''Caetano v. Massachusetts'', 577 U.S. 411 (2016), was a case in which the

Supreme Court of the United States The Supreme Court of the United States (SCOTUS) is the highest court in the federal judiciary of the United States. It has ultimate appellate jurisdiction over all Federal tribunals in the United States, U.S. federal court cases, and over Stat ...

unanimously vacated a

Massachusetts Massachusetts ( ; ), officially the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, is a U.S. state, state in the New England region of the Northeastern United States. It borders the Atlantic Ocean and the Gulf of Maine to its east, Connecticut and Rhode ...

conviction of a woman who carried a stun gun for self-defense., slip op. at 1-2 (2016) (per curiam).

Background

Jaime Caetano was reported to have been hospitalized and "in fear for erlife" after an altercation with her "abusive" boyfriend. After obtaining several restraining orders that "proved futile", Caetano accepted a stun gun from a friend for self-defense.''Caetano'', slip op. at 1 (Alito, J., concurring in the judgment). One night, when her ex-boyfriend confronted her outside her work and threatened her, she displayed the stun gun and successfully avoided an altercation. However, when police discovered that she was in possession of the stun gun, she was arrested, tried, and convicted under a Massachusetts law that outlawed the possession of stun guns. The

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court (SJC) is the highest court in the Commonwealth of Massachusetts. Although the claim is disputed by the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, the SJC claims the distinction of being the oldest continuously fu ...

had said her stun gun was "not the type of weapon that is eligible for Second Amendment protection" because it was "not in common use at the time of he Second Amendment'senactment." Caetano then appealed the Massachusetts court's ruling to the Supreme Court of the United States.''Caetano'', slip op. at 1 (per curiam).

Opinion of the Court

In a ''per curiam'' decision, the Supreme Court vacated the ruling of the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court.''Caetano'', slip op. at 2 (per curiam). Citing '' District of Columbia v. Heller'' and '' McDonald v. City of Chicago'', the Court began its opinion by stating that "the Second Amendment extends, prima facie, to all instruments that constitute bearable arms, even those that were not in existence at the time of the founding" and that "the Second Amendment right is fully applicable to the States". The term "bearable arms" was defined in '' District of Columbia v. Heller'', 554 U.S. 570 (2008) and includes any "" apo of offence" or "thing that a man wears for his defence, or takes into his hands," that is "carr ed. . . for the purpose of offensive or defensive action." 554 U. S., at 581, 584 (internal quotation marks omitted)." The Court then identified three reasons why the Massachusetts court's opinion contradicted prior rulings by the United States Supreme Court. First, the Massachusetts court said that stun guns could be banned because they "were not in common use at the time of the Second Amendment's enactment", but the Supreme Court noted that this contradicted ''Heller'' conclusion that Second Amendment protects "arms ... that were not in existence at the time of the founding". Second, the Massachusetts court said that stun guns were "dangerous per se at common law and unusual" because they were "a thoroughly modern invention", but the Supreme Court held that this was also inconsistent with ''Heller''. Third, the Massachusetts court said that stun guns could be banned because they were not "readily adaptable to use in the military", but the Supreme Court held that ''Heller'' rejected the argument that "only those weapons useful in warfare" were protected by the Second Amendment.

Justice Alito's concurring opinion

Justice

Samuel Alito Samuel Anthony Alito Jr. ( ; born April 1, 1950) is an American jurist who serves as an Associate Justice of the Supreme Court of the United States, associate justice of the Supreme Court of the United States. He was Samuel Alito Supreme Court ...

wrote an opinion concurring in the judgment, in which he was joined by Justice

Clarence Thomas Clarence Thomas (born June 23, 1948) is an American lawyer and jurist who has served since 1991 as an associate justice of the Supreme Court of the United States. President George H. W. Bush nominated him to succeed Thurgood Marshall. Afte ...

. Justice Alito characterized the per curiam decision as "grudging" and wrote that " e reasoning of the Massachusetts court poses a grave threat to the fundamental right of self-defense". He provided an analysis of why he believed that the Massachusetts court's ruling contradicted ''Heller'' and other cases interpreting the Second Amendment. After concluding that the Massachusetts stun gun ban violates the Second Amendment, Justice Alito wrote: "if the fundamental right of self-defense does not protect Caetano, then the safety of all Americans is left to the mercy of state authorities who may be more concerned about disarming people than about keeping them safe".

Subsequent developments

On July 6, 2016, after the prosecution and defense reached an agreement, Caetano was found not guilty by a Massachusetts judge. In a subsequent case, ''Ramirez v. Commonwealth'', the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court relied on ''Caetano'' to strike down the state's stun gun law.

Commentary and analysis

Lyle Denniston Lyle Denniston (born March 16, 1931) is an American journalist, professor, and author who has reported on the Supreme Court of the United States since 1958. He wrote for SCOTUSblog, an online blog featuring news and analysis of the Supreme Court ...

observed that the Court's opinion was the first direct interpretation of the meaning of the Second Amendment since the Court's 2008 ruling in ''Heller''. However, given the limited nature of the per curiam opinion, Denniston noted that " e facts in this case do not necessarily stand as a definite constitutional declaration".

References

External links

* {{US2ndAmendment United States Supreme Court cases of the Roberts Court United States Supreme Court cases United States Second Amendment case law 2016 in United States case law