plural voting

Plural voting is the practice whereby one person might be able to vote multiple times in an election. It is not to be confused with a plurality voting system, which elects winners by relative lead in vote tallies and does not necessarily involve plural voting. It is different from the multiple voting that occurs under block voting.

Weighted voting is a generalisation of plural voting.

Belgium

In Belgium, voting was restricted to the wealthy tax brackets from independence in 1830 until 1848, when it was expanded to include a somewhat larger number of voters. The restriction on voting was abolished in 1893 after the first general strike in Europe and replaced wide adult male franchise but with plural voting for some males. They were allowed one or two additional votes, if they were head of a family or had a certain amount of education or money. This was applied for elections from 1894 to 1919 as a way to limit the impact of universal suffrage.

Every male citizen over 25 got one vote for legislative elections, but some electors got up to two supplementary votes according to some criteria:
*holder of a school diploma;
*family head over 30, paying a poll tax of at least five francs;
*holder of a savings account of at least 2,000 francs, or beneficiary of a life annuity of at least 100 francs.

The system was unpopular. Two more general strikes - in 1902 and in 1913 - were conducted to demand the abolition of plural voting.

For municipal elections, a fourth vote was granted to family heads who paid a fixed level of electoral tax, or whose cadastral income was at least of 150 francs.

Ireland

Plural voting for Dáil elections was abolished by the Electoral Act 1923: electors could be registered in only one constituency: the constituency in which he or she was ordinarily resident; the constituency in which he or she occupied business premises; or one of two university constituencies. University constituencies were abolished at the 1937 general election. University constituencies were recreated in 1938 for the Seanad Éireann, the upper house of the Oireachtas (the Irish legislature). Graduates of Dublin University and the National University are entitled to vote in these constituencies in addition to exercising their normal vote for Dáil Éireann, the lower house of the Oireachtas, and may vote in both constituencies if entitled.

The Local Government (Dublin) Act 1930, passed by the Cumann na nGaedheal government, provided that Dublin City Council would comprise 30 popularly elected "ordinary members" and five "commercial members" elected by business ratepayers (individuals or corporate persons). The commercial members were elected in a single five-member constituency. They were elected by single transferable vote but with each elector casting one ballot or up to six ballots, depending on the tax amount they paid. The commercial members were abolished in 1935 by the Fianna Fáil government.

Inland fisheries boards prior to 2010 were elected by holders of fishing licences, who until 1980 had varying numbers of votes depending on the cost of their licences.

New Zealand

Plural voting, also referred to as "dual voting", was abolished in New Zealand in 1889 for general elections. However, it is still permitted in some local elections, such as Auckland Council.

United Kingdom

In the United Kingdom, up to 1948, people affiliated with a university were allowed a vote in both a university constituency and their home constituency, and property owners could vote in the constituencies where their property lay and that in which they lived, if they were different. In 1892 George Shaw-Lefevre MP stated:

After 1910, the Liberal government was intent on passing a Plural Voting Bill that sought to prevent electors who appeared on the electoral register more than once from voting more than once. Liberal and Unionist headquarters were in agreement that 29 seats were won by Unionists in December 1910 because of plural voting. The bill actually passed third reading, but before the bill could pass into law, the Great War started and the bill was shelved. These practices were finally abolished for parliamentary elections by the Representation of the People Act 1948, which first applied in the 1950 General Election. However, plural voting for local government elections continued until it was abolished, outside the City of London, by the Representation of the People Act 1969. It still exists in the City of London.

Northern Ireland

Until the Electoral Law Act 1968 took effect in 1969, the Queen's University, Belfast constituency was retained in the Parliament of Northern Ireland, giving an additional vote to graduates. As well, owners of businesses were allowed to cast more than one vote in parliamentary elections. Tim Pat Coogan wrote on this subject:

Limited companies and occupiers of premises with a rateable valuation of £10 could appoint nominees—as could companies for each £10 of their valuations—under a system of plural voting, which even allowed such votes to be cast in another constituency...

Plural voting also existed in local government elections in Northern Ireland, as in the rest of the United Kingdom (see above).

Contemporary theory

Philosopher Thomas Mulligan has proposed a system of plural voting which uses a mathematical algorithm to determine voters' ability and then gives higher-ability voters more votes.

Yulia Latynina proposes to offer money to voters who agree to sell their voting right.

See also

*University constituency
*One man, one vote
*Suffrage
* Prussian three-class franchise
* Cumulative voting

References

{{Reflist

Electoral systems