Versus populum

''Versus populum'' (Latin for "towards the people") is the liturgical stance of a priest who, while celebrating Mass, faces the people from the other side of the altar. The opposite stance, that of a priest facing in the same direction as the people, is today called ''ad orientem'' (literally, "towards the east" − even if the priest is really facing in some other direction) or ''ad apsidem'' ("towards the apse" − even if the altar is unrelated to the apse of the church or even if the church or chapel has no apse).

In the early history of Christianity it was considered the norm to pray facing the geographical east. From the middle of the 17th century, almost all new Roman Rite altars were built against a wall or backed by a reredos, with a tabernacle placed on the main altar or inserted into the reredos. This meant that the priest turned to the people, putting his back to the altar, for a few short moments at Mass. However, the Tridentine Missal is not celebrated ''versus populum'' since the Ritus Servandus gives corresponding instructions for the priest when performing actions that require him to face the people. In the Ritus Servandus, the rubrics say "with his hands joined before his breast, and with his eyes downcast, he turns toward the people from left to right." This would otherwise not make sense in the context of versus populum since versus populum assumes that he is already facing the people.

History

Earliest churches in Rome

It has been said that the reason the Pope always faced the people when celebrating Mass in St Peter's was that early Christians faced eastward when praying and, due to the difficult terrain, the basilica was built with its apse to the west. Some have attributed this orientation in other early Roman churches to the influence of Saint Peter's. However, the arrangement whereby the apse with the altar is at the west end of the church and the entrance on the east is found also in Roman churches contemporary with Saint Peter's (such as the original Basilica of Saint Paul Outside the Walls) that were under no such constraints of terrain, and the same arrangement remained the usual one until the sixth century."When Christians in fourth-century Rome could first freely begin to build churches, they customarily located the sanctuary towards the west end of the building in imitation of the sanctuary of the Jerusalem Temple. Although in the days of the Jerusalem Temple the high priest indeed faced east when sacrificing on Yom Kippur, the sanctuary within which he stood was located at the west end of the Temple. The Christian replication of the layout and the orientation of the Jerusalem Temple helped to dramatize the eschatological meaning attached to the sacrificial death of Jesus the High Priest in the Epistle to the Hebrews"
The Eschatological Dimension of Church Architecture: The Biblical Roots of Church Orientation
The Institute for Sacred Architecture, volume 10, 2005 According to Klaus Gamber, in this early layout the people were situated not in the central nave but in the side aisles of the church and, while the priest faced both the altar and east throughout the Mass, the people faced the altar (from the sides) until the high point of the Mass, when they would turn to face east, the direction in which the priest was already facing. This view is strongly criticized on the grounds of the unlikelihood that, in churches where the altar was to the west, they would turn their backs on the altar (and the priest) at the celebration of the Eucharist.

Later pre-twentieth-century churches in Rome

It was in the 8th or 9th century that the position whereby the priest faced the apse, not the people, when celebrating Mass was adopted in Rome, under the influence of the Frankish Empire, where it had become general. However, in several churches in Rome, it was physically impossible, even before the twentieth-century liturgical reforms, for the priest to celebrate Mass facing away from the people, because of the presence, immediately in front of the altar, of the "confession" ( la, confessio), an area sunk below floor level to enable people to come close to the tomb of the saint buried beneath the altar. The best-known such "confession" is that in St Peter's Basilica, but many other churches in Rome have the same architectural feature, including at least one, the present Basilica of Saint Paul Outside the Walls, which, although the original Constantinian basilica was arranged like St Peter's, is oriented since 386 in such a way that the priest faces west when celebrating Mass.

Outside of Rome

The earliest Christian churches were not built with any particular orientation in mind, but by the fifth century it became the rule in the Eastern Roman Empire to have the altar at the east end of the church, an arrangement that became normal but not universal in northern Europe.''The Oxford Dictionary of Christian Art and Architecture'' (2013
), p. 117 The old Roman custom of having the altar at the west end and the entrance at the east was sometimes followed as late as the 11th century even in areas under Frankish rule, as seen in Petershausen (Constance), Bamberg Cathedral, Augsburg Cathedral, Regensburg Cathedral, and Hildesheim Cathedral (all in present-day Germany). In the east also, the original Constantinian Church of the Holy Sepulchre in Jerusalem had its apse to the west until it was Byzantinized in 1048.

Modernity

Roman Rite

In the Roman Rite of the Catholic Church, the altar is "the center of thanksgiving that the Eucharist accomplishes" and the point around which the other rites are in some manner arrayed. Its importance was made evident by Romano Guardini (1885–1968), about whom Robert R. Kuehn wrote: "with him uardinion the altar, the sacred table became the center of the universe" ..The impact of the sacred action was all the more profound because Guardini celebrated the Mass ''versus populum'' – facing the people."

Roman Missal

The present (2002) General Instruction of the Roman Missal says, in the official English translation: "The altar should be built separate from the wall, in such a way that it is possible to walk around it easily and that Mass can be celebrated at it facing the people, which is desirable wherever possible." Where practicable, the church altar should be built in such a way that the priest can easily walk around it and can celebrate Mass ''versus populum'', but the text does not oblige the priest to avail of these possibilities.

In practice, after the Second Vatican Council, altars that obliged the priest to have his back to the people were generally moved away from the wall or reredos, or, where this was unsuitable, a new freestanding altar was built closer to the people. This, however, is not universal, and in some churches and chapels it is physically impossible for the priest to face the people throughout the Mass, as before 1970 some churches, especially in Rome, had altars at which it was physically impossible for the priest not to face the people throughout the Mass.

The present Roman Missal prescribes that the priest should face the people at six points of the Mass:
*When giving the opening greeting (GIRM 124);
*When giving the invitation to pray, ''Orate, fratres'' (GIRM 146);
*When giving the greeting of peace, ''Pax Domini sit semper vobiscum'' (GIRM 154);
*When displaying the consecrated Host (or Host and Chalice) before Communion and saying: ''Ecce Agnus Dei'' (GIRM 157);
*When inviting to pray (''Oremus'') before the prayer after communion (GIRM 165);
*When giving the final blessing (''Ordo Missae'' 141).

The Tridentine Roman Missal requires the priest to face the people, without looking at them, since he is directed to have his eyes cast down to the ground (''Ritus servandus'', V, 1; VII, 7; XII, 1), and, if he is at the same side of the altar as the people, to turn his back to the altar, eight times:
*When greeting the people (''Dominus vobiscum'') before the collect (''Ritus servandus in celebratione Missae'', V, 1);
*When greeting the people (''Dominus vobiscum'') before the offertory rite (''Ritus servandus'', VII, 1);
*When giving the invitation to pray, ''Orate, fratres'' (''Ritus servandus'', VII, 7);
*Twice before giving Communion to others, first when saying the two prayers after the Confiteor, and again while displaying a consecrated Host and saying ''Ecce Agnus Dei''; (''Ritus servandus'', X, 6);
*When greeting the people (''Dominus vobiscum'') before the prayer after communion (''Ritus servandus'', XI, 1);
*When saying ''Ite, missa est'' (''Ritus servandus'', XI, 1);
*When giving the last part of the final blessing (''Ritus servandus'', XII, 1).

The Tridentine and the Vatican II editions of the Roman Missal expressly direct the priest to face the altar at exactly the same points. His position in relation to the altar and the people determines whether facing the altar means also facing the people.

Tabernacle on the altar

In the second half of the 17th century, it became customary to place the tabernacle on the main altar of the church. When a priest celebrates Mass at such an altar with his back to the people, he sometimes necessarily turns his back directly to the Blessed Sacrament, as when he turns to the people at the '' Orate fratres''. This seeming disrespect is absent when the priest stands on the side of the altar away from the people; but locating so large an object on the altar is arguably inconvenient for a celebration in which the priest faces the people. Accordingly, the revised Roman Missal states:
:'' is preferable that the tabernacle be located, according to the judgment of the Diocesan Bishop,''
:: ''a. Either in the sanctuary, apart from the altar of celebration, in a form and place more appropriate, not excluding on an old altar no longer used for celebration;''
:: ''b. Or even in some chapel suitable for the faithful’s private adoration and prayer and which is organically connected to the church and readily visible to the Christian faithful.'' (GIRM 315)

The Missal does, however, direct that the tabernacle be situated "in a part of the church that is truly noble, prominent, readily visible, beautifully decorated, and suitable for prayer" (GIRM 314).

Anglican

Historically, priests in the Church of England and other churches of the Anglican Communion celebrated the Holy Eucharist standing at the north-end (i.e. the left side) of the communion table, according to the rubric in the Book of Common Prayer. This standard was challenged in the 19th century by the Oxford Movement, many of whose leaders preferred the ''ad orientem'' position, which was standard in the Roman Catholic tradition. At first, this was controversial, however, the rubric requiring that the priest stand at the north end of the table, facing liturgical South, was removed from the 1928 American Book of Common Prayer, which opened up the option to be widely practiced. Praying ''ad orientem'' then became common especially at the Gloria Patri, Gloria in Excelsis and Ecumenical creeds in that direction. However, over "the course of the last forty years or so, a great many of those altars have either been removed and pulled out away from the wall or replaced by the kind of freestanding table-like altar", in "response to the popular sentiment that the priest ought not turn his back to the people during the service; the perception was that this represented an insult to the laity and their centrality in worship. Thus developed today’s widespread practice in which the clergy stand behind the altar facing the people."

Methodist

'' The United Methodist Book of Worship'' mandates that:

Lutheran

In the Lutheran German Mass (Deutsche Messe), Martin Luther, the founder of that denomination, wrote that:

In discussing the Divine Service, Lorraine S. Brugh and Gordon W. Lathrop write that "Many Lutherans, in concert with many other Christians, think that the time of which Luther spoke has indeed come, and that the pastor should preside at the table facting the people, i.e., ''versus populum''. The assembly needs to have a sense that it is gathered around that table, sees and hears what happens there, has a promise of Christ clearly addressed to it, participates in the thanksgiving, and is made into a community through God's gift." Thus, in the Lutheran Church, many altars are now built to be freestanding. In churches where the former altar attached to the wall cannot be moved, it has often been converted to be used as a credence table, as a "significant new table is set up, closer to the people and standing free".

Disputation

Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger (later Pope Benedict XVI) in his book the Spirit of the Liturgy criticised the use of versus populum as ahistorical and even harmful to the liturgy. He stated that versus populum "turns the community into a self-enclosed circle", where the presider becomes the real point of reference instead of God. He also maintained that praying toward the east (ad orientem) is a tradition that goes back to the beginning of Christianity and that is a "fundamental expression of the Christian synthesis of cosmos and history" and urged Catholics to gradually return to this tradition. On the other hand, he warned against quick and frequent changes to the liturgy, so he proposed a temporary solution - placing the cross in the middle of the altar, so the entire congregation "turns toward the Lord", who should be the real center of the Mass.

Edward Slattery, from 1993 to 2016 Bishop of the Roman Catholic Diocese of Tulsa, argued that the change towards ''versus populum'' has had a number of unforeseen and largely negative effects. First of all, he said, "it is a serious rupture with the Church's ancient tradition. Secondly, it can give the appearance that the priest and the people were engaged in a conversation about God, rather than the worship of God. Thirdly, it places an inordinate importance on the personality of the celebrant by placing him on a kind of liturgical stage".

On the other hand, the Jesuit theologian John Zupez, in an article in ''Emmanuel'' based on modern studies in scriptural exegesis, found that the New Testament word for sacrifice (''hilasterion)'' refers to our expiation from sin, not propitiation impacting or appeasing God. This current translation, accepted in the Catholic lectionary, should "eliminate a strong argument for the priest at Mass facing toward God (''ad orientem'')" and "support the practice of the priest facing the people to elicit their active involvement." However, the Council of Trent had already authoritatively confirmed that "this sacrifice f the Massis truly propitiatory."

See also

* ''Ad orientem''

References

External list

{{Liturgical Movement

Catholic liturgy
Latin religious words and phrases
Orientation (geometry)