At First Sight (1999 Film)

''At First Sight'' is a 1999 American romantic drama film directed by Irwin Winkler and starring Val Kilmer and Mira Sorvino. It is based on the essay "To See and Not See" in neurologist Oliver Sacks's 1995 book ''An Anthropologist on Mars'' and inspired by the true life story of Shirl Jennings. The film was written by Steve Levitt.

Plot

Amy Benic (Mira Sorvino) takes a vacation at a spa outside New York City. Virgil Adamson (Val Kilmer) is a masseur at the spa and gives Amy a massage. Amy inexplicably cries and Virgil comforts her. While complimenting Virgil on the massage, Amy realizes that Virgil is blind. Virgil asks her out, and the two eventually begin a relationship.

Virgil lives alone, though his over-protective sister Jennie ( Kelly McGillis) lives next door and takes care of him. Virgil reveals that he went blind when he was three and that the last thing he saw was something fluffy. While researching Virgil's condition, Amy learns of Doctor Charles Aaron, a specialist in eye treatment who suggests to Virgil that, with surgery, he could restore his sight. Virgil angrily refuses. Jennie reveals that their father left the family after putting Virgil through several kinds of treatments in order to restore his sight.

Virgil eventually decides he will give the operation a try. It is a success, but after Virgil regains sight, he becomes confused and disoriented, unable to perceive light and distance. Dr. Aaron suggests that he should visit Phil Webster (Nathan Lane), a visual physiotherapist. Webster in turn suggests that Virgil needs to learn everything from scratch himself, through experience.

Virgil and Amy begin living in New York City. The pair begin drifting apart, as Virgil finds it hard to decipher the look on Amy's face at times. Amy finds herself constantly having to explain basic things to Virgil. While at a party, Virgil walks into a glass pane due to his poor perception.

Virgil's father sees him on television and arranges a reunion; Virgil goes to his father's workplace, but decides at the last minute that he cannot face him yet.

On one of the regular visits with Webster, they engage in a deep conversation, where Webster notes that instead of just "seeing", Virgil should "look"; there are a lot of things that sight alone cannot solve. Virgil confesses that he and Amy are drifting apart, but insists that Amy is the most important thing in his life.

Upon returning from a work trip to Atlanta, where she and her ex-husband shared a sensual moment, Amy decides to save the relationship. She finds Virgil in a park looking for "the horizon" in the city.

Virgil's sight begins deteriorating. After consulting with Dr. Aaron, Virgil realizes that he is losing his sight yet again. He decides to look for his father. Virgil reveals to him that he is going blind again, and asks him why he left. His father tells him that he felt he was a failure when he did not find a way to help his son regain sight. Virgil states that he should not have left because his mother and sister suffered greatly after his father walked away.

Virgil looks for Amy, who tells him about her plans to travel with him to places like Egypt and Europe. Withholding the fact that he is again going blind, Virgil tells her there is one thing he really wants to see, and brings her to a New York Rangers game.

At the game, Virgil realizes that the "fluffy cloud" he last remembers seeing was cotton candy. He suffers a lengthened vision blackout and admits to Amy that he is going blind, which Amy refuses to accept. Back home, Virgil and Amy argue. He asks if she wants to spend her life with him if he is going to be blind forever. Amy hesitates, and Virgil decides to return home. Virgil eases back into his old way of life. While losing his sight, Virgil decides to look at as many things as possible, going through magazines and pictorial books in the library. He stays up to watch the sunset, seeing the horizon for the first and last time.

After he has been blind again for some time, Virgil is at a park with a guide dog. Amy approaches and they reconnect. Amy apologizes to Virgil for trying to change him and for moving too fast. She asks if he wants to take a walk and "see what they see". They leave the park together.

Cast

*Mira Sorvino as Amy Benic
*Val Kilmer as Virgil Adamson
* Kelly McGillis as Jennie Adamson
*Steven Weber as Duncan Allanbrook
*Bruce Davison as Dr. Charles Aaron
*Nathan Lane as Phil Webster
* Drena De Niro as Caroline
*Laura Kirk as Betsy Ernst

Production

In February 1997, it was announced Irwin Winkler was working on “To See or Not To See” by Steve Levitt based on a story by Oliver Sacks. Initially the project had been set up at Sony Pictures until it was placed into Turnaround and was acquired by MGM at the behest of then MGM President Michael Nathanson. In September 1997, it was announced Val Kilmer had joined the film (now titled ''Sight Unseen'') to play the lead for $9 million.

Reception

The film holds a "rotten" rating of 32% on the review aggregator website Rotten Tomatoes, based on 38 reviews, with an average rating of 5.4/10. The website's consensus reads, "Interesting premise, but too long and conventional." On Metacritic, it holds a weighted average score of 40 out of 100 based on 21 reviews, indicating "mixed or average" reviews. Audiences polled by CinemaScore gave the film an average rating of "B+" on an A+ to F scale.

References

External links

*
*

{{Oliver Sacks

1999 films
1999 romantic drama films
American romantic drama films
Films about blind people in the United States
Films based on non-fiction books
Films directed by Irwin Winkler
Films set in New York City
Films shot in New York (state)
Films shot in New York City
Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer films
Films produced by Irwin Winkler
Films based on works by Oliver Sacks
Films scored by Mark Isham
1990s English-language films
1990s American films
English-language romantic drama films