. wrightianus'' to ''Dunsopterus'', creating ''Dunsopterus wrightianus''. Other than ''C. peachi'' and ''C. caledonicus'', further species were added to ''Cyrtoctenus'' by Størmer and Waterston; ''Eurypterus dewalquei'', described in 1889, and '' Ctenopterus ostraviensis'', described in 1951, became ''Cyrtoctenus dewalquei'' and ''C. ostraviensis'', respectively. Despite noting the presence of eurypterid-type tergites, Størmer and Waterston thought that the ''Cyrtoctenus'' fossils represented remains of a new order of aquatic arthropods which they dubbed "Cyrtoctenida". The species ''C. dewalquei'' had originally been described as the fragmentary remains of a eurypterid in 1889 was assigned to ''Cyrtoctenus'' on the basis of the perceived filaments present on its appendages, similar to those of ''C. peachi''. Størmer and Waterston disregarded specimens referred to ''C. caledonicus'' other than the unique fragmentary type specimen, which at this point had been plastically preserved in sandstone. Like ''C. caledonicus'', ''C. ostraviensis'' was also known only from a single specimen, a fragment of an appendage described in 1951. No distinguishing features were given for the species, and the authors noted that it was possibly synonymous with ''C. peachi'', but they chose to maintain it as distinct due to the very limited fossil material. Known from a single specimen described in 1985, ''H. wittebergensis'' (described as ''Cyrtoctenus wittebergensis'') is the only species of ''Hibbertopterus'' known from reasonably complete remains other than the type species itself. The fossil, discovered in the Waaipoort Formation near Klaarstroom,
Cape Province The Province of the Cape of Good Hope (), commonly referred to as the Cape Province () and colloquially as The Cape (), was a province in the Union of South Africa and subsequently the Republic of South Africa. It encompassed the old Cape Co ...
,
South Africa South Africa, officially the Republic of South Africa (RSA), is the Southern Africa, southernmost country in Africa. Its Provinces of South Africa, nine provinces are bounded to the south by of coastline that stretches along the Atlantic O ...
, is remarkably complete, preserving not only the prosoma, the telson and several tergites, but also coxae and even part of the digestive system. The discovery was also important for eurypterid research in general, since it represents one of the few eurypterids known from the southern hemisphere, where eurypterid finds are rare and usually fragmentary. The presence of the gut in the fossil proves that the specimen represents a dead individual, and not only
exuviae In biology, exuviae are the remains of an exoskeleton and related structures that are left after ecdysozoans (including insects, crustaceans and arachnids) have molted. The exuviae of an animal can be important to biologists as they can often be ...
, and scientists examining it could conclude that it had been preserved as lying on its back. The description of ''H. wittebergensis'' affirmed that the "cyrtoctenids" were definitely ''Hibbertopterus''-type eurypterids, not representatives of a new order of arthropods.


Classification

''Hibbertopterus'' is classified as part of the family Hibbertopteridae, which it also lends its name to, a family of eurypterids within the
superfamily SUPERFAMILY is a database and search platform of structural and functional annotation for all proteins and genomes. It classifies amino acid sequences into known structural domains, especially into SCOP superfamilies. Domains are functional, str ...
Mycteropoidea, alongside the genera ''Campylocephalus'' and ''Vernonopterus''. The hibbertopterids are united as a group by being large mycteropoids with broad prosomas, a hastate telson similar to that of ''Hibbertopterus'', ornamentation consisting of scales or other similar structures on the exoskeleton, the fourth pair of appendages possessing spines, the more posterior tergites of the abdomen possessing tongue-shaped scales near their edges and there being lobes positioned posterolaterally (posteriorly on both sides) on the prosoma. Historically, the morphology of ''Hibbertopterus'' and the other hibbertopterids has been seen as so unusual that they have been thought to be an order separate from
Eurypterida Eurypterids, often informally called sea scorpions, are a group of extinct marine arthropods that form the order Eurypterida. The earliest known eurypterids date to the Darriwilian stage of the Ordovician period, 467.3 million years ago. The ...
. The features of ''Campylocephalus'' and ''Vernonopterus'' makes it clear that both genera represent hibbertopterid eurypterids, but the incomplete nature of all fossil specimens referred to them make any further study of the precise
phylogenetic In biology, phylogenetics () is the study of the evolutionary history of life using observable characteristics of organisms (or genes), which is known as phylogenetic inference. It infers the relationship among organisms based on empirical dat ...
relationships within the Hibbertopteridae difficult. Both genera could even represent synonyms of ''Hibbertopterus'' itself, though the highly incomplete nature of their remains again makes that hypothesis impossible to confirm. The cladogram below is adapted from Lamsdell (2012), collapsed to only show the superfamily Mycteropoidea.


''Cyrtoctenus'' and ''Dunsopterus''

Many analyses and overviews treat the ten species assigned to ''Hibbertopterus'' as composing three separate, but closely related, hibbertopterid genera. In these arrangements, ''Hibbertopterus'' is typically restricted to the species ''H. scouleri'' and ''H. hibernicus'', with the species ''H. stevensoni'' being the type and only species of the genus ''Dunsopterus'' and the species ''H. caledonicus'', ''H. dewalquei'', ''H. dicki'', ''H. ostraviensis'', ''H. peachi'' and ''H. wittebergensis'' being referred to the genus ''Cyrtoctenus'' (where ''H. peachi'' is the type species). The idea that ''Dunsopterus'' and ''Cyrtoctenus'' were congeneric (e.g. synonymous) was first suggested by British geologist Charles D. Waterston in 1985. ''Dunsopterus'' is known from very fragmentary material, mainly
sclerite A sclerite (Greek language, Greek , ', meaning "hardness, hard") is a hardened body part. In various branches of biology the term is applied to various structures, but not as a rule to vertebrate anatomical features such as bones and teeth. Instea ...
s (various hardened body parts) which have little diagnostic potential and are poorly known in fossils attributed to ''Cyrtoctenus''. The morphology of fossils attributed to ''Dunsopterus'' and ''Cyrtoctenus'' does suggest that they were more specialised than ''H. scouleri'', particularly in their adaptations to sweep-feeding. If valid, ''Cyrtoctenus'' would have had further adaptations towards sweep-feeding than any other hibbertopterid, with its blades modified into comb-like rachis that could entrap smaller prey or other organic food particles. It was suggested as early as 1993 by American paleontologist Paul Selden and British paleontologist Andrew J. Jeram that these adaptations might not have been due to ''Dunsopterus'' and ''Cyrtoctenus'' representing more derived genera of hibbertopterids, but rather due to both genera perhaps representing adult forms of ''Hibbertopterus''. In this case, the development of the more specialized sweep-feeding method of ''Cyrtoctenus'' can directly be explained by the larger size of the specimens referred to ''Cyrtoctenus''. The method of ''Hibbertopterus'', which involves raking, would have become significantly less effective the larger the animal grew since a larger and larger portion of its prey would be small enough to pass between its sweep-feeding spines. Any specimen over the size of a metre (3.2 ft) which continued to feed on small invertebrates would need modified sweep-feeding appendages or would need to employ a different feeding method altogether. As such, it is more than possible that later
ontogenetic stage Ontogeny (also ontogenesis) is the origination and development of an organism (both physical and psychological, e.g., moral development), usually from the time of fertilization of the egg to adult. The term can also be used to refer to the stu ...
s of ''Hibbertopterus'' developed the structures seen in ''Cyrtoctenus'' to be able to continue to feed at larger body sizes. Fossil specimens of ''Hibbertopterus'' frequently occur together with fragments referred to ''Cyrtoctenus'', ''Dunsopterus'' and ''Vernonopterus''. The three fragmentary genera were suggested to by synonyms of each other by American paleontologist James Lamsdell in 2010, which would have meant the oldest name, ''Dunsopterus'', taking priority and subsuming both ''Cyrtoctenus'' and ''Vernonopterus'' as
junior synonyms In taxonomy, the scientific classification of living organisms, a synonym is an alternative scientific name for the accepted scientific name of a taxon. The botanical and zoological codes of nomenclature treat the concept of synonymy differently. ...
. Following studies on the ontogeny of '' Drepanopterus'', a more primitid mycteropoid eurypterid, large-scale changes in the developments of the appendages over the course of the life of a single animal have been proven to have happened in some eurypterids. One of the key features distinguishing ''Cyrtoctenus'' from ''Hibbertopterus'' is the presence of grooves on its podomeres, which studies on ''Drepanopterus'' suggest might have been a feature which appeared late in an animal's life cycle. Differences in the positions of the eyes in specimens of ''Hibbertopterus'' and ''Cyrtoctenus'' is not surprising as movements of the eyes through ontogeny has been described in other eurypterid genera. Lamsdell considered it almost certain that ''Dunsopterus'' was a junior synonym of ''Hibbertopterus'' and that ''Cyrtoctenus'' and ''Vernonopterus'' in turn represented junior synonyms of ''Dunsopterus'', which would subsume all three into ''Hibbertopterus''. Synonymizing ''Hibbertopterus'' with ''Cyrtoctenus'' and ''Dunsopterus'' would also explain why smaller ''Hibbertopterus'' specimens are more complete than the known fossil remains of ''Cyrtoctenus'', often fragmentary. The majority of ''Hibbertopterus'' specimens would then represent exuviae whilst ''Cyrtoctenus'' specimens represent the actual mortalities, susceptible to
scavenger Scavengers are animals that consume Corpse decomposition, dead organisms that have died from causes other than predation or have been killed by other predators. While scavenging generally refers to carnivores feeding on carrion, it is also a he ...
s. In a 2019 graduate thesis, American geologist Emily Hughes suggested the synonymization of ''Hibbertopterus'' and ''Dunsopterus'' due to the "strong morphological similarities" between them, and as ''Dunsopterus'' was found to be paraphyletic in regards to ''Cyrtoctenus'', all three were subsumed into just ''Hibbertopterus''. In particular, she noted that though the feeding appendages were different, the ornamentation and form of the raking tools seen in ''Hibbertopterus'' were probably the precursors of the more moveable finger-like organs present in ''Cyrtoctenus''. Hughes suggested that ''Vernonopterus'', due to its distinct ornamentation, represented a genus distinct from ''Hibbertopterus''. The same conclusions and suggestions were also published in a later 2020 conference abstract, co-authored by Hughes and James Lamsdell. However, a 2023 study describing a new species ''H. lamsdelli'' argued that ''Dunsopterus'' and ''Vernonopterus'' should be synonymized with ''Hibbertopterus'', while ''Cyrtoctenus'' is distinct from it.


Palaeoecology

Hibbertopterids such as ''Hibbertopterus'' were sweep-feeders, having modified spines on their forward-facing prosomal appendages that allowed them to rake through the substrate of their living environments. Though sweep-feeding was used as a strategy by many genera within the Stylonurina, it was most developed within the hibbertopterids, which possessed blades on the second, third and fourth pair of appendages. Inhabiting freshwater swamps and rivers, the diet of ''Hibbertopterus'' and other sweep-feeders was probably composed of what they could find raking through its living environment, likely primarily small invertebrates. This method of feeding is quite similar to
filter feeding Filter feeders are aquatic animals that acquire nutrients by feeding on organic matters, food particles or smaller organisms (bacteria, microalgae and zooplanktons) suspended in water, typically by having the water pass over or through a spe ...
. This has led some researchers to suggest that ''Hibbertopterus'' would have been a
pelagic The pelagic zone consists of the water column of the open ocean and can be further divided into regions by depth. The word ''pelagic'' is derived . The pelagic zone can be thought of as an imaginary cylinder or water column between the sur ...
animal, as modern filter feeding crustaceans, but the robust and massive nature of the genus (in contrast to modern filter feeding crustaceans which are typically very small) makes such a conclusion unlikely. The chelicerae (pincers) of ''Hibbertopterus'' were weak and they would not have been able to grasp any potential prey which means ''Hibbertopterus'' would probably have been incapable of preying on larger animals. The conclusion that ''Hibbertopterus'' wasn't preying on large animals is also supported by the complete lack of adaptations towards any organs used for trapping prey in younger specimens (though they are present on adult specimens once referred to ''Cyrtoctenus'') and a lack of swimming adaptations. Through sweep-feeding, ''Hibbertopterus'' could sweep up small animals from the soft sediments of shallow bodies of water, presumably small crustaceans and other arthropods, and could then sweep them into its mouth when it detected them. Through the different adaptations of juveniles and adults ("''Cyrtoctenus''"), individuals of different ages would possibly have preferred different types of prey, which would have reduced competition between members of the same genus.Hughes, Emily Samantha (2019),
Discerning the Diets of Sweep-Feeding Eurypterids Through Analyses of Mesh-Modified Appendage Armature
. ''Graduate Theses, Dissertations, and Problem Reports''. 3890.
A fossil trackway discovered near
St Andrews St Andrews (; ; , pronounced ʰʲɪʎˈrˠiː.ɪɲ is a town on the east coast of Fife in Scotland, southeast of Dundee and northeast of Edinburgh. St Andrews had a recorded population of 16,800 , making it Fife's fourth-largest settleme ...
in
Fife Fife ( , ; ; ) is a council areas of Scotland, council area and lieutenancy areas of Scotland, lieutenancy area in Scotland. A peninsula, it is bordered by the Firth of Tay to the north, the North Sea to the east, the Firth of Forth to the s ...
, Scotland, reveals that ''Hibbertopterus'' was capable of at least limited
terrestrial locomotion Terrestrial locomotion has evolution, evolved as animals adapted from ecoregion#Marine, aquatic to ecoregion#Terrestrial, terrestrial environments. Animal locomotion, Locomotion on land raises different problems than that in water, with reduced f ...
. The trackway found was roughly long and wide, and suggests that the eurypterid responsible was long, consistent with other giant sizes attributed to ''Hibbertopterus''. The tracks indicate a lumbering, jerky and dragging movement. Scarps with crescent-shapes were left by the outer limbs, inner markings were made by the keeled belly and the telson carved a central groove. The slow progression and dragging of the tail indicate that the animal responsible was moving out of water. The presence of terrestrial tracks indicate that ''Hibbertopterus'' was able to survive on land at least briefly, possible due to the probability that their gills could function in air as long as they remained wet. Additionally, some studies suggest that eurypterids possessed a dual
respiratory system The respiratory system (also respiratory apparatus, ventilatory system) is a biological system consisting of specific organs and structures used for gas exchange in animals and plants. The anatomy and physiology that make this happen varies grea ...
, which would allow short periods of time in terrestrial environments. In the Midland Valley of Scotland, 27 kilometres (16.8 miles) to the west of
Edinburgh Edinburgh is the capital city of Scotland and one of its 32 Council areas of Scotland, council areas. The city is located in southeast Scotland and is bounded to the north by the Firth of Forth and to the south by the Pentland Hills. Edinburgh ...
,
East Kirkton Quarry East Kirkton Quarry, or simply East Kirkton, is a former limestone quarry in West Lothian, Scotland, now a renowned fossil site. The quarry is known for terrestrial and freshwater fossils up to 341 million years old, from the Viséan stage of ...
contains deposits that were once a freshwater lake near a volcano. The locality has preserved a diverse fauna of the Viséan age of the Carboniferous (about 335 million years ago). Other than ''H. scouleri'', the fauna includes several terrestrial animals, such as anthracosaurs, aistopods, baphetids and
temnospondyls Temnospondyli (from Greek τέμνειν, ''temnein'' 'to cut' and σπόνδυλος, ''spondylos'' 'vertebra') or temnospondyls is a diverse ancient order of small to giant tetrapods—often considered primitive amphibians—that flourished wo ...
, representing some of the oldest known terrestrial
tetrapod A tetrapod (; from Ancient Greek :wiktionary:τετρα-#Ancient Greek, τετρα- ''(tetra-)'' 'four' and :wiktionary:πούς#Ancient Greek, πούς ''(poús)'' 'foot') is any four-Limb (anatomy), limbed vertebrate animal of the clade Tetr ...
s. Several terrestrial invertebrates are also known from the location, including several species of
millipede Millipedes (originating from the Latin , "thousand", and , "foot") are a group of arthropods that are characterised by having two pairs of jointed legs on most body segments; they are known scientifically as the class Diplopoda, the name derive ...
s, '' Gigantoscorpio'' (one of the earliest
scorpion Scorpions are predatory arachnids of the Order (biology), order Scorpiones. They have eight legs and are easily recognized by a pair of Chela (organ), grasping pincers and a narrow, segmented tail, often carried in a characteristic forward cur ...
s proven to have been terrestrial) and early representatives of the
Opiliones The Opiliones (formerly Phalangida) are an Order (biology), order of arachnids, Common name, colloquially known as harvestmen, harvesters, harvest spiders, or daddy longlegs (see below). , over 6,650 species of harvestmen have been discovered w ...
. The site also preserves abundant plant life, including the genera ''
Lepidodendron ''Lepidodendron'' is an extinct genus of primitive lycopodian vascular plants belonging the order Lepidodendrales. It is well preserved and common in the fossil record. Like other Lepidodendrales, species of ''Lepidodendron'' grew as large-tree ...
'', '' Lepidophloios'', ''
Stigmaria ''Stigmaria'' is a form taxon for common fossils found in Carboniferous rocks. They represent the underground rooting structures of arborescent lycophytes such as ''Sigillaria'' and '' Lepidodendron'' under the order '' Lepidodendrales.'' Descr ...
'' and ''
Sphenopteris ''Sphenopteris'' is a genus of seed ferns containing the foliage of various extinct plants, ranging from the Devonian to Late Cretaceous. One species, ''S. höninghausi'', was transferred to the genus '' Crossotheca'' in 1911. Biology The fro ...
''. Locally, the strange fossil carapaces of ''H. scouleri'' have been given the
common name In biology, a common name of a taxon or organism (also known as a vernacular name, English name, colloquial name, country name, popular name, or farmer's name) is a name that is based on the normal language of everyday life; and is often con ...
"Scouler's heids" ("heid" being Scots for "head"). The Waaipoort Formation, where ''H. wittebergensis'' has been discovered, also preserves a diverse Carboniferous fauna and some species of plants. Interpreted as having been a large and open fresh to brackish water lake, with possibly occasional influences by storms and glacial processes, fossil remains recovered is most commonly that of various types of fish. Among these types are palaeoniscoids,
shark Sharks are a group of elasmobranch cartilaginous fish characterized by a ribless endoskeleton, dermal denticles, five to seven gill slits on each side, and pectoral fins that are not fused to the head. Modern sharks are classified within the ...
s and
acanthodians Acanthodii or acanthodians is an extinct class of gnathostomes (jawed fishes). They are currently considered to represent a paraphyletic grade of various fish lineages basal to extant Chondrichthyes, which includes living sharks, rays, and c ...
. Though shark material is too fragmentary to be identifiable, at least some fossils might represent the remains of protacrodontoids. Among the acanthodians, at least three genera have been identified from fossil scales and spines, including the derived climatiiform ''
Gyracanthides ''Gyracanthides'' is an extinct genus of Acanthodii, acanthodian gnathostome, known from Devonian to Mississippian (geology), Early Carboniferous. Description ''Gyracanthides'' is large Acanthodii, acanthodian, ''G. murrayi'' reached the lengt ...
''. Among the palaeoniscoids, eight distinct genera have been identified. Several of these palaeoniscoid genera also occur in deposits of similar age in Scotland. Other than ''H. wittebergensis'', the only known invertebrates are two rare species of
bivalves Bivalvia () or bivalves, in previous centuries referred to as the Lamellibranchiata and Pelecypoda, is a class of aquatic molluscs (marine and freshwater) that have laterally compressed soft bodies enclosed by a calcified exoskeleton consis ...
, possibly representing unionids. Plant fossils in the Waaiport Formation are notably less diverse than those of preceding ages in the same location, possibly because of climate reasons. Among the genera present are the common '' Praeramunculus'' (possibly representing a progymnosperm) and '' Archaeosigillaria'' (a small type of
lycopod Lycopodiopsida is a class of vascular plants also known as lycopsids, lycopods, or lycophytes. Members of the class are also called clubmosses, firmosses, spikemosses and quillworts. They have dichotomously branching stems bearing simple leaves ...
).


See also

*
List of eurypterid genera This list of eurypterid genera is a comprehensive listing of all genera that have ever been included in the order Eurypterida, excluding purely vernacular terms. The list includes all commonly accepted genera, but also genera that are now consider ...
*
Timeline of eurypterid research This timeline of eurypterid research is a chronologically ordered list of important fossil discoveries, controversies of interpretation, and Biological taxonomy, taxonomic revisions of eurypterids, a group of extinct aquatic arthropods closely re ...


References

{{Taxonbar, from=Q141251 Carboniferous arthropods of Europe Stylonurina Fossil trackways Prehistoric life of Europe Carboniferous eurypterids Eurypterids of Europe Eurypterids of Africa