Saurolophus

''Saurolophus'' (; meaning "lizard crest") is a genus of large hadrosaurid dinosaur from the Late Cretaceous period of Asia and North America, that lived in what is now the Horseshoe Canyon and Nemegt formations about 70 million to 68 million years ago. It is one of the few genera of dinosaurs known from multiple continents. The type species, ''S. osborni'', was described by Barnum Brown in 1912 from Canadian fossils. A second valid species, ''S. angustirostris'', is represented by numerous specimens from Mongolia, and was described by Anatoly Konstantinovich Rozhdestvensky.

''Saurolophus'' is distinguished by a spike-like crest which projects up and back from the skull. It was a herbivorous dinosaur which could move about either bipedally or quadrupedally.

Discovery and history

Barnum Brown recovered the first described remains of ''Saurolophus'' in 1911, including a nearly complete skeleton ( AMNH 5220). Now on display in the American Museum of Natural History, this skeleton was the first nearly complete dinosaur skeleton from Canada. It was found in rocks of early Maastrichtian age, in the Upper Cretaceous Horseshoe Canyon Formation (then known as the Edmonton Formation) near Tolman Ferry on the Red Deer River in Alberta. Brown wasted little time in describing his material, giving it its own subfamily. ''Saurolophus'' was an important early reference for other hadrosaurs, as seen in the names of ''Prosaurolophus'' ("before ''Saurolophus''") and '' Parasaurolophus'' ("near ''Saurolophus''"). However, little additional material has been recovered and described.

Instead, more abundant remains from Asia have provided more data. Initial remains were not promising; a partial fragmentary ischium from Heilongjiang, China, that Riabinin named ''S. kryschtofovici''. Much better remains were soon recovered, though, but from Mongolia's early Maastrichtian-age Nemegt Formation. The 1946–1949 Russian- Mongolian paleontological expeditions recovered the large skeleton that became ''S. angustirostris'' as described by Anatoly Rozhdestvensky. Other skeletons from a variety of growth stages have also been discovered, and ''S. angustirostris'' is now the most abundant Asian hadrosaurid.

Species

Two species are regarded as valid today: the type species ''S. osborni'', and ''S. angustirostris''. ''S. osborni'' (Brown, 1912) is known from a skull and skeleton, two other complete skulls, and skull fragments. ''S. angustirostris'' (Rozhdestvensky, 1952) is known from at least 15 specimens. It differs from ''S. osborni'' by some details of the skull, as well as in the pattern of scales found in skin impressions. The Mongolian species had a longer skull (by 20%) and the front of the snout (the premaxillary bones) were more upwardly directed. ''S. angustirostris'' also had a distinctive row of rectangular scales along the midline of the back and tail, known as 'midline feature-scales'; these are not currently preserved in ''S. osborni''. In ''S. angustirostris'', the scales on the tail flank were arranged in vertical patterns, which may have corresponded to striped coloration in life. This area was covered in radial scale patterns in ''S. osborni'', possibly indicating a more mottled or spotted coloration.

''S. kryschtofovici'' (Riabinin, 1930) is not considered valid; either it is regarded as a dubious name, or as a synonym of ''S. angustirostris'' (although the name antedates ''S. angustirostris'').

Until a 2011 reevaluation of the species by Phil R. Bell, ''S. angustirostris'' was not well-described. No autapomorphies, unique derived traits, had been established distinguishing it from ''S. osborni''. Bell found in a publication earlier in the year that the two previous studies of ''S. angustirostris'', by Rozhdestvensky in 1952, and Maryanska and Osmolska in 1981, do not provide a comprehensive enough description to compare the species with ''S. osborni''.

In 1939–40, two partial skeletons were found in the late Maastrichtian age Moreno Formation of California. These specimens were referred to cf. ''Saurolophus'' sp. In 2010, one of the skulls was instead assigned to '' Edmontosaurus''. A 2013 study placed the two specimens in a new species, ''S. morrisi''. In 2014, the species was reassigned to a new genus, '' Augustynolophus''.

Description

''Saurolophus'' is known from material including nearly complete skeletons, giving researchers a clear picture of its bony anatomy. ''S. osborni'', the rarer Albertan species, was around long, with its skull long. It has been estimated to have weighed around . ''S. angustirostris'', the Mongolian species, was larger; it got as large as in length, and larger remains are reported. It has been estimated to have potentially weighed up to . The largest known skull of ''S.angustirostris'' measures in length. Aside from size, the two species are virtually identical, with differentiation hindered by lack of study.

Skull

The most distinctive feature of ''Saurolophus'' is its cranial crest, which is present in young individuals, but is smaller. It is long and spike-like and projects upward and backward at about a 45° angle, starting from over the eyes. This crest is often described as solid, but appears to be solid only at the point, with internal chambers that may have had a respiratory and/or heat-regulation function. The unique crest of ''Saurolophus'' is made up almost completely by the nasal bones, and in ''S. angustirostris'' it is solid. In adult specimens the crests are a rounded triangular shape in cross section. The crest protrudes past the edge of the skull backwards. Thin processes from the frontals and prefrontals extend along the underside of the crest, probably to strengthen it. At the end of the crest is a swelling of the nasal, which is often termed differently.

The holotype of ''S. angustirostris'' is a skull and postcrania, so the cranium of the species is well-described. Bell ''et al.'' re-evaluated the entire species in a 2011 publication with '' Acta Palaeontologica Polonica''. Their description found the skull to be generalized among hadrosaurines, and are much larger than any skulls of ''S. osborni''. The most unusual feature for a hadrosaurine is the long, protruding, solid crest that extends upwards diagonally from the back of the skull roof. Unlike lambeosaurines, the crests are made up completely of the nasal bone. The premaxilla bones make up almost 50% of the entire skull length, and both sides are filled with small holes. Only in adult individuals has the front of the premaxillary contact been fused. Longer than the premaxilla, the nasal bones are the longest in the skull. They make up the entire length of the crest, and are never preserved as fused.

Classification

Barnum Brown, who described the first specimens, put it in its own subfamily in "Trachodontidae" (=Hadrosauridae), the Saurolophinae. At the time, this also included ''Corythosaurus'' and '' Hypacrosaurus'', the only well-known examples of what would become the Lambeosaurinae. Brown thought that ''Saurolophus'' had an expanded tip to the ischium bone in the hip, as dinosaurs now recognized as lambeosaurines had, but this appears to have been based on a mistakenly associated lambeosaurine ischium. Additionally, he misinterpreted the crests of ''Saurolophus'' and lambeosaurines as being made of the same bones.

Most publications before 2010 classified ''Saurolophus'' as a member of Hadrosaurinae, often known colloquially as the "flat-headed hadrosaurs". In 2010, the subfamily Saurolophinae was brought back into use because '' Hadrosaurus'' appears to have branched off prior to the "hadrosaurine"–lambeosaurine split. As a result, Hadrosaurinae by definition cannot include the traditional "hadrosaurines". Saurolophinae is the oldest available name for the former "hadrosaurine" clade. ''Saurolophus'', as the name suggests, is a saurolophine, as it has a saurolophine pelvis and a (largely) solid crest.

The following cladogram of hadrosaurid relationships was published in 2013 by Alberto Prieto-Márquez ''et al.'' in ''Acta Palaeontologica Polonica'':

Paleobiology

Feeding

As a hadrosaurid, ''Saurolophus'' would have been a bipedal/ quadrupedal herbivore, eating a variety of plants. Its skull permitted a grinding motion analogous to chewing, and its teeth were continually replacing and packed into dental batteries that contained hundreds of teeth, only a relative handful of which were in use at any time. Plant material would have been cropped by its broad beak, and held in the jaws by a cheek-like organ. Its feeding range would have extended from the ground to about above.

Crest function

The distinctive spike-like crest of ''Saurolophus'' has been interpreted in multiple ways, and could have had multiple functions. Brown compared it to the crest of a chameleon, and suggested it could provide an area for muscle attachment and a connection point for a nonbody back frill like that seen in the basilisk lizard. Peter Dodson interpreted similar features in other duckbills as having use in sexual identification. Maryańska and Osmólska, noting the hollow base, suggested that the crest increased the surface area of the respiratory cavity, and helped in thermoregulation. James Hopson supported a function as a visual signal, and further mentioned the possibility that the inflatable skin flaps over the nostrils could have acted as resonators and additional visual signals. This idea has been picked up by authors of popular dinosaur works, such as David B. Norman, who discussed hadrosaurid display at length and included a life restoration of such an adaptation in action.

Ontogeny

In 2015 Leonard Dewaele and colleagues described a small and partial nest containing several juveniles of ''S. angustirostris''. The specimen (MPC-D 100/764) was recovered from the notorious Dragon's Tomb assambleage of the Nemegt Formation. The team noted that among remains, three or even four juveniles can be recognized, and two fragmentary eggshells were found in association. Juveniles within this block were identified as perinates, as they had skull lengths less than five percent of the length of the skulls of the adults, indicating they were in the earliest developmental stage at the time of their deaths. Based on these juveniles, Dewaele and team indicated that during the ontogeny of ''S. angustirostris'' the distinct crest found in adults was poorly developed in infancy, the snout grew proportionally longer, the orbit became more oval-shaped, the doming of the frontal became less prominent, and the coronoid process became higher.

Social behavior

Bell and team in 2018 described the famous Dragon's Tomb assambleage of the Altan Uul II locality, Nemegt Formation, which contains a large-sized bonebed of ''S. angustirostris''. This bonebed is largely monodominant (one dominant species), with at least three size-classes (juveniles, subadults, and adults) of ''S. angustirostris''. Examinations made to Dragon's Tomb suggest that at least 21 ''Saurolophus'' individuals can be currently found. The team indicated that this bonebed has a minimum size of about 2000 m2, which suggest that over 100 ''Saurolophus'' carcasses may have contributed to the event. However, they discussed that even though evidence clearly reflects a catastrophic mass-mortality of a social group of ''S. angustirostris'' and provide the first evidence of gregariousness in this taxon, the exact conditions and cause surrounding the group death can not be determined. Bell and team also noted that while Dragon's Tomb provides direct evidence for social behaviour in ''S. angustirostris'', there is yet no evidence for it in ''S. osborni''. Nevertheless, gregariousness is apparently widespread in hadrosaurines.

Paleopathology

David W.E. Hone and Mahito Watabe in 2011 reported the left humerus of a nearly complete ''S. angustirostris'' skeleton (MPC-D 100/764) from the Bügiin Tsav locality of the Nemegt Formation, which was heavily damaged from bite marks attributed to the sympatric '' Tarbosaurus''. As suggested by the lack of damage to the rest of the skeleton (such as large wounds in skeletal remains indicative of predation), this tyrannosaurid was likely scavenging an already dead ''S. angustirostris''. It is unlikely that a large-bodied predator such as ''Tarbosaurus'' would have left sparse feeding traces on a single humerus having an entire carcass to feed on. The humerus shows three distinctive feeding methods, interpreted as punctures, drag marks, and bite−and−drag marks. Hone and Watabe noted that bite marks were mostly located at the deltopectoral crest, suggesting that this ''Tarbosaurus'' was actively selecting which biting style employ to scavenge the bone.

Daily activity

Comparisons between the scleral rings of ''Saurolophus'' and modern birds and reptiles suggest that it may have been cathemeral, active throughout the day at short intervals.

Paleoenvironment

Horseshoe Canyon Formation

''S. osborni'' is known only from the upper part (unit 4) of the Horseshoe Canyon Formation. The formation is interpreted as having a significant marine influence, due to an encroaching Western Interior Seaway, the shallow sea that covered the midsection of North America through much of the Cretaceous. ''S. osborni'' may have preferred to stay inland. It lived alongside other dinosaur species including the ornithopods ''Hypacrosaurus altispinus'' and ''Parksosaurus warreni'', ankylosaurid '' Anodontosaurus lambei'', pachycephalosaurid ''Sphaerotholus edmontonense'', ornithomimids ''Ornithomimus brevitertius'' and an unnamed species of '' Struthiomimus'', small theropods including ''Atrociraptor marshalli'' and ''Albertonykus borealis'', and the tyrannosaurid '' Albertosaurus sarcophagus''. The dinosaurs from this formation form part of the Edmontonian land vertebrate age. A 2001 study suggested that ''Saurolophus osborni'' was part of a distinct inland fauna characterized by an association between ''Anchiceratops ornatus'' and it, while the contemporary coastal fauna was characterized by the association of ''Pachyrhinosaurus canadensis'' and ''Edmontosaurus regalis''.Lehman, T. M., 2001, Late Cretaceous dinosaur provinciality: In: Mesozoic Vertebrate Life, edited by Tanke, D. H., and Carpenter, K., Indiana University Press, pp. 310-328. However, the association between ''S. osborni'' and ''Anchiceratops'' was later noted to be in error, ''Anchiceratops'' only occurs lower in the Horseshoe Canyon Formation, before the major transgression of the Western Interior Seaway represented by the Drumheller Marine Tongue.Sullivan, R.M. and Lucas, S. G. (2006). "The Kirtlandian land-vertebrate "age"–faunal composition, temporal position and biostratigraphic correlation in the nonmarine Upper Cretaceous of western North America." Pp. 7-29 in Lucas, S. G. and Sullivan, R.M. (eds.), ''Late Cretaceous vertebrates from the Western Interior. New Mexico Museum of Natural History and Science Bulletin 35''.

Nemegt Formation

''S. angustirostris'' was one of the largest herbivores of the Nemegt Formation, which lacked large ceratopsians, but had sauropods and a more diverse theropod fauna. Unlike other Mongolian formations like the well-known Djadochta Formation that includes ''Velociraptor'' and '' Protoceratops'', the Nemegt is interpreted as being well-watered region, like the Dinosaur Park Formation in Alberta. When examined, the rock facies of the Nemegt formation suggest the presence of stream and river channels, mudflats, and shallow lakes. Sediments also indicate that a rich habitat existed, offering diverse food in abundant amounts that could sustain Cretaceous dinosaurs.Novacek, M. (1996). Dinosaurs of the Flaming Cliffs. Bantam Doubleday Dell Publishing Group Inc. New York, New York. It coexisted with the rare hadrosaurid '' Barsboldia'', flat-headed pachycephalosaurian '' Homalocephale'' and domed '' Prenocephale'', the large ankylosaurid '' Saichania'', rare titanosaurs sauropods '' Nemegtosaurus'' and '' Opisthocoelicaudia'', the alvarezsaurid ''Mononykus'', three types of troodontids including ''Zanabazar'', several oviraptorosaurians including '' Rinchenia'' and '' Nemegtomaia'', the ornithomimosaurs '' Anserimimus'' and '' Gallimimus'', and the giant theropods '' Deinocheirus'' and ''Therizinosaurus'', including the tyrannosaurid '' Tarbosaurus''.

''S. angustirostris'' was common, and would have been an important large herbivore in the Nemegt Formation. By comparison, ''S. osborni'' was rare in the Horseshoe Canyon Formation, and faced competition from other duckbills (genus '' Hypacrosaurus'').

See also

* Timeline of hadrosaur research

References

External links

''Saurolophus'', from the Natural History Museum

{{Taxonbar, from=Q131096

Saurolophines
Maastrichtian genera
Late Cretaceous dinosaurs of Asia
Late Cretaceous dinosaurs of North America
Fossils of Canada
Cretaceous Alberta
Paleontology in Alberta
Fossil taxa described in 1912
Taxa named by Barnum Brown
Ornithischian genera
Fossils of Mongolia