Tim Shell

Bomis ( to rhyme with "promise") was a dot-com company best known for supporting the creations of free-content online-encyclopedia projects Nupedia and Wikipedia. It was co-founded in 1996 by Jimmy Wales, Tim Shell, and Michael Davis. By 2007, the company was inactive, with its Wikipedia-related resources transferred to the Wikimedia Foundation.

The company initially tried a number of ideas for content, including being a directory of information about Chicago. The site subsequently focused on content geared to a male audience, including information on sporting activities, automobiles, and women. Bomis became successful after focusing on X-rated media. "Bomis Babes" was devoted to erotic images; the "Bomis Babe Report" featured adult pictures. Bomis Premium, available for an additional fee, provided explicit material. "The Babe Engine" helped users find erotic content through a web search engine. The advertising director for Bomis noted that 99 percent of queries on the site were for nude women.

Bomis created Nupedia as a free online encyclopedia (with content submitted by experts) but it had a tedious, slow review process. Wikipedia was initially launched by Bomis to provide content for Nupedia, and was a for-profit venture (a Bomis subsidiary) through the end of 2002. As the costs of Wikipedia rose with its popularity, Bomis' revenues declined; these losses were compounded by the dot-com crash. Since Wikipedia was a drain on Bomis' resources, Wales and philosophy graduate student Larry Sanger decided to fund the project as a nonprofit. Sanger was laid off from Bomis in 2002. Nupedia content was merged into Wikipedia, and it ceased in 2003.

The non-profit Wikimedia Foundation began in 2003 with a board of trustees composed of Bomis' three founders (Wales, Davis, and Shell) and was first headquartered in St. Petersburg, Florida, Bomis' location. Wales used about US$100,000 of revenue from Bomis to fund Wikipedia before the decision to shift the encyclopedia to non-profit status. Wales stepped down from his role as CEO of Bomis in 2004. Shell served as CEO of the company in 2005, while on the Wikimedia Foundation board of trustees. Wales edited Wikipedia in 2005 to remove the characterizations of Bomis as providing softcore pornography, which attracted media attention; Wales expressed regret for his actions. ''The Atlantic'' gave Bomis the nickname "''Playboy'' of the Internet", and the term caught on in other media outlets. Scholars have described Bomis as a provider of softcore pornography.

History

Background

Jimmy Wales left a study track at Indiana University as a PhD candidate to work in finance before completing his doctoral dissertation.Edemariam 2011, p. 27Long 2012, p. 5 In 1994 Wales was hired by Michael Davis, CEO of finance company Chicago Options Associates, as a traderChozick 2013, p. MM28 focusing on futures contracts and options. Wales was adept at determining future movements of foreign currencies and interest rates; he was successful in Chicago, became independently wealthy, and was director of research at Chicago Options Associates from 1994 to 2000.Doran 2006, p. 49McNichol 2007 He became acquainted with Tim Shell from email lists discussing philosophy.Craig 2013, p. 84

Wales wanted to participate in the online-based entrepreneurial ventures which were increasingly popular and successful during the mid-1990s. His experience (from gaming in his youth) impressed on him the importance of networking. Wales was interested in computer science, experimenting with source code on the Internet and improving his skill at computer programming. In his spare time after work at Chicago Options Associates, Wales constructed his own web browser. While at the firm, he noted the successful 1995 initial public offering of Netscape Communications.

Foundation

Wales co-founded Bomis in 1996, with business associates Tim Shell,Zittrain 2008, p. 133Meyer 2012 and his then-manager Michael Davis,Seybold 2006, p. 250DiBona 2005 as a for-profit corporation with joint ownership.Lee 2013, p 91 Wales was its chief manager. In 1998 he moved from Chicago to San Diego to work for Bomis,Mangu-Ward 2007Pink 2005 and then to St. Petersburg, Florida (where the company subsequently relocated).Mehegan 2006

The staff at Bomis was originally about five employees. Its 2000 staff included programmer Toan Vo, Andrew McCague and system administrator Jason Richey; Wales employed his high-school friend and best man in his second wedding, Terry Foote, as advertising director.The Economist 2008 In June 2000, Bomis was one of five network partners of Ask Jeeves. The majority of the revenue that came in to Bomis was generated through advertising. The most successful time for Bomis was during its venture as a member of the NBC web portal NBCi; this collapsed at the end of the dot-com bubble.

Although Bomis is not an acronym, the name stemmed from "Bitter Old Men in Suits"Isaacson 2014, ''The Daily Beast'' (as Wales and Shell called themselves in Chicago). The site began as a web portal, trying a number of ideas (including serving as an access point for information about Chicago). It later focused on male-oriented content, including information on sporting activities, automobiles, and women.The Globe and Mail 2012, pp. 89–91Weinberger 2008, p. 138Shirky 2009

Hosted content

Working from the Open Directory Project,Gillmor 1999 Bomis created and maintained hundreds of webrings on topics related to lad culture. In 1999 the company introduced the Bomis Browser, which helped users block online pop-up ads.Wright 1999 Its webring on '' Star Wars'' was considered a useful resource for information on '' Star Wars: Episode I – The Phantom Menace'' (1999). Additional webrings included sections helping users find information on the 1942 film '' Casablanca'', Hunter S. Thompson, Farrah Fawcett, Geri Halliwell of the Spice Girls, and the 1998 film '' Snake Eyes''. "Bomis: The Buffy the Vampire Slayer Ring", devoted to '' Buffy the Vampire Slayer'', organized over 50 sites related to the program. Sheila Jeffreys noted in her ''Beauty and Misogyny'' that in 2004 Bomis maintained "The Lipstick Fetish Ring", which helped users with a particular attraction to women in makeup.Jeffreys 2005, pp. 60, 181

Bomis became successful after it focused on X-rated and erotic media.Kuchinskas 2009 Advertising generated revenue which enabled the company to fund other websites,Stöcker 2010Bhaskar 2013, pp. 158–159 and the site published suggestive pictures of professional models. In addition to Bomis the company maintained nekkid.com and nekkid.info, which featured pictures of nude women.Nekkid.info 2002 About ten percent of Bomis' revenue was derived from pornographic films and blogs.Business Insider 2013Schiff 2006

The website included a segment devoted to erotic images, "Bomis Babes",Hansen 2005Miller 2007, p. 17 and a feature enabled users to submit recommended links to other sites appealing to a male audience. Peer-to-peer services provided by the site helped users find other websites about female celebrities, including Anna Kournikova and Pamela Anderson. In the Bomis Babes section was the Bomis Babe Report, begun in 2000, with pictures of porn starsRosenzweig 2013Rosenzweig 2006Hutcheon 2007 in a blog format. The Bomis Babe Report produced original erotic material, including reports on pornographic film actors and celebrities who had posed nude. It was referred to as ''The Babe Report'' for short.Elliott 2007, p. 22

Wales referred to the site's softcore pornography as "glamour photography",Howe 2008, pp. 58–60Beveridge 2007, p. 68 and Bomis became familiar to Internet users for its erotic images. During this period Wales was photographed steering a yacht with a peaked cap, posing as a sea captain with a female professional model on either side of him. In the photograph, the women were wearing panties and T-shirts advertising Bomis.Forman 2010

A subscription section, Bomis Premium, provided access to adult content and erotic material;Blakely 2005 A three-day trial was US$2.95.Schilling 2012
While Bomis Babes provided nude images of females to subscribers, Bomis Premium featured lesbian sexual practices and female anatomy. Bomis created the Babe Engine, which helped users find erotic material online through a web search engine.Henderson 2008, p. 500 According to Bomis advertising director Terry Foote, 99 percent of searches on the site related to nude women.

Nupedia and Wikipedia

Bomis is best known for supporting the creation of free-content online-encyclopedia projects Nupedia and Wikipedia. Tim Shell and Michael Davis continued their partnership with Wales during the 2000 Nupedia venture. Larry Sanger met Jimmy Wales through an e-mail communication group about philosophy and objectivism, and joined Bomis in May, 1999. Sanger was a graduate student working towards a PhD degree in philosophy, with research focused on epistemology;Anderson 2012, pp. 136–138 he received his degree from Ohio State University,Moody 2006, p. 5 moving to San Diego to help Bomis with its encyclopedia venture.Reagle 2010 At the time Sanger joined Bomis the company had a total workforce of two employees with help from programmers.

Sanger and Wales began Nupedia with resources from Bomis; at the beginning of 2000, the company agreed to provide early financing for Nupedia from its profits.Lessig 2009, pp. 156–157 Nupedia went live in March, when Wales was CEO of Bomis;Myers 2006, p. 163 Sanger was Nupedia's editor-in-chief.Seitz 2011, p. A3 Nupedia's reading comprehension was intended for high-school graduates, and Bomis set its goal: "To set a new standard for breadth, depth, timeliness and lack of bias, and in the fullness of time to become the most comprehensive encyclopedia in the history of humankind."Frauenfelder 2000, p. 110Rollins 2000, p. 1786

Although Bomis began a search for experts to vet Nupedia articles, this proved tedious. In August 2000 Nupedia had more than 60 academics contributing to the peer-review process on the site, most with doctorates in philosophy or medicine.''School Library Journal'' 2000, p. S6 Scholars wishing to contribute to Nupedia were required to submit their credentials via fax for verification. At that time, Bomis was attempting to obtain advertising revenue for Nupedia and the company was optimistic that it could fund the project with ad space on Nupedia.com.

Wikipedia began as a feature of Nupedia.com on January 15, 2001,Curley 2012, pp. 35–38 later known as Wikipedia Day.Chozick 2013, p. 9 Someone working from the office.bomis.com server created the first edit to the website,Starling rclog the creation of HomePage with the text "This is the new WikiPedia!" It was originally intended only to generate draft articles for Nupedia, with finished articles moved to the latter. Wikipedia became a separate site days after the Nupedia advisory board opposed combining the two. In September 2001, Wales was simultaneously CEO of Bomis and co-founder of Wikipedia;Meyers 2001, p. D2 Sanger was chief organizer of Wikipedia and editor-in-chief of Nupedia.

Nupedia was encumbered by its peer-review system, a seven-step process of review and copyediting, and Wikipedia grew at a faster rate. In November 2000, Nupedia had 115 potential articles awaiting its peer-review process. By September 2001, after a total investment of US$250,000 from Bomis, Nupedia produced 12 articles;Koerner 2006, pp. 115–117 from 2000 through 2003, Nupedia contributors produced a total of 24 finalized articles. Wikipedia had about 20,000 articles and versions in 18 languages by the end of 2001.

Bomis originally planned to make Wikipedia profitable,Finkelstein (September 24, 2008) providing staffing and hardware for its initial structure; Wikipedia would not have survived without this early support. Bomis provided web servers and bandwidth (computing), bandwidth for the projects, owning key items such as domain names. Wales used money from Bomis to maintain the Wikipedia servers in Tampa, Florida.

As the cost of Wikipedia rose with its popularity, Bomis' revenues declined as a result of the dot-com crash.Slater 2011, p. B3 In late 2000 Bomis had a staff of about 11 employees, but by early 2002 layoffs reduced the staff to its original size of about five. Sanger was laid off in February 2002;The Star 2007 from January 15, 2001, through March 1, 2002, he was the sole paid editor of Wikipedia. Sanger stepped down from his dual roles as chief organizer of Wikipedia and editor-in-chief of Nupedia on March 1, 2002, feeling unable to commit to these areas on a volunteer basis and a dearth of "the habit or tradition of respect for expertise" from high-ranking Wikipedia members. He continued contributing to community discussions, optimistic about Wikipedia's future success.Duval 2010

After Sanger's departure, Wikipedia was managed by Wales and a burgeoning online community. Although Wales thought advertising was a possibility, the Wikipedia community was opposed to business developmentPoe 2006 and Internet marketing was difficult in 2002. Wikipedia remained a for-profit venture (under the auspices of Bomis) through the end of 2002. By then it had moved from a .com domain name to .org, and Wales said that the site would not accept advertising.Kleeman 2007, p. 4

Material from Nupedia was folded into WikipediaWaters 2010, pp. 179–180 and it was discontinued by 2003.Mahadevan 2006, p. 15Hasan 2011

Wikimedia Foundation Board of Trustees

By 2003 Wikipedia had grown to 100,000 articles in its English-language version, and it became difficult for Bomis to continue financially supporting the project. With Wikipedia a drain on the company's resources, Wales and Sanger decided to fund the project on a non-profit basis. Bomis laid off most of its employees to continue operating, since Wikipedia was not generating revenue. The company owned Wikipedia from its creation through 2003, and Wales used about $100,000 of Bomis' revenue to fund Wikipedia before the decision to shift the encyclopedia to non-profit status.Hickman 2006

In June 2003 Wikipedia was transferred to a nascent non-profit organization, the Wikimedia Foundation, which was formed as a charitable institution to supervise Wikipedia and its associated wiki-based sites. When the foundation was established, its staff began to solicit public funding and Bomis turned Wikipedia over to the non-profit. All Bomis-owned hardware used to run Wikipedia-associated websites was donated to the Wikimedia Foundation, and Wales transferred Wikipedia-related copyrights from Bomis to the foundation. It was first headquartered in St. Petersburg, Florida,Ayers 2008 where Bomis was located. The foundation shifted Wikipedia's dependence away from Bomis, allowing it to purchase hardware for expansion.

The Wikimedia Foundation board of trustees was initially composed of Bomis' three founders: Jimmy Wales and his two business partners, Michael Davis and Tim Shell.Lih 2009 Shell and Davis were appointed to the board by Wales, but after Wikipedia community members complained that the board was composed of appointed individuals, the first elections were held in 2004. Two community members, Florence Devouard and Angela Beesley, were elected to the board of trustees.

In August 2004 Wales was chief executive officer of Bomis, and on September 20 Wikipedia reached the million-article mark on an expenditure of $500,000 (most directly from Wales). In November 2004 he told the ''St. Petersburg Times'' he no longer controlled Bomis' day-to-day operations, but retained ownership as a shareholder.Krueger 2004, p. 1E In 2005, Tim Shell was CEO of Bomis and one of the board members overseeing Wikipedia. Shell remained CEO of Bomis in 2006, becoming vice-president of the Wikimedia Foundation and continuing to serve on its board.Heise Online (October 28, 2006) Bomis co-founder Michael Davis became treasurer of the Wikimedia Foundation that year. Wales told ''The Sydney Morning Herald'' in 2007 that although he retained partial ownership of Bomis, "It's pretty much dead." According to the Internet Archive, the Bomis website was last accessible with content in 2010;Bomis.com (February 24, 2010) when accessed in 2013 by the archive, it had a welcome message for PetaBox.Bomis.com (August 15, 2013) When accessed in 2014 by the archive, the website featured a blank white page with a line of text saying "Hello, world!".

Aftermath

In 2005, Wales made 18 changes to his Wikipedia biography. He removed references to Bomis Babes as softcore pornography and erotica, and Larry Sanger as co-founder of Wikipedia. Wales' actions were publicized by author Rogers Cadenhead, attracting attention from US and UK media. In 2011, ''Time'' listed Wales' 2005 edits in its "Top 10 Wikipedia Moments".Romero 2011

Wikipedia policy warned users not to edit their own biography pages, with its rules on autobiographical editing quoting Wales: "It is a social faux pas to write about yourself." Larry Sanger said, "It does seem that Jimmy is attempting to rewrite history", and began a discussion on the talk page of Wales' biography about Historical revisionism (negationism), historical revisionism.

Wales called his actions fixing mistakes, but after Cadenhead publicized the edits to his biography he expressed regret for his actions.Bergstein (April 2, 2007) In ''The Times'' Wales said that individuals should not edit their own Wikipedia biographies, telling ''The New Yorker'' that the standard applied to himself as well. Wales warned that the activity should be discouraged because of the potential for bias: "I wish I hadn't done it. It's in poor taste."

Bomis was called the "''Playboy'' of the Internet" by ''The Atlantic'', and the sobriquet was subsequently used by publications including ''The Sunday Times'',''The Sunday Times'' 2011 ''The Daily Telegraph'',Neate 2008 ''MSN Money'',Buckland 2011, p. 1 ''Wired (website), Wired'',Greenwald 2013, p. 82 ''The Torch Magazine'',Lewis 2013 and the 2007 book ''The Cult of the Amateur'' by Andrew Keen.Keen 2008, pp. 41–42 Wales considered the "''Playboy'' of the Internet" nickname inappropriate, although he was asked in interviews if his time at Bomis made him a "porn king".Paley Center for Media 2014Tai 2013 The 2010 documentary film about Wikipedia, ''Truth in Numbers?, Truth in Numbers? Everything, According to Wikipedia'', discussed this characterization of Wales by journalists.Glosserman 2010, Time index 34:30 Wales, interviewed in the film, called the characterization inaccurate and explained that his company responded to content demand from customers. In later interviews, he responded to "porn king" questions by telling journalists to look at a page on Yahoo! about pornography related to dwarfism. According to a 2007 article in ''Reason (magazine), Reason'', "If he was a porn king, he suggests, so is the head of the biggest Web portal in the world."

Analysis

''The Chronicle of Philanthropy'' characterized Bomis as "an Internet marketing firm... which also traded in erotic photographs for a while."Jensen 2006 Jeff Howe wrote in his 2008 book, ''Crowdsourcing: How the Power of the Crowd is Driving the Future of Business'', about "one of Wales's less altruistic ventures, a Web portal called Bomis.com that featured, among other items, soft-core pornography." In his 2008 book, ''The Future of the Internet and How to Stop It'', legal scholar Jonathan Zittrain wrote that "Bomis helped people find 'erotic photography', and earned money through advertising as well as subscription fees for premium content." ''The Guardian'' described the site as on "the fringes of the adult entertainment industry",Finkelstein (December 18, 2008) and ''The Edge (Malaysia), The Edge'' called Bomis.com an "explicit-content search engine".Chern 2008 ''Business 2.0, Business 2.0 Magazine'' described it as "a search portal... which created and hosted Web rings around popular search terms – including, not surprisingly, a lot of adult themes."

Footnotes

References

Bibliography

*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*

Further reading

;Primary sources
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*

External links

Bomis
at the Internet Archive
* m:Wikimedia Foundation Board of Trustees, Wikimedia Foundation Board of Trustees, at Wikipedia:Meta
* wmf:Former Board of Trustees members, Former Board of Trustees members, at Wikimedia Foundation

{{Portal bar, Companies, Florida, Internet, Nudity, Erotica and pornography, Human sexuality, United States

Defunct online companies of the United States
Online mass media companies of the United States
History of Wikipedia
Companies established in 1996
Companies based in St. Petersburg, Florida
Defunct networking companies
Adult entertainment companies
American erotica and pornography websites
Conflict-of-interest editing on Wikipedia
1996 establishments in Florida
Jimmy Wales