Copacabana (1947 Film)

''Copacabana'' is a 1947 American musical comedy film directed by Alfred E. Green starring Carmen Miranda, Groucho Marx, and Steve Cochran. The film is a showcase for Miranda, who performs several numbers in her usual style, including a high-energy rendition of " Tico-Tico". Groucho, as Lionel, her fiancé and agent, also sings a musical number, "Go West, Young Man", wearing his traditional greasepaint brows, mustache, and baggy suit. This was Groucho's first significant film appearance as a solo act, minus Harpo and Chico.

Anne (Gloria Jean), at the urging of Andy ( Andy Russell), sings a song called "Stranger Things Have Happened", admitting her unrequited love for her employer, Steve (Steve Cochran).

Plot

Lionel Q. Devereaux and his alluring girlfriend, Brazilian singer Carmen Navarro, have been engaged for 10 years. They are highly unsuccessful nightclub performers, due to Lionel's total lack of talent. They stay at an upscale hotel in New York City. One day, they get a 24-hour notice to pay their bill, but they lack the funds to oblige. They hurriedly try to convince the big-shot producer Steve Hunt to give Carmen a job at the Club Copacabana, and with the help of the easily convinced, gullible singer Andy Russell, posing as an agent, they achieve their goal to get her an audition.

When the producer asks Lionel and Russell whom else they represent, they invent out of thin air a veiled, mysterious beauty from Paris and call her Fifi. They persuade Carmen to play the part of Fifi. The producer hires both ladies for the job, but Fifi is the new big sensation who gets mentioned in the press. Steve is very attracted to the girls, and to protect Carmen from the producer, Lionel tells him that he is engaged to be married to Carmen. Steve then turns to Fifi and asks her out, instead. Desperate to solve the troublesome situation, Lionel asks Carmen to play Fifi and go on a date with the producer, veiled as usual. Another complication to add to the plot is that Anne, Steve's secretary, is in love with the producer, and not very keen on him going on a date with Fifi.

Andy tries to fix up Steve and Anne, to save both himself and Carmen from discovery. He gets Anne to sing her feelings towards Steve, in an attempt to make him more attracted to and aware of her. The plan does not work, as Steve shows no interest in Anne.

A Hollywood movie producer, Anatole Murphy, takes an interest in Fifi, and makes a generous offer to Steve, to take over Lionel's contract for the sum of $100,000, which he refuses. At the same time, an agent named Liggett persuades Lionel to sell Fifi's contract to him for the lesser sum of $5,000. Murphy, in turn, pays $100,000 to Liggett.

Liggett becomes suspicious, though, since he sees how the veiled Fifi gets into a taxi, and then Carmen comes out of it. Anne reveals to Carmen that the mysterious Fifi has made her getting Steve's attention impossible. To help Anne out, Lionel and Carmen stage a fight between Carmen and Fifi in Carmen's dressing room. The fight ends with Fifi disappearing. Lionel reports back to Steve that Fifi has been found dead in the river, but he also expresses his feeling of joy over "killing" her. The conversation is overheard, and he is blamed and arrested for Fifi's murder. Lionel tries to explain to the police during the investigation that he only made Fifi up.

In the meantime, Steve confesses to Anne that he only expressed an interest in Fifi because of his business, and that he is in love with Anne. Carmen enters the scene, dressed as Fifi, but removes her veil in front of everybody, showing that Carmen and Fifi are one and the same. The film producer, Murphy, offers to sign a contract with Carmen, to use her as an actor in his productions, and also wants to buy the story for a film. Lionel becomes involved in the following film productions, and gets credit for almost everything, from casting to storyline. The picture opens with a song about the Club Copacabana.

Cast

* Carmen Miranda as Carmen Navarro / Mademoiselle Fifi
* Groucho Marx as Lionel Q. Devereaux
* Steve Cochran as Steve Hunt
* Andy Russell as Himself
* Gloria Jean as Anne Stuart
* Abel Green as Himself (editor of ''Variety'' magazine)
* Louis Sobol as Himself, columnist
* Earl Wilson as Himself
* Ralph Sanford as Liggett
* The DeCastro Sisters as Themselves
* Andrew Tombes as Anatole Murphy
* Frank J. Scannell as Joe Lane
*Mari Blanchard as Copa Girl
Kay Marvis, Groucho's then-wife, has a small role as a clerk from whom Groucho tries to mooch a cigar.

Production

According to a report in the ''Hollywood Reporter'' (June 1944), independent producer Jack H. Skirball was originally set to make the film, with assistance from Monte Proser. Around the same time, George Raft was announced as a potential lead for the film.

The film's origins trace back to when United Artists suggested to Sam Coslow that the studio could use a musical film to balance its release schedule. Coslow discussed the idea with George Frank, Carmen Miranda's manager, and Monte Proser and Walter Bachelor, managers of the famous New York City nightclub Copacabana, located at 10 East 60th St. They decided to combine Miranda with the Copacabana. This was Miranda’s first film after leaving 20th Century-Fox, the studio with which she had been under contract since 1940. Coslow wrote a story that included a dual role for Miranda. They made an agreement with David Hersh as their financial man, and the United Artists approved it.

In August, Coslow cast Gloria Jean for her first film since 1945. In September 1946, it was announced that Groucho Marx would star. This was the first film in which Groucho would appear without his older brothers. It was also the first film where Groucho appeared with his own mustache, instead of a makeup one. Groucho received 10% of the profits.

Coslow, Frank, Proser, Bachelor, and Hersh invested preproduction funds, including scriptwriter fees and secretarial expenses. They borrowed 65% of the $1,300,000 budget from a bank at 5% interest. The remaining 35% came from a private financing company.

The film includes cameo appearances by Broadway writers Abel Green (editor of ''Variety''), Louie Sobol (''New York Journal-American''), and Earl Wilson (''New York Post''). At the time of production, Groucho Marx was married to Kay Gorcey, who had a small role in this film.

''The Hollywood Reporter'' mentions that Chester Clute, Richard Elliott, Frank Scannell, Pierre Andre, and Andrew Tombes were added to the cast, but their involvement in the completed film was not confirmed. Pierre Andre was hired to perform a special dance number with Dee Turnell, according to ''The Hollywood Reporter''.

Filming began on November 1, 1946, at Goldwyn Studios.

In mid-February 1947, ''The Hollywood Reporter'' reported that producer Sam Coslow was considering reshooting scenes in which Miranda appeared with blonde hair, due to fan letters from Brazilian fans stating they preferred her as a brunette. The reshot scenes would be inserted only in copies released in South America, according to the item.

Soundtrack songs

*We've Come to the Copa — The Copa Girls
* Tico-Tico no Fubá — Carmen Miranda
*Je Vous Aime — Carmen Miranda
*My Heart Was Doing a Bolero — Andy Russell
*He Hasn't Got a Thing to Sell — Carmen Miranda and Andy Russell
*To Make a Hit with Fifi — Carmen Miranda
*Stranger Things Have Happened — Andy Russell
*Stranger Things Have Happened — Gloria Jean
*Go West, Young Man — Groucho Marx
*Je Vous Aime — Andy Russell
*Let's Do The Copacabana — Carmen Miranda

Critical reception

Bosley Crowther's review of ''Copacabana'' in the ''New York Times'' is quite negative. He begins by saying that the film follows the typical Hollywood nightclub movie formula, with clichéd sets, musical numbers, and shallow characters. The main attraction of the film is Groucho Marx, who without his brothers and his trademark mustache, plays the agent of an artist in an absurd plot. Crowther praises Groucho’s ability to make the most of the limited material, but notes that the absence of his usual comedic partners (the Marx Brothers) weakens the comedy, leaving the film lacking the sparkle that characterizes his previous work. Carmen Miranda, who plays two characters in the film, is mentioned as Groucho’s partner, but her performance as a singer is limited to making faces and playing exaggerated roles. Other actors such as Steve Cochran, Gloria Jean, and Andy Russell contribute to a boring romantic subplot, and the "Copa Girls" number is described as lackluster. Crowther concludes that despite efforts to keep the film lively, it lacks originality and energy, with a cast that fails to save the plot.

Tina Hassannia from ''Slant Magazine'' gave the film 2.5 out of 5 stars, describing it as an irreverent musical that mixes love and hate toward show business. While it follows the stereotypical story of social ascent, the film stands out for its sarcasm and critique of the falseness and tricks necessary in the entertainment world. The film subtly criticizes Orientalism in Hollywood, addressing how Miranda was often perceived through the lens of the "Other", while her real talent was overshadowed by the exotic persona imposed on her. The review also mentions that despite its funny jokes and good music, the film is an escapist fantasy that reflects the reality of show business and the struggles of artists such as Miranda, whose careers were in decline at the time. Groucho Marx's presence, with his famous ''non sequitur''s, adds humor, but also serves as a façade for deeper criticism. The film is described as a mix of sarcasm, flattery, and sweetness, at times silly, but still entertaining.

The review from ''AMC'' channel describes the film as a peculiar slapstick musical, with Groucho Marx and Carmen Miranda forming an unusual pairing. The review notes that without his brothers, Groucho loses some of his energy, becoming somewhat "thin" when he is not delivering his usual sharp jokes. The text also points out that the musical numbers dominate the film, and the romantic subplot involving secondary characters takes up a significant portion of the narrative, making the second half of the film more tedious. Miranda's performance playing two different characters is fun for a short period, but the review suggests that this material is only enough to fill a sitcom episode. Despite this, the review emphasizes that Groucho Marx is still "at the top of his game" with his witty retorts, especially considering the less impressive cast around him. In the end, the review concludes that the film has its fun moments, but is, for the most part, a superficial entertainment spectacle.

Rianne Hill Soriano’s review for ''Yahoo!'' points out that ''Copacabana'' might seem silly and cheesy by modern musical standards, but it has a certain charm due to its period production and the unexpected appeal of some of its comedic and musical scenes. While the film has aged predictably, its energy and pacing keep it surprisingly fun, especially for fans of old musicals and classic comedies.

Craig Butler's review for ''AllMovie'' describes the film as "monotonous and prosaic," despite the talents of the lead stars, Carmen Miranda and Groucho Marx. Butler suggests that the idea of pairing these two icons could have been much more interesting. However, he believes that although the stars do not disappoint, their talents are underutilized in a film that lacks energy and originality, resulting in a cinematic experience without any standout moments. The critic emphasizes that the film drags predictably and lacks elements that would make it truly special or memorable.

Sérgio Augusto wrote in Brazilian newspaper ''Folha de S. Paulo'' about how ''Copacabana'' is a disappointing film, especially for fans of Carmen Miranda. Instead of being a memorable classic, the film is seen as a bland chanchada, with a plot full of clichés and low-quality production. Augusto criticizes the direction of Alfred E. Green, whom he considers bureaucratic and uninspired, and the production of Sam Coslow, the composer of the film’s songs, most of which are described as atrocious. He also mentions the presence of fake sambas and points out that Carmen Miranda is forced to sing in French while portraying a French character, Mademoiselle Fifi, in a role that feels more like a caricature than an authentic performance. The pairing of Groucho Marx and Carmen Miranda, though potentially interesting, is seen as underused, making the film monotonous, though there is still some charm in the jokes and interactions between the two leads. In terms of music, " Tico-Tico no Fubá" is the only song that stands out among the many weak numbers, including "How to Make a Hit with Fifi" and "I Haven't a Thing to Sell." Ultimately, the review laments that the film does not live up to expectations, offering a spectacle without the energy and magic one might expect from a movie starring Carmen Miranda and Groucho Marx.

Lawsuit

As reported in ''Los Angeles Times'' on 14 July 1953, Murray P. Koch sued Coslow and George Frank for $80,000, money he claimed to have advanced Beacon to aid in the making of this film. Along with Walter Batchelor and David Hersh, both of whom were dead by the time the suit was filed, Frank and Coslow held a controlling interest in Beacon, which was deemed insolvent.

The disposition of this lawsuit is not known. According to ''The Hollywood Reporter'', the film was obtained for re-release by Hal R. Makelim's Atlas Pictures Co. in Jan 1954. The film was also re-issued in July 1972.

Home media

The film was released on DVD by Republic Pictures through Artisan Entertainment in 2003. In 2013, Olive Films released a new DVD and Blu-ray of the film.

References

External links

*
*
*
Copacabana
' at Turner Classic Movies
*
Copacabana
' at NNDB
*
The Marx Brothers Council Podcast discussing "Copacabana"

{{Alfred E. Green

1947 films
1947 musical comedy films
American musical comedy films
American black-and-white films
1940s English-language films
United Artists films
Films directed by Alfred E. Green
Films scored by Edward Ward (composer)
1940s American films
Films set in New York City
English-language musical comedy films