Plot summary
At the time of the investigation, the newspaper was in deep financial trouble. The company, which also owns the ''Philadelphia Inquirer'', only had one lawyer at the time. The lawyer was bogged down with other legal proceedings and was unable to offer too much help to the women. So instead, when the city refused to give them access to search warrants, Ruderman and Laker convinced the custodian of the records onAftermath of the investigation
The investigation was quite the controversy in Philadelphia. In part, that was because several police officers died in the line of duty leading up to the investigation, which made people already more sensitive to police at that time. After the investigation trickled out through the tabloid over a few months, hundreds of drug cases in the city had been re-examined out and some were thrown out. Philadelphia police also launched a task force with the FBI, the department's Internal Affairs division and the city's Inspector General's Office, to investigate the incidents. As of May 10, five officers involved with the allegations were on desk duty and more than 15 civil suits had been filed in federal court. Federal and local prosecutors decided not to press any charges against the four officers who were accused of lying about evidence on search warrants and stealing from corner drug stores—one of the officers was accused of sexually assaulting at least three women. In July 2014, the president of Philadelphia's Fraternal Order of Police, John McNesby, demanded an investigation into how Ruderman and Laker interacted with the sources used during their "Tainted Justice" investigation. According to a NewsWorks report at the time, McNesby suggested that the reporters "may have given money, paid utility bills and provided diapers to sources who accused the offers at the center of the 2009 series." McNesby said the Pulitzer Prize should be revoked from the women.Pulitzer Prize
A video from a staff member at the ''Daily News'' shows the two women jumping wildly up and down after learning they had won. Ruderman is seen opening a small bottle of champagne, pouring it into her tennis shoe and drinking it. She later called this a reference to "shoe leather" journalism.Reception
Rosella Elanor Lafevre praised the book in a review for the ''Philadelphia'' magazine, writing:It’s a captivating story that I tore through in two days. There are moments that inspire riotous laughter and quiet awe, and some that will make your skin crawl. It gives as much proof to the importance of hard-working reporters in a one-party town as it does the importance of chasing your dreams, even when they seem preposterous.In the May 23, 2014, edition of the ''New York Times''' Sunday Book Review,
This is a shoe-leather journalistic procedural set against the ticking clock of the failing newspaper industry. The book is sometimes a bit self-conscious about its buddy movie potential, but it’s impossible not to root for the self-described “slime sistas” as they follow up on a series of tips about a Philly police squad that regularly robbed immigrant-owned bodegas, and a badge-wielding sexual predator known only as “the Boob Man.”''The Washington Post''
The new book... is the chick, noir version of “All the President’s Men,” with a little “Rocky,” a little “Deadline U.S.A.” and a little almost anything with Rosalind Russell or Barbara Stanwyck.Many have compared Ruderman and Laker to Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein, the journalists behind
The effect is a little jarring for a co-written book, but it does have the immediacy that comes with first-person narrative, while avoiding the flattening effect of a “we” voice stretching for hundreds of pages. (For the record, Woodward and Bernstein in ''All The President’s Men'' opted for a third-person narrator who knows the reporters’ thoughts, a choice that comes with its own idiosyncrasies: “ ’Oh god, not Bernstein,’ Woodward thought . . . .”)
TV series
In June 2014, Sidney Kimmel Entertainment considered developing an hour-long, limited television series based on the book. ''Sex and the City''References
{{Reflist 2014 non-fiction books Books about journalism Crimes in Philadelphia HarperCollins books Non-fiction crime books