Matthew McClung

Matthew Henry McClung Jr. (December 1, 1868 – March 3, 1908), sometimes referred to as Dibby McClung, was an American college football player, coach and official. Born into a powerful southern family, McClung was raised in Memphis, Tennessee until he was accepted into Lehigh University. Immediately establishing himself as a skilled sportsman, McClung participated on both the school's football and baseball teams. He served as captain of the former in 1892 and is credited with turning it into one of the school's best ever football squads. McClung graduated from Lehigh in 1893 with degrees in metallurgy and mining engineering.

After graduating, McClung took a position as the coach of the Naval Academy football team. He served for one season, leading the team to a 5-2 record against a mediocre schedule. Following the season, he started his career as a college football referee which would span twelve years. Lehigh Alumni Association (1910), p. 65

Early life and college

Matthew McClung was born on December 1, 1868, the fifth of seven children between Matthew McClung Sr. and Julia Frances Anderson. The younger McClung was raised in Knoxville, Tennessee, where both of his parents' families were well established. McClung (1904), pp. 28-29 McClung entered Lehigh University in 1889, majoring in mining engineering and metallurgy; the classes were held by students to be the hardest at the university. ''The Lehigh Epitome'' (1898), pp. 222-223 He joined the school's chapter of the Psi Upsilon fraternity, one of nine freshmen to be accepted ''In Universitate''. ''The Lehigh Epitome'' (1890), p. 58 He also became a member of one of the school's several clubs, the "Aetos Club", which he represented in intramural athletics. ''The Lehigh Epitome'' (1890), pp. 104, 165 McClung immediately made his athletic presence at the school known, joining the lawn tennis team and the freshman baseball team as a left fielder; he also won the university's baseball-throwing competition. ''The Lehigh Epitome'' (1890), pp. 145, 164-168 He was starting catcher for the 1889 baseball team that went 4-7-1 and played in approximately one quarter of a football game. ''The Lehigh Epitome'' (1891), pp. 167-171 McClung completed his first year by toasting for the university's fraternities at the year's freshman banquet. ''The Lehigh Epitome'' (1895), p. 22

McClung's sophomore year remained largely the same as his freshman one. He maintained membership with the Psi Upsilon and the Aetos Club, but he also joined the university's Southern Club, German club, and its Chemical and Natural History Society. ''The Lehigh Epitome'' (1891), pp. 64, 109, 128 ''The Lehigh Epitome'' (1892), pp. 137, 146 He shifted from being the baseball team's catcher to center fielder, where he played in twelve out of twenty games. McClung had the third worst batting stats of anyone on the team, getting only nine hits on fifty-seven at-bats. He was also named starting quarterback of the school's football team and led the squad to a 6-4 record, which included two wins over rival Lafayette. ''The Lehigh Epitome'' (1892), pp. 194-199

Career

Football coach

Following his graduation, McClung remained at Lehigh, assisting in coaching the school's 1894 season. In 1895, McClung was hired by the United States Naval Academy to replace William Wurtenburg as the head coach of their football program. ''The Cornell Daily Sun'' (1895), p. 1 McClung was the fifth football coach for the school in as many years. He took over during a period at the Academy when, according to historian Morris Allison Bealle, "football was waning in Annapolis" and that "there was no climax incentive to steam up players". Bealle (1951), p. 44 McClung scheduled seven games for the 1895 season, three of which were simply squads from nearby athletic clubs. He hired Paul Dashiell, a former teammate of his at Lehigh, as his assistant coach for the year. Bealle (1951), p. 45 His team played at home for the entire season, due to restrictions put forth by president Grover Cleveland following the bloody 1893 Army-Navy Game. Nesbit (2000), p. 1 Cromartie (1996), p. 27 McClung's squad began the season with wins over two of the athletic clubs by a combined score of 40-0. These wins were followed by consecutive shutouts of Franklin & Marshall and Carlisle. Virginia was the next team on Navy's schedule, but their opponents were forced to forfeit the match after a fire destroyed one of the campus's major structures. Navy Game Results 1895-1899 ''The Cavalier Daily'' (1982), p. 7 McClung's team finished their season with two consecutive close losses to the Orange Athletic Club and his former team, Lehigh. He did not return to coach the following year's squad; instead, the job went to Princeton dropout Johnny Poe. Edwards (1916), p. 205 Because of McClung's scheduling, the Naval Academy in 1896 banned the football team from playing another athletic club. Jackson (1959), p. 3

Referee and steelworker

Shortly after he left Lehigh, McClung began a career as a college football referee. He began as early as November 1895, when he partnered with Paul Dashiell to officiate a game between Yale and Princeton. ''The Salt Lake Herald (1895), p. 2 The pairing with Dashiell quickly became regular, with McClung acting as referee and Dashiell as Umpire. Former Princeton guard William "Big Bill" Edwards stated that "within my recollection, for many years the two most prominent, as well as most efficient officials, whose names were always coupled, were McClung, Referee, and Dashiell, Umpire. No two better officials ever worked together and there is as much necessity for team work in officiating as there is in playing". Edwards' opinion was often shared by sportswriters and fellow players. After the Yale-Princeton game, a writer for the '' New York Tribune'' stated that Dashiell and McClung were "excellent" at their jobs and "that their rulings were just and impartial was admitted everywhere". ''The New York Tribune'' (1895), p. 3

In the following year, McClung refereed a single game, again between Yale and Princeton. ''The Norfolk Virginian'' (1896), p. 1 He was a top candidate for umpiring a contest between Wisconsin and Carlisle in what would be one of the first games played at night, but did not receive the position. ''The Evening Times'' (1896), p. 3 Pruter (2011), pp. 2-3 McClung refereed two games in 1897 alongside Dashiell. The first game they served was Harvard and Yale's rivalry, The Game. The contest, which ended in a 0-0 tie, was the first time the rivalry was played since a bloody 1894 game led it to be cancelled. Samuels (2011), The Back Page ''The Sun'' (1897), p. 2 Following that work, they officiated a close game between Cornell and Penn. ''The Saint Paul Globe'' (1897), p. 1 McClung gained some fame among the football community following the 1897 year, so he was selected to referee in three games the following year. He was chosen before the season to again serve in the Harvard-Yale game, and was likely going to be a referee for the Yale-Princeton contest; ''Omaha Daily Bee'' (1898), p. 10 ''Evening Star'' (1898), p. 7 before the game, however, McClung was replaced by Edgar Wrightington. Presbrey and Moffat (1901), p. 386 The other two games refereed that year were for Penn, their contests with Harvard and Cornell. ''The Times'' (1898), p. 8 ''The Scranton Tribune'' (1898), p. 1 McClung's 1899 season was very similar to his previous year. He was selected before the season to referee the Harvard-Yale game, ''The Kansas City Journal'' (1899), p. 5 and officiated a game between Pennsylvania and Harvard. ''The Saint Paul Globe'' (1899), p. 10

By 1900, McClung and Dashiell's fame had risen considerably. Two western teams, California and Stanford, asked them to officiate their rivalry game. The ''San Francisco Call'', while covering the rivalry, referred to the two as "the two most expert fficialsin America". ''The San Francisco Call'' (1900), p. 32 McClung ended up only refereeing one game that year, his usual role in the Harvard-Yale game. ''New-York Daily Tribune'' (1900), p. 5 He was sought after for another game for Yale, but had to turn down the offer. ''The Times'' (1900), p. 3 He officiated two games in 1901. The first was his usual job at the Yale-Harvard game, which ended up being a very cleanly played contest. The second was another game for Harvard, against Penn. Athletic Association of Harvard Graduates (1901), p. 4 ''The San Francisco Call'' (1901), p. 34 McClung's routine was broken in 1902, when he officiated four games. After beginning the year with a normal game between Columbia and Princeton, McClung refereed a game between Columbia and Penn where, for the first time, Dashiell was not umpiring for him. ''The Indianapolis Journal'' (1902), p. 6 ''The Saint Paul Globe'' (1902), p. 8 The 1903 season saw McClung referee three games, all for Yale. In the season's Yale-Princeton game, he acted as umpire for the first time in his officiating career. ''The Minneapolis Journal'' (1903), p. 21 As with the previous year, McClung was selected prior to the 1904 season's beginning as the referee for three games for Yale, against Columbia, Princeton, and Harvard. ''The Saint Paul Globe'' (1904), p. 5 The Princeton game led to a minor controversy surrounding McClung, after he decided to shorten the length of the game. He was also chosen by Harvard to officiate their game against Penn, ''The Times-Dispatch'' (1904), p. 1 and by Penn in their game with Columbia. In the latter, both teams wanted McClung to umpire; he flatly refused, and decided to shorten the game to 40 minutes. ''The New-York Tribune'' (1904), p. 10

In 1905, McClung refereed only two games, one of which turned out to be the biggest in his career. The first game of the season was between Harvard and Pennsylvania, which McClung officiated alongside "Big Bill" Edwards. The pairing was troublesome, since both men had previously served almost always as a referee, which left the position of umpire unfilled. Edwards eventually accepted the umpire role, and remained at the position for the rest of his officiating career following the game. Edwards (1916), p. 391 The Harvard-Yale game was the most controversial game of McClung's career, although most of the issue surrounded Dashiell's umpiring. Late in the game, the teams were tied 0-0. Yale punted the ball to Francis Burr, Harvard's guard, who called a fair catch. However, Burr was hit by two Yale players and fumbled the ball, which set up Yale's winning score. Harvard fans and players believed that Burr had called the fair catch, while Yale claimed he never had and both officials agreed with Yale. After the game, McClung said that " he hitlooked ugly, but was within the rules of the game". Reid (1994), pp. 307-318 The officials' decision remained a big problem for college football for some time, and eventually then-president Theodore Roosevelt met with Dashiell to discuss the play. Their reputations as good officials were significantly hurt by the game and Harvard would not allow them to again referee in a game involving their team. Smith (2011), pp. 46-50 Following the season's conclusion, McClung joined other prominent football personnel in selecting that year's All-America team. McClung's selection included seven players who were later recognized as consensus All-Americans, and one of which, Tom Shevlin, would later make the Hall of Fame. Whitney (1906), p. 27 McClung refereed the final game of his career in 1906, when, alongside William Herbert Corbin, he officiated the Army–Navy Game. Navy, coached by Paul Dashiell, won the contest 10-0. 1906 Navy Midshipmen Schedule and Results ''The Minneapolis Journal'' (1906), p. 3

During the time that he was a referee, McClung also pursued a career in steelmaking. His first work was as a chemist at the Carnegie Steel Company's Carrie Furnace in Rankin, Pennsylvania. During that time, he took up residence in Pittsburgh. Packer (1899), P. 175 Sometime in 1898, McClung was hired as the assistant superintendent at the blast furnaces of the Cambria Steel Company. After serving that position for about five years, he was hired by the Illinois Steel Company and was made the superintendent of the company's Joliet iron and steel blast furnaces. McClung would hold the position until his death, five years later.

Death and legacy

While working at the Joliet Blast Furnaces, McClung developed a severe tooth infection, which eventually gave him blood poisoning. He succumbed to the latter condition on March 3, 1908, at the age of just 39. McClung's death came before those of his parents and all six of his siblings. ''The Allentown Leader'' (1908), p. 6 ''The Iron Trade Review'' (March 12, 1908), p. 498 He was replaced just days after his death by W.J. Moore, a chemist who had worked under him at the plant. ''The Iron Trade Review'' (March 19, 1908), p. 534 Following his death, McClung was memorialized by several of his former teammates and officials. When "Big Bill" Edwards wrote and published his book ''Football Days'', he included McClung in his tribute to deceased college football players. He wrote that: "Richard Harding Davis and cClungwere two Lehigh men whose position in the football world was most prominent. The esteem in which they are held by their Alma Mater is enduring". Edwards (1916), pp. 459-460 Edwards also praised McClung and Dashiell's refereeing, stating that "Officials come and go. These men have had their day, but no two ever contributed better work. The game of Football was safe in their hands". Edwards (1916), p. 387 Paul Dashiell, when interviewed by Edwards' for ''Football Days'', spoke about his relationship with McClung. He said that:
: One friendship was made in these years that has been worth more than words can tell. I refer to that of Matthew McClung. To be known as a co-official with McClung was a privilege that only those who knew him can appreciate. I had known him before at Lehigh in his undergraduate days, and had played on the same teams with him ..Never was there a squarer sportsman, or a fairer, more conscientious and efficient official; nor a truer, more gallant type of real man than he. His early death took out of the game a man of the kind we can ill afford to lose and no tribute that I could pay him would be high enough. Edwards (1916), pp. 389-390

Head coaching record

College football

College baseball

See also

*
*

References

Notes

Footnotes

Bibliography

;Books, journals, and yearbooks

*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*

;Newspapers

*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*

;Other

*
*

External links

*

{{DEFAULTSORT:McClung, Matthew
1868 births
1908 deaths
19th-century players of American football
American football quarterbacks
College football officials
Lehigh Mountain Hawks football players
Lehigh Mountain Hawks baseball coaches
Lehigh Mountain Hawks baseball players
Navy Midshipmen football coaches
Players of American football from Knoxville, Tennessee
Baseball players from Knoxville, Tennessee