FanMail

''FanMail'' is the third studio album by American girl group TLC, released on February 23, 1999, by LaFace and Arista Records. The album title is a tribute to TLC's fans who sent them fan mail during their hiatus. ''FanMail'' debuted at number one on the US ''Billboard'' 200, selling 318,000 copies in its first week of release, and spent five weeks at number one.

To promote the album, TLC embarked on their first concert tour titled the FanMail Tour. ''FanMail'' received acclaim from most music critics, who praised its innovative sound and themes. The album received eight nominations at the 42nd Annual Grammy Awards, including one for Album of the Year, winning three. It has been certified six-times platinum by the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA), and has sold 10 million copies worldwide. ''FanMail'' is TLC's second-best-selling album after their 1994 studio album '' CrazySexyCool''.

Released following a period of uncertainty marked by financial difficulties and disputes with their record label and among group members, ''FanMail'' reaffirmed TLC's commercial viability. The album's incorporation of technological themes and futuristic production has been credited with helping to reshape the sound of R&B at the turn of the 21st century. TLC were among the first mainstream artists to aestheticize the internet in their music, and ''FanMail'' is regarded as an early precursor to the direct artist-to-fan interaction that would later become common in the era of social media. It was the group's final album released in Lisa "Left Eye" Lopes' lifetime before she died on April 25, 2002, as she was killed in a car crash prior to the release of their fourth studio album '' 3D'' (2002).

Background

After filing for Chapter 11 bankruptcy on July 3, 1995, the group went on a recording hiatus. The suit was eventually settled on November 25, 1996. Preliminary work on their third studio album was delayed when friction arose between the group and their main producer Dallas Austin, who was at the time dating member Rozonda "Chilli" Thomas, and helped to raise their son Tron. Austin wanted $4.2 million and creative control on the project, resulting in a stand-off between him and the group. TLC eventually entered recording studios in April 1998 to start work on their then-untitled third album with Austin, who returned with a handshake agreement. While he contributed the most to the album and served as the executive producer, they also collaborated with long-term producers Babyface and L.A. Reid, as well as with Kevin "She'kspere" Briggs, Jimmy Jam and Terry Lewis. ''FanMail'' was initially scheduled for release on November 10, 1998, but was delayed to the first quarter of 1999.

Lisa "Left Eye" Lopes wrote and composed eight songs for the album, all of which Austin rejected, stating that they were "inferior". Consequently, Lopes told MTV News in July 1998 that she decided to work on a solo album assisted by Erick Sermon. The album was planned to be released before ''FanMail'', further causing tension among the group. During an interview with ''Vibe'' in 1999, Lopes publicly derided her involvement in TLC, remarking: "I've graduated from this era. I cannot stand 100 percent behind this TLC project and the music that is supposed to represent me. This will be my last interview until I can speak freely about the truth and present myself on my solo project."

Recording and production

During the recording of ''FanMail'', the group were offered many songs that would eventually be recorded by other artists such as 702's " Where My Girls At?" (1999), Whitney Houston's "Heartbreak Hotel" (1998), and Britney Spears' " ...Baby One More Time" (1998). Thomas stated that the group considered recording each track but were worried that it did not represent them well. Tionne "T-Boz" Watkins reiterated Thomas' reasoning in an interview with MTV News, stating that "...Baby One More Time" was not good for them despite appreciating and respecting Spears' decision to record it. Each member received at least one songwriting credit throughout ''FanMail''.

Watkins decided to begin writing poetry to deal with her emotions after being in and out of hospital due to sickle cell disease. She took her collection of poems to Austin, who helped her adapt one into the song "Unpretty", while another was adapted by Babyface into " Dear Lie". While writing and recording "I'm Good at Being Bad" in Minneapolis, Watkins had been inspired by grunge band Nirvana's loud and soft dynamic shifts in their discography, and wanted to create a song in a similar style for TLC. Jam encouraged her to hum the melody while he played the beat in the recording booth, which was unlike her usual process of listening to the beat and writing out the lyrics. She stated that the technique influenced her as a songwriter. She sought to have Lopes rap the pre-chorus herself, but Lopes insisted that Watkins' thicker voice should be used for the track. Watkins also contributed to writing two more songs for the album, co-writing "If They Knew" and "Shout" with Austin and Lopes. Two of the album's tracks, "Come on Down" and "I Miss You So Much", were originally written for Watkins to sing lead. However, she decided that Thomas would be more suited as the lead vocalist after attempting to record them. During the recording of the latter, Thomas was suffering from a sinus infection. She asked to re-record the song the next week despite it being near the album's deadline, but Babyface decided that the vocal take she had recorded would be suitable for the final version. " No Scrubs" was one of the final tracks recorded for the album. It was originally written by Kandi Burruss, Tameka Cottle, and Briggs for the former two artists to record together as part of the girl group Xscape. However, Austin persuaded Briggs to give the song to TLC as their first single for ''FanMail'', with Thomas singing the lead vocals. Austin further emphasized that it was a breakthrough for her, as he believed that she was more capable than being relegated to a secondary vocalist.

Composition

''FanMail'' took on a new, futuristic style, due to the rapid advancement in technology heading into the new millennium such as the Y2K bug and Napster. This was effectively portrayed in the album's most popular song "No Scrubs" along with the music video, which embraces a modern emphasis on female strength and independence. The album contains several tracks featuring vocals by the computer modulated voice Vic-E, a talking android which is reminiscent of the "tour guide" on A Tribe Called Quest's 1993 studio album, ''Midnight Marauders''. Initially, the android was created through the Macintosh's greeting voice as a replacement for Lopes, as she refused to work with the group. However, once she reconciled with them, she approved of the android and decided to include it on the album as a character.

''FanMail'' is an R&B album, that includes tracks featuring funk, hip hop-inspired dance-pop, and ballads. Several producers were involved in the album's production, including Dallas Austin, Babyface, Jermaine Dupri, Jimmy Jam, and Terry Lewis. Throughout 17 tracks, TLC brought up issues of sexuality, insecurities, self-reliance, and vulnerability with resistant messaging. It fused elements of "new jill swing" and sounds created from a Roland TR-808, to form a "cyber-R&B masterpiece". On the first track "FanMail", Austin used multiple samples from the internet and movies in order to create a "space sound" that "will sound like what the album cover looks like". The background noise consisting of typewriters and printers was incorporated to represent the fan letters and fan mail, while Austin added a sample from an interview with Lopes commenting "all these conflicting fan mail", and created a hook with it. The song consisted of a sneaking bassline, vocal stutters, and glitches similar to that of dial-up Internet. However, in contrast to the album's dominating technological sound, "Unpretty" is an alternative pop song that describes the insecurity caused by body-shaming. The song was inspired by a poem written by Watkins. "Communicate (Interlude)" establishes the connection between the thoughts and feelings of people nearby through technology. The lyrics from the song, "There's over a thousand ways/ To communicate in our world today/ And it's a shame/ That we don't connect" describe the lack of interaction between humans, which in turn has increased the rate of depression among adolescents. It combines the typing of a keyboard in the background with Left Eye's vocals, "will you communicate with me?".

Artwork, packaging, and title

The ''FanMail'' cover featured a custom font design, and cover art with decode-able binary code which included images of the TLC members in metallic skin tones. The photographer, Dan Levy, shot the silver-painted group members without any digital alterations. Writing for '' i-D'', Annie Lord described the members on the cover as "three digitised, disembodied cyborgs from another dimension", and compared the binary code across their faces to ''The Matrix''. The CD insert folds out to form a large poster featuring a picture of the three TLC members and the names of thousands of people who sent them fan mail throughout their career. A limited edition of the album was released, which had an insert with a lenticular version of the cover placed in front of the original booklet in the jewel case.

The album title is a tribute to TLC's fans after their five-year hiatus. It came from Lopes, who also coined the group's first two album titles '' Ooooooohhh... On the TLC Tip'' and '' CrazySexyCool'', and initially wanted to name the album ''Fan2See''. She stated to the group, "let's write and sing one big fan letter. Let's put fan names on everything – all the singles, the album cover, T-shirts, mugs. Just show our appreciation".

Promotion

Singles

"FanMail", " Silly Ho", "I'm Good at Being Bad", and "My Life" served as promotional singles for the album. Those songs charted on the US ''Billboard'' R&B/Hip-Hop Songs.

" No Scrubs" was the official lead single and topped the US ''Billboard'' Hot 100 for four consecutive weeks, becoming TLC's biggest commercial success in years. It also ranked at number two on ''Billboards Year-End Hot 100 of 1999.

Follow-up single "Unpretty" also topped the ''Billboard'' Hot 100, spending three weeks at number one and placing at number 20 on the Year-End Hot 100.

Originally, "Shout" was planned to be a single in the United States, while " Dear Lie" would be a single internationally, but only the latter would end up being released as a single with an accompanying music video. It peaked at number 51 on the ''Billboard'' Hot 100.

Tour

TLC embarked on the FanMail Tour to promote the album. It was their first headlining tour, and their first tour in five years. As part of a sponsorship with MP3.com, the group released "I Need That", with proceeds sent to the Sickle Cell Disease Association of America. The song was described by the producer Rico Lumpkins as "more R&B than hip-hop". The stage and costumes were all designed by each TLC member. The FanMail Tour became the highest-grossing tour by a girl group, as it grossed over $72.8 million. It was the final tour with all three members together.

Critical reception

Upon release, ''FanMail'' received acclaim from most music critics, many of whom regarded it as TLC's most progressive project to date. Reviewers also complimented the album's sound and lyrics for addressing complex themes in a catchy, mainstream manner.

Writing for ''Muzik'', Tony Farsides stated that ''FanMail'' was "a real grower" in comparison to other albums released during the time. ''NME'' writer Roger Morton compared the album's "cyber concept" to Prince's electronic funk discography and opined that TLC were not diminished by other girl groups such as Honeyz, All Saints, and the Spice Girls.

Ann Powers of ''Rolling Stone'' opined that elements of ''FanMail'' were "fragmented" despite sounding more "sharper ndaggressive" than ''CrazySexyCool'', but praised the TLC members for taking "brave" risks. Writing for AllMusic, Stephen Thomas Erlewine noted that the group were attempting to imitate the production of ''CrazySexyCool'' although he noted the album's versatility. ''Los Angeles Times'' staff writer Marc Weingarten negatively stated that the vocals were "wispy ndflat", and that all members were "severely limited singers". However, he commented that the album's production managed to overpower their vocals with "sinewy beats and startling arrangements".

David Browne of ''Entertainment Weekly'' criticized TLC's "startlingly faceless and homogeneous" vocals and opined that ''FanMail'' was an "endless parade of hooks" without the essence of R&B. He acknowledged that their vocals were typical of some R&B artists in the 1990s who "warble in the same half-asleep murmur" and lamented that the genre is "curiously dispassionate". Writing for ''Spin'', Joshua Clover stated that the album was "a burning, physical message that looks like a spectacle but reads like sexual politics" and criticized the producers for attempting to resemble Timbaland's production.

Commercial performance

In the United States, ''FanMail'' debuted at number one on the ''Billboard'' 200 and the Top R&B/Hip-Hop Albums charts with 318,000 copies sold in its first week, becoming TLC's first number-one album on both charts. On June 21, 2000, it was certified six-times platinum by the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA). According to Nielsen SoundScan, the album had sold 4.8 million copies in the United States as of July 2017; it had sold an additional 877,000 copies through the BMG Music Club as of February 2003. Internationally, the album reached the top 10 in New Zealand, Canada, and the United Kingdom. As of February 2019, ''FanMail'' has sold over 10 million copies worldwide.

Legacy

''FanMail'' marked a return to form for TLC, following a turbulent hiatus from recording music that included a highly publicized period of financial struggles, record label disagreements, and internal conflict among group members. Although it did not replicate the commercial success of ''CrazySexyCool'', ''FanMail'' further cemented TLC's status as one of the most influential girl groups of all-time, and nevertheless established them as the best-selling female musical act in the United States. According to Preezy Brown of Revolt, its success proved their longevity as the preeminent R&B girl group of the 1990s, "bookend ngone of the dominant runs we’ve seen in music over the past quarter-century and stamped TLC as modern-day legends". In a BBC Radio 1 listener poll, ''FanMail'' was voted the 17th best album of the 1993-2003 decade.

The album is credited with helping to reshape the sound of R&B upon the turn of the 21st century. Its production, which incorporated futuristic and electronic sounds, influenced the genre's shift towards a more technology-inspired style, consequently introducing other sub-genres of R&B. Music journalist Suzy Exposito said the album "would serve as a blueprint for a new, digitally-savvy generation of genre-defying musicians". With the album's release, TLC were among the first artists to adopt a soundscape and aesthetic inspired by the country's fascination with and fear of the new millennium, the internet, and Y2K, with Julianne Escobedo Shepherd of ''Complex'' declaring them "the most accurately prescient of any of the musicians" who donned metallic outfits. According to Natelegé Whaley of ''Vibe'', it "proved that TLC was more in tune with the future than their pop peers". ''Rated R&B'''s Danielle Brissett agreed that it "launched them into a space that most female R&B groups had yet to experience", while allowing them to compete alongside the likes of emerging R&B girl groups such as 702, Blaque, and Destiny’s Child by releasing music that sounded different than theirs. Apple Music said the album maintains relevance despite its retrofuturism, writing, "there isn't a better snapshot of where things were headed around the turn of the millennium".

Music publications have discussed the impact of the album's themes. Apple Music said the project "delivered some of R&B's most timeless empowerment anthems and channeled the future with remarkable prescience". Similarly, Nick C. Levine of ''Dazed'' said in 2019 that the album's themes about self-preservation and self-worth continue to resonate. In response, TLC has received an outpouring of support from both established and new fans during and decades after the album's release, who wrote to them sharing their own struggles with body image and other issues. Whaley believes the record's defiance granted women "permission to be vocal about the spectrum of their emotions", particularly via its most popular single, "No Scrubs". In addition to introducing the term "scrub" into the public's lexicon, the song had been sampled on over 37 songs by 2019. A reviewer for ''Sputnikmusic'' crowned the album "THE female urban album of our generation to evoke integrity in women, and companionship with their special someone", which they found deserving of TLC's recognition in the history books. In retrospect, some critics have admitted that certain aspects of ''FanMail'' sound outdated. However, Kish Lal of Junkee noted that although ''FanMail'' may contain dated production elements, its thematic substance and overarching messages remain timeless compared to offerings from other contemporary artists attempting Y2K-inspired pop at the time. Shepherd noted that the "weightless" production that characterized ''FanMail'' had fallen out of fashion but already resurged by 2014.

Because of its title and tracks that directly address fans, several reporters have noted that the album positioned TLC as early adopters of digital fan engagement in a pre-social media era, with both Chilli and T-Boz frequently interacting with their fans online. Lindsay Zoladz of ''Pitchfork'' reported that because ''FanMail'' is often overlooked in favor of its immediate predecessor, ''CrazySexyCool'', fans fail to realize that the album is responsible for "a whole crop of web-minded, Tumblr-savvy, android-obsessed artists". Zoladz argues that ''FanMail'' explores the isolating effects of being constantly connected; she sees this theme reflected across contemporary media, from Drake's ''Take Care'' (2011) to ''The Social Network'' (2010) and '' Girls'' (2012-2017), all of which similarly grapple with the emotional toll of digital life. Lal said in 2019 "The disconnect that TLC emanates in ''FanMail'' has trickled into the lives of everyone on social media", while '' i-D'''s Annie Lord said TLC "predicted internet anxiety". The album has been cited as an influence on the works of female R&B artists in particular, namely Destiny’s Child, SZA, H.E.R., and Summer Walker. In 2019, Brissett credited the album's success with helping launch a Black music movement "that went against the norm" and "has a heavy presence today". ''FanMail'' was the final album TLC released comprising their original trio, becoming the last album they recorded with Lopes prior to her death in 2002. Double J contributor Sose Fuamoli said that, even when removed from Lopes's legacy, ''FanMail'''s "importance at the end of the 90s is untouchable".

Track listing

Digital download track

* "I Need That" – 3:52
** Released online by TLC exclusively on MP3.com to promote the FanMail Tour. Produced by Rico Lumpkins for PWPX, LLC. Written by R. Lumpkins, L. Lopes, and S. Chunn. Left Eye's rap was later expanded and re-recorded on the track "Gimme Some" from Toni Braxton's album '' The Heat'', as well as being completely reused and shortened on the track "Whoop De Woo" from the compilation '' Now and Forever: The Hits'', originally intended for the group's fourth album '' 3D''.

Notes
* signifies a co-producer
* signifies an additional vocal producer

Sample credits
* "FanMail" contains an excerpt from an MTV interview that features the instrumental of TLC's song " Diggin' on You" in the background.
* "I'm Good at Being Bad" contains elements from " Slippin' into Darkness" by War. The song also originally contained interpolated lyrics from " Love to Love You Baby" by Donna Summer, but the interpolated lyrics were later removed on later pressings of the explicit version.
* On initial pressings of the album, "Whispering Playa – Interlude" contained a sample of " Cold Blooded" by Rick James playing in the background. The sample was removed on subsequent editions, with TLC's song "U in Me" being played in the background instead.
* "Automatic" contains portions from Neil Armstrong's "Moon Landing" speech.

Personnel

Credits adapted from the liner notes of ''FanMail''.

Musicians

* Dallas Austin – arrangements ; gang vocals
* T-Boz – background vocals ; gang vocals
* Chilli – background vocals
* Debra Killings – background vocals ; bass
* Rick Sheppard – MIDI, sound design
* Vic-E – speech ; rap
* Leslie Brathwaite – gang vocals
* Ty Hudson – gang vocals
* Joi Gilliam – gang vocals
* Peach – gang vocals
* Sonji – gang vocals
* Carolyn Paige – gang vocals
* Kevin Wales – gang vocals
* "Big" Stan Smith – gang vocals
* Papi – playa
* Kandi Burruss – background vocals
* Tameka "Tiny" Cottle – background vocals
* She'kspere – MIDI, sound design
* Jimmy Jam and Terry Lewis – arrangements, all other musical instruments
* Mike Scott – guitar
* Alex Richbourg – drum programming
* Jerry Lumpkins – additional keyboards
* Babyface – drum programming, acoustic guitar ; keyboards, electric guitar
* Greg Phillinganes – piano ; Wurlitzer
* Michael Thompson – acoustic guitar ; electric guitar
* C.C. Thomas – bass
* Necia Bray – background vocals
* Tomi Martin – guitar
* Tom Knight – drums
* LaMarquis Jefferson – bass
* Marde Johnson – gang vocals
* Koko Watkins – gang vocals
* Solomon Jackson – gang vocals
* James Killings – guitar
* Nathan East – bass
* Paulinho da Costa – percussion
* Colin Wolfe – bass
* Melvin M. Jones – trumpet
* Gregory Hudspeth – saxophone
* Anthony Roberson – trombone

Technical

* Cyptron – production
* Carlton Lynn – recording ; recording assistance ; mixing
* Leslie Brathwaite – recording ; mixing
* Jeff Griffin – recording assistance
* Sejoon Kahng – recording assistance
* Alvin Speights – mixing
* Vernon J. Mungo – mixing assistance ; recording assistance ; recording
* Ty Hudson – recording assistance ; mixing assistance
* Dallas Austin – production ; executive production
* Kevin "She'kspere" Briggs – production ; additional vocal production
* Jimmy Jam and Terry Lewis – production
* Steve Hodge – recording, mixing
* Xavier Smith – recording assistance, mixing assistance
* Dave Rideau – vocal recording
* Gordon Fordyce – vocal recording assistance
* Dylan Dresdow – vocal recording assistance
* Ricciano Lumpkins – production ; recording
* John Horesco IV – mixing assistance ; digital editing
* Babyface – production ; executive production
* Daryl Simmons – production
* Paul Boutin – recording
* Thom "TK" Kidd – lead vocals recording
* Kevin Lively – lead vocals recording assistance ; mixing assistance
* Ralph Cacciurri – lead vocals recording assistance
* Jon Gass – mixing
* Ivy Skoff – production coordination
* Jermaine Dupri – production, mixing
* Carl So-Lowe – co-production
* Brian Frye – recording
* Phil Tan – mixing
* Diane Makowski – production coordination
* Debra Killings – production
* Aman Junaid – recording
* E'lyk – mixing assistance
* Claudine Pontier – recording assistance
* Herb Powers Jr. – mastering
* Antonio M. Reid – executive production
* TLC – executive production

Artwork

* TLC – creative concept
* D.L. Warfield – art direction, design
* Cherie O'Brien – creative coordination
* Nigel Sawyer – layout assistance
* Seb Janiak – photography

Charts

Weekly charts

Year-end charts

Decade-end charts

Certifications and sales

See also

* List of ''Billboard'' 200 number-one albums of 1999
* List of ''Billboard'' number-one R&B albums of 1999

Notes

References

{{DEFAULTSORT:Fanmail
1999 albums
Albums produced by Babyface (musician)
Albums produced by Dallas Austin
Albums produced by Jermaine Dupri
Albums produced by Jimmy Jam and Terry Lewis
Arista Records albums
Grammy Award for Best R&B Album
LaFace Records albums
TLC (group) albums