400px, The A-value for a is 1.74 as derived from the chemical equilibrium">methyl group is 1.74 as derived from the chemical equilibrium above. This means it costs of energy to have a methyl group in the axial position compared to the equatorial position.
A-values are numerical values used in the determination of the most stable orientation of atoms in a molecule (Conformational isomerism, conformational analysis), as well as a general representation of
steric bulk. A-values are derived from energy measurements of the different
cyclohexane conformations of a monosubstituted cyclohexane chemical.
Substituent
A substituent is one or a group of atoms that replaces (one or more) atoms, thereby becoming a moiety in the resultant (new) molecule. (In organic chemistry and biochemistry, the terms ''substituent'' and '' functional group'', as well as '' ...
s on a
cyclohexane
Cyclohexane is a cycloalkane with the molecular formula . Cyclohexane is non-polar. Cyclohexane is a colorless, flammable liquid with a distinctive detergent-like odor, reminiscent of cleaning products (in which it is sometimes used). Cyclohex ...
ring prefer to reside in the
equatorial position to the axial. The difference in
Gibbs free energy
In thermodynamics, the Gibbs free energy (or Gibbs energy; symbol G) is a thermodynamic potential that can be used to calculate the maximum amount of work (physics), work that may be performed by a closed system, thermodynamically closed system a ...
(ΔG) between the higher energy conformation (axial substitution) and the lower energy conformation (equatorial substitution) is the A-value for that particular substituent.
Utility
A-values help predict the
conformation of cyclohexane rings. The most stable conformation will be the one which has the substituent or substituents equatorial. When multiple substituents are taken into consideration, the conformation where the substituent with the largest A-value is equatorial is favored.
600px, center, A methyl substituent has a significantly smaller A-value than a ''tert''-butyl substituent; therefore the most stable conformation has the ''tert''-butyl in the equatorial position.
The utility of A-values can be generalized for use outside of cyclohexane conformations. A-values can help predict the
steric effect of a substituent. In general, the larger a substituent's A-value, the larger the steric effect of that substituent. A
methyl group
In organic chemistry, a methyl group is an alkyl derived from methane, containing one carbon atom bonded to three hydrogen atoms, having chemical formula . In formulas, the group is often abbreviated as Me. This hydrocarbon group occurs in ma ...
has an A-value of 1.74 while
''tert''-butyl group has an A-value of ~5. Because the A-value of ''tert''-butyl is higher, ''tert''-butyl has a larger
steric effect than methyl. This difference in steric effects can be used to help predict reactivity in chemical reactions.
Free energy considerations
Steric effects play a major role in the assignment of configurations in cyclohexanes. One can use steric hindrances to determine the propensity of a substituent to reside in the axial or equatorial plane. It is known that axial bonds are more hindered than the corresponding equatorial bonds. This is because substituents in the axial position are relatively close to two other axial substituents. This makes it very crowded when bulky substituents are oriented in the axial position. These types of steric interactions are commonly known as 1,3 diaxial interactions.
These types of interactions are not present with substituents at the equatorial position.
There are generally considered three principle contributions to the conformational
free energy:
#
Baeyer strain
In organic chemistry, ring strain is a type of instability that exists when bonds in a molecule form angles that are abnormal. Strain is most commonly discussed for small rings such as cyclopropanes and cyclobutanes, whose internal angles a ...
, defined as the strain arising from deformation of bond angles.
#
Pitzer strain, defined as the torsional strain arising from 1,2 interactions between groups attached to contiguous carbons,
#
Van der Waals interaction
In molecular physics, the van der Waals force is a distance-dependent interaction between atoms or molecules. Unlike ionic or covalent bonds, these attractions do not result from a chemical electronic bond; they are comparatively weak and t ...
s, which are similar to 1,3 diaxial interactions.
Enthalpic components
When comparing relative stability, 6- and 7-atom interactions can be used to approximate differences in
enthalpy
Enthalpy , a property of a thermodynamic system, is the sum of the system's internal energy and the product of its pressure and volume. It is a state function used in many measurements in chemical, biological, and physical systems at a constant ...
between conformations. Each 6-atom interaction is worth and each 7-atom interaction is worth .
Entropic components
Entropy
Entropy is a scientific concept, as well as a measurable physical property, that is most commonly associated with a state of disorder, randomness, or uncertainty. The term and the concept are used in diverse fields, from classical thermodyna ...
also plays a role in a substituent's preference for the equatorial position. The entropic component is determined by the following formula:
:
Where σ is equal to the number of
microstates available for each conformation.
350px, center, Possible axial conformations of ethyl cyclohexane.
500px, center, Possible equatorial conformations of ethyl cyclohexane.
Due to the larger number of possible conformations of ethyl cyclohexane, the A value is reduced from what would be predicted based purely on enthalpic terms. Due to these favorable entropic conditions, the steric relevance of an ethyl group is similar to that of a methyl substituent.
Table of A-values
Applications
Predicting reactivity
One of the original experiments performed by Winston and Holness was measuring the
rate
Rate or rates may refer to:
Finance
* Rates (tax), a type of taxation system in the United Kingdom used to fund local government
* Exchange rate, rate at which one currency will be exchanged for another
Mathematics and science
* Rate (mathema ...
of oxidation in trans and cis substituted rings using a chromium catalyst. The large ''tert''-butyl group used locks the conformation of each molecule, placing it equatorial (cis compound shown).
400px, center, Possible chair conformations of ''cis''-4-''tert''-butyl-cyclohexan-1-ol
It was observed that the cis compound underwent oxidation at a much faster rate than the trans compound. The proposition was that the large hydroxyl group in the axial position was disfavored and formed the carbonyl more readily to relieve this strain. The trans compound had rates identical to those found in the monosubstituted cyclohexanol.
400px, center, Chromium oxidation of ''cis''-4-''tert''-butyl-cyclohexan-1-ol
Approximating intramolecular force strength using A-values
Using the A-values of the hydroxyl and isopropyl subunit, the energetic value of a favorable intramolecular hydrogen bond can be calculated.
400px, center, Possible chair conformations and the favorable hydrogen bond available in the conformation where both hydroxyl substituents are equatorial
Limitations
A-Values are measured using a mono-substituted cyclohexane ring, and are an indication of only the sterics a particular substituent imparts on the molecule. This leads to a problem when there are possible stabilizing electronic factors in a different system. The
carboxylic acid
In organic chemistry, a carboxylic acid is an organic acid that contains a carboxyl group () attached to an R-group. The general formula of a carboxylic acid is or , with R referring to the alkyl, alkenyl, aryl, or other group. Carboxyl ...
substituent shown below is axial in the ground state, despite a positive A-value. From this observation, it is clear that there are other possible electronic interactions that stabilize the axial conformation.
image:CarboxylicAcidChairFlip.png, 400px, center, Equilibrium representation of a chair flip of a carboxylic acid; the axial position is preferred due to favorable electronic factors, despite a steric bias favoring the equatorial position.
Other considerations
It is important to note that A-values do not predict the physical size of a molecule, only the steric effect. For example, the ''tert''-butyl group (A-value=4.9) has a larger A-value than the
trimethylsilyl
A trimethylsilyl group (abbreviated TMS) is a functional group in organic chemistry. This group consists of three methyl groups bonded to a silicon atom minus;Si(CH3)3 which is in turn bonded to the rest of a molecule. This structural group is c ...
group (A-value=2.5), yet the ''tert''-butyl group actually occupies less space. This difference can be attributed to the longer length of the
carbon–silicon bond as compared to the
carbon–carbon bond
A carbon–carbon bond is a covalent bond between two carbon atoms. The most common form is the single bond: a bond composed of two electrons, one from each of the two atoms. The carbon–carbon single bond is a sigma bond and is formed be ...
of the ''tert''-butyl group. The longer bond allows for less interactions with neighboring substituents, which effectively makes the trimethylsilyl group less sterically hindering, thus, lowering its A-value.
This can also be seen when comparing the
halogens. Bromine, iodine, and chlorine all have similar A-values even though their atomic radii differ.
A-values then, predict the apparent size of a substituent, and the relative apparent sizes determine the differences in steric effects between compounds. Thus, A-values are useful tools in determining compound reactivity in chemical reactions.
References
{{reflist
Isomerism
Physical organic chemistry