Baohuang Hui

The Chinese Empire Reform Association, abbreviated as C.E.R.A (''Baojiu Da-Qing Huangdi Hui'', ), or, more often, Baohuanghui, ) was a worldwide Chinese political association founded by Kang Youwei (1858–1927) in Victoria, British Columbia on 20 July 1899. Its goal was to unite overseas Chinese to restore the Guangxu Emperor to his throne and transform China's autocratic empire into a constitutional monarchy.

Kang was a Cantonese scholar, teacher, and constitutional reformer who helped Guangxu enact extensive educational, political, social, military, economic, and administrative reforms during the tumultuous Hundred Days of Reform, June 11 to September 21, 1898.

The reforms only lasted 103 days because they threatened the power and position of the conservative Qing court and Guangxu's aunt and former regent, Empress Dowager Cixi. Cixi took back the throne, put Guangxu under house arrest, and abolished the reform program. She executed six of the reform advisors, including Kang's brother, and called for Kang's arrest and execution.

Warned by the emperor of the impending crackdown, Kang fled into exile, and made it his mission to restore the emperor and his reform program. Kang turned to Chinese living in the Americas, Australia, Asia, Africa and Europe to join this nationalist movement. The result was a worldwide organization that grew to at least 230 local chapters and 100,000 members. The Chinese Empire Reform Association appealed to overseas Chinese who hoped to see their homeland modernize and democratize. It remained a strong organization until the end of 1911, when the revolutionaries led by Sun Yatsen were able to topple the Qing dynasty and form a republic. In effect, the Baohuanghui was the first mass Chinese political party.

North America—Canada, the United States, and Mexico—was where the association fulfilled its greatest potential, with at least 160 chapters that managed the full gamut of associated endeavors that Kang believed were necessary to save China: newspapers and schools to propagate reform ideology; military academies to train young Chinese to defend their country; women’s associations to promote gender equality; and businesses to raise funds for reform activities and expand Chinese commercial power in China and abroad. Between 1899 and 1907, Kang spent 29 months in North America, traveling widely both for his education and pleasure; organizing, fundraising, and making speeches to both Chinese and American audiences; and meeting North American leaders, including Canadian Prime Minister Wilfrid Laurier, U.S. President Theodore Roosevelt, and Mexican President José de la Cruz Porfirio Díaz Mori.

Name Changes and Re-organization, 1899–1912

Although the organization was always known in English as the Chinese Empire Reform Association, its Chinese name changed over time, along with its goals and governing documents.

Baohuanghui 保皇會 (Protect the Emperor Society), 1899–1906

During the founding meetings in July 1899, the name Baohuanghui 保皇會 was chosen because the Guangxu emperor “had risked his life to save the people.” For Baohuanghui members, the imprisoned emperor symbolized the endangered quest for reform and modernization of China. Kang wrote the founding document in September 1899, and while he informally called the organization Baohuanghui, the formal name was Baojiu Da-Qing Huangdi Gongsi 保救大清皇帝公司 ompany to Protect the Great Qing Emperor This name reflected the dual mission of political and economic reform and encouraged commercial investment by the overseas Chinese merchants who dominated the Baohuanghui leadership.

Xianzhenghui 憲政會 (Constitutional Association), 1907-1912

On September 1, 1906, the Qing declared that China would begin the transition to a constitutional monarchy, after receiving positive reports from two imperial missions that studied constitutional systems in Japan, the United States and Europe. Kang decided the time was right for the Baohuanghui to change its name and its function from protecting the emperor, who appeared to be in no danger, to preparing its members to return to China to participate in a reformed government. In October 1906, he announced that on the lunar new year (February 13, 1907), the Baohuanghui would become the Guomin Xianzhenghui 國民憲政會 (Citizens’ Constitutional Association), or for short, Xianzhenghui (Constitutional Association). While the final name as adopted in 1907 hearkened back to the Baohuanghui connection, replacing Guomin 國民 (Citizen) with Diguo 帝國 (Imperial), the new charter stated that its goal was to expand the rights and duties of China’s citizens and form a parliament. The organization was intended to teach members “how to structure a constitutional government, how to set up a political party, how citizens of a constitutional government and their country are interdependent, and how they rely on political parties.” In many ways, the Xianzhenghui charter resembled a national constitution.

Often Kang would use the term for "party" (''dang'' 黨) rather than "association" (''hui'' 會), and occasionally referred to the Xianzhenghui as Xianzhengdang (Constitutional Party), which became the organization's name in 1912 under the new Republic of China. Kang had first named the new party Guomindang (Citizens' Party) until this name was taken by the Nationalists.

Organizational Structure

The organizational structure of the Chinese Empire Reform Association was mandated in successive charters drafted by Kang Youwei, the first in 1899, and the second two discussed and amended at plenary meetings in New York City in 1905 and 1907. From top to bottom, the association was governed by a president who made all final decisions; one or more headquarters that collected and dispersed funds from chapters and Association businesses; chapters; and members. The chapters were based in towns and cities, and in the United States, which had most chapters of any country, were divided into regional divisions (Northwest, California, Montana, Central, East, South). Driving the expansion of the association between 1899 and 1905 was an organizing push by Kang himself as well as a traveling cadre of former students who had attended his school in Guangzhou in the 1890s and local leaders who took the initiative to form new chapters and recruit members.

All officers, including the president, were to be elected by members or chapter delegates. The association president was always Kang Youwei and the vice-president Liang Qichao, who like Kang, was an advisor to the Guangxu Emperor in 1898 and fled into exile. Hong Kong, Macau, and Yokohama all functioned at one time or another as headquarters, centralizing association finances as much as possible. However, as the building commemorating the July 1899 organizational founding in Victoria, BC, the Chinese Empire Reform Association founding headquarters is at 1715 Government Street.

Each local chapter was to publicly elect a number of local officers for the local chapters, who led weekly member meetings, collected membership fees and forwarded a portion to the headquarters, went on speaking tours, raised shares for businesses and funds for schools, and organized local events (such as celebration of the Emperor's birthday) and political activism. Liang Qichao wrote the Los Angeles chapter's charter in 1903, which describes the purpose of the association, the most important activities it was to carry out, how meetings should be handled, and the duties of the officers. Many of the local chapters had physical offices or even their own building, which might also serve as meeting places and schools. For example, the New York City chapter occupied different addresses on Mott Street in Chinatown, where in addition to a meeting room, it ran a school and a branch of the Western Military Academy; it also operated a newspaper and sponsored a branch of the affiliated women's association. Two plenary meetings convened by Kang Youwei and attended by Baohuanghui leaders representing chapters around the world were held at 7-9 Mott Street in 1905 and 1907.

Association members had obligations to fulfill; in 1905, the charter stated, “Everyone who joins the society will be loyal and righteous to each other and join together as a group 'hequn''to rescue the country.” Beginning in 1905, they also had to pay membership fees ($5 in the United States), which was to be remitted to the organizational headquarters to "handle national affairs." The 1907 charter expanded the rights and duties of members, more closely mirroring a national constitution. It included such rights as the right to elect association officers and to be elected to office, the right to appeal if defamed by another member or chapter, and the right to be received as a guest when visiting other chapters. Membership fees to support the organization were equated to taxes paid by citizens of a country to support its administration of national affairs.

The Chinese Empire Reform Association 1905 and 1907 charters also mandated several divisions, expanding the reach of the organization in local communities. Most significant were those dedicated to military affairs, education, business affairs, support of students abroad, services such as bathhouses to improve sanitation, and encouragement of Chinese immigration to underdeveloped lands where they might prosper.

Organizational Activities

While focused on the larger aim of bringing about a constitutional monarchy in China, on an individual level, Chinese Empire Reform Association activities were meant to cultivate citizenship and nationalism in its members. Members were encouraged to read newspapers and listen to speeches in order to learn about the world, especially current events in China, as well as agriculture, industry, and commerce, essential tools for modernization. Local offices supplied newspapers published by the Association, and the weekly chapter meetings were to feature speeches on these topics. Traveling speakers visited the chapters, rousing members to support whatever political activity was most urgent at the time. In addition, the Association organized a network of schools, military academy branches, businesses, women's associations, and newspapers that promoted Association goals and involved thousands of members and many non-members. Finally, the Association sponsored political and military actions, including anti-foreign boycotts, constitutional petitions, and attempted uprisings inside China.

Schools

The education of members and their children was a priority for the Association, given Kang's most devoted disciples were his former students at Wanmucaotang (萬木草堂 Thatched Hut among 10,000 Trees) in Guangzhou, an innovative school that blended Kang's reform-oriented version of Confucianism with world history, science, mathematics, and even calisthenics. Beginning in 1898 with the Datong (大同 Great Unity) School in Yokohama, founded by Liang Qichao, a network of schools was established in Japan, Macau, China, Southeast Asia, North America, Honolulu, and Australia. In the overseas schools, the students typically studied the Chinese language alongside Confucian ethics, Chinese history, science, and physical education. Some schools taught both boys and girls; many used graded textbooks by the progressive educator and Kang disciple, Chen Zibao, which introduced topics in colloquial language and in a style appealing to children. Although establishing and staffing schools was a costly venture for the Association, members willingly donated money to support education. Two of the schools sponsored by the Association are still in existence today, Tongwen Xuexiao (Common Culture School 同文學校) in Kōbe, Japan, and Mun Lun School (Minglun Liangdeng Xuetang 明倫兩等學堂 ) in Honolulu, Hawaiʻi.

Western Military Academy

Kang Youwei espoused military training and the discipline that it required as essential for "saving China." In the United States, he endorsed the proposal by a young American visionary in Los Angeles whose military expertise came solely from books, Homer Lea, to establish the Western Military Academy (its Chinese name was Gancheng Xuexiao 干城學校 or Shield and Ramparts School). Founded in 1904 by the Los Angeles Chinese Empire Reform Association chapter with retired American military veterans as instructors and a curriculum designed by Lea, the Academy expanded to around 30 branches in the United States, all funded by local Association chapters.

The cadets wore second-hand American uniforms, learned to drill and use weapons, and made a positive impression not only on their local Chinese compatriots but by American observers when they marched in formation whether at the January 1905 Rose Parade in Pasadena or greeting Kang and other dignitaries upon arrival at train stations. The 1905 charter stated that the Association would support the further education of graduating cadets who were admitted by American military schools.

No doubt the pride and patriotism instilled by the Association's military training program would have insured its continued success if it had not been for Lea's many public statements that the Academy was a reform army and he was its General, alerting the Governors of California and New York as well as the federal government that the Academy could be violating the law of neutrality by training foreign soldiers on American soil. Kang dismissed Lea in December 1905 and the Academy branches disbanded over time.

Businesses

Kang had long promoted private enterprise and modern commercial practices as essential for China's strength. Once abroad, he met many successful Chinese businessmen, who helped him found the Chinese Empire Reform Association in 1899 in Canada and led most of the local Association chapters. Taking advantage of their energy and entrepreneurship, Kang, with the assistance of the Hong Kong headquarters and Canadian leaders, proposed a Commercial Corporation (Shangwu Gongsi 商务公司). This multi-national conglomerate was formally established in 1904. Eventually, it encompassed banks, newspapers, book publishing companies, restaurants and hotels, rice brokerages and fishing monopolies, streetcar and steamship lines, railroad investments, mining; real estate and land development. Members bought shares in the Corporation, and members also managed the companies, with varying success, given that the members Kang trusted the most were his past students, few of whom had business experience. Some of the businesses for which funds were raised never materialized, such as a steamship line between Mexico and China, while others survived far longer than the Association itself, often under leadership of former Association members (e.g., King Joy Lo (1906–26), a Chicago restaurant founded to fund studies abroad for Association youth and sold in 1912 to a group of members).

The Commercial Corporation began to falter after Kang's 1905–7 sojourns in Mexico, a country that then encouraged Chinese immigration and investment. Kang's eagerness to capitalize on the seeming ease of doing business there diverted Association resources into expensive investments—a bank (and large building to house it), tramway line, the proposed steamship line, and real estate development. While promising at first, a worldwide depression in 1907 and conflict between Kang and some of the members managing Association businesses not only led to the failure of many of the conglomerate's businesses but also to internal dissention and disillusion among Association members, which led to the organization losing membership to the rising revolutionary faction led by Sun Yatsen.

Women's Association

Kang Tongbi, Kang's second daughter, came to North America in 1903 in pursuit of an education. She had accompanied him in India in 1902, when he completed writing ''Datong Shu'' (The Book of Great Community 大同書), a utopian plan not only for China but the entire world. One of its unusual features was complete equality of men and women. Tongbi thus was primed to advocate for women's rights when she landed in Victoria, BC, and soon after organized the first chapters of the Chinese Empire Ladies Reform Association (Baohuangnühui 保皇女會). Because there were few women among the Chinese immigrants, most of the members were the wives of Association leaders, who being primarily merchants, were allowed to bring their wives to the United States. Activities included making speeches about women's rights and raising funds for Association projects. A poster of the Victoria women's association pictures Kang, daughter Tongbi, Liang Qichao, and the Guangxu Emperor above photos of each woman officer; several outstanding women are singled out for emulation: Joan of Arc, Ming dynasty general Qin Liangyu, and Russian assassin Sophia Perovskaya. Women's Association chapters were formed across the United States and in Honolulu. Kang Tongbi was just one of several women Association members who spread a feminist message, but her ability to command an audience and press attention was unique.

Newspapers

A network of about forty Chinese Empire Reform Association newspapers was its most effective tool for promoting the organization in Chinese communities and communicating with far-flung chapters. The first newspapers were begun by the reformers in Macau (''Zhixin Bao'' 知新報, November 1897) and Yokohama, Japan (''Qingyi Bao'' 清議報 December 1898), and after the Association was founded in 1899, the network quickly expanded in North America, Southeast Asia, Japan, China, and Australia. Newspaper offices often became meeting places for organizing political actions, as with Shanghai's ''Shi Bao'' in planning the 1905 anti-American boycott (see Political Movements below). Chapter news was sent by telegraph to newspaper offices, which featured regular columns on activities, including listing new members and donors to various causes. Newspapers in the network reprinted each other's articles and editorials, extending the reach of popular writers, such as Liang Qichao, whose following was greater than Kang's. Both international and local news was covered, as well as commentary and messages from Association leaders. Only one Association newspaper's complete run still exists, ''Donghua Bao'' (''Tung Wah'' 東華報 ), which was published in Sydney, Australia between 1898 and 1936 and contains news of chapters throughout the world.

Political Movements

To influence both Chinese and foreign governments, the Chinese Empire Reform Association organized boycotts (the most famous being the 1905 anti-American boycott to protest Chinese Exclusion), sent petitions and group telegrams to the Qing court, and became directly involved in the burgeoning constitutional movement inside China from 1907 to 1911.

The political issues of greatest concern to the Association were: restoration of the emperor, constitutional government, convening a parliament, transformation of imperial subjects into citizens, instilling Chinese nationalism, women's rights, China's modernization, foreign intervention in China, and anti-Chinese policies abroad. The first step in mobilizing members to take political action was educating them about the importance of these issues both for their own lives and for the future of China. Kang and other Association leaders conveyed these ideas through speeches, newspapers, group letters and telegrams.

Petitions

In keeping with Chinese tradition, the Association most often expressed its political positions by submitting memorials and petitions to the Emperor, sending letters or more often telegrams from multiple Association chapters to the Qing court. These were usually initiated by Kang himself and circulated internally or published in newspapers, accumulating supporters, before being telegraphed to Beijing. The first major circular telegram movement was in January1900, after Kang alerted members that the Empress Dowager planned to depose Guangxu and replace him with 14-year old Prince Pujun. Association chapters from 46 cities sent telegrams to the Qing Foreign Affairs Office in opposition to this move, which were reprinted in ''Qingyi Bao'' and ''Zhixin Bao'', and along with a telegram movement inside China, caused Cixi to back down from removing Guangxu. When Qing officials went abroad, they would often be approached by members of the local Association chapter conveying their demands in writing. For example, in 1910, Prince Zaitao, a half-brother of Guangxu, visited the United States on an imperial mission to study military modernization and met with Association leaders in Chicago and New York City, receiving their petitions calling for the convening of a parliament.

A particularly active period for petitions coincided with the Qing government constitutional preparation period, particularly between 1907 and 1911, when the Association pressed for more rapid implementation of constitutional reforms. This was an active movement inside and outside China, with those advocating for the convening of parliament and the writing of a constitution coming from officials of the Qing government as well as from reform-minded Chinese, many of them overseas. A series of constitutional petitions issued by different combinations of groups included the most controversial petition written by Kang. This petition was published (serially because of its length) in Association newspapers and circulated among the chapters between July and November 1907 for the collection of signatures. In July 1908, it appeared for the first time inside China, and brought a strong backlash from the Qing court. The 12-point petition was submitted on behalf of the members of the Xianzhenghui in 200 cities and bemoaned the increasing danger China faced from within (the threat of revolution) and without (foreign aggression). Apart from the usual calls for restoring the Guangxu Emperor to his throne and the election of a parliament that would draft the constitution, the most provocative demands were to change the name of China from Great Qing Empire, or (Da-Qing Guo 大清國) to China (Zhonghua 中華) and to equalize the status of the majority Han ethnic group with the Manchus (the ethnic group of the Qing rulers whose rights were greater than the Han). These demands so outraged the Qing court that it banned a newly-formed domestic arm of the Xianzhenghui, the Political Information Society (Zhengwenshe 政聞社), which was growing rapidly inside China, and began arresting its members. The result was a radicalization of the constitutional reformers in China.

Anti-foreign Movements

Anti-foreign movements were a powerful political tactic that involved members and sympathizers in rallies, boycotting foreign products, and raising funds to support the boycotters. The Association was involved in three anti-foreign movements: the anti-Russia movement (1901-5), the anti-American boycott (1905-6), and the anti-Japanese boycott (1908). Just like a war, movements pitting Chinese citizens against foreign nations galvanized nationalism and created a new personal identity as members of a modern nation.

= Anti-Russia Movement (1901–5)

=
Just as with the other anti-foreign movements, the anti-Russia movement was also directed to the Qing government, Animosity toward Russia arose in 1901 when Russian troops remained in Manchuria after the Boxer Rebellion and the Qing seemed powerless to expel them. The movement was kicked off at a March 24, 1901 rally in Zhang Yuan park in Shanghai, with the first public speech by a woman in China. Seventeen-year old Xue Jinqin (薛锦琴) blamed the fecklessness of China when faced with the Russian troops in Manchuria on the Chinese people, who "regard themselves as helpless babies and left everything in the hands of officials." Xue would soon move to the United States to study and become an activist in the Chinese Empire Reform Association, giving speeches and leading the San Francisco women's reform chapter; she also promised Kang Youwei she would return to China after her studies and assassinate the Empress Dowager. More than 130 Association chapters signed a 1904 petition supporting the anti-Russia movement, which was published in Association newspapers.

= Anti-American Boycott (1905–6)

=
What has been described as China's first mass movement, the anti-American boycott was triggered by the possibility that the Qing would agree to the extension of the Gresham-Yang treaty with the United States that excluded most Chinese immigrants from entering the country. Since the 1882 enactment of Chinese Exclusion policies by the U.S. Congress, Chinese of all classes, but especially those who were not officials, merchants, or students, met with increasingly stringent restrictions and harsh treatment when crossing the borders. As the only nationality encountering such treatment, these policies and the stories told by those sent back to China by US immigration officials were humiliating to Chinese at home and abroad. The anti-American boycott gave Chinese a way to protest American discrimination and for a few months in 1905, the boycott mobilized merchants who refused to sell American goods, consumers who refused to buy American products, as well as overseas supporters who lent their voices at rallies and made donations to the boycotting merchants. A nationwide boycott was announced on May10, 1905 by the Shanghai General Chamber of Commerce.

While the organization of the boycott was largely at the direction of China's new chambers of commerce, influential Association leaders were behind its initiation, and the boycott's impact was magnified by the propaganda of the Chinese Empire Reform Association. For several years, Liang Qichao and Association leaders had written lengthy articles in their widely-read newspapers opposing Chinese exclusion. In 1903, Chen Yikan (陳儀侃) edited the Association newspaper in Honolulu and wrote a powerful statement proposing that a boycott of American products could influence the U.S. government because of the importance of American trade with China. Kang himself felt strongly about the Exclusion policy and when he finally was permitted o enter the United States in 1905, he knew he wanted to speak directly to President Theodore Roosevelt about the harm Exclusion caused to U.S.-China relations. Thus early in May 1905, he sent a circular telegram to Association leaders in Shanghai, Yokohama, and Hong Kong asking them to take urgent action because U.S Envoy William W. Rockhill had left for China to persuade the Qing Foreign Ministry to sign the exclusion treaty. In Shanghai, the editors of the ''Shi Bao'' met secretly with two members of the Shanghai Chamber of Commerce who became the spearheads of the boycott, and the newspaper served as a meeting place for boycott organizers and a medium to spread national boycott news. In the United States, Kang spoke to both Chinese and American audiences about Exclusion and the boycott and met twice with President Roosevelt in June, 1905, resulting in an executive order directing immigration officers to relax enforcement of the regulations. The boycott continued until early 1906 and resulted in a halving of American exports to China between 1905 and 1907. While the Qing refused to sign the Gresham-Yang treaty, it did succumb to pressure by the U.S. government to stop the boycott.

= Anti-Japanese Boycott (1908)

=
Humiliation brought on by foreign aggression and Qing government capitulation to this aggression was behind the 1908 anti-Japanese boycott. The incident triggering the boycott took place in the Macau harbor on February 5, 1908. The ''Tatsu Maru'', a Japanese ship docked at Macau, was raided by Qing naval officers and its cargo seized—smuggled weapons for revolutionaries in Guangdong. The officers replaced the Japanese flag with the Qing dragon flag, further inflaming the Japanese government, which demanded that the Chinese government apologize and pay for the seized cargo. Outrage by both Chinese merchants and officials as well as citizens in Guangdong, Hong Kong, and Shanghai, was channeled into a boycott of Japanese products and services—matches, clothing, tobacco, shipping, and insurance—that both affected the Japanese economy and resulted in new Chinese factories to produce what had been imported from Japan. Even more so than in earlier anti-foreign movements, public anger was also directed against the Qing. Notably, there was no boycott support from revolutionaries in China.

Furthermore, the Chinese Empire Reform Association promoted the movement, with two newspapers in the region, ''Guoshi Bao'' (國事報) in Guangzhou and ''Shang Bao'' (商報) in Hong Kong acting as boycott clearinghouses and propaganda arms. It was significant that three major Association leaders were in Guangzhou—Xu Qin (徐勤) in Guangzhou and Chen Yikan, the man who first proposed an anti-American boycott—and Hong Kong—Wu Xianzi (伍憲子). Overseas chapters, particularly in Australia, Japan, and the United States, raised funds and began promoting the strengthening of the Chinese navy. Chinese merchants in Japan turned from exporting Japanese products in China to building domestic factories. The boycott lasted eight months and for the reformers, segued into the constitutional petition movement, highlighted by Kang's petition described above.

Uprisings and other Violent Methods

In 1900, the Chinese Empire Reform Association plotted with domestic correspondents to engineer an armed uprising in China, taking advantage of the chaos of the Eight-Nation Alliance marching on Beijing. The Association's promised funds were delayed, however, with some (such as Liang Qichao) accusing Kang of deliberately withholding funds due to his disagreement with the more radical co-conspirators such as Sun Yat-sen. This resulted in some cells starting action as originally planned while others stayed put, and the conspiracy was discovered by Qing authorities. Tang Caichang, the designated leader of the uprising in Hankou, was executed by the Qing government.

After suing for peace with the foreign powers, the Qing court softened its resistance to constitutional reform, so the Reform Association's platform shifted to co-operating with the push for top-down reform in China. Its main perceived threat changed to the republican revolutionaries led by Sun Yat-sen. In 1906, the Qing government adopted the policy of establishing a constitutional monarchy by 1911. Kang Youwei declared that the Association's goals were accomplished, and in 1907 it changed its Chinese name to the "Empire Constitutionalist Association" (帝國憲政會), which was much closer to the association's English name. In its new incarnation, the Association aligned itself with the Qing court and opposed the republicans. In 1910, the Association reorganized itself into the political party "Empire Unity Party" (帝國統一黨), which was the first officially registered political party in China, later renamed the "Friends of the Constitution Association" (憲友會).

After the Xinhai Revolution of 1911 and the establishment of the Republic of China in 1912, some members of Association went on to form new political parties that participated in elections to the republican parliament, while Kang himself agitated for restoration of monarchy, including organising the brief Manchu Restoration of 1917. The bulk of the "Friends of the Constitution Association" became the Democratic Party, which merged into the Progressive Party in 1913.

References

External links

*
A Chinese Reformer in Exile: Kang Youwei and the Chinese Empire Reform Association in North America, 1899-1911
' by Robert L. Worden and Jane Leung Larson, with Zhongping Chen, Evelyn Hu-DeHart, Chen Xuezhang, and Yang Zheng (Leiden, The Netherlands: Brill, 27 Jan. 2025). doi: https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004713383
*
Transpacific Reform and Revolution: The Chinese in North America, 1898-1918
' by Zhongping Chen (Stanford: Stanford University Press, 2023).
*
Revolutionaries, Monarchists, and Chinatowns: Chinese Politics in the Americas and the 1911 Revolution
' by L. Eve Armentrout Ma (Honolulu: University of Hawai‘i Press, 1990).
Victoria's Chinatown - Chinese Empire Reform Association An Association to Save China, the Baohuang Hui 保皇會Baohuanghui ScholarshipChinese Empire Reform Association
{{Authority control

Monarchism in China
1899 establishments in Canada
1899 in politics
1900s in China