Breast Cancer Show Ever

"Breast Cancer Show Ever" is the ninth episode in the twelfth season of the American animated television series ''South Park'', and the 176th episode of the series overall. It originally aired on Comedy Central in the United States on October 15, 2008. The episode was written and directed by series co-creator Trey Parker. In the episode, Eric Cartman's disrespectful behavior puts him on the wrong side of Wendy Testaburger when he mocks her presentation on breast cancer awareness, which leads to Wendy threatening to beat him up after school. The episode was rated TV-MA L in the United States.

Plot

During Wendy Testaburger's presentation on breast cancer awareness, Eric Cartman ridicules the disease while their teacher Mr. Garrison does little to stop him. After class, as Wendy is putting up posters to raise breast cancer awareness, Cartman continues to mock the disease, prompting an infuriated Wendy to challenge him to a fistfight after school. As word of the fight quickly spreads through the school, Cartman becomes frightened and reluctant to go through with the fight, afraid of losing to a girl in front of his friends. He tries to call off the fight with quiet apologies and bribery, but Wendy is not convinced of his sincerity.

Cartman tries to convince Stan Marsh to talk Wendy out of it, but Stan does not believe he can do anything to stop her. Finally, Cartman pulls Wendy aside and tells her that his mother has been diagnosed with breast cancer, though she does not believe him. Desperate to avoid the fight, Cartman defecates on Mr. Garrison's desk in order to get detention. Butters Stotch, Craig Tucker, and Jimmy Valmer tell Cartman there are rumors that he deliberately got detention to avoid the fight, though Cartman refutes this. Relieved, Craig reveals that they rescheduled the fight for the following morning before school.

Later, Cartman plays the victim by having his mother convince Wendy's parents that he is being tormented and bullied by Wendy at school. Wendy's parents forbid her from fighting and she reluctantly acquiesces. Cartman then taunts Wendy further by making faces at her and giving her the middle finger, unseen by the adults, further enraging Wendy. Due to the severe warnings from her parents, Wendy does not show up for the fight the following morning, arriving only in time to begin school. Cartman takes the opportunity to call her names like "chicken", convincing the others that she is a coward.

In class, Cartman taunts Wendy further by giving a presentation about breast cancer the following day, claiming that "much like the victims of breast cancer, there's something eneed to get off ischest": ridiculing Wendy's prior efforts. Wendy, losing her temper, begins to attack Cartman but is called to Principal Victoria's office.

After Wendy assures her that there will be no fight between her and Cartman, Principal Victoria commends Wendy for all she has done to spread awareness of breast cancer, and reveals that she is a breast cancer survivor herself, much to Wendy's astonishment. Principal Victoria continues to talk about cancer, using underlying subtext, refers to Cartman as a cancer that is "pure evil" and "a fat little lump that needs to be destroyed". She then concludes by explaining, "When you have cancer, you fight. Because it doesn't matter if you beat it or not. You refuse to let that fat little lump make you feel powerless." Wendy decides to fight Cartman anyway despite the threat of punishment.

Wendy then meets Cartman on the playground for the fight. Cartman makes final efforts to escape the situation: claiming it is too late in their recess period do go through, but he eventually gives in: calling Wendy a "big bully" and decides to fight. Although Cartman briefly gains the upper hand, Wendy dominates the fight and soon emerges victorious with only a few bruises, while leaving Cartman bruised, bloody, and having knocked out many of his teeth. The other students cheer her, and after Wendy leaves and a few students disperse, Cartman begins to sob in front of the remaining students: bemoaning that he will no longer be considered "the cool kid". Cartman's classmates assure him that they never thought he was cool in the first place and that they all have always hated him; Cartman in delusion assumes they're trying to make him feel better, reasoning that they must still like him. Cartman is suddenly elated at this thought, leaving the others dumbfounded by his psychosis.

Cultural references

The plot of the episode is loosely based on the film ''Three O'Clock High''. The fight scene is also based on that of the film '' Snatch'' and references the ending scene of ''There Will Be Blood''. In the DVD commentary, Parker and Matt Stone refer to the character's interactions in the episode as thematically similar to the cartoon show ''Peanuts'' and "kids being kids". While Cartman awaits the fight in class, Mr. Garrison says, "So you see, at this point Euripides knew he could not win the battle", referencing ''The Frogs'', a comedic play by Aristophanes where the Greek tragedians Euripides and Aeschylus are measured against one another, the better to be revived so he can "educate the thoughtless" and rid Athens of evil politicians that are ruining the city (1500-1502, The Frogs).

Reception

''The A.V. Club'' graded the episode a B+, stating "All in all, not the most-ambitious episode, but that actually worked in its favor: Outside of Wendy's crib from ''There Will Be Blood'' at the end, it could have been broadcast 10 years ago and worked, and I also have a feeling it will still be funny 10 years from now since it wasn't crammed with instantly-dated references". IGN gave the episode an 8.2/10 rating, stating "While this is a fun sequence, and a nice bit of observation, the episode does seem somewhat anticlimactic. It's amusing that Cartman thinks he somehow achieved something when he finds out the kids always thought he sucked and their opinion of him 'couldn't possibly be any lower'. Massive self-delusion is part of Cartman's 'charm'. But the episode is unusually focused for ''South Park'' and once the fight is over there's a sense (perhaps intentionally?) of 'that's it?'. It's not one of the best episodes ever, but it's a solid old-school installment that offers up some truly great momentsmany of them quintessential Cartman. Which is always fun to watch".

Home release

"Breast Cancer Show Ever", along with the thirteen other episodes from ''South Parks twelfth season, were released on a three-disc DVD set and two-disc Blu-ray set in the United States on March 10, 2009. The sets included brief audio commentaries by Parker and Stone for each episode, a collection of deleted scenes, and two special mini-features, ''The Making of 'Major Boobage'' and ''Six Days to South Park''.

References

External links

"Breast Cancer Show Ever"
Full episode at South Park Studios
*

{{South Park episodes, 12

South Park season 12 episodes
Breast cancer
Television episodes about bullying