Ed Mirvish Theatre

The Ed Mirvish Theatre, also currently known by naming rights sponsorship as CAA Ed Mirvish Theatre, is a historic film and play theatre in the downtown core of Toronto, Ontario, Canada. It was initially known as the Pantages Theatre, then became the Imperial Theatre, and Canon Theatre before being renamed in honour of Ed Mirvish, a well-known businessman and theatre impresario. The theatre first opened in 1920 and is located near Yonge–Dundas Square.

History

Early years

The Pantages Theatre opened in 1920 as a combination vaudeville and motion picture house. Designed by the theatre architect Thomas W. Lamb, it was the largest cinema in Canada (originally having 3373 seats) and one of the most elegant.Doherty, Brennan (August 27, 2016)
"This week in history: August 28, 1920, Pantages Theatre opens"
''Toronto Star''. Retrieved July 15, 2022.

The Pantages was built by the Canadian motion picture distributor Nathan L. Nathanson, founder of Famous Players Canadian Corporation, the Canadian motion picture distributing arm of Adolph Zukor's Paramount Pictures. While Famous Players retained ownership, management and booking were turned over to the Pantages organization, one of the largest vaudeville and motion picture theatre circuits in North America.

The Pantages circuit had its beginnings in Canada, in the Yukon. Alexander Pantages had been a sailor on a Greek merchant ship who left the sea in search of riches during the great 1897 Klondike Gold Rush. Although he found no gold, he became part owner of a small theatre in Dawson City, the Orpheum, that staged vaudeville and burlesque shows. From this beginning, he built over a period of 30 years a large entertainment company that would eventually include a Hollywood film studio, a vaudeville booking agency and ownership or control of more than 120 theatres across Canada and the western United States – most of which were known as "The Pantages". The Toronto theatre was the easternmost house of the Pantages circuit, which then dominated the western market; in the east development was blocked by competition from the Keith-Albee-Orpheum vaudeville chain.

In 1929 Alexander Pantages was convicted of the rape of Eunice Pringle, a 17-year-old chorus girl, and sentenced to 50 years in prison. Although the conviction was overturned on appeal, the scandal and the legal costs ruined Pantages. To the public, he had "got away with it" thanks to a clever lawyer. In 1930, he was forced to sell his theatres at a loss; most of his assets were bought by RKO Pictures.

With the collapse of the Pantages circuit, the Pantages name came off the marquees of almost all the theatres. In 1930 the Toronto Pantages was renamed the Imperial, and became exclusively a cinema with no more live vaudeville. Management and control were taken over by Famous Players, which retained ownership for more than 50 years.

Multiplex

In 1972, the Imperial closed after a 9-month run of ''The Godfather'', and was divided into six separate cinemas by Toronto architect Mandel Sprachman. The Yonge façade was replaced with a modern front without canopy. It was officially reopened by Mayor David Crombie in 1973 as the "Imperial Six". Cinema 1 was built forward from the balcony edge toward the top half of the stage proscenium arch. Cinema 2 was located on the original balcony. Cinemas 3 and 4 were built in the original stage house, with cinema 3 being on top in the loft and cinema 4 underneath on the stage floor, and both accessed by a long glass walkway that ran the length of the building exterior above Victoria Street. Cinemas 5 and 6 were in the original main floor seating area, divided in half by a partition wall.

All traces of its elegant past, including the gold leaf and faux marble balustrades, were painted over with bold colours of yellow, red, blue, black, and silver, with the walls carpeted in red and blue. The entrance at Yonge Street was a modern-looking, aluminum-paneled front, with no canopy or vertical, featuring a large circle opening above the entrance into a brightly lit open outdoor square with bright modern marquee panels above on 3 sides, and 6 television screens on each side of the approach to the entrance doors showing movie trailers of features and coming attractions. The TV screens were later replaced by poster cases due to visibility problems with sunlight washing out the TV screens and technical problems with the early 1-inch video tape machines (12 in total, a separate machine for each screen).

The Imperial Six was a big money-maker for Famous Players throughout the 1970s and early 1980s, playing all the big releases including all the James Bond and Rocky releases. It had the same manager, Philip A. Traynor, from well before it closed for renovations in 1972, until its last day of operations by Famous Players in 1986. Following the closing of the Imperial Six, Traynor moved to the Plaza Cinemas and subsequently retired from Famous Players.

Division of ownership

The Imperial Six sat on three separate lots. Famous Players owned the Yonge Street entrance, which bridged an alley and connected to the main building on Victoria Street, and they also owned the front half of the main theatre building, from the centre of the dome to the back wall of the stage house. The other half of the main theatre building, from the centre of the dome to the north wall of the main lobby, was leased from Edna Rakas in Michigan, whose family had owned the property previous to the original construction of the theatre in 1920.

Famous Players Development Corp., an arms-length real estate company spun off from Famous Players Ltd. in the 1970s, and based in New York, attempted to negotiate with Rakas in February 1986 to renew the lease at a more favourable rate. When the lease expired on May 24, 1986, with no agreement in place, Rakas announced her intention to approach Famous Players' rival cinema chain, Cineplex Odeon Corporation. The representatives for Famous Players Development suggested that Cineplex Odeon would have no use for "half a theatre".

They were wrong however, Garth Drabinsky, (CEO of Cineplex Odeon at the time), flew to Michigan the same day that his company was contacted by Rakas' lawyers, and signed a lease. The following day, May 31, 1986, with the assistance of a bailiff and paid security, Cineplex Odeon seized control of the north half of the Imperial Six, thus effectively locked Famous Players out of their flagship downtown Toronto theatre, including the theatre offices, all the lobby space, four of the six projection booths, all of Cinema 2, and the back half of Cinemas 5 and 6. Temporary walls were erected to keep Famous Players out of Cineplex Odeon's space. The Supreme Court of Ontario dismissed Famous Players' application of an injunction blocking Cineplex Odeon's lease on June 2, 1986.

Cineplex Odeon made plans to open their half of the theatre despite the lack of an entrance on Yonge Street. This meant replacing the fire exits, which were all on the Famous Players' end of the main theatre building. Initial plans were to completely gut their half and build a new multiplex cinema, which would augment the nearby Eaton Centre Cineplex, increasing their presence in downtown Toronto. However, because of the elegant grand lobby, vaulted ornate plaster ceilings, columns and grand staircase, plans to gut the building and build as many as eight screens were dropped, and instead plans were drawn up for a three-screen cinema utilizing as much of the existing interior as possible. This would maintain the historic grandness which did not exist in any of the other theatre properties owned and operated by Cineplex Odeon, as most of them dated from after World War II when J. Arthur Rank came to Canada to start Odeon Theatres of Canada.

The need for new fire exits, and the fact that the grand lobby occupied a major part of the space under the original balcony, made the construction of two smaller cinemas on the main floor impractical. The final plan was for a single-screen 800-seat stadium-style cinema utilizing the only complete auditorium on their half, which had been Cinema 2 on the original balcony.
After a costly construction project, the single-screen Pantages Cinema opened on December 12, 1987. The cinema entrance was located on Victoria Street, which did not get as much foot traffic as Yonge Street.

The loss of the Imperial Six led to a corporate shakeup at Famous Players' head office, which saw the ousting of their long-time President George Destounis, even though Famous Players Ltd. in Toronto was not involved with the failed lease renegotiation. Famous Players responded in late 1987 when the company planned to built 11 theatres with 60 screens in eight Canadian cities. The war between Famous Players and Cineplex Odeon continued; the bitterness between the two rival chains was very much in play at the gala opening of the Pantages Cinema. In an attempt to disrupt the screening of ''Wall Street'', Famous Players organized a construction crew to stand by with jackhammers 5 feet behind the Pantages screen, on the other side of the drywall partition between the two companies' halves of the property. Famous Players also called in a complaint about the fire exits; less than an hour before the scheduled gala event, a Toronto Fire Department inspection confirmed that the fire exits were still incomplete, with wet concrete, and the gala was moved to the Varsity Cinemas.

Crews worked around the clock to finish the fire exits, and the cinema opened to the public the next day with its scheduled run of ''Wall Street''. Following the opening, Famous Players removed the doors from every fire exit on their half to allow freezing cold winter air to fill their portion of the building. The partition wall between Cineplex Odeon and Famous Players had been built as a fire wall and was not insulated as an exterior wall.

Other films that showed during this brief time as a single-screen cinema were '' The Unbearable Lightness of Being'', ''Colors'', and a gala screening attended by director Robert Redford for the launch of his film '' The Milagro Beanfield War''.

Live theatre

After a long, bitter legal fight, Famous Players eventually agreed to sell their portions of the original theatre and Yonge Street entrance to Cineplex Odeon, but the victory was a pyrrhic one: as was standard practice for Famous Players when they sold a major downtown theatre property, they attached a condition to the sale forbidding Cineplex from ever again using the theatre for motion pictures. The last film ever to play in the Pantages Cinema was '' Die Hard''.

Even before the Pantages closed to movies on August 26, 1988, Garth Drabinsky had a vision for restoring the complete theatre intact to its original 1920 look and creating a new live entertainment division of Cineplex Odeon. At the time, Toronto was experiencing a renaissance in live theatre, and there was an interest both to restore large historic theatres; such as the ambitious restoration at the Elgin & Winter Garden Theatre by the Ontario Heritage Foundation only one block to the south, and to create more venues that could attract big successful Broadway shows to Toronto, such as the successful runs that ''Cats'' had enjoyed earlier in the 1980s.

With the successful acquisition of Famous Players' remaining portions of the theatre, it was announced that the cinema would close and be restored to its former 1920 glory. Work began in earnest immediately following the closing of the cinema, with interior demolition work removing all the 1973 partition walls, floors, fire exits and passageways, as well as excavating the entire basement underneath the original theatre floor to allow for deeper below grade spaces to accommodate modern live theatre amenities. All of the original plasterwork, some of which had been hidden behind drywall during the 1973 multiplexing, was kept and restored. The original paint colours from 1920 were researched, with experts on scaffolds using fine instruments to pick away layer after layer of paint. Black and white original photos were studied to faithfully recreate everything from the fountain on the grand staircase, to the ticket box in the Yonge Street link, to the ornate marquee and canopy on Yonge Street with the original Pantages vertical as it had looked at its original opening in 1920.

The "new" 2,200-seat Pantages reopened in 1989 with its first legitimate theatre production, Andrew Lloyd Webber's musical ''The Phantom of the Opera'', starring Colm Wilkinson and Rebecca Caine, which played at the Pantages for more than a decade.

The Pantages was operated by a division of Cineplex Odeon known as Livent. After a battle for control of Cineplex between its founder, Garth Drabinsky, and Cineplex Odeon's majority shareholder, MCA, Livent became an independent company, with no ties to the parent corporation. Livent continued to own and operate the Pantages until 1999, when the theatre was purchased, along with other assets of the bankrupt Livent, by Clear Channel Entertainment.

Ownership fell to Live Nation, owners of Broadway Across Canada and Broadway Across America, a subsidiary of Clear Channel, which turned management of the facility over to Mirvish Productions, also giving Mirvish right of first negotiation should the theatre ever be put up for sale.

In July, 2001, Live Nation announced a sponsorship for the theatre from Canon Canada, Inc. In recognition of this sponsorship, the theatre was renamed the Canon Theatre.

On January 24, 2008, Key Brand Entertainment announced that it had acquired all of Live Nation's North American theatrical assets. Key Brand Entertainment is owned and controlled by British theatre producer John Gore and led by entertainment industry veteran Thomas B. McGrath. As part of the financing arrangements for the purchase of Live Nation's assets, Key Brand agreed to sell both the Canon Theatre and the nearby Panasonic Theatre. Honouring the original lease agreement between Mirvish Productions and Live Nation, Key Brand offered Mirvish Productions the right of first negotiation and Mirvish Productions successfully bid to purchase both theatres.

This bid prompted Toronto-based theatre producer Aubrey Dan, of Dancap Productions, a minority shareholder in Key Brand, to seek an injunction forbidding the sale. Mr. Dan's injunction application was dismissed by the court on August 19, 2008, and sale of the theatres to Mirvish Productions was allowed to proceed.

On December 6, 2011, the theatre was renamed to honour Ed Mirvish, who died in July, 2007.

In September 2021, after forging partnerships between the Canadian Automobile Association South Central Ontario (CAA SCO) and Mirvish Productions, the theatre was renamed to CAA Ed Mirvish Theatre.

Heritage designations

On October 1, 1979, the City of Toronto listed the property on the City of Toronto Heritage Property Inventory. On June 13, 1988, the property was designated under Part IV of the ''Ontario Heritage Act'' resulting in heritage protection for the theatre.

Honest Ed's sign

There are plans to relocate one of the iconic Honest Ed's signs to the façade at the 244 Victoria St. entrance of the theatre, pending city approval and restoration of the sign.

References

External links

*

{{Theatres in Toronto

Theatres in Toronto
Movie palaces
Former cinemas in Toronto
City of Toronto Heritage Properties
Mirvish family
Thomas W. Lamb buildings