Claud Schuster, 1st Baron Schuster, (22 August 1869 – 28 June 1956) was a British
barrister
A barrister is a type of lawyer in common law jurisdictions. Barristers mostly specialise in courtroom advocacy and litigation. Their tasks include taking cases in superior courts and tribunals, drafting legal pleadings, researching law and ...
and civil servant noted for his long tenure as
Permanent Secretary to the Lord Chancellor's Office. Born to a
Mancunian Mancunian is the associated adjective and demonym of Manchester, a city in North West England. It may refer to:
*Anything from or related to the city of Manchester or the county of Greater Manchester, in particular:
**The people of Manchester (see ...
business family, Schuster was educated at
St. George's School, Ascot
St George's School, Ascot is an independent boarding and day school in Ascot, Berkshire, England. It was founded as a boys' school and later became a girls' school.
History
The school was founded in 1877 as a boys' preparatory school. Among i ...
and
Winchester College before
matriculating at
New College, Oxford
New College is one of the constituent colleges of the University of Oxford in the United Kingdom. Founded in 1379 by William of Wykeham in conjunction with Winchester College as its feeder school, New College is one of the oldest colleges at th ...
in 1888 to read history. After graduation, he joined the
Inner Temple with the aim of becoming a barrister, and was
called to the Bar
The call to the bar is a legal term of art in most common law jurisdictions where persons must be qualified to be allowed to argue in court on behalf of another party and are then said to have been "called to the bar" or to have received "call to ...
in 1895. Practising in Liverpool, Schuster was not noted as a particularly successful barrister, and he joined
Her Majesty's Civil Service in 1899 as secretary to the Chief Commissioner of the Local Government Act Commission.
After serving as secretary to several more commissions, he was made Permanent Secretary to the Lord Chancellor's Office in 1915. Schuster served in this position for 29 years under ten different Lord Chancellors, and with the contacts obtained thanks to his long tenure and his work outside the Office he became "one of the most influential Permanent Secretaries of the 20th century". His influence over decisions within the Lord Chancellor's Office and greater Civil Service led to criticism and suspicions that he was a "power behind the throne", which culminated in a verbal attack by the
Lord Chief Justice Lord Hewart in 1934 during a session of the
House of Lords. Schuster retired in 1944 and was elevated to the
peerage
A peerage is a legal system historically comprising various hereditary titles (and sometimes non-hereditary titles) in a number of countries, and composed of assorted noble ranks.
Peerages include:
Australia
* Australian peers
Belgium
* Belgi ...
. Despite being officially retired he continued to work in government circles, such as with the
Allied Commission for Austria and by using his seat in the House of Lords as a way to directly criticise legislation.
Early life and education

Schuster was born on 22 August 1869 to Frederick Schuster, a manager of the Manchester firm of merchants Schuster, Fulder and Company, and his wife Sophia Wood, the daughter of a
lieutenant colonel
Lieutenant colonel ( , ) is a rank of commissioned officers in the armies, most marine forces and some air forces of the world, above a major and below a colonel. Several police forces in the United States use the rank of lieutenant colone ...
in the
Indian Army. The family described themselves as "
Unitarian
Unitarian or Unitarianism may refer to:
Christian and Christian-derived theologies
A Unitarian is a follower of, or a member of an organisation that follows, any of several theologies referred to as Unitarianism:
* Unitarianism (1565–present ...
" but were descended from Jews who had converted to Christianity in the mid-1850s and included other notable people such as
Sir Arthur Schuster,
Sir Felix Schuster, and later
Sir George Schuster
''Sir'' is a formal honorific address in English for men, derived from Sire in the High Middle Ages. Both are derived from the old French "Sieur" (Lord), brought to England by the French-speaking Normans, and which now exist in French only as p ...
. From the age of seven he was educated at
St. George's School, Ascot
St George's School, Ascot is an independent boarding and day school in Ascot, Berkshire, England. It was founded as a boys' school and later became a girls' school.
History
The school was founded in 1877 as a boys' preparatory school. Among i ...
, one of the most expensive preparatory schools in the country but one known for harsh treatment; it was standard for the headmaster to flog pupils until they bled and force other students and staff to listen to their screams. During the school holidays he accompanied his father to Switzerland, where he developed a lifelong love of mountaineering and skiing.
[Hall (2003) p.4] He was president of the
Alpine Club from 1938 to 1940.
When he was fourteen he was sent to
Winchester College, which was known as both the most academic of the main
public schools
Public school may refer to:
*State school (known as a public school in many countries), a no-fee school, publicly funded and operated by the government
*Public school (United Kingdom), certain elite fee-charging independent schools in England and ...
and also for its discomfort. Schuster's time at St George's had prepared him for discomfort, however, and he was noted as being very proud of attending the school.
While at Winchester Schuster played
Winchester College football and was occasionally involved in debates; he was not, however, noted as a particularly exceptional pupil. He
matriculated at
New College, Oxford
New College is one of the constituent colleges of the University of Oxford in the United Kingdom. Founded in 1379 by William of Wykeham in conjunction with Winchester College as its feeder school, New College is one of the oldest colleges at th ...
in 1888 and graduated with second-class honours in history in 1892; again he was not noted as a particularly outstanding student, which was attributed to the time he spent enjoying himself rather than studying.
[Hall (2003) p.8] Despite his lack of academic brilliance he was invited to deliver the
Romanes Lecture in 1949, an honour normally only given to the most eminent alumni of Oxford.
After graduation, he unsuccessfully tried to become an examination fellow of
All Souls College, Oxford
All Souls College (official name: College of the Souls of All the Faithful Departed) is a constituent college of the University of Oxford in England. Unique to All Souls, all of its members automatically become fellows (i.e., full members of t ...
.
[Hall (2003) p.11]
Bar work and career change

After his failure to become a fellow of All Souls, Schuster joined the
Inner Temple and was called to the bar in 1895.
He practised in Liverpool and, though he was not noted as a particularly successful barrister, he became Circuit Junior of the Northern Circuit Bar in late 1895, an important position.
By this point Schuster was married and required a steady income to support his family, something which the bar was not providing.
[Hall (2003) p.12] With his love of the English language and the knowledge that he was "good with paper" Schuster decided to join
Civil Service
The civil service is a collective term for a sector of government composed mainly of career civil servants hired on professional merit rather than appointed or elected, whose institutional tenure typically survives transitions of political leaders ...
, with the intention of becoming a
Permanent Secretary
A permanent secretary (also known as a principal secretary) is the most senior Civil Service (United Kingdom), civil servant of a department or Ministry (government department), ministry charged with running the department or ministry's day-to-day ...
.
Schuster entered the Civil Service in 1899 and as a qualified lawyer was exempt from the required examinations, something that marked him as "different" from other civil service employees with whom he worked.
[Hall (2003) p.13] His first post was as secretary to the Chief Commissioner of the Local Government Act Commission, which produced a report leading to the creation of the
London County Council.
After this he worked as a secretary to the
Great Northern Railway and then for the workers' union at London & Smith's Bank Ltd. After his job at the union he was noticed by
Robert Morant
Sir Robert Laurie Morant, (7 April 1863 – 13 March 1920) was an English administrator and educationalist.
Career overview
Born in Hampstead, Morant was the older brother of Amy Morant. He was educated at Winchester College and New College, ...
who employed him as a temporary legal assistant to the
Board of Education
A board of education, school committee or school board is the board of directors or board of trustees of a school, local school district or an equivalent institution.
The elected council determines the educational policy in a small regional are ...
on the understanding that the job would become permanent, which it did in 1907.
In 1911 he was promoted to Principal Assistant Secretary, and after Morant was appointed to the English Commission under the
National Insurance Act 1911 Schuster followed him by being appointed Chief Registrar of the
Friendly Societies, which granted him a place on the Societies' committee.
[Hall (2003) p.14]
In February 1912 he gave up his position as Chief Registrar to become Secretary (and then legal adviser) to the English Insurance Commission, with the newspapers of the time reporting that he had had "three promotions in two months", a consequence of his high standing with Morant.
During this period he was also involved in drafting education bills with
Arthur Thring.
The commission was "a galaxy of future Whitehall stars", and contained many individuals who would later become noted civil servants in their own right, including Morant, Schuster,
John Anderson John Anderson may refer to:
Business
*John Anderson (Scottish businessman) (1747–1820), Scottish merchant and founder of Fermoy, Ireland
* John Byers Anderson (1817–1897), American educator, military officer and railroad executive, mentor of ...
,
Warren Fisher and
John Bradbury. The contacts Schuster made during his time on the committee were instrumental in advancing his career; as a lawyer rather than a dedicated civil servant he was considered an outsider, and the links he made – particularly the friendships he struck up with Fisher and Anderson – helped allay this to some extent.
He was knighted in 1913 for his services on various committees.
Permanent Secretary to the Lord Chancellor's Office
In 1915
Sir Kenneth Muir Mackenzie, the Permanent Secretary to the
Lord Chancellor's Office, was close to retirement. The Lord Chancellor,
Lord Haldane, believed that the duties of the lord chancellorship were too much for one man, and should be divided between a lord chancellor and a minister of justice.
[Hall (2003) p.44] As such, he looked for a Permanent Secretary who was a qualified lawyer and who could help him set up a Ministry of Justice after the war, appointing Schuster in early 1915.
The two did not work together, however, until Haldane became Lord Chancellor for a second time in 1924; he was forced to resign several months before Schuster started work on 2 July 1915 after being accused of pro-German sympathies.
Lords Buckmaster and Findlay (1915–1916, 1916–1919)
The first Lord Chancellor under whom Schuster served was
Lord Buckmaster, who was appointed on 27 May 1915.
[Hall (2003) p.72] Although most senior government offices at this time were held by wealthy aristocrats, the office of Lord Chancellor stood out as most of the appointees were lawyers from the middle class.
Buckmaster was considered "the most
plebeian
In ancient Rome, the plebeians (also called plebs) were the general body of free Roman citizens who were not patricians, as determined by the census, or in other words " commoners". Both classes were hereditary.
Etymology
The precise origins of ...
of Lord Chancellors", as he was the son of a farmer and schoolteacher who later became a
justice of the peace
A justice of the peace (JP) is a judicial officer of a lower or ''puisne'' court, elected or appointed by means of a commission ( letters patent) to keep the peace. In past centuries the term commissioner of the peace was often used with the sa ...
.
Schuster became Permanent Secretary in July, a month after Buckmaster took his post, and immediately tried to make an impression on the workings of the office by modernising it; under the previous Permanent Secretary – who abhorred time-saving mechanisms – shorthand had been forbidden, and the office had owned only one typewriter. Buckmaster and Schuster had similar outlooks on
World War I, with both their sons serving on the
Western Front Western Front or West Front may refer to:
Military frontiers
*Western Front (World War I), a military frontier to the west of Germany
*Western Front (World War II), a military frontier to the west of Germany
*Western Front (Russian Empire), a majo ...
; Schuster almost certainly helped write the 1915 memorandum Buckmaster circulated to
Cabinet arguing that forces should be concentrated on the Western Front rather than spread out in an attempt to assault other areas.
H. H. Asquith resigned as Prime Minister in December 1916, and as a member of Asquith's cabinet Buckmaster followed him. He was replaced by
Lord Finlay who was appointed on 12 December.
[Hall (2003) p.79] Aged 74 when he was appointed, Finlay was the oldest person to be made Lord Chancellor since
Lord Campbell, who was 80 when he was appointed in 1859, and his age showed, with his decisions being slow and cautious.
Luckily the job of the Lord Chancellor during the last two years of World War I was limited to maintaining the system rather than instituting any changes, and his tenure was uneventful.
During this period Schuster was very influential in judicial appointments, phrasing his reports in such a way that Finlay could only logically accept one candidate. Although Finlay was not a member of the
War Cabinet, which limited his political influence to some extent, he was close friends with
Lord Haldane and through Haldane Schuster made contacts with up and coming politicians such as
Sir Alan Sykes and
Jimmy Thomas; the group was described as "the future Labour Cabinet". During Findlay's tenure as Lord Chancellor the question of a Ministry of Justice again came up; while the
Law Society
A law society is an association of lawyers with a regulatory role that includes the right to supervise the training, qualifications, and conduct of lawyers. Where there is a distinction between barristers and solicitors, solicitors are regulated ...
was in favour of such a department the
Bar Council along with Schuster was opposed to any changes in the status quo, and as the person who prepared a report on the matter for the Lord Chancellor Schuster did his best to express his disapproval of any changes. For his continued work in the Civil Service Schuster was made a
Commander of the Royal Victorian Order in 1918.
A year later he was made a
King's Counsel
In the United Kingdom and in some Commonwealth countries, a King's Counsel ( post-nominal initials KC) during the reign of a king, or Queen's Counsel (post-nominal initials QC) during the reign of a queen, is a lawyer (usually a barrister or ...
: an odd honour for a man who no longer practiced as a barrister.
Lord Birkenhead (1919–1922)
Finlay had been appointed on the conditions that he would not claim a pension (it was war-time, and there were already four retired Lord Chancellors claiming £5,000 per year pensions) and that he would resign when required.
[Hall (2003) p.83] Despite this he was surprised when he was dismissed after the
1918 general election, first hearing about it when it was mentioned in the newspapers.
His replacement
Lord Birkenhead
Earl of Birkenhead was a title in the Peerage of the United Kingdom. It was created in 1922 for the noted lawyer and Conservative politician F. E. Smith, 1st Viscount Birkenhead. He was Solicitor-General in 1915, Attorney-General from 1915 to ...
was appointed on 14 January 1919, and was a controversial choice; he was only 46 when appointed and was unpopular with large sections of the Bar as a result;
George V himself wrote to the Prime Minister before Birkenhead was appointed and said that "His Majesty does not feel sure that
irkenheadhas established such a reputation in men's minds as to ensure that the country will welcome him to the second highest position which can be occupied by a subject of the Crown". Birkenhead and Schuster established a strong partnership, and Schuster played a part in instituting Birkenhead's legal reforms, particularly those relating to the
law of real property.
Real property law in the English and Welsh legal system had evolved from
feudalism, and was an immensely complex system understood by only a small number of lawyers.
[Hall (2003) p.105] In particular peculiarities meant that land owned by beneficiaries could be sold without the agreement of all the beneficiaries involved, something partially rectified by the
Settled Land Act 1882
A settler is a person who has migrated to an area and established a permanent residence there, often to colonize the area.
A settler who migrates to an area previously uninhabited or sparsely inhabited may be described as a pioneer.
Settl ...
and the Land Transfer Act 1897.
Despite these statutes reform in this area was still needed, and Lord Haldane presented reform bills to parliament in 1913, 1914 and 1915 with no real progress thanks to the opposition of the Law Society.
[Hall (2003) p.106] In March 1917 a Reconstruction Subcommittee under
Sir Leslie Scott was created to consider land policy after the
First World War, and Schuster (who had
devilled for Scott when working as a barrister in Liverpool) was appointed as a member.
The subcommittee decided that the law should be changed to merge
real and
personal property
property is property that is movable. In common law systems, personal property may also be called chattels or personalty. In civil law systems, personal property is often called movable property or movables—any property that can be moved fr ...
law, and that outdated aspects of land law such as
copyholds and
gavelkind should be eliminated.
When Birkenhead became Lord Chancellor in 1919 he inherited the problem of English property law, and immediately instructed Schuster to prepare the department for forcing a bill through Parliament on the matter.
[Hall (2003) p.107]
Although there was general agreement that property law should be reformed the process was made more difficult by the various vested interests involved; the Law Society, for example, was opposed to the changes because it would reduce the fees dedicated property solicitors could earn by making it possible for more solicitors to understand that area of law and become involved.
After intense negotiation Schuster and the Law Society representative agreed that a "period of probation" lasting three years would be included in the bill, which
Charles Brickdale
Sir Charles Fortescue Brickdale (1 March 1857 – 20 September 1944) was a British barrister and civil servant best known for his reform of HM Land Registry as Chief Registrar.
Life
Brickdale was born on 1 March 1857 to Matthew Brickdale, a barr ...
the Chief Registrar of
HM Land Registry considered "a very good bargain". When the bill finally got to the
House of Commons it met additional opposition from Members of Parliament who were also members of the Law Society and Bar Council, as well as
Lord Cave who later became Lord Chancellor. After further negotiations the bill was passed on 8 June 1922, with Birkenhead taking the credit, and it became the Law of Property Act 1922.
Schuster also assisted Birkenhead in his attempts to reform the administration of the court system, particularly in his preparation of the
Supreme Court of Judicature (Consolidation) Act 1925
The Supreme Court of Judicature (Consolidation) Act 1925, sometimes referred to as the Supreme Court of Judicature Act 1925, was an Act of the Parliament of the United Kingdom.
Section 99
This section was replaced by section 84 of the Supreme C ...
.
[Hall (2003) p.111] A committee was also set up to look into the reform of the
Supreme Court of Judicature, the
County Court
A county court is a court based in or with a jurisdiction covering one or more counties, which are administrative divisions (subnational entities) within a country, not to be confused with the medieval system of ''county courts'' held by the high ...
s and the
Probate Services, divided into a subcommittee for each institution.
Schuster served as a member of the committee, with his primary goal being to end the
patronage
Patronage is the support, encouragement, privilege, or financial aid that an organization or individual bestows on another. In the history of art, arts patronage refers to the support that kings, popes, and the wealthy have provided to artists su ...
and
nepotism
Nepotism is an advantage, privilege, or position that is granted to relatives and friends in an occupation or field. These fields may include but are not limited to, business, politics, academia, entertainment, sports, fitness, religion, an ...
that filled the judicial system.
[Hall (2003) p.112] Although the Supreme Court was resistant the committee did succeed in making some changes, such as introducing mandatory retirement ages for
masters and
clerks; they were unable, however, to end the patronage.
Schuster also attempted to reform the County Courts by increasing their jurisdiction, and a Committee on County Court Procedure (known as the Swift Committee after its chairman
Rigby Swift) was set up in 1920, with Schuster serving as a member.
[Hall (2003) p.113] The commission concluded that the
Treasury had mismanaged the County Courts, and on 1 August 1922 the
Lord Chancellor's Office instead became responsible for the courts, with Schuster becoming Accounting Officer.
The committee's final report was used as the basis for the County Courts Act 1924, which did much to correct the problems with the County Courts.
Schuster was appointed
Knight Commander of the Order of the Bath (KCB) in the 1920 New Year War Honours.
Lords Cave and Haldane (1922–1924, 1924)
By the summer of 1922 the
coalition government
A coalition government is a form of government in which political parties cooperate to form a government. The usual reason for such an arrangement is that no single party has achieved an absolute majority after an election, an atypical outcome in ...
Birkenhead was a member of began to splinter, and when it finally collapsed Birkenhead was forced to resign on 25 October 1922.
His replacement was
Lord Cave, a member of the new
Conservative government who was appointed on 27 October 1922. The Conservative government under
Stanley Baldwin
Stanley Baldwin, 1st Earl Baldwin of Bewdley, (3 August 186714 December 1947) was a British Conservative Party politician who dominated the government of the United Kingdom between the world wars, serving as prime minister on three occasions, ...
soon ran into trouble due to his desire to introduce
protectionist tariffs to protect British jobs.
[Hall (2003) p.140] Baldwin called an early general election in
December 1923
The following events occurred in December 1923:
December 1, 1923 (Saturday)
*The damburst of the Gleno Dam killed 356 people in the province of Bergamo, sweeping away people in the villages of Bueggio, Corna and Dezzo. Initial reports from ...
to serve as a referendum on the subject, and although the Conservatives remained the largest party they did not have enough Members of Parliament to claim a parliamentary majority.
At the opening of the new Parliament in January 1924 the party was defeated in a
vote of no confidence, and the King instead invited the
Labour Party leader
Ramsay MacDonald
James Ramsay MacDonald (; 12 October 18669 November 1937) was a British politician who served as Prime Minister of the United Kingdom, the first who belonged to the Labour Party, leading minority Labour governments for nine months in 1924 ...
to form a government.
This caused various constitutional problems; traditionally every member of a cabinet, including the Prime Minister, must be a
Privy Councillor
A privy council is a body that advises the head of state of a state, typically, but not always, in the context of a monarchic government. The word "privy" means "private" or "secret"; thus, a privy council was originally a committee of the mon ...
. MacDonald was not a Privy Councillor, and therefore could not be made Prime Minister.
[Hall (2003) p.141] The king asked Lord Cave for a way around this problem, and as an expert on constitutional issues Schuster helped draft the response.
In the end it was determined that MacDonald would be sworn in as a Privy Councillor and then invited to form a government.
As a member of the old Conservative government Cave left office on 23 January 1924. He was replaced by
Lord Haldane, who was serving for a second time and was sworn in on 25 January. Haldane was in favour of the creation of a Ministry of Justice, and although Schuster was privately against it he suggested that he would have accepted the responsibilities of such a Ministry on the condition that it remained under his control as the Lord Chancellor's Office was. Haldane was ill, however, and the Labour government lasted only ten months thanks to the publishing of the
Zinoviev Letter, and no large-scale reforms such as the creation of a Ministry of Justice were ever pushed through.
Lords Cave and Hailsham (1924–1928, 1928–1929)
After the collapse of the Labour government in October 1924 the Conservative Party returned to power, and
Lord Cave became Lord Chancellor for a second time on 7 November. Spending four and a half years in office Cave had time to push through some significant reforms, including the
Law of Property Act 1925
The Law of Property Act 1925c 20 is a statute of the United Kingdom Parliament. It forms part of an interrelated programme of legislation introduced by Lord Chancellor Lord Birkenhead between 1922 and 1925. The programme was intended to moderni ...
based on the 1922 act Schuster had been involved in.
By 1925 Schuster had spent a decade as Permanent Secretary and was described as a "
Whitehall Mandarin
Mandarin or The Mandarin may refer to:
Language
* Mandarin Chinese, branch of Chinese originally spoken in northern parts of the country
** Standard Chinese or Modern Standard Mandarin, the official language of China
** Taiwanese Mandarin, Stand ...
", his contacts and long service allowing him greater influence over policy decisions than a Permanent Secretary normally had.
[Hall (2003) p.146] The expansion of the Lord Chancellor's Office he had overseen also gave him greater opportunities to delegate to his subordinates, allowing him more time to spend on committees and inquiries directly influencing the way the government worked.
As a result of his power and influence he grew to dislike being opposed in any way, and this led to conflict between him and other heads of department.
As a reward for his continued service with the Lord Chancellor's Office he was made a
Knight Grand Cross of the Order of the Bath
The Most Honourable Order of the Bath is a British order of chivalry founded by George I on 18 May 1725. The name derives from the elaborate medieval ceremony for appointing a knight, which involved bathing (as a symbol of purification) as one ...
in the
1927 New Year Honours.
Lord Cave resigned on 28 March 1928 due to ill health, and died the day after. His replacement was
Lord Hailsham, who was appointed by
Stanley Baldwin
Stanley Baldwin, 1st Earl Baldwin of Bewdley, (3 August 186714 December 1947) was a British Conservative Party politician who dominated the government of the United Kingdom between the world wars, serving as prime minister on three occasions, ...
on 29 March 1928. Hailsham's first tenure as Lord Chancellor lasted barely a year and highlighted the fact that despite his abilities (many thought that if he had not accepted the offer to become Lord Chancellor he would likely have become Prime Minister) he was not a particularly innovative Lord Chancellor.
[Hall (2003) p.156] For a short period in August 1928 he acted as Prime Minister (Baldwin was on holiday in
Aix-en-Provence
Aix-en-Provence (, , ; oc, label= Provençal, Ais de Provença in classical norm, or in Mistralian norm, ; la, Aquae Sextiae), or simply Aix ( medieval Occitan: ''Aics''), is a city and commune in southern France, about north of Marseille. ...
) with Schuster as his chief adviser, but he rarely went to
10 Downing Street
10 Downing Street in London, also known colloquially in the United Kingdom as Number 10, is the official residence and executive office of the first lord of the treasury, usually, by convention, the prime minister of the United Kingdom. Along wi ...
and nothing eventful happened during his time in charge.
Lord Sankey (1929–1935)
Lord Hailsham left office in mid-1929 with the fall of the
Conservative government in 1929. His replacement was a member of the newly elected Labour Government,
Lord Sankey
John Sankey, 1st Viscount Sankey, (26 October 1866 – 6 February 1948) was a British lawyer, judge, Labour politician and Lord High Chancellor of Great Britain, famous for many of his judgments in the House of Lords. He gave his name to th ...
, who was appointed on 8 June 1929. Sankey was appointed on Schuster's advice, and served longer with him than any other Lord Chancellor.
[Hall (2003) p.165] Sankey was a "reforming" Lord Chancellor, and as part of one of his first reforms Schuster helped him draft and pass the
Statute of Westminster in 1931.
During this period the question of Judge's salaries also arose, and almost caused a constitutional crisis. As Permanent Secretary Schuster was tasked with ensuring that the courts ran correctly, and although the Judges were independent they were paid by the Lord Chancellor's Office.
[Hall (2003) p.179] Although a Select Committee in 1878 had recommended that
County Court
A county court is a court based in or with a jurisdiction covering one or more counties, which are administrative divisions (subnational entities) within a country, not to be confused with the medieval system of ''county courts'' held by the high ...
Judges be paid £2,000 a year this increase had still failed to appear due to the economic hardships caused by the
First World War.
The increase was eventually implemented in 1937, but in the meantime
High Court Judges had also been lobbying for an increase, as their pay had stayed at the same level since 1832.
Schuster and
Warren Fisher had produced a report recommending a pay increase in 1920, but again the economic hardship prevented their plan from being implemented.
The 1931
economic crash led to the government passing the National Recovery Act 1931, which reduced the salaries of High Court judges by 20%.
The judges, who had been expecting a pay raise instead, were shocked, and six High Court judges threatened to resign, with
Mr Justice McCardie accusing Schuster of having his salary almost doubled in the last twelve years.
The Prime Minister and Sankey met to write a letter to the judges demanding that they give in; as soon as Schuster heard about this he rushed to Whitehall to "stop the madness".
[Hall (2003) p.181] The protests from the judges increased through 1931 and 1932, with several judges including
Mr Justice Clauson and
Mr Justice Luxmoore threatening to sue the government.
After negotiations between Schuster and the judges failed to bring an end to the crisis the section of the act cutting judges' pay was quietly dropped.
Soon after becoming Permanent Secretary Schuster had decided that his aim should be to make sure that the entire court system was under the control of his office, rather than partially under his control and partially under the control of the
Treasury as it had been when he started.
[Hall (2003) p.190] The 1931 Royal Commission on the Civil Service recommended that all Civil Service departments take a more business-like approach to their work, and spurred Schuster into making a further attempt to reorganise and reform the Lord Chancellor's Office.
As such he persuaded Sankey to set up a Departmental Committee on the Business of the Courts, with
Lord Hanworth (one of Schuster's friends) chairing the committee and Schuster himself sitting as a member.
As he had under
Lord Birkenhead
Earl of Birkenhead was a title in the Peerage of the United Kingdom. It was created in 1922 for the noted lawyer and Conservative politician F. E. Smith, 1st Viscount Birkenhead. He was Solicitor-General in 1915, Attorney-General from 1915 to ...
Schuster attempted to reform the County Courts. He partially succeeded in doing when his recommendations were included in the Administration of Justice
ppealsAct 1934 which sent appeals from the county courts straight to the
Court of Appeal
A court of appeals, also called a court of appeal, appellate court, appeal court, court of second instance or second instance court, is any court of law that is empowered to hear an appeal of a trial court or other lower tribunal. In much of t ...
rather than the
Divisional Courts.
[Hall (2003) p.191] He also attempted to have the number of jury trials in civil cases reduced, something which Hanworth supported but which was blocked by the
King's Bench Division.
Schuster also took part in law reform after Lord Sankey decided to set up a Law Revision Committee in January 1934 which consisted of Sankey, Schuster, four judges, five barristers, one solicitor and two academic lawyers.
[Hall (2003) p.192] The committee produced 86 reports from 1934 to 1939 on a variety of subjects, and many of their recommendations were made into legislation after negotiations with the
Home Office.
Although the Law Revision Committee fell into disuse after this it was re-formed as a permanent
Law Commission in 1965.
In 1934 Schuster was subject to a public attack by
Lord Hewart, the
Lord Chief Justice.
[Hall (2003) p.216] On 7 December 1934 his clerk found a
bill amongst Hewart's parliamentary papers with a clause that allowed the Lord Chancellor to appoint any
Lord Justice of Appeal
A Lord Justice of Appeal or Lady Justice of Appeal is a judge of the Court of Appeal of England and Wales, the court that hears appeals from the High Court of Justice, the Crown Court and other courts and tribunals. A Lord (or Lady) Justice ...
as vice-president of the
Court of Appeal
A court of appeals, also called a court of appeal, appellate court, appeal court, court of second instance or second instance court, is any court of law that is empowered to hear an appeal of a trial court or other lower tribunal. In much of t ...
, a right traditionally held by the Lord Chief Justice.
Hewart immediately made plans to attend the House of Lords, where Lord Sankey was expected to move the
second reading of the bill in question. Immediately after second reading Hewart rose and began a speech that was "as violent an attack as has ever been made in the Lords".
[Hall (2003) p.219] In it he criticised the officials of the Lord Chancellor's Department
(which to listeners clearly meant Schuster specifically) and insinuated that the bill was part of a conspiracy to move power from the judiciary to the politicians (and thus the civil service) and create a Ministry of Justice.
The speech provoked uproar in the house; a public quarrel between senior judges and civil servants had not happened in centuries, especially in such a traditionally calm and collected place.
Lord Reading, himself a former Lord Chief Justice, adjourned the debate,
and the following Friday
Lord Hailsham, at the time the
Leader of the House of Lords, made a defence of Schuster, saying that "I can show that this is an absolute delusion
ndthat there was no such scheme ever hatched".
[Hall (2003) p.224] He showed that the proposal of a Ministry of Justice had originated in 1836, long before Schuster became Permanent Secretary, and in addition that the report Schuster had helped prepare for Sankey was clearly biased against the creation of such a Ministry as he himself was opposed to it.
He went on to praise Schuster as "the author and instigator of many great reforms", and along with a similar speech by Lord Sankey and an amendment to the offending bill this helped appease Hewart.
Lords Hailsham and Maugham (1935–1938, 1938–1939)
Lord Hailsham returned to power on 7 June 1935 after the election of a new government, and by this point his health was beginning to decline, limiting his effectiveness.
[Hall (2003) p.157] The
Second Italo-Abyssinian War
The Second Italo-Ethiopian War, also referred to as the Second Italo-Abyssinian War, was a war of aggression which was fought between Italy and Ethiopia from October 1935 to February 1937. In Ethiopia it is often referred to simply as the Itali ...
alerted the Civil Service and MI5 to the ambitions of Italy and Germany, and the
Committee of Imperial Defence
The Committee of Imperial Defence was an important ''ad hoc'' part of the Government of the United Kingdom and the British Empire from just after the Second Boer War until the start of the Second World War. It was responsible for research, and som ...
was asked to review the defence legislation that had been used in the
First World War and present it to
Warren Fisher.
Fisher was horrified at how outdated the laws were, and with the permission of the Cabinet organised a War Legislation Committee under Schuster to draft a new code of defence regulations.
[Hall (2003) p.159] Norman Brook, later head of the Civil Service, served as secretary, and the committee was described as "a model piece of organisation" thanks to the work of Schuster as chairman.
The regulations drafted by the committee were eventually made into law after the passing of the
Emergency Powers (Defence) Act 1939.
Lord Hailsham left his position in 1938 due to his failing health, and was replaced by
Lord Maugham
Viscount Maugham, of Hartfield in the County of Sussex, was a title in the Peerage of the United Kingdom. It was created on 22 September 1939 for the former Lord Chancellor, Frederic Maugham, Baron Maugham. He had already been created a life ...
, who was appointed on 15 March. His appointment was done on Schuster's advice and was considered quite a surprise as he had no real political experience; even Maugham himself admitted he had not expected to be offered the job. Schuster and Maugham had a difficult relationship, especially after the start of the
Second World War in 1939, due to their differing political opinions.
[Hall (2003) p.237] Schuster did not play an active part in policy decisions in this period, partially because of his disagreements with Maugham and partially because Maugham preferred to work on legislation and policy changes himself. Schuster later said that he got on with all of his Lord Chancellors except one—Maugham.
Lords Caldecote and Simon (1939–1940, 1940–1945)
Lord Maugham
Viscount Maugham, of Hartfield in the County of Sussex, was a title in the Peerage of the United Kingdom. It was created on 22 September 1939 for the former Lord Chancellor, Frederic Maugham, Baron Maugham. He had already been created a life ...
resigned on 3 September 1939, giving his failing health as a reason (he was 73 when he left the post), and he was replaced by
Lord Caldecote a day later. Caldecote only held the office for eight months, but during this period spent a large amount of time preparing legislation for the
Second World War. Putting the country on a war footing would impact on the ability of people to fulfil their civil obligations if, for example, they were conscripted, and Schuster was made chairman of a Cabinet subcommittee "to consider the problems arising from the inability of persons, owing to war conditions, to fulfil their contractual and other obligations, and in particular to consider the complaints already made to MPs and government departments".
[Hall (2003) p.241] The subcommittee made six reports and their recommendations were eventually made into the Liabilities (Wartime Adjustment) Acts of 1941 and 1944.
Schuster also led the committee that drafted the USA (Visiting Forces) Bill that provided that any criminal proceedings in relation to the behaviour of US soldiers stationed in Britain would be led by the US military authorities rather than the British government.
Lord Caldecote was forced to leave his position after only 8 months due to the fall of
Neville Chamberlain
Arthur Neville Chamberlain (; 18 March 18699 November 1940) was a British politician of the Conservative Party who served as Prime Minister of the United Kingdom from May 1937 to May 1940. He is best known for his foreign policy of appeasemen ...
's government, of which he was a part. He was replaced by
Lord Simon Lord Simon may refer to multiple peerages in the United Kingdom:
Hereditary peers
*Holders of the title Viscount Simon
**John Simon, 1st Viscount Simon (1873–1954)
** John Gilbert Simon, 2nd Viscount Simon (1902–1993)
**Jan David Simon, 3rd V ...
, who took up his position on 12 May 1940. Simon frequently delegated to Schuster and accepted his advice on judicial appointments, such as that of
Tom Denning
Alfred Thompson "Tom" Denning, Baron Denning (23 January 1899 – 5 March 1999) was an English lawyer and judge. He was called to the bar of England and Wales in 1923 and became a King's Counsel in 1938. Denning became a judge in 1944 when ...
to the
High Court in 1944. Schuster also had influence in committee appointments; when Simon was asked to select a chairman for the Committee on Reconstruction Priorities he delegated to Schuster, who chose
Sir Walter Monckton.
Retirement
Schuster retired in 1944, and on 22 June of that year he was raised to the peerage as Baron Schuster, of Cerne in the County of
Dorset. By the time he retired Schuster had served as Permanent Secretary for 29 years under 10 Lord Chancellors, records that have not yet been broken.
He also served as
High Sheriff of Dorset in 1941. In retirement he undertook work for the Allied Commission for Austria and "tackled the unexpected with the zest of a young man" despite being 75. He returned to Britain in 1946. He served as Treasurer of the
Inner Temple in 1947, and in 1948 and 1949 took his seat in the House of Lords to voice his opinions on legislation, something he had previously been unable to do publicly due to Civil Service neutrality. He participated in debates over the
Criminal Justice Act 1948 and
Criminal Justice Act 1949
In ordinary language, a crime is an unlawful act punishable by a state or other authority. The term ''crime'' does not, in modern criminal law, have any simple and universally accepted definition,Farmer, Lindsay: "Crime, definitions of", in Can ...
, and was noted for being polite to the point of obsequiousness. He gave the
Romanes Lecture in 1949 on the subject of "Mountaineering" and continued to play an active part in public life, helping reconstruct the Inner Temple after it was bombed in the
Second World War. On 27 June 1956 he fell ill at an
old Wykehamist dinner and was taken to
Charing Cross Hospital, where he died the next morning.
Personal life
Schuster met
William Walter Merry
William Walter Merry (1835–1918) was an English classical scholar, clergyman, and educator.
Life
William Merry was born in Evesham, Worcestershire, and was educated at Cheltenham College and Balliol College, Oxford, where he gained the Chance ...
when he was Rector of
Lincoln College, Oxford
Lincoln College (formally, The College of the Blessed Mary and All Saints, Lincoln) is one of the constituent colleges of the University of Oxford, situated on Turl Street in central Oxford. Lincoln was founded in 1427 by Richard Fleming, the ...
and the two became friends due to their shared love of mountaineering. Through him he met Merry's daughter, Elizabeth, whom he married in 1896. They had two children: a son, Christopher John Claud Schuster, in 1899 and a daughter, Elizabeth Alice Schuster, in 1902, before Elizabeth Merry's death in 1936.
[Hall (2003) p.xvii][Hall (2003) p.10] Christopher also attended Winchester College and was killed in 1918 on the
Western Front Western Front or West Front may refer to:
Military frontiers
*Western Front (World War I), a military frontier to the west of Germany
*Western Front (World War II), a military frontier to the west of Germany
*Western Front (Russian Empire), a majo ...
,
and Elizabeth later married Theodore Turner, a
King's Counsel
In the United Kingdom and in some Commonwealth countries, a King's Counsel ( post-nominal initials KC) during the reign of a king, or Queen's Counsel (post-nominal initials QC) during the reign of a queen, is a lawyer (usually a barrister or ...
, before dying in 1983.
Arms
References
Bibliography
*
{{DEFAULTSORT:Schuster, Claud Schuser, 1st Baron
1869 births
1956 deaths
Alumni of New College, Oxford
British barristers
British King's Counsel
Commanders of the Royal Victorian Order
Knights Bachelor
Knights Grand Cross of the Order of the Bath
Members of the Inner Temple
People educated at Winchester College
Permanent Secretaries to the Lord Chancellor's Office
Private secretaries in the British Civil Service
Presidents of the Alpine Club (UK)
20th-century King's Counsel
High Sheriffs of Dorset
People educated at St. George's School, Ascot
Barons created by George VI