HOME
The Info List - Jewish Assimilation


--- Advertisement ---



Jewish assimilation
Jewish assimilation
(Hebrew: התבוללות‬, Hitbolelut) refers to the gradual cultural assimilation and social integration of Jews
Jews
in their surrounding culture as well as the ideological program promoting conformity as a potential solution to historic Jewish marginalization in the age of emancipation.[1]

Contents

1 History 2 Contemporary debate 3 Christian–Jewish relations 4 See also 5 References 6 External links

History[edit] The Jewish holiday
Jewish holiday
Hanukkah
Hanukkah
stems from the Maccabees' revolt against the Seleucid Empire. Many Jews
Jews
of the era had adopted the Hellenistic language and culture, which the Maccabee group considered an abomination. Use of the vernacular is an example of acculturation, one of the key characteristics of Jewish assimilation
Jewish assimilation
in the modern era.[1] Jewish assimilation
Jewish assimilation
began anew among Ashkenazi Jews
Jews
on an extensive scale towards the end of the 18th century in Western Europe, especially Germany, as the Haskalah
Haskalah
emerged as a culture. Reasons cited for its initial success included hope for better opportunities accompanying assimilation into the non-Jewish European communities, especially among the upper classes. "The concentration of the Jewish population in large cities had a strong impact on their lifestyle and made them more visible in the economy and in the culture."[2] As legal emancipation remained incomplete in Germany, many upper-middle class urban Jews
Jews
propagated Enlightenment ideals, which they believed would allow them to improve their social standing. "The ideologues consequently envisioned a regeneration of German Jewry that would gain it equal rights but would also lead to the formation of a new kind of Jew based on its ideal of man."[3]

Part of a series on

Jews
Jews
and Judaism

Etymology Who is a Jew?

Jewish peoplehood Jewish identity

Religion

God in Judaism (names)

Principles of faith Mitzvot (613) Halakha Shabbat Holidays Prayer Tzedakah Land of Israel Brit Bar and Bat Mitzvah Marriage Bereavement Philosophy Ethics Kabbalah Customs Synagogue Rabbi

Texts

Tanakh

(Torah Nevi'im Ketuvim)

Talmud

(Mishnah Gemara)

Rabbinic

(Midrash Tosefta)

Targum Beit Yosef Mishneh Torah Tur Shulchan Aruch Zohar

Communities

Ashkenazim Sephardim Italkim Romaniotes Mizrahim Cochin Bene Israel Beta Israel

Related groups

Bnei Anusim Lemba Crimean Karaites Krymchaks Samaritans Crypto-Jews Mosaic Arabs Subbotniks

Population

Land of Israel

Old Yishuv New Yishuv Israeli Jews

Europe

Austria Belarus Bulgaria Czech Republic Estonia France Georgia Germany Greece Hungary Italy Latvia Lithuania Moldova Netherlands Poland Portugal Romania Russia Spain Sweden Ukraine United Kingdom

Asia

Yemen Iraq Iran Turkey Cyprus Syria Lebanon Uzbekistan Azerbaijan India China Indonesia Vietnam Japan Philippines

Africa

Morocco Algeria Tunisia Libya Egypt Ethiopia South Africa Zimbabwe

North America

United States Canada

Latin America
Latin America
and Caribbean

Argentina Bolivia Brazil Chile Colombia Cuba Dominican Republic El Salvador Guyana Haiti Jamaica Mexico Paraguay Puerto Rico Suriname Uruguay Venezuela

Oceania

Australia Fiji Guam New Zealand Palau

Judaism
Judaism
by country Lists of Jews Historical population comparisons

Denominations

Orthodox Reform Conservative Karaite Reconstructionist Renewal Humanistic Haymanot

Culture

Minyan Music

Religious Secular

Wedding Clothing Niddah Pidyon haben Kashrut Shidduch Zeved habat Conversion to Judaism Hiloni Cuisine

Israelite Israeli Sephardic Mizrahi

Literature

Israeli Yiddish American

Yiddish
Yiddish
theatre Dance Humour

Languages

Hebrew (Biblical) Yiddish Jewish Koine Greek Yevanic Juhuri Shassi Judaeo-Iranian Ladino Ghardaïa Sign Bukharian Knaanic Zarphatic Italkian Gruzinic Judeo-Aramaic Judeo-Arabic Judeo-Berber Judeo-Malayalam

History

Timeline Leaders Ancient history

Kingdom of Judah Temple in Jerusalem Babylonian captivity Assyrian captivity Yehud Medinata Jerusalem (in Judaism timeline) Hasmonean dynasty Sanhedrin Schisms Pharisees Hellenistic Judaism Jewish–Roman wars History of the Jews
Jews
in the Byzantine Empire Christianity and Judaism Hinduism and Judaism Islamic–Jewish relations Diaspora Middle Ages Golden Age Sabbateans Hasidism Haskalah Emancipation Antisemitism Anti-Judaism Persecution The Holocaust Israel Land of Israel Aliyah Jewish atheism Baal teshuva Arab–Israeli conflict

Politics

Politics of Israel

Zionism

(General Green Labor Neo Religious Revisionist)

Judaism
Judaism
and politics World Agudath Israel Bundism Feminism Jewish left

Category: Jews
Jews
and Judaism Portal: Judaism

v t e

Both the Christian and Jewish communities were divided concerning answers to what was known as the Jewish question. The question, coming during the rise of nationalism in Europe, included the extent to which each nation could integrate its Jewish citizens, and if not integrated, how should they be treated and the question solved. The breakdown of the traditional Jewish communal structure, the Kehilla, marked the declining perception of a distinct Jewish nationality among those Jews
Jews
that promoted emancipation. However, attempts to reduce Judaism
Judaism
to a confession did not necessarily induce an increase in tolerance of the Jews
Jews
on the part of the majority society. As an alternative to a more liberal practice of Judaism, assimilation also took the form of conversion to Christianity. None of the descendants of Moses Mendelssohn
Moses Mendelssohn
retained the Jewish religion. Assimilationists saw Jewish cultural distinctiveness and tribalism as the root of antisemitic hostility and thus felt that Jewish social bonds needed to be weakened.[1] This led some Jews
Jews
to philosophical questions of Jewish identity
Jewish identity
and Who is a Jew?. The propriety of assimilation, and various paths toward it were among the earliest internal debates of the emancipation era, including whether and to what extent Jews
Jews
should relinquish their right to uniqueness in return for civic equality. These debates initially took place within the diaspora, a population with a revered historical Biblical homeland, but without a state of their own for nearly 2,000 years. Jewish academics in the nineteenth century partook in social scientific studies concerning anti-Semitic notions of Jewish degeneration. Their active role in this intellectual discussion served as both a calculated response to anti-Semitic allegations and a way to explore common social bonds uniting Jews
Jews
as the autonomous community had been in full decline. Many Jewish social scientists did not entirely disagree with the ideas of distinct Jewish traits conceived by anti-Semites. This lent itself well to the contentious debate over assimilatory practices. "The political and social message of this immutable Jewish nature was clear: the 'Jewish body' was racially different and pathological, and opponents of emancipation and integration were correct in insisting that Jews
Jews
were unfit to be part of a healthy modern nation-state."[4] Participating in the exploration of Jewish lineage can also be seen as a form of appeasement as "It allowed Jewish social scientists to fill the roles of apologist and reformer, to defend their own people based on the knowledge and insights of science."[4] In the late 19th and early 20th centuries, conditions in Eastern Europe convinced many Jews
Jews
to emigrate to the United States. In Germany, Jewish integration into the Army and other occupations was successful. In the United States traditional disabilities were generally absent but they faced many different challenges of acculturation. In the early 20th century, there was social discrimination against Jews
Jews
in certain quarters,[5] with many universities and professions barred to them or with a quota limit. In the modern 21st century, although the view on Jews
Jews
has considerably improved, in the US specifically, the nation is guided as a Christian nation, with a common example being all of the Christmas songs and ads being played during the holiday season with parents needing to say "we do not celebrate Christmas." ,[6] and the lack of such advertisement for any Jewish holiday
Jewish holiday
during the year. Jewish assimilation
Jewish assimilation
is common more in the modern day since the pressures of society to be like everyone else are high. The new Reform Judaism
Judaism
Movement also adds to this, since it is a branch of Judaism
Judaism
that has become more moderate on following the laws of the torah, leading Jews
Jews
to be more relaxed instead of strict on their religion. Contemporary debate[edit] The issue of Jewish assimilation
Jewish assimilation
has agitated Jewish polemicists and intrigued Jewish historians for a considerable time. Since some Jews supposedly abandoned traditional Jewish customs to embrace modern secular Western culture, more conservative Jews
Jews
have chastised them for deserting the Jewish people. "Religious Jews
Jews
regarded those who assimilated with horror, and Zionists campaigned against assimilation as an act of treason."[7] As a result, the term assimilation, once used proudly by those who sought integration into European society, became seen as a term of contempt for a symbol of subservience to gentile culture, a sign of rejection of all links to the common history and destiny of the Jewish people, and a betrayal of their ancestors who suffered pogroms to keep Judaism
Judaism
alive. Such Jews consider assimilation a loss of Jewish identity
Jewish identity
of an individual either by marriage to a spouse who is not Jewish or by abandonment of Judaism
Judaism
to adopt another religion. In Assimilation in American Life, Milton Gordon defined assimilation as a continuum, with the first stage acculturation, that is, the adoption of such outward cultural forms of the larger society as language, dress, recreational tastes, and political views. Total assimilation is possible only if the host society is receptive and extensive interfaith marriage takes place (at its most in former European colonies with a divisive black-white line, which allowed Jews to be seen as part of the desirable white element and where miscegenation was hardly a taboo). Most European and American Jews acculturated, but they rarely lost their sense of Jewish identity. They most frequently abstained from what Gordon called "structural assimilation," the creation of friendships and other contacts primarily with members of the host society. In Assimilation and Community: The Jews
Jews
in nineteenth-century Europe, Marion Kaplan describes how the Jewish identity
Jewish identity
was maintained and how the German- Jewish identity
Jewish identity
was formed, specifically through Jewish women and their actions within their families and their communities. Jewish women placed a lot of importance on their culture and religion by reinforcing their traditions. They accomplished this by continually observing Jewish traditions and rituals, such as family dinners on Friday evenings, and holidays from the Jewish calendar. Strict adherence to Judaism
Judaism
was essential in maintaining their Jewish identity within their household.[8] Kaplan also stresses the importance of family and community; close knit families had strong ties with one another. This strong sense of community helped them in protecting and maintaining their culture. However, ways in which Jews adapted to the culture can be seen in the way Jewish women raised their children in Germany. They encouraged them to take part in sports, learn musical instruments, and read German fairy tales to them. Jewish women also subscribed to German periodicals, following its fashion styles and news.[9] In Paula Hyman's book The Jews
Jews
of Modern France demonstrates that Jewish assimilation
Jewish assimilation
into French society allowed them to integrate in the community. The term assimilation is based on the modern term. Assimilation is presumed to "reflection the substitution of a French identity for a Jewish one."[10] It is believed that this simplistic view does not give an all encompassing view on the intricate relations between Jews
Jews
and the French. The Jews
Jews
had to constantly defend their legitimacy as a minority group in France. While most people associate assimilation as a negative term, "they were not simply passive absorbers of bourgeois French culture; they also participated in its shaping."[10] Jews
Jews
contributed to French society, through participating in all aspects of society like government and universities. In her book Hyman helps illustrate instances that show integration in French society. Beginning with the cooperation of the French state, Jews
Jews
were able to maintain networks of communal institutions in the system of consistories that both promoted acculturation and reinforced Jewish feelings of solidarity. These consistories also helped support the existence of specific Jewish institutions. These institutions provided charitable assistance to Jews
Jews
through a variety of philanthropic societies. Examples of these would be a network of modern Jewish primary schools as well as extended supplemental Jewish education to Jewish children who began attending public schools. Despite mass participation by Jews
Jews
in all levels of French society – government, universities, and professional careers – the vast majority of Jews
Jews
in 19th century France chose to be married and buried as Jews.[10] This clarifies that Jews
Jews
were not fully assimilated into French society nor sought the disappearance of their institutions and/or biological merger with the French society.[10] David Sorkin's The Transformation of German Jewry 1780-1840 assesses what should have been an immensely successful integration process given the Jewish population's great societal contributions as they adopted German secular culture and the bourgeois ideal of individualism known as Bildung. Instead, a separate German-Jewish subculture developed while emancipation lagged. Sorkin depicts the fruitless attempts of the Jews
Jews
to be tolerated as no level of self-denial would ultimately prove acceptable to their counterparts.[3] From an international conference on Jewish assimilation
Jewish assimilation
held at Haifa University in May 1976, Bela Vago
Bela Vago
edited a collection of papers entitled Jewish Assimilation in Modern Times. Most of these papers accept the Zionist
Zionist
equation of assimilation with Jewish group disappearance. Christian–Jewish relations[edit] See also: Conversion of the Jews
Jews
and Proselytization and counter-proselytization of Jews The question of Jewish assimilation
Jewish assimilation
is a topic of concern for both Jewish and Christian religious leaders. A number of Progressive Christian denominations have publicly declared that they will no longer proselytize Jews. They have made use of dual-covenant theology.[11][12][13] Early Christian Europe proved a time and place where Jews
Jews
and Christians could come together while coexisting socially and creatively amidst the persecution. They were living so closely together in some areas that leaders from both would be worried about the influence one religion had on the other. A Christian Monarch in charge of a growing town would invite Jewish merchants to help revitalize the economy. There was a pattern of expulsion and re-invitation that allowed for the two to live intimately together in smaller towns throughout Europe. Louis the Pious, son of Charlemagne in the Holy Roman Empire, was the first to leave detailed descriptions of the rights of Jewish Merchants.[14] In Spain and Portugal, after the 15th century, there was controversy over the sincerity of Iberian Judeo-Catholics who converted under pain of being expelled from the Peninsula.[15] In Spain and Portugal, descendants of Arabs, Moors, and Jews
Jews
(moriscos and marranos), were, for a period of time banned from certain guilds, positions in the clergy and particularly from emigrating to Latin America
Latin America
(limpieza de sangre). This early discrimination system was weaker in Latin America due to the social status that Sub-Saharan African slaves had, much below that of New Christians from the Old World, a contributing factor to the absorption of these elements in the developing culturally pluralistic societies of the New World. The Roman Catholic Church
Roman Catholic Church
has attracted some Jews, such as Gustav Mahler, Ludwig Wittgenstein, Marcel Proust, Edith Stein, Israel Zolli, Erich von Stroheim, and Jean-Marie Lustiger. See also[edit]

Historical Jewish population comparisons Bundism Yevsektsiya Zera Yisrael Apostasy
Apostasy
in Judaism Converso Who is a Jew?

References[edit]

^ a b c "YIVO Assimilation". www.yivoencyclopedia.org. Retrieved 2016-12-05.  ^ "Wayback Machine" (PDF). 13 October 2012. Retrieved 9 February 2018.  ^ a b Sorkin, David (1987). The Transformation of German Jewry 1780-1840. New York: Oxford University Press. p. 5. The ideologues consequently envisioned a regeneration of German Jewry that would gain it equal rights but would also lead to the formation of a new kind of Jew based on its ideal of man.  ^ a b "Racial Science, Social Science, and the Politics of Jewish Assimilation on JSTOR" (PDF). www.jstor.org. Retrieved 2016-12-05.  ^ "The American Jewish Experience in the Twentieth Century: Antisemitism
Antisemitism
and Assimilation, The Twentieth Century, Divining America: Religion in American History, TeacherServe, National Humanities Center". nationalhumanitiescenter.org. Retrieved 9 February 2018.  ^ Israel, Jeffrey. "What Jesus Means to a 21st Century Jew". Big Think. Retrieved 2017-10-11.  ^ Vago, Bela (1982). Marsha L. Rozenblit, ed. "Review of Jewish Assimilation in Modern Times". Jewish Social Studies. 44 (3-4). JSTOR 4467195.  ^ Kaplan, Marion A. Assimilation and community: The Jews
Jews
in nineteenth-century Europe. New York: Cambridge University Press. p. 205.  ^ Kaplan, Marion A. Assimilation and community: The Jews
Jews
in nineteenth-century Europe. New York: Cambridge University Press. p. 210.  ^ a b c d Hyman, Paula (1999). The Jews
Jews
of Modern France. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press. p. 57.  ^ Ecumenical Considerations on Jewish-Christian Dialogue (World Council of Churches) ^ Brockway, Allan R. "Should Christians Attempt to Evangelize Jews?". www.abrock.com. Retrieved 9 February 2018.  ^ Policies of mainline and liberal Christians towards proselytizing Jews
Jews
(religioustolerance.org) ^ Marcus, Ivan (2002). A Jewish-Christian Symbiosis. Schocken. pp. 453; 449. ISBN 0805212019.  ^ "Famous Jewish Catholics". www.adherents.com. Retrieved 9 February 2018. 

Bibliography

Frankel, Jonathan; Zipperstein, Steven J. (1992). Assimilation and Community: The Jews
Jews
in Nineteenth-Century Europe. Cambridge University Press. 

External links[edit]

Are we assimilating?, Eretz Acheret Magazine The History of the Jews
Jews
in Europe Assimilation

v t e

Jews
Jews
and Judaism

Outline of Judaism Index of Jewish history-related articles

History

Timeline Israelites Origins of Judaism Ancient Israel and Judah Second Temple period Rabbinic Judaism Middle Ages Haskalah Zionism

Population

Assimilation Diaspora

Ashkenazi Sephardi Mizrahi

Languages

Hebrew Judeo-Arabic Judaeo-Spanish Yiddish

Lists of Jews Persecution

Antisemitism

Philosophy

Beliefs

Mitzvah

Chosen people Conversion Eschatology

Messiah

Ethics God Halakha Kabbalah Land of Israel Who is a Jew?

Schisms

Religious movements

Orthodox Haredi Hasidic Conservative Reform Karaite relations

Secularism

Literature

Tanakh

Torah Nevi'im Ketuvim

Rabbinic

Mishnah Talmud Midrash

Kabbalah
Kabbalah
texts

Zohar

Shulchan Aruch Siddur Hebrew literature

Culture

Calendar

Holidays

Cuisine

Kashrut

Education Leadership

Rabbi

Marriage Music Names Politics Prayer

Synagogue Hazzan

Symbolism

Studies

Ashkenazi intelligence Genetics Jew (word) Jewish Virtual Library Relations with other Abrahamic religions

Christianity Islam

 Category: Jews
Jews
and Judaism Judaism
Judaism
portal Judaism
Judaism

.